1/20
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Katz
FACTS: Police placed listening device to outside of phone booth w/o warrant to listen to and record calls.
SEARCH. The Fourth Amendment protects people, not places.
REOP: (1) took steps to manifest subjective expectation of privacy and (2) society agrees this expectation is reasonable
Greenwood
FACTS: Police searched garbage bag D had left on curb.
NOT a search. No REOP in garbage left on curb (knowingly exposed to the public).
Kyllo
FACTS: Police in car across the street used thermal imaging to detect heat inside the home, discovered marijuana.
SEARCH. Device that discloses activities inside the home constitute a search. Consider whether the public has access to that tech and whether the officers would have been able to observe this otherwise from their vantage point.
White
FACTS: Government informant wore radio transmitter to speak with D.
NOT a search. You assume the risk when you talk to someone that they may be a government informant recording you.
Smith
FACTS: Police have phone company install a pen register at HQ to track the phone numbers that D calls.
NOT a search. No REOP in numbers dialed. Only recorded the numbers dialed, not the contents of the conversation—the level of detail the government is able to ascertain from a particular circumstance matters.
Curtilage definition
private land near a house; considered part of the home for Fourth Amendment purposes
Open fields definition
land, even privately owned, which is beyond the curtilage
Dunn Test (curtilage vs. open fields)
Proximity to the house
In an enclosed area
Use for the area (“could be fairly characterized as so associated with the activities and privacies of domestic life”)
Steps taken to protect the activity
Jardines
FACTS: Drug-sniffing dog on front porch signalled marijuana.
SEARCH. On curtilage, performed in an intrusive way, exceeded implied license. Drug-sniffing dog is technology (advanced tech that violates REOP)
License to enter private property
approach home, knock, wait briefly, leave if no one answers; inquiry is whether CONDUCT exceeds implied license, NOT how long it takes
Caballes
FACTS: Drug-sniffing dog alerted police to marijuana in car trunk.
NOT a search. Not very invasive; does not violate REOP; in public, unlike Jardines, limited scope of intrusion
Ciarolo
FACTS: Police plane flew 1000 feet above house to identify marijuana plants in backyard.
NOT a search. Public vantage point where they have right to be. Officers aren’t using anything technologically advanced (just looking).
Officers can view _____ from any _____.
curtilage; lawful vantage point.
Trespass definition
physical intrusion on constitutionally protected area (persons, houses, papers, effects)
REOP definition
Subjective expectation: The person actually exhibited an expectation that their activity or information would remain private (such as closing a phone booth door).
Objective expectation: Society is prepared to recognize that expectation as reasonable.
Jones
FACTS: Tracker on car for 28 days
SEARCH. Physical trespass to put tracker on the vehicle. Visual surveillance would be permissible, but this is more invasive. Car is an effect under the Fourth Amendment. The government engaged in occupying someone’s physical property for the purposes of gaining information.
Carpenter
FACTS: Police accessed 152 days of location data from D’s cell phone from phone companies (CSLI).
SEARCH. Mosaic theory—REOP in physical movements captured with cell towers. Every individual ping to the cell phone tower to the person is NOT a search. BUT with all of the pings, it’s a comprehensive portrait of a person’s movements from one moment to the next. In the aggregate, this is invasive.
Chatrie (2026)
FACTS: Police acquired Google cell phone location history data from Google.
SEARCH. Law enforcement’s acquisition of Google’s Location History data constitutes a Fourth Amendment search. They are invading a cell phone user’s REOP when they access this data without a warrant.