Rhetoric, Argumentation, and Rhetorical Criticism

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/82

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Practice vocabulary flashcards defining key concepts, models, fallacies, and methodologies across argumentation, rhetorical dependency, narrative criticism, pentadic criticism, and feminist criticism.

83 Terms

1
New cards

Argument as a Thing

Speech exchanged between participants where one person presents a claim and supports it with evidence.

2
New cards

Argument as a Relationship

The way cultural norms, rituals, and learning shape how arguments function socially within a given cultural context.

3
New cards

Question of Fact

A claim type that corresponds to the forensic Aristotelian genre and focuses on whether something is true or false.

4
New cards

Question of Value

A claim type that corresponds to the epideictic Aristotelian genre and deals with praise, blame, or the relative worth of ideas.

5
New cards

Question of Policy

A claim type that corresponds to the deliberative Aristotelian genre and advocates for a future course of action.

6
New cards

Syllogism

A form of longform deductive reasoning consisting of a major premise, a minor premise, and a conclusion, where all logical steps are explicitly stated.

7
New cards

Enthymeme

A persuasive argument in which one or more premises are omitted, leaving the audience to supply the missing premise in their own minds.

8
New cards

Monroe’s Motivated Sequence

A five-step structure for persuasive appeals consisting of Attention, Need, Satisfaction, Visualization, and Call to Action.

9
New cards

Presumption

The default belief that a claim or existing position is true unless sufficient contravening evidence is presented.

10
New cards

Burden of Proof

The obligation placed on the party making an affirmative claim or bringing charges to provide strong enough reasons to overcome presumption.

11
New cards

Universal Audience

An imagined audience composed of all reasonable and rational beings, used for messages intended for broad public reception.

12
New cards

Particular Audience

A real-world audience characterized by specific, concrete values, attitudes, and cultural traditions.

13
New cards

Goodnight’s Three Spheres of Argument

A classification of communicative spaces dividing arguments into the personal sphere (informal), technical sphere (formal/expert), and public sphere (broad public debate).

14
New cards

Toulmin Model

A framework for analyzing or constructing individual arguments using primary elements (claim, data, warrant) and secondary elements (backing, qualifier, rebuttal).

15
New cards

Warrant (Toulmin)

The component of the Toulmin model that provides the logical connection and justification linking the data to the claim.

16
New cards

Backing (Toulmin)

Additional support, justification, or credentials provided specifically to substantiate the warrant in a Toulmin argument.

17
New cards

Logical Dependency

The structural relationship showing how one claim requires another claim to be true before it can stand.

18
New cards

Convergent Support

An argument structure in which multiple independent reasons separately support the same main claim.

19
New cards

Linked Support

An argument structure where two or more reasons only work together to support a claim, collapsing if any single reason is removed.

20
New cards

Serial Support

A chain of reasoning in which one claim serves as the premise that supports a subsequent claim, which then supports another.

21
New cards

Non Sequitur

A fallacy where the conclusion or claim does not logically follow from the evidence presented.

22
New cards

Hasty Generalization

A fallacy characterized by drawing a broad, serial conclusion based on insufficient or unrepresentative evidence.

23
New cards

Begging the Question

A circular reasoning fallacy where an argument relies on linked support that merely restates the claim as its own premise.

24
New cards

Straw Person

A fallacy that involves misrepresenting or oversimplifying an opponent’s argument to make it easier to attack.

25
New cards

Slippery Slope

A fallacy that assumes taking an initial step will inevitably trigger a chain reaction leading to extreme or catastrophic consequences.

26
New cards

False Cause

A fallacy that mistakes mere correlation or temporal sequence for direct causation.

27
New cards

Ad Hominem

A classical fallacy where an arguer attacks the character or personal traits of an opponent rather than addressing their argument.

28
New cards

Textual Analysis

The close reading of rhetorical artifacts to uncover how meaning is constructed, conveyed, and ideologically situated.

29
New cards

Cherry-Picking

The flawed analytical practice of selecting only convenient evidence that supports a thesis while ignoring structural nuances, omissions, or contradictory text.

30
New cards

Whole-Text Integrity

An analytical standard requiring critics to account for the entire text, including tone shifts, policy claims, emotional appeals, and internal contradictions.

