1/8
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Litigation Funding Basics
What Litigation Funding Is Third-party litigation financing (TPLF) is when an outside investor pays money to someone in a lawsuit, or to their law firm, in exchange for a share of any money won. If the case is lost, the money does not have to be paid back.
Where Funding Is Used In the U.S., this funding is available for business claims and for claims by individual consumers, in both federal and state courts. It can also be used in arbitration, a way of settling disputes without a trial, in the U.S. or abroad.
Growth and Concerns Litigation funding has been common in other countries for decades but only gained a foothold in the U.S. around 2010, and public information about it is still limited. Some policymakers worry that these deals are not transparent and that funders charge high fees.
Old Legal Barriers Litigation funding was long held back by old common law rules that banned paying for someone else's lawsuit, especially in exchange for a share of the winnings. Many states have relaxed these bans, which may help explain the market's recent growth.
Two Main Types of Funding Commercial funding goes to businesses or law firms for business disputes, while consumer funding goes to individuals, such as people injured in accidents. A plaintiff who wins repays the funding plus a return, and a plaintiff who loses repays nothing.
Who the Funders Are Many funders are private firms that specialize in litigation funding and raise money from investors such as pension funds and endowments. Others invest in many kinds of markets, a few are large public companies, and some are small firms or wealthy investors who fund cases only occasionally.
Industry Trade Groups Funders have formed trade groups, such as the International Legal Finance Association (commercial funders) and the American Legal Finance Association (consumer funders), to speak for them with lawmakers and regulators. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Institute for Legal Reform, by contrast, has pushed for rules requiring funding deals to be disclosed in federal court.
Commercial Funding
Who Uses Commercial Funding Businesses and law firms use commercial funding to pay legal costs or to support their general operating budgets. Clients include companies and law firms of all sizes.
Scale of Commercial Funding Commercial funders usually provide millions of dollars, either for a single case or for a group of cases. The kinds of claims funded, and the kinds of investors behind them, vary.
Single-Case Deals In a single-case deal, a business trades part of the value of one lawsuit for funding. Defendants rarely get funding because they usually do not win money, unless they have a strong counterclaim against the plaintiff.
Portfolio Deals In a portfolio deal, a law firm or company trades part of the value of a group of cases for funding, and can use the money more flexibly, for example to grow its business. Law firms can include defense cases in a portfolio, which is a way to fund work that would be hard to fund on its own.
Types of Commercial Claims Commercial funders back many kinds of claims, including intellectual property, antitrust, fraud and class actions. Most also fund cases abroad and choose where to operate based on whether local law is friendly to funding.
Commercial Funding Amounts Commercial funders focus on high-value cases, often investing at least $2 million per deal. GAO's data showed averages of about $2.3 million per single-case deal and $4.5 million per portfolio deal, and a market report found even higher 2021 averages of $3.5 million and $8.5 million.
Commercial Investors One commercial funder is publicly traded in the U.S. and the U.K., and another in Australia, while most investors are large private institutions such as pension funds. Some funders also take money from government-controlled investment funds (sovereign wealth funds) or from family offices that manage wealthy families' money.
Careful Case Selection Before funding, commercial funders check the strength of the case, the quality of the legal team and whether the defendant can pay. Only about 4 to 5 percent of formal funding requests end in a deal, because funders get paid only when cases succeed.
No Control Over Strategy All the commercial funders GAO interviewed said they do not make decisions about how cases are run, including whether to settle. Some said they share their views on a case only if the client asks.
Overview of Commercial Growth Data from three commercial funders show growth between 2017 and 2021. Funders and experts said the wider U.S. market has also grown, with changes in who the clients are and what kinds of deals are offered.
Measuring Growth For the three funders, total funding more than doubled, funding requests rose 27 percent and new deals rose 19 percent. Funders credited the growth to big companies and law firms becoming more familiar and comfortable with litigation funding.
Market Size Estimates A 2021 market report found that money committed to new deals rose 11 percent from the prior year. The report counted 47 active commercial funders managing $12.4 billion, which had committed $2.8 billion to new deals in 2021.
No Full Picture of the Market No one knows the total size of the market, because there is no central database and no federal requirement to report. Industry observers also disagree about what should be measured.
