1/97
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Major factors leading to loan work-outs
Market deterioration
Property Uncompetitive
Reduction in CF / liquidity dries up
Market deterioration
demand contracts since there is a recession
increasing supply meets decreasing demand
demand contracts with recession
companies need less office space
shoppers spend less
less travel
what decision do borrowers make when increasing supply meets decreasing demand
tight on cash from lost revenue so do we keep funding deficits knowing we will spend money on leasing costs
leasing costs
broker commissions
TI allowance
deficit
cannot pay debt service from rents anymore because market deteriorated
types of default
payment default
repayment default
payment default
missed monthly payment like debt service
repayment default
failure to repay loan balance at maturity
Property is uncompetitive
borrower doesn’t have cash to upgrade it or pay for leasing costs
Downward spiral of having an unfunded property
prospective tenants see deterioration and go elsewhere or ask for lower rent
Examples of upgrades
landscaping
new carpeting
What happens to property when it is not upgraded
can move to lower class ratings quickly
reduction in cf / liquidity
debt service payment default
loan repayment default
capital markets correction
capital markets correction
owner cannot refinance or sell
lender won’t modify loan terms
main factor influencing loan repayment default
rising interest rates
how does rising interest rates affect loan repayment
new loan sizes are smaller
fewer buyers
new loan sizes are smaller
lenders size loans on debt coverage at the current interest rate so if interest rates rise the constant payment factor increases causing the loan value to fall
fewer buyers
capacity of capital markets isn’t large enough to take on loans that can’t be paid at loan maturity
Why do lenders not want to own properties
time consuming, deal with angry tenants and bills inherit problems borrower had
what does lender think about for loan workout
is it worth taking over ownership
if lender takes over ownership what does it need to do
assess market and outlook for property
lender hires receiver and installs management company
Receiver
hired by lender when taking property to collect rents
costly expenses of lender taking property from borrower
cost of collection
lost money from sale to new buyer
cost of collection
legal fee to collect property from borrower
Why do lenders lose money when they sell to a new buyer
the property is worth less than the debt, makes sense because if there was equity then the borrower would protect it
caveat for cost of collection
lender goes to judge for repayment of cost of collection
key financial analysis for loan workout
noi and appraised value at loan default
projected mkt conditions/cf
prevailing loan interest rate
borrower recourse and liquidity
recourse
alternative means of collection
covenant
promise
important covenant for loans
covenant to maintain a certain debt coverage ratio because it is the main margin of safety
how does lender ensure a covenant is followed
lender asks to come in and audit the property’s books
What happens if a property is outside of the covenant
lender sends a notice that they are under default and they have x amount of months to fix
mortgage financing legal documents
promissory note
assignment of rent
mortgage agreement
guaranty agreement
promissory note
document saying borrower owes this much money at this rate due at this time
assignment of rent
legal formality assigning rent to the lender as extra collateral
rent still goes to borrower to pay for recurring expenses, capital costs, and leasing
Why is mortgage agreement heavily negotiated
defines Events of Default, cure period, right to accelerate repayment, and right to foreclose
Events of Default importance
if you do not fix default within cure period allowed by mortgage agreement the lender will accelerate repayment of loan early
What happens if you do not repay accelerated loan
lender will foreclose
three types of guaranty agreement
completion guaranty
guaranty of interest above budget
guaranty of repayment
guaranty of repayment types
full recourse
limited guarantee of repayment
burns off
full recourse example
we lent 8 mil and sold for 6 mil you still owe 2 mil
limited guarantee of repayment
agreed on 1 mil of recourse so if sell for 8 mil and sell for 6 mil lender only guaranteed 1 mil
burns off
at milestones in construction projects recourse is burned off or reduced because lender risk is reduced
milestones burnsoff
completion of building
hitting leasing level at rents outlined in pro forma
what does lender do when understanding borrower liquidity
footnote personal financial statement itemizing every contingent liability borrower has
why is it important to see guarantor contingent liabilities
if guarantor has a lot of liabilities then they are at risk of not having money to get recourse when other properties fail
types of default
technical
material
conveyance
monetary
technical default
unpaid taxes and insurance
fail to give required financial reports
major tenant leaves
material default
wasting property
misapply rent or insurance proceeds