31
New cards

Corpus Consistency

The principle of selecting multiple artifacts using transparent, balanced criteria that include both typical and atypical examples, rather than only confirming cases.

32
New cards

Mapping the Terrain

The preliminary step in rhetorical criticism where a critic examines the surrounding environment—including rhetor, audience, and occasion—before textual analysis.

33
New cards

Narrative Paradigm

Walter Fisher's rhetorical theory asserting that all humans are storytellers who evaluate discourse through good reasons rather than formal logic alone.

34
New cards

Narrative Rationality

The standard used to evaluate stories, comprised of two components: narrative probability and narrative fidelity.

35
New cards

Narrative Probability

A test of narrative rationality evaluating whether a story is internally coherent, consistent with itself, believable, and free of contradictions.

36
New cards

Narrative Fidelity

A test of narrative rationality assessing whether a story rings true to the audience's experiences and represents accurate assertions about reality.

37
New cards

Kernels (Narrative)

Essential narrative events that form the core structure and plot points necessary to the story's progression.

38
New cards

Satellites (Narrative)

Nonessential narrative elements and descriptive details that enhance understanding without altering the fundamental plot.

39
New cards

Dramatic Pentad

A systematic rhetorical framework designed to analyze motive in human action through five terms: act, scene, agent, agency, and purpose.

40
New cards

Act (Pentad)

The element of the pentad identifying what was done or what took place in thought or deed.

41
New cards

Scene (Pentad)

The element of the pentad identifying the background, context, situation, time, or location in which an act occurred.

42
New cards

Agent (Pentad)

The element of the pentad identifying who performed the action, including their nature, co-agents, or counter-agents.

43
New cards

Agency (Pentad)

The element of the pentad identifying the means, tools, or instruments used to perform the act.

44
New cards

Purpose (Pentad)

The element of the pentad identifying the conscious reason, objective, or motive for performing the act.

45
New cards

Pentadic Ratio

A paired comparison between any two elements of the pentad (such as scene-act or agent-purpose) used to determine how one term shapes, justifies, or explains the other.

46
New cards

Sex (Feminist Criticism)

Biological characteristics determined predominantly by anatomy, hormones, and chromosomes, categorized as male or female.

47
New cards

Gender (Feminist Criticism)

Cultural conceptualizations of roles and traits, such as masculinity and femininity, which vary across societies and historical eras.

48
New cards

Gender Identity

A broad spectrum reflecting how individuals identify and perceive themselves, which may align with or differ from sex assigned at birth.

49
New cards

Paternalistic Rhetoric

A historically dominant rhetorical tradition centered on white male authority that historically silenced, ridiculed, or invalidated feminist and women's speech.

50
New cards

What are the 3 spheres of argument identified by G. Thomas Goodnight?

  1. the personal sphere

  2. the technical sphere

  3. the public sphere


51
New cards

What are the main characteristics of the personal sphere?

  • place of limited circulation and informal reasoning

  • participants are laypeople and non-experts

  • uses enthymemes rather than formal syllogisms

  • involves limited demands of proof and focuses on private topics among a small number of people


52
New cards

what are the main characteristics of the technical sphere?

  • features expert participants who use formal reasoning

  • participants belong to a shared community where they can vet each other’s arguments

  • has explicit rules for argument and is judged by subject-matter experts

  • like the personal sphere, arguments have limited circulation


53
New cards

What are the main characteristics of the public sphere?

  • the widest sphere of argument circulation

  • exists to handle disagreements that transcend personal and technical disputes

  • a place where arguments escaping the personal or technical spheres can be interpreted, misinterpreted, and negotiated


54
New cards

What is the primary purpose and scope of the Toulmin Model?

  • imagines arguments as objects of verbal exchange

  • useful for individual claims, paragraphs, or single sentences

  • serves as a tool to diagnose the strengths and weaknesses of individual arguments


55
New cards

What are the 3 primary elements of the Toulmin model?

  1. Claim: A contestable statement based on data/evidence.

  2. Data (or Evidence): The foundational information supporting the claim.

  3. Warrant (or Reasoning): The logical connection between the data and the claim.


56
New cards

What are the 3 secondary elements of the Toulmin Model?

