evaluative points

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/7

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

8 Terms

1
New cards

Discuss the role of chromosomes and hormones in sex and gender A01

Chromosomes determine biological sex — 23rd pair, XX female, XY male; the Y chromosome carries the SRY gene, triggering testes development and testosterone production. Hormones: testosterone (male sex hormone, influences sex organs and possibly aggression), oestrogen (female sex hormone, menstruation, secondary sexual characteristics), oxytocin (women produce more, associated with childbirth and bonding, possibly reducing cortisol).

2
New cards

Discuss the role of chromosomes and hormones in sex and gender A03

  • Strength — supporting evidence: David Reimer (biological boy raised as girl after circumcision accident) rejected female identity and later lived as male → suggests biology has a stronger influence than socialisation. Counter: he was told the truth as a teen, so it's a case study — poor generalisability.

  • Weakness - other affecting factors than chromosones and hormones Deeming and Ferguson (1989) arranged for the incubation of alligator eggs at varying temperatures to see how this affected biological sex when they hatched. They found that when the eggs were incubated at 30 degrees (C), 100% of the eggs produced biological females, and when the eggs were incubated at 33 degrees (C), 100% of the eggs produced biological males.

  • Limitation — the explanation is reductionist and biologically deterministic. It explains gender purely in terms of chromosomes and hormones, ignoring social learning theory (imitation and reinforcement of gender roles) and cognitive explanations (gender schema theory). It's also deterministic because it implies our gender is fixed by biology before birth, leaving no room for choice or experience — yet David Reimer's case shows biology alone doesn't settle gender identity. This means the explanation is incomplete on its own and is better seen as one part of a broader interactionist account.


3
New cards

"Discuss diversity in sex development" / "Discuss atypical sex chromosome patterns." A01

AO1 (6): Atypical development includes Klinefelter's syndrome (XXY — 1 in 500–1000 males; reduced body hair, breast development, long limbs, infertility, shyness, poor reading/spatial skills) and Turner's syndrome (XO — 1 in 5000 females; no ovaries, no menstruation, short stature, webbed neck, socially immature, good reading but poor spatial/maths skills). Also mention intersex conditions / DSDs where chromosomal, gonadal or anatomical sex is not clearly male or female.

4
New cards

"Discuss diversity in sex development" / "Discuss atypical sex chromosome patterns." A03

  • Strength — real-world application: Knowledge of these conditions allows earlier diagnosis and support (e.g. hormone replacement therapy for Turner's (no control group as it was unethical), testosterone for Klinefelter's), improving quality of life.

  • Strength — challenges the XX/XY dichotomy: shows sex is a spectrum, so simple biological explanations of gender are incomplete; supports a more interactionist view.

  • Limitation — research issues: small samples, often clinical/self-selected, poor generalisability; the syndromes are rare so findings may not apply broadly. Also ethical concerns about labelling and about how these conditions have historically been treated (e.g. involuntary surgery on intersex infants).


5
New cards

"Discuss gender identity" / "Discuss Bem's Sex Role Inventory" / "Discuss androgyny and Bem's SRI." A01

AO1 (6): Androgyny = high levels of both masculine and feminine traits, associated with psychological wellbeing and flexibility. Bem's SRI (1974) — 20 masculine, 20 feminine, 20 neutral traits rated on a 7-point scale; produces four categories: masculine, feminine, androgynous, undifferentiated. Bem argued androgynous individuals are better adjusted and more adaptable.

6
New cards

"Discuss gender identity" / "Discuss Bem's Sex Role Inventory" / "Discuss androgyny and Bem's SRI." A03

  • Strength — supporting evidence: Bem (1975) found androgynous individuals were more adaptable across situations; Flaherty et al. found androgyny linked to greater wellbeing → supports the benefits of androgyny.

  • Limitation — validity of the SRI: self-report questionnaire → social desirability bias, and it measures traits, not actual behaviour; also culturally biased (traits reflect Western, middle-class stereotypes) and may be outdated.

  • Limitation — the concept itself is contested: the "androgyny is better" claim is not consistently supported (some studies find masculinity, not androgyny, predicts wellbeing); also assumes traits are fixed and ignores cultural change in gender roles.

  • the SRI is outdated because it assumes a binary of masculine and feminine traits and doesn't capture non-binary or gender-fluid identities, which limits its validity today


7
New cards

Discuss biological explanations of gender development" / "Discuss genetic and hormonal influences on gender." A01

AO1 (6): Biological explanations include genetic factors (SRY gene on Y chromosome), hormonal influences (testosterone in utero, organising effects on brain development; oestrogen), and evolutionary explanations (e.g. male aggression/competition, female nurturing). Reference to brain sex differences (e.g. sexually dimorphic nucleus) can be included.

8
New cards

"Discuss biological explanations of gender development" / "Discuss genetic and hormonal influences on gender." A03

  • Strength — evidence from animal studies: Young (1966) and Quadagno et al. (1977) — female monkeys given testosterone prenatally showed male-typical behaviour → supports hormonal organising effects.

  • Strength — evidence from human atypical development: CAH girls (exposed to high androgen prenatally) show more male-typical play; David Reimer case → supports biological influence.

  • Limitation — ignores social/cognitive factors: social learning theory and gender schema theory also explain gender development; biological explanations are reductionist and deterministic, and human evidence is often correlational or based on small/clinical samples, so causation is unclear.