Wider Acceptance and Shift to Portfolios Funders said wider acceptance has brought in new users and new kinds of deals. Portfolio deals grew from about 19 percent of new deals in 2017 to about 39 percent in 2021, and from 28 percent to 51 percent of the money provided.
Consumer Funding
Consumer Funding Pays Living Costs Consumer clients mostly use funding to pay rent, medical bills and other living costs while their case is pending, not to pay for the lawsuit itself. Using the money for legal costs could conflict with some states' bans on paying for another person's lawsuit.
Consumer Deal Types Consumer funders mainly fund single cases for individual plaintiffs, sometimes several times during one case. They usually do not fund defendants, who are typically backed by their insurance.
Consumer Claim Types Consumer funding mostly goes to personal injury cases, such as car accidents, slip-and-falls and medical malpractice. Most consumer funders work in several states, depending on local rules, but not internationally.
Small Consumer Amounts Consumer advances are small, usually $1,000 to $10,000, and often no more than about 7 to 10 percent of the case's estimated value. Funders keep amounts low so they can be repaid and so clients are not discouraged from accepting reasonable settlements.
Consumer Investors Consumer funders are private companies. They get their money from several sources, including sales of securities and private investors.
How Consumer Funders Decide Consumer funders check things like whether the defendant's fault is clear and whether the defendant has insurance. Approval rates varied: one funder approved about 21 percent of first-time requests, while two others funded about half.
No Consumer Case Control All five consumer funders said their agreements give them no control over the client's case. They also said they do not advise clients on decisions such as whether to settle.
Consumer Market Trends The consumer market is seeing more familiarity, more maturity and more state regulation. Each trend is explained in the paragraphs that follow.
More Familiarity Consumers have become more familiar with litigation funding, which one funder said has increased competition and lowered costs. Lawyers may also become more accepting as more of their clients want to use it.
A Maturing Market The market is maturing, as shown by funders raising money by selling securities, which suggests more investor interest. One researcher said funders now use established business practices and technology.
State Regulation Efforts Both supporters and opponents of consumer funding are pushing for state rules, including fee limits and, in some states, outright bans. Some states now require contract terms to be stated clearly.
No Consumer Market Size Data There is no public data or industry survey on the size of the consumer market. Maine collects some data from registered funders, but does not publish it, and experts were unsure whether the market has grown.
Policy for Getting Data
Missing Data Experts identified gaps in U.S. market data. Examples include funders' returns, how many funders operate, and how much funding they provide.
Why Better Data Matters More data could show how funding affects lawsuits and whether judges with stakes in funders face conflicts of interest. It could also improve protections for consumers and investors, and might even be an alternative to regulation.
Six Policy Options Experts suggested six ways to fill the data gaps, which lawmakers, regulators, courts or industry could carry out. GAO groups the options by market and notes who would supply the data and what challenges each faces.
Option: Arbitration Bodies Arbitration organizations with disclosure rules could collect data on commercial funding. But a trade group said this would give only part of the picture.
Option: State Regulators States could require funders to be licensed and to report consumer data, though passing such laws in many states may be hard. There is also a concern that defendants could learn things about plaintiffs, which could be avoided by reporting data anonymously or in combined form.
Option: Federal Regulators The CFPB could collect consumer data, and the SEC could collect data from commercial funders it already regulates. However, trade groups questioned whether the CFPB has the legal authority to do so without new legislation.
Option: Courts Federal or state courts could require disclosure of funding or survey litigants. But differences between state courts, gaps in coverage (such as state cases and arbitration) and extra workload for courts are challenges.
Option: Voluntary Reporting Congress or the courts could ask funders to share data voluntarily, or offer them incentives to do so. But funders may decline for confidentiality reasons, and the data might not represent the whole industry.
Option: Lawyers Report Lawyers could report funding data, for example through state bar registration. But lawyers' confidentiality and ethics duties could limit what they share.
Limits of the Options These options come from the roundtable, may not be the only ones, and each involves trade-offs. Many would require new laws, regulations or court rules, and GAO did not evaluate how well they would work.
Funding Debate
Overview of Pros and Cons Funding can help plaintiffs without money take on well-funded defendants and shift risk to someone else. But it can be expensive and may discourage settlement.
Leveling the Playing Field Funding lets small businesses sue large companies and pay for experienced lawyers and expert witnesses. Consumer funding pays an injured person's living costs so they do not have to accept a low settlement.