  1. Qualifier: Softens the claim by making it conditional.

  2. Rebuttal: Offers likely counterarguments to the major claim.

  3. Backing: Evidence that proves the warrant itself is sound.


57
New cards

What are the primary rhetorical functions/purposes of narratives?

  • They are reflections of an audience's values and dominant ideologies (a story is never just a story).

  • They reflect contemporary problems, ways of envisioning the future, and the perspectives of the tellers.

  • They shape public memory, help us remember the past, and organize how we interpret everyday public events.


58
New cards

What is the difference between the diegesis and the extra-diegesis in a narrative?

  • Diegesis: The inside of the narrative, encompassing elements that occur directly within the timeline and scope of the story's events.

  • Extra-diegesis: The outside of the narrative, referring to elements or events that fall outside the timeline or scope of the story (such as historical context preceding the story, or cinematic elements only perceptible to the audience).


59
New cards

How do diegetic and extra-diegetic sounds differ in film?

  • Diegetic Sound: Sounds that are audible to both the characters within the story and the audience (e.g., characters splashing in the water in Jaws).

  • Extra-diegetic Sound: Sounds that are only audible to the audience watching, not to the characters on screen (e.g., the ominous "Jaws" theme music playing to build tension).


60
New cards

What is Kenneth Burke's dramatism, and what is its primary question?

  • An analysis of human motivation through terms derived from the study of drama.

  • Primary question: "What is involved, when we say what people are doing and why they are doing it?"


61
New cards

What is the difference between motion and action in dramatism?

  • Motion: The biological/nonsymbolic aspect of humans (e.g., bodily processes like digestion, breathing, and requiring food/shelter).

  • Action: The symbolic/neurological aspect of humans involving language, symbols, and choices (e.g., politics, religion, finance). Note: Action requires motion, but motion can exist without action.


62
New cards

What are the three conditions necessary for action?

  • Freedom or Choice: Must involve some capacity to choose (otherwise it's mechanical behavior).

  • Purpose: Consciously or unconsciously selecting one option over others.

  • Motion: Symbolic activity must be grounded in the physical/nonsymbolic realm.


63
New cards

What are terministic screens according to Burke?

  • The vocabularies and terms we select to describe the world, acting like a screen that directs our attention to certain aspects of reality rather than others.

  • They constitute a selection and deflection of reality and reveal a rhetor's worldview and motives.


64
New cards

What are the five elements of Burke’s Pentad?

  • Act: What took place (in thought or deed).

  • Scene: The background or situation in which the act occurred.

  • Agent: The person or kind of person who performed the act.

  • Agency: The means or instruments used to perform the act.

  • Purpose: Why the act was performed. (Sometimes attitude is included as a sixth element).


65
New cards

What are the primary operations a critic performs when analyzing an artifact using the pentad?

  • Labeling the five terms internal to the text from the perspective of the rhetor.

  • Applying the ratios of the terms to identify the dominant term.

  • Identifying motive derived from that dominant term.


66
New cards

What are ecofeminists, and what is their core argument?

They link women's oppression to the destruction of the environment, viewing Earth as having a female essence capable of healing both human interaction and nature.

67
New cards

How do cultural feminists view the differences between women and men?

They believe women and men differ primarily because culture shapes individuals, and that women's traditional roles socialize them into nurturing, supportive behaviors.

68
New cards

What is the perspective of power feminists (or power feminism)?

They reject viewing women as victims, instead encouraging women to actively seek power and use it responsibly.

69
New cards

Who are womanists, and what do they emphasize?

They are women of color who argue that understanding the intersection of race and gender is essential to addressing the oppression of women of color.

70
New cards

What do girlie feminists (also called lipstick or cupcake feminists) embrace?

They embrace both feminist politics and traditionally feminine activities and products, such as makeup, baking, crafting, and pedicures.

71
New cards

What is the focus of transnational feminists?

How global capitalism has created relations of inequality for people across different nations, races, genders, classes, and sexualities.

72
New cards

According to theorist bell hooks, what characterizes the ideology of domination?

The belief in a notion of superior and inferior, and its concomitant ideology—that the superior should rule over the inferior.

73
New cards

What is Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw’s intersectionality thesis?

A concept that calls attention to interlocking and intermeshing oppressions, pointing out how gender and race interact in unique and plural ways.

