1/27
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Gender differences in starting school
In 2013 teacher assessments showed girls ahead of boys between seven and 17 percentage points in 7 areas of learning assessed including literacy language maths personal social and emotional development Girls were also better boys than concentrating DFE 2013 study found that in state primary schools boys were two and a half times more likely than girls to have statements of special need education
Key Stage 1 2 3
Girls do you consistently better than boys this is especially so in English with a gender gap steadily widens with age incense and Maths the gap is much narrower but girls still do better
at gcse, the gap stands around …% points
10
At AS and A level
while boys have ocassionally edged slightly ahead, females take the lead overall, and are more likely to sit, pass and get higher grades than boys, though the gap is much narrower than at gcse. even in so called ‘boy’ subjects such as physics and maths girls were more likely to get a grade A-C
On vocational subjects
large proportions of girls achieve distinction in every subject, including subjects like engineering and construction.
impact of feminism
feminist movements have challenged traditional stereotypes of a woman’s role as a mother and housewife.the feminist movements have considerable success in improving women’s rights and the opportunities through changes in the law. mcrobbies 1994 studies of girls magazines found that often older magazines showed images of women being married but now there are images of assertive independant women.
this change may affect girls self image and ambitions and encourage them to do well in education as the reliance on men depletes
changes in the family
increase in divorce rate
increase in cohabitation and a decrease in the number of first marriages
increase in the number of lone parent famillies
smaller famillies
these changes are affecting girls attitudes towards education, such as the increase of female lone parent fammillies may mean that more women need to take on the breadwinner role. this creates a new independant role model for girls - financially independant. women need well paid jobs and a good education to achieve this. increase in divorce may show that reliance on men isnt needed anymore encouraging girls to look to themselves and their own qualifications to make a living
changes to womens emloyment
the 1970 equal pay act makes it illegal to pay women less than men for work of the same value and the 1975 sex discrimination act outlaws discrimination at work
since 1975, the pay gap between women and men have halved from 30% to 15%
the proportion of women in education has risen from 53% in 1971 to 72% in late 2025
some women are now breaking through the ‘glass ceiling’ that prevents them from getting high level professional and managerial jobs
greater career opportunities and better pay for women provide incentives for women to gain an education
girls changing ambitions
sharpe 1994 interviwed girls in 1970s - low aspirarions, educational success was unfeminine and appearing to be ambitious would be unattractive, had priorities as love, marriage,husbands, childrens, jobs
1990s- careers and supporting themselves was the priority. they saw futyres as indeendant woman
oconnors 2006 study of 14-17 year olds found that marriage and children were not part of their major life plans
fullers 2011 study found that educational success was part of their identity, seeing themselves as creators of their own future, and individualised notion of seld beleieved in meritocracy and aimed for professional careers.
ambition related to class
WC girls often still had a stereotyped aspiration for marriage and children and expected to go into traditional low paid womens work. reay 1998 argues that thsi reflects their low job opportunities they think is available to them, and they think that a traditional gender identity offers them a source of status
biggart 2002 found that - wc girls are wmore likely to face a precaurious position in the labourmarket ans see motherhood as the only viable option for their futures.
internal factors - equal opportunity policies
policymakers aremmuch more aware of gender issues and avoid stereotyping, policies such as GIST and WISE encorurage girls to pursue education in non traditional areas. Female scientists visit schools acting as role models, and now non sexist careers advice is given . learning materials of women in non traditional careers are given and mainstream
the introduction of the national curicculum in 1988 removed one source of gender inequality by making girls and boys study the same subjects which wasnt the case previously
positive role models
increase in female teachers/heads. women in senior roles may act as role models for girls, showing them that women can achieve postions of importance, non traditional goals to aim for
teachers often take a lengthy and successful education career themselves
GCSE and courswork
changes in assesssment have favourd girls and disadvantaged boys, for example, Gorard 2005 found that the gender gap in achievement was fairly constant until 1989 when gcses were introduced, bringing in courswork. gorard argues that this is ‘product of the changed system instead of the general failure of boys’
mitsos and browne 1998
girls are more sucessful in courswork because they are better organised
they
spend more time on their work
careful with the way its presented
are better at meeting deadlines
bring the right material into lesson
also oral exams favour girls because they have better developed language skills
why are they like this
early gender role socialisationin the family. girls are encouraged to be neat and tidy, ultimatley coming in use when its time for assessments
elwood 2005 argues that it cant be coursework alone, instead it is a ramge of factors causing the gender gap
teacher attention
french 1993 assessed clasroom interaction and found boys recieve more attention because they attracted more reprimands
francis 2001 found that while boys got more attention, they were disciplined more harshly and felt picked on, tending to have lower expectations of them
swann 2998 found gender differenced in communication styles. boys dominate in whole class discussuons whereas girls prefer pair work and group work and are better at listening and co operating
this may explain why teachers respond more positively to girls who are cooperative than to boys who are distruptive. this may lead to a self fuffilling prophecy.
