Scientific explanations of NDEs

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/3

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

4 Terms

1
New cards

Dying Brain Theory

  • Dr Susan Blackmore in her book ‘Dying To Live’

  • the “sameness” evidence of following the path towards the light, suggest that NDEs are functions of the dying brain

  • All brains, regardless of where they came from, die in the same way

  • Neurotransmitters in the brain are shutting down and creating the same lovely illusions for all who are near death


2
New cards

Hallucination Theory

  • suggested that dying secrets endorphins, hormones which act on the CNS to supress pain and which are known to create “runner’s high” - which happens when long distance runners go through a pain barrier and find themselves running with ease and without tiredness, and with a feeling of elation

  • HOWEVER endorphins are not hallucinogens and cannot recreate a state similar to NDEs, so even though they may be involved in the process as a painkiller, they are not responsible for the whole experience

  • ketamine can also produce many of the features of a NDE, particularly the out of body element. The theory being that ketamine-like substances may be released by the body at the time of a NDE

  • Dr Ronald Siegel from UCLA claims to have reproduced NDEs by giving LSD to volunteers.

  • HOWEVER others suggest that though drug induced hallucinations may have some resemblance to NDEs, they are not the same, as drug induced hallucinations often evoke fearful and paranoid experiences

  • For many it is easier to believe NDEs are real afterlife experiences and not mass hallucinations (e.g. many report being told “Your mission has been completed”)


3
New cards

Temporal Lobe Theory

  • some features of NDEs known to occur in a TLE

  • by electrically stimulating the lobe they can mimic some of the elements of NDEs, such as leaving ones self behind or sense of life’s memories flashing past

  • some evidence to support this theory in the lower number of NDEs reported by people who suffer strokes which affect this part of the brain, or have tumours in this area

  • HOWEVER characteristic emotions that arise from temporal lobe simulation are fear, sadness and loneliness not calm and love like NDEs

  • HOWEVER just because a chemical mechanism is present in the brain, this does not mean NDEs are strictly chemical reactions. Science may be only describing the aspects of dying that deal with the brain


4
New cards

Lack of Oxygen Theory

  • or too much carbon dioxide, in the brain

  • HOWEVER would not be able to explain how patients can give ful and cogent reports of things that went on around them during their NDE

  • Dr Michael Sabom has reported one patient who, while having a NDE, had both high oxygen and low carbon dioxide

  • Hallucinations produced by an oxygen-starved brain are more chaotic and much more similar to psychotic hallucinations, than NDEs (confusion, disorientation and fear rather than tranquility and sense of order)

  • Hallucinations almost always take place while the subject is awake and conscious, while NDEs happen during unconsciousness, sometimes when the subject is so close to death that no record of brain activity is recorded on an electroencephalograph (machine that monitors brain waves)