74
New cards

What are the three key values feminists emphasize to disrupt the ideology of domination?

  1. Equality

  2. Immanent value

  3. Self-determination


75
New cards

What is the core assumption and purpose of generic criticism?

  • Assumption: Certain types of situations provoke similar needs and expectations in audiences, calling for particular kinds of rhetoric.

  • Purpose: To discover commonalities in rhetorical patterns across recurring situations and understand rhetorical practices across different times and places.


76
New cards

What are the three key elements that combine to form a unique rhetorical genre?

  • Situational Requirements: Conditions in a situation that call for particular rhetorical responses.

  • Substantive and Stylistic Characteristics: The content (substantive) and form/style (stylistic) chosen by the rhetor.

  • Organizing Principle: The root term or key idea that serves as an umbrella label for the internal dynamic connecting the situational, substantive, and stylistic features.


77
New cards

How do Aristotle's classical types of discourse differ in their aims and strategies?

  • Deliberative (Political): Aimed at expedience; uses exhortation and dissuasion.

  • Forensic (Legal): Aimed at justice; uses accusation and defense.

  • Epideictic (Ceremonial): Aimed at honor; uses praise and blame.


78
New cards

Who introduced the term generic criticism to the communication discipline, and what were its initial tenets?

Edwin Black (1965): Proposed a generic frame with three tenets: (1) a limited number of situations exist for a rhetor; (2) a limited number of ways exist to respond rhetorically; and (3) recurring situational types provide information on available rhetorical responses.

79
New cards

How did Lloyd F. Bitzer’s notion of the rhetorical situation (1968) contribute to generic criticism?

His focus on recurring situations highlighted that comparable situations prompt comparable responses, which gives birth to rhetorical forms and establishes a special vocabulary, grammar, and style.

80
New cards

What did Carolyn R. Miller argue in her influential 1984 essay "Genre as Social Action"?

She argued that a rhetorically sound definition of genre must be centered not just on substance or form, but on action—viewing genres as ways of recognizing, responding to, and helping to reproduce recurrent social situations.

81
New cards

Creating meaning with language

  • language is more than words

    • people do not simply hear information. they interpret meaning through the words a speaker chooses. Consider the difference:

      • “My grandfather died” OR “my grandfather’s influence continues through the lessons he left behind.”

  • Both statements describe the same reality, but they create very different impressions. One helps the audience understand why something matters.

  • For special occasion speeches, ask yourself:

    • what do i want my audience to think?

    • What do I want my audience to feel?

    • What words best create that response?

  • Remember: the words you choose help your audience decide why something matters. Choose your words intentionally with emotional effect.


82
New cards

Clarity Beats Complexity

  • great speakers are easy to understand: no one has ever been criticized or lost points on an assignment for being too clear

  • Choose language that is: familiar, concrete, direct

  • Your audience only hears your speech once. They cannot:

    • re-read a sentence

    • look up a word

    • ask you to repeat something

  • Which version is better for an effective speech?

    • my teacher was really good

    • my teacher demonstrated exceptional pedagogical effectiveness and prowess.

    • my teacher made difficult ideas and concepts understandable.

  • Helpful rule: don’t try to sound smart or artistic. Be creative with your words but try to have your thoughts and feelings understood clearly most of all.


83
New cards

Make your language memorable

  • Vivid Language Helps Audiences Remember. Show, Don't Just Tell

    • Plain: "She was hardworking.”

    • Vivid: "She was the first person in the office every morning and was always the last person to leave.“

    • Plain: “He was generous.”

    • Vivid: “It seems like he never lived a day without helping someone out in some small way.”

Two Style Techniques Often Used In Ceremonial Speeches: Repetition and Parallel Structure

  • "We remember. We appreciate. We celebrate.” Repeated structure emphasizes important ideas.

  • "She led with integrity, served with humility, and inspired with compassion.” Parallel wording creates rhythm and makes ideas easier to remember.

  • You don’t need to be a poet, but memorable lines that sound intentional may be helpful.



As You Write Your Special Occasion Speech, ask yourself:

  • Is my message clear and providing proper imagery?\

  • Will the audience understand it immediately?

  • Is there a phrase or moment they will remember afterward?



Bottom Line: Strong special occasion speeches are clear, meaningful, and memorable.