1/43
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Ways to bring a lease to an end, incl…:
X5
Break clause
Merge of FH & LH (i.e. T buys FH/ Someone buys both)
serve a notice to quit (periodic tenancies)
Effluxion of time (lease expires)
Surrender (T hands back lease to LL
Effluxion of time - with a protected tenancy; the tenant can…
& then the tenancy can…
‘Hold over’
& then the tenancy can only be brought to an end with one of the prescribed notices - s.25 / 26/ 27
With other tenancies (other than protected), if the tenant remains in occupation past expiry of the lease, with the consent of the LL, …
If rent is paid periodically?
The tenancy becomes a tenancy at will
It may become an implied periodic tenancy
Surrendering = where…
LL?
Tenant?
LL and T bring lease to end & both agree; if LL wants to end early, may need to pay a premium to the T To compensate for loss of premises (=effectively paying for LH interest back)
& if T wants to end early; they may need to pay a reverse premium to the LL to compensate for the loss of rent
Surrendering - what if both parties want the lease to end early?
May be no premium paid
A surrender releases…
& need to take care not to…
Both LL and T from their ongoing obligations under the lease
Release prev obligs unless have been satisfied in full i.e. T paid rent in full up to date of surrender.
2 types of surrendering
express surrender (by deed)
By operation of law - T/LL act in way inconsistent w continuation of lease
LL’s remedies?
damages
Action for debt
Guarantor (i.e. AGA, personal guarantee)
Rent deposit
CRAR - commercial rent arrears recovery,
Forfeiture
Specific performance, injunction
Self help
Remedies for rent arrears/ non payment of rent
debt action (in court)
CRAR
Damages - what will LL get?
Cost of reduction in value to LL’s premises
NOT cost to repair
Action in debt
court invovlement?
What can you claim back?
How far back?
& debt can be claimed from…
Could also deduct from…
yes
All monies owed
6 years
A former tenant (i.e. old lease, or AGA for new lease)
Rent deposit if there is one
CRAR
court involvement?
What can your recover/ not?
No
Main rent + VAT + interest, NOT service charge. Insurance charge (even if these are labelled as additional rent!)
CRAR - what must there be owed?
Minimum of 7 days rent owed & a maximum of 6 years rent arrears.
CRAR procedure?
7, 14, 7
7 clear days rent overdue
14 clear days notice to enter
7 clear days notice of selling
CRAR; how is money recovered?
LL can seize goods up to the value of the rent
But note!! CRAR cannot be used…
And using it…
After the lease has been forfeited!!
Waives the right to forfeit the lease!
Remedies for breach of a repairing obligation
damages (but limited by statutory cap, by reduction in value of LL’s reversion/ interest)
Self help/ Jarvis v Harris clause
Jarvis v Harris clause
aka
Procedure
What happens?
Consequence? Now the sum …
Self-help
LL serve notice requiring T to repair, if T fails to do so by specified time, …
LL enters property, carries out repairs, and recovers cost of doing so from T as a debt!! (So this is the full sum, not restricted by a cap)
(→ now = sum due under the lease!! I.e. ‘all other sums due under this lease’; can forfeit lease if not paid
→ then tenant could apply for relief; but court would only grant this if they pay all sums due)
Common law damages are available for?
Any type of breach
Forfeiture =
LL right to re-enter the premises & take back from T, / end lease prematurely because of a T breach.
Normally LL will have the right to forfeit a lease if non payment of rent…
the LL should have made a … unless..
For 21 days
Formal written demand, unless specifies that this is unnecessary
Other likely triggering events for forfeiture right?
breach of repairing obligation
Tenant insolvency
→ these trigger right for LL to re enter etc.
Forfeiture - so LL can re-enter premises and bring lease to an end prematurely; but it will also…
But these people can…
End the interests of anyone who derives an interest from the lease i.e. under tenants/ mortgagees
But they can apply to the court for relief from forfeiture
Forfeiture - methods x2
peaceable re entry
Court order
Forfeiture - peaceful re-entry involves…
cannot be used …
bailiff to change locks & exclude T from premises
cannot be used if premises partly/ wholly residential
Forfeiture:
legal leases?
Equitable leases?
Legal → must be an express forfeiture clause in the lease
(RIGHT TO FORFEIT NEVER IMPLIED INTO A LEGAL LEASE)
Equitable —> does not need express forfeiture clause, can be IMPLIED.
Forfeiture - & s.146 notice
is this required?
Not required → non payment of rent
Required → all other breaches
Forfeiture - T counter notice?
breach of repair
If lease 7 years+, + at least 3 years left to run
→ T has 28 days notice to serve a counter notice
(Why we have J v H clause)
Forfeiture - T counter notice?
other breaches?
No 28 days to serve counter notice
Does a LL have to act reasonably in holding consent for a qualified user clause?
NO - only for the 2 As (alterations/ …)
Rent deposits are?
Topped up (6 months rent)
Clear days - every day but?
Sundays & bank holidays
(I.e. because this is when banks are closed)
If LL wishes to forfeit it must not…
Have WAIVED its right to !
How might LL waive its right to forfeit?
X2
Aware of acts/ omissions giving rise to right to forfeit,
Does unequivocal act recognising continued existence of the lease
I.e. accepts/ asks for rent
Waiver of forfeiture does not apply to accepting rent which..
Forms part of the breach which is the basis of forfeiture!
Only i.e. continuing rent after this point
Effects of waiving right to forfeit depends on whether?
Breach is continuing/ non continuing
Non-continuing breaches
X3
& LL can…..?
non payment rent
Acts of insolvency
Unlawful assignment
Can NEVER regain right to forfeit for that breach!!!
So nonpayment of rent is a continuing breach, BUT…
Each missing payment is treated separately
Continuing breaches?
I.e.
& the right to forfeit…?
Breach of repair
→ the right to forfeit continues for as long as the premises remains in disrepair
Waiver only operates on?
LL right to forfeit, NOT right to other remedies
→ LL retains these
Would a LL waive their right to forfeit if rent for march not paid, demanded rent for this several times, threatened action?
No; they haven’t i.e. accepted rent for the next quarter (June)
Notice to quit - for a periodic tenancy
yearly period of tenancy? - notice period?
Quarterly?
Monthly?
Weekly?
6 mos
A quarter
a month
A week (but 4 weeks for a residential tenancy)
Relief from forfeiture
type of remedy
Court must show…
Effect…
equitable/ discretionary
T must show court why equitable to grant relief
To restore the lease & any under leases
A LL agrees an unwritten tenancy of 1 year with a commercial T, rent payable monthly. The T paid the first couple of months' rent on time, but not paid last 3 months.
Can LL forfeit the lease?
No LL cannot forfeit the tenancy as there is no express R.O.F (unwritten, but legal!)