Details of Argument Reconstruction - Richard Feldman

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
Card Sorting

1/13

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Vocabulary flashcards covering the key terms, reconstruction techniques, and concepts from Chapter 6 of Richard Feldman's 'Reason and Argument'.

14 Terms

1
New cards

Fine-tuning a reconstruction

The process of revising and improving a preliminary argument reconstruction until it becomes a clear, concise version that states the argument in the best possible way.

2
New cards

Three common problems in argument reconstruction

The frequent errors encountered when reconstructing arguments: improperly worded reconstructions, reconstructions with missing premises, and reconstructions with unnecessary premises included.

3
New cards

Uniform wording policy

The practice of keeping wording exactly the same across related premises and conclusions to ensure the argument conforms to a valid pattern and avoids subtle, misleading shifts in meaning.

4
New cards

Standard pattern of argument

A recognized, recurring logical template (such as "All As are Bs; x is an A; therefore, x is a B") that reconstructions are shaped to fit in order to ensure they are well-formed.

5
New cards

Missing premise

A premise omitted from an informal presentation or reconstruction that is required to make the argument valid or well-formed.

6
New cards

Stating a justification

The step in argument reconstruction of labeling each line as an explicit premise (EP), an implicit premise (IP), or by noting the specific preceding line numbers from which it is derived.

7
New cards

Explicit premise (EP)

A premise that is directly and openly stated in the original informal presentation of an argument.

8
New cards

Implicit premise (IP)

An unstated premise supplied by the analyst during reconstruction to make the argument well-formed, adhering to principles of charity, generality, and faithfulness.

9
New cards

Intermediate conclusion

A statement within a complex argument that is derived from earlier steps and subsequently used as a premise to justify later steps or the final conclusion.

10
New cards

Compound argument

An argument structure made up of several linked subarguments leading through one or more intermediate conclusions to a final conclusion.

11
New cards

Unnecessary premise

A premise included in a reconstruction that plays no role, directly or indirectly, in justifying the conclusion.

12
New cards

Direct justification

Support provided by a premise when it is explicitly cited in the line justification for the final conclusion.

13
New cards

Indirect justification

Support provided by a premise when it justifies an intermediate conclusion that in turn directly or indirectly justifies the final conclusion.

14
New cards

Three steps of argument analysis

The comprehensive procedure for evaluating arguments: (1) decide if there is an argument, (2) reconstruct the argument, and (3) fine-tune the reconstruction.