Anselm's Ontological Arguments and Critiques

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/18

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Comprehensive vocabulary flashcards reviewing Anselm of Canterbury's ontological arguments, their theological and philosophical foundations, and the principal objections from Gaunilo, Averroes, and G.E. Moore.

19 Terms

1
New cards

Anselm of Canterbury

An Italian-born Benedictine monk (c.1033c.1033–11091109) recognized as the founder of Scholasticism and Archbishop of Canterbury, celebrated for formulating a priori ontological arguments for the existence of God.

2
New cards

Scholasticism

A medieval philosophical and theological movement that integrated Christian doctrine with classical philosophy, of which Anselm of Canterbury is generally recognized as the founder.

3
New cards

Investiture Controversy

A historic church-versus-state dispute between church authority and secular rulers over who had the right to appoint bishops, which resulted in Anselm twice being exiled from England.

4
New cards

The Monologium

A major philosophical treatise written by Anselm of Canterbury, subtitled 'A Monologue on the Reason for Faith.'

5
New cards

The Proslogium

A principal work written by Anselm of Canterbury, subtitled 'Discourse on the Existence of God,' in which he sets out his ontological arguments.

6
New cards

G.E. Moore

A Cambridge philosopher (18731873–19581958) who co-founded modern analytic philosophy alongside Bertrand Russell and is renowned for defending common-sense realism and ethical non-naturalism.

7
New cards

Open-Question Argument

A philosophical argument advanced by G.E. Moore in defense of ethical non-naturalism.

8
New cards

Principia Ethica

A landmark ethical treatise published by Cambridge philosopher G.E. Moore in 19031903.

9
New cards

Existence in the Understanding

In Anselm's framework, the mode of existence possessed by concepts or objects that exist within human thought or the mind (e.g., the idea of Pegasus).

10
New cards

Existence in Reality

In Anselm's framework, the mode of existence possessed by entities that exist concretely in the actual world (e.g., King Charles III or undiscovered planets).

11
New cards

Ontological Argument (First Version)

An a priori, reductio ad absurdum proof by Anselm defining God as 'that than which nothing greater can be conceived,' asserting that because real existence is greater than mere mental existence, God must exist in reality to avoid a logical contradiction.

12
New cards

Ontological Argument (Second Version)

Anselm's modal reformulation arguing that a being that cannot be conceived not to exist (necessary existence) is greater than one that can be conceived not to exist (contingent existence), concluding God cannot be conceived not to exist.

13
New cards

Necessary Existence

The property of an entity that exists so truly that it cannot be conceived not to exist, which Anselm considers greater than contingent existence.

14
New cards

Contingent Existence

The status of a being or entity that can be conceived not to exist.

15
New cards

The Lost-Island Objection

A parody objection formulated by Gaunilo arguing that if Anselm's logic holds, one could absurdly prove the actual existence of a perfect 'lost island' possessing an inestimable wealth of riches simply because existing in reality is greater than existing in the understanding alone.

16
New cards

Gaunilo

The contemporary critic of Anselm who offered the Lost-Island objection to demonstrate the alleged absurdity of the ontological argument.

17
New cards

Anselm's Reply to Gaunilo

Anselm's response that the ontological argument applies uniquely to a being than which a greater is inconceivable (God), and that finite entities like islands, rocks, or thieves cannot possess intrinsic perfection.

18
New cards

Stone Paradox

A paradox of omnipotence associated with Averroes questioning whether God can create a stone too heavy for Him to lift, demonstrating that verbal formulations may describe contradictory impossibilities rather than coherent conceivabilities.

19
New cards

Existence is Not a Property Objection

G.E. Moore's objection demonstrating that 'exists' does not function as a true predicate like 'growl,' concluding that Anselm erroneously treats existence as an attribute that makes an object greater than the idea representing it.