environmental contamination
material default importance
meaningful in reducing actual physical value of real estate
misapplication of rent
move revenue to another bank account instead of paying debt service or property expenses
misapplication of insurance proceeds
hurricane blows roof off and you do not replace
conveyance default
change in majority ownership without lender consent
additional liens without lender consent
conveyance default importance
lenders underwrite sponsor so if they sell their stake and lose control rights then lender can go after guarantor if they foreclose because it caused them to lose money
monetary default
fail to maintain agreed debt coverage
did not pay interest and principal when due
did not repay loan at maturity
monetary default importance
most likely to result in foreclosure
borrower options
stop paying debt service
modify loan terms
short sale property
stop paying debt service leads to
lender recourse of personal assets
modify loan terms requires what
a cash pay down on loan
modify loan terms allows for what
if term is extended the property has time to get tenants and improve
short sale requires what
lender approval
short sale property
go to lender and ask to sell for 7 mil even though they bought for 8 mil
Why is a short sale attractive
if the lender and borrower fight they incur legal fees
lender options
send event of default notice
agree to forbearance agreement
modify loan terms
sell loan
How does a lender modify loan terms
change int rate or amortization
cash flow sweep
rent does not cover interest payments so remaining interest payments accrued and rent goes to lender
what happens in forbearance agreement
lender gives a year to try and improve occupancy
lender watches CF through lockbox account which makes them a co-signatory
cash flow sweep so borrowers see no income
relation between lender and borrower in forbearance agreement
trust is damaged, lender wonders if borrower diverts CF to other projects
lockbox account
new bank account that traps cash flow and makes the bank a co-signatory
Demand Notice
all cure periods exhausted under different events of default so lender accelerates loan and demands full repayment
Lender sells the loan known as what
known loss today for unknown loss tomorrow
Lender sells the loan as a business
lender sells loan to another party for discount and writes off loss
recourse is available on total loan amount
new lender negotiates discounted payoff to borrower and can accept anything above purchase price
New lender has what when they buy the loan from og lender
negotiating power with the borrower, borrower does not know how big of a discount they got
why would a lender sell the loan
cut loss because ran up legal bills or has not been getting full int payments for a prolonged amount of time
largest categories of inflation and expenses
insurance premiums
utilities
Reasons for downside case of loan modification
rents lower
softer market, vacancy increase and expected returns increase
inflation of expenses
2 ways borrower can get out from loan
foreclose
deed
caveats for foreclosure to get out from loan
reputational damage
costly
deed
evidence of ownership in lieu of foreclosure
caveat for deed in lieu of foreclosure
IRS sees as debt forgiveness, so you owe 20% capital gains tax on loan amount forgiven
Why does IRS put tax on deed in lieu of foreclosure
disincentivize people from defaulting instead of restructuring
cash pay down
avoid foreclosure by paying down loan since current NOI only supports smaller loan at required debt coverage
caveat for cash pay down
borrower has alternative of moving the paydown to t bills
what does lender give in return for paydown
lender takes interest payments only on new loan until property is back on its feet
why is lender incentivized to take interest only payments
they need to pay interest to depositors and overhead on bills
they keep loan afloat
issues in default situation for lender
uncertain if loan file complete
deferred maintenance cost
environmental liability
loan file complete
if property struggled then reports are usually out of date, need accurate rent roll
deferred maintenance costs
reserves for replacements build up so capital improvements can be made
Build up of reserves for replacements goes to who
goes to lender as additional collateral for loan but usually inadequate if well maintained wouldnt foreclose
environmental liability
dont want contaminated site, once you buy you need to clean
tradeoffs in foreclosure
lots of money lost but lots of money made in buying at deep discount
2 ways foreclosure happens
administrative
judicial
administrative
lender schedules and publishes foreclosure date, needs to have public notice
Who does lender hire in administrative foreclosure
company that owns foreclosure sets, auctioneer gets info they can obtain and publishes it for prospective buyers
judicial foreclosure
go to judge and judge adminsters foreclosure
deficiency judgement
lender sues for deficiency judgement if property sold at loss and can collect remaining unpaid balance on secured loan
What happens to capital in foreclosure
Joint venture equity loses investment
all subordinate capital loses money