Turning Claims Into Cash Funding lets plaintiffs get the value of their claim up front instead of waiting until they win. Companies can use the money for business needs and individuals for living expenses.
Shifting Risk Funding moves some of the risk of losing onto the funder. Because plaintiffs owe nothing if they lose, it works somewhat like insurance does for defendants.
Extra Benefits for Businesses A funder's review of a case gives businesses useful feedback on its strengths and weaknesses. Funding can also keep litigation costs off a company's financial statements.
May Discourage Settlement Plaintiffs with funding may turn down a fair settlement offer. They may want extra money to cover what they owe the funder.
Higher Costs for Defendants Funding could encourage weak lawsuits and lead to extra legal fights over access to the funding agreement, raising defendants' costs. Cases may also last longer if plaintiffs are less willing to settle.
Litigation funding for Investors
Investor Overview Litigation funding offers investors high possible returns and a way to diversify, because its results do not move with the stock market. The main downside is a high risk of losing the investment.
High Returns Two commercial funders reported returns of about 91 to 93 percent on certain investments. These returns are high because the risk is high: investors lose everything if the case fails.
Separate From Financial Markets Lawsuit results do not depend on stock, bond or commodity prices or on the wider economy. That makes litigation funding a good way for investors to spread their risk.
Risk of Total Loss Because funding does not have to be repaid if a case is lost, the funder loses its whole investment in that case. Five funders said this is the biggest downside for investors.
Slow and Uncertain Returns Cases can take years to resolve, which delays returns. Funders may also lack full information about a case, and investors could be misled about its chances.
Rules surrounding litigation funding
No Specific Federal Regulation No federal law specifically regulates litigation funding. Funders may still be covered by general laws, such as federal securities laws.
SEC Reporting by Public Funders Funders that are public companies must regularly report business and financial information to the SEC, which can include their funding activities. One example is Burford Capital, which is listed on the New York Stock Exchange and files annual reports with the SEC.
Other Securities Issues and Proposed SEC Rules SEC staff said some funding deals might count as securities under federal law. The SEC has proposed rules that would require certain investment advisers to report their private funds' litigation finance investments confidentially, to help monitor risks to the financial system.
CFPB's Role The CFPB regulates consumer credit, and whether a funding deal counts as credit depends on its specific facts. In a 2017 enforcement case, the CFPB said certain advances to consumers awaiting payment of an award were credit.
State Rules for Consumer Funding Some states cap rates and fees, such as Arkansas's 17 percent interest cap and Tennessee's 10 percent annual fee limit. States such as Maine and Nebraska require funders to register and to disclose key terms, like the total amount owed.
Uniform Rules and Balance Two consumer funders said uniform state rules would make it easier to work across state lines. Others noted the difficulty of protecting consumers without over-regulating and limiting access to funding.
Voluntary Best Practices Industry groups have voluntary standards, such as not giving consumers more money than they need and not paying referral fees to lawyers. The American Bar Association advises lawyers to put funding deals in writing and make sure the client stays in control of the case.
No National Disclosure Rule Federal litigation has no nationwide rule requiring funding deals to be disclosed, and proposals to add one in 2014 and 2017, along with proposed legislation, have not been adopted. Supporters say disclosure would reveal conflicts of interest, while critics say defendants want it mainly to learn how much plaintiffs can spend.
Courts Can Still Get Information Even without a national rule, judges can ask about funding when it matters in a case. Some federal courts have adopted their own local disclosure rules.
Northern District of California Since November 2018, this court has required parties in class and similar group cases to identify anyone funding a claim. The disclosure goes to the court.
District of New Jersey Since June 2021, litigants in New Jersey federal court with certain funding deals must name the funder. They must also say whether the funder must approve litigation or settlement decisions and briefly describe the funder's financial stake.
Financial Interest Disclosure Rules Several federal courts require parties to name outsiders with a financial stake in the case so judges can check for conflicts. These rules do not target litigation funding specifically but may still reveal funders.
State Disclosure Laws Wisconsin (2018) and West Virginia (2019) require disclosure of funding agreements in civil cases. Texas and Florida have considered similar bills.