external - changes to stereotypes in the curiculum
research found that reading schemes in 1970’s and 1980s found that reading schemes often portrayed women as mainly housewives and mothers, and physics books schowerd them as frieghtened by science/ weiner 1995 argues that since the 1980s teachers have challenged such stereotypes and sexist images have been removed from learning materials
external - selection and league tables
marketisation policies have created a more competitive climate in which schools see girls as desirable recruits because they have better exam results
jackson 1998 notes that the introduction of league tables have improved the opportunities for girls, as they are often attractive to schools.
slee argues that boys are less attractive because they are more likely to suffer from behavioural difficulties and 4x more likely to be excluded. boys are often seen as liability students
liberal feminists - views on girls achievement
celebrate the proress made so far in improving achievement. believe that further progress will be made by continuing equal opportunity policies, encouraging positive role models and overcoming sexist attitudes and stereotypes. similar to functionalists view that education is mertocratic
radical feminists view
emphasise the system remains patriarchal
sexual harrassment of girls in school
education still limits girls subject choicesand career options
male teachers are still more likely to be heads of secondary schools
women are still underrepresented in many aspects of the curiculum weiner describes school history as a ‘woman free zone’
In 2013 how much garbs from poor families achieved five a stars ccgcse grades
40.6% of girls from poorer families whereas 67.5% of those not in free schools mealsdid so
Symbolic capital Luis Archer 2010 on the reason for differences in the conflict between working class feminine identities and the value of Ethos in the school
Studying working class goals Archer to use the concept of symbolic capital to understand this conflict referring to the status recognition when sense of worth that we are able to obtain from others and ultra fun that working class feminine identities were performed and girls gained symbolic capital from the peers however this brought them into conflict with school preventing them from acquiring educational capital and economic capital Archer identifies several strategies that girls followed for creating a valued sense of self these included hyperextrose sexual feminine identity and being loud
Hyper heterosexual feminine identities
Many girls invested considerable time effort and money in constructing cerebral and glamorous hyper heterosexual feminine identities for example one girl spent all of the 40 pounds so we actually earned from babysitting on her appearance the gods performance of this feminine identity but status from the female peer group and avoided them being ridiculed or being called a trump for wearing the wrong brand
however it bought them into conflict with the school for example they were often punished for having the wrong appearance too much jewelry and the wrong clothing or makeup and teachers saw the gospel occupation with their parents to the destruction that prevented them from engaging with education
this LED to the school otherwing the girls defining them as not one of us incapable of Educational success and less worthy of respect bordeiu simply describes this process as symbolic violence which is harm done by denying someone's symbolic capital for example defining their culture as worthless
Being loud
Some working class gold adopted loud feminine identities that often led them to be outspoken independence and assertive for example questioning teachers authority this filled to conform to the school's stereotype of the ideal female pupil identity is passive and submissive to authority and bought conflict with the teachers who interpreted their behavior as aggressive rather than assertive
Working class girls dilemma
Gaining symbolic capital from the peers by conforming to a hypersexual feminine identity or gaining educational capital by rejecting the working class identity and conforming to the schools in the middle class notions our respectable ideal female people
Sarah Evans 2009 study of 21 working class six form girls in a South London Comprehensive School
Girls wanted to go to university increase their earning power however this was not for themselves but to help their families as one goal said the one thing I want to do is to give something back to my family the gods are motivations reflected they're working class feminine identities
skegs 1997 notes caring is a crucial part of their identity
moreover most of them want to live at home from economic necessity as the cost and fear of getting into debt on major issues for many working class students in deciding which universities to apply to however while living at home made higher education more affordable it also limited the choice of university and market value of the degree
Archer 2010 shows up for local is a key feature of the working class habitualist
Boys and literacy
According to the dcsf 2007 the gender Cup is mainly the result of voice poor electricity and language skills one reason for this may be that parents spend less time reading for their sons another maybe that is mothers you do most of Reading to children in addition boys leisure Pursuits such as football do little to help develop their language and communication skills by contrast girls tend to have a bedroom culture Center on staying in and talking with their friends poor language and literacy skills are likely to affect boys performance across a wide range of subjects in response to this problem government have introduced a range of policies to improve boys skills
Globalisation and the decline of traditional men's jobs
Since the 1980s has been a significant decline in Heavy Industries such as iron and steel Shipbuilding mining and Engineering as a result of globalization and manufacturing industry relocating to developing countries such as China to take advantage of cheap labor traditionally these sectors of the economy mainly employed men mitzos and brown claim that this the kind of male employment opportunities has led to identity crisis for men many boys now believe little prospect of getting a proper job this undermines the motivation and self-esteem and so they give up trying to get qualifications while there may be some truth to this claim we should note that the client has largely been in manual working class jobs that require a few if any qualifications this it seems unlikely that the disappearance of such jobs would have much impact on the boys motivation to obtain qualifications