Class Notes
Final Exam
Guideposts are important
In re Fordham
Client decides, doesn’t matter what lawyer and paying father
Fees - Guideposts
6-8, 13 - business intake, billing and extension
1.5(a): Reasonable fees
Lawyer shall not make an agreeemtn for ,chare, or collect and unreasonable fee or an unreasonable amount for expenses. The factors to be considered in determining the reasonabless of fee include
time and labor, novelthy and ifficulty, skill requisite
likelihood that
1.5(b): Communication re Fees
Scope of the represtnation and the basis or rate of the fee and expenses shall be communicated (always accroding to professor: client ID, confirm any changes) before or within reaonable timee xcept when lawyer know client and charges on regular basis. Any changes of fee rate or basis shall be communicated
1.5©: Contingent
Contingent fees allowed except. Contingent fee agreeemtn shall be in a writing signed by the client and state the method by which fee is to be determined, aggreemuent must clearly notify the clinet of any expenses for which client will be liable whether or not the client is the prevailing party. Lawyer at conclusion must provide in writing
1.5(e): Division of fees
Division fee allowed only if:
Division is in propretion oto the services or each lawyer assumes joint reposnbility for th represtneation; and the client agrees to tthe arragnement in writing, and total fee is reaosnable
1.15: Safekeeping Property
Upshots: no comingling. Why? Maintain records
A lawyer may depoist the lawyer’s own funds in a client trust account fo the sole purpose of paying bank service charges on that account, but only in an amount necessary for that purpose
Paid in advance? Funds to client trust account until fees earned.
Upon receiveing funds or other proprety in which client or third person has an interest, lawyer shall promoptly notify the client
Lawyer shall promptly deliver the client or third person any funds or other property that the client or third person is entitled to received
When lawyer si in possesson of property in whcih two or more persons claim interest, the property shall be kept separate by ther lawyer until the idspute is resolved
Lawyer shall promptly distribute all portions of the porperty as towhich
Rule 5.4: Professiopnal Independence of Lawyer
lawyer or law firm shall not share legal fees with a nonlawyer, execept that [four discrete exceptions]:
lawyer shall not form a partnership witgh a nonlawyer if any of the activities of the partnership consist of the pracitice of law
Lawyer shall not permit a person who recommends, employs
Litigation Funding - Gist
We funder loan $ to client or law firm
We don’t get repaid unless you win
But then we get paid LOTS - repay loan, plus interest, plus a cut of the take
Commercial: Case-specific, Portfoilo funding - loan based on a group of cases (invest in / loan to a co., invest in / loan to a law firm)
Consumer: Case-specific, portfolio funding. based on a group of cases, incl. mass tort/class action
Litiation Funding v. Black’s Law Dictionary
Champerty: Agreement between officious intermedder in lawsuit and ligiant by which intermedddler helps pursue the litigant’s claim as consideration for receiving part of any judgment proceeds
Maintenance: Improper assistance in prosecuting or defending a lawsuit given to a litigant by someone who has no bona fide interest in the case; meddling in someone else’s ligiation (Harry Styles run over and victim gets lawsuit throught Taylor switft) (28 jurisdiction permitted)
Barratry: Vexatious incitement to litigation esp. by solicing potential legal clients. There must typically be a showing that the resutling lawsuit was utterly baseless.
Litigation Funding v. Rule 5.4
5.4a - no sharing legal fees with nonlawyers
It’s a loan, not legal fees
5.4b - no partnerships with nonlawyers to practice law
5.43c 3d party payor cannot ‘direct or regulate the lawyers’s propfessional jdugemnt
GAO Pros and Cons
Pros: Evens playing field for underfunded plaintiffs. (Contingecy fee too?) Allows plaintiffs to moetize claims sooner (Contingent fee lawuyers cannot do. Rule 1.8 limits to court costs and expenses only.)(Bus. puprpose, living expense). Transfer risk of loss to 3d pty (akin to insurance). LIt funder due diligence decrease number of frivolous claims.
Cons: Expensive rate on loans. Expensive share cut into party’ recover. May deter settlement. Increase litig costs for def’ts. Funder influencing litigation strategy, settlement decisions. Conflicts between clients and lawyers. Consumer funding: Plaintiffs unawayre of total cost, taking advtg of peo in dire cmstncs, Meritless cases. Privilege and confidentiality
Diversity