1/15
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what is illiberalism
hen democratic states act in opposition to liberal principles to address crises or perceived necessity.
Some call it empty democracy
Although elections take place and there may be some democratic institutions, the elite exercise real power (Russia).
Different from dictatorship—anti-liberal
core liberal values at risk with illiberalism
individual rights: Fundamental freedoms such as privacy, expression, and movement.Â
Illiberalism often seeks to limit these to provide collective security or enforce state ideology
due process: The principle that legal matters should be resolved according to established rules (e.g., habeas corpus). Illiberal actions often bypass these to speed up legal or state outcomes
two forms of illiberalism
AN ENTIRE STATE OR COUNTRY BECOMES ILLIBERAL
or
LIBERAL DEMOCRATIC COUNTRIES HAVE ELEMENTS OF ILLIBERALISM
is emergency legislation illiberal?
not necessarily
emergency legislation is fine if it is like:
Are temporary and time-limited
Are clearly defined in law
Are subject to parliamentary approval and review
Are subject to court challenges
Have clear limits on what the government can do
Can be investigated after the fact
but its not fine if it is like:
They are used too easily or too often
They are open-ended or indefinite
They bypass courts or legislatures
They suppress opposition or dissent permanently
They normalize exceptional powers
note: emergency legislation has been manipulated to create authoritarian regimes (Weimar Germany)
reasonable accommodation
Face veil at citizenship ceremonies
kirpan in schools
burqa ban in France
Quebec secularism law
censorship
Censorship puts a strain on liberal societies. One of the key aspects of liberalism is freedom of speech—but can we limit your right to say what you want and still claim to be liberal? Should you be able to read books and watch videos that show you how to make bombs? Or read racist books?
illiberal actions in canada’s history
Banning Catholics from government
Residential schools
Land claims issues
Immigration policies (Komogata Maru)
Head tax
Internment camps
Racial segregation laws (Viola Desmond)
the war on terror
Following the 9/11 attacks, Western democracies shifted significantly toward prioritizing collective security over individual rights.
This "emergency" mindset has led to permanent changes in how states monitor citizens and handle suspects, often diverging from classic liberal norms.
the USA patriot act (2001)
written during the highly emotional period after 9/11
The power of the Act is slowly being removed by the courts as they find it unconstitutional.
included:
surveillance expansion: Massive increase in the government's power to monitor phone records, emails, and financial data.
bulk correction: The shift from targeting specific suspects to gathering metadata on millions of innocent citizens.
lowered thresholds: Â Reduced judicial oversight for search warrants and seizures, undermining the 4th Amendment.
privacy vs security: A Â fundamental illiberal trade-off that persists in the digital age.
illiberalism as a reaction to terrorism
We also see profiling in the reaction to various terrorist attacks in the 21st century. In the highly emotional days after 9/11, many Muslim people were accused of being terrorists because of their religion or appearance.Â
How do these actions compare to other crisis situations, such as limiting mobility rights during the pandemic or McCarthyism during the Cold War? Is there a precedent created?
guantanamo bay
The detention facility at Guantanamo Bay represents one of the most stark examples of modern illiberalism.
By holding "enemy combatants" outside of traditional legal jurisdictions, the state suspended Habeas Corpus and used "enhanced interrogation" techniques that violate international law.
Are these “techniques”—which some equate to torture—effective at gaining information to make us safer?
canada’s no-fly list
passenger protection: The program allows the state to prevent individuals from boarding aircraft without ever revealing why they are listed.
due process issues: Critics argue the list lacks transparency and makes it nearly impossible for "false positives" (including children) to be removed.
legal challenges: Questions the Charter right to freedom of movement vs. the state's duty to provide national security.
maher arar
Canadian citizen born in Syria in 1970.
came to Canada in 1987
bachelor's and master's degrees in computer engineering
worked in Ottawa as a telecommunications engineer
stopover in New York returning to Canada from a vacation Sept 2002, US officials detained him
Claimed he had links to Al-Qaeda & deported him to Syria despite having his Canadian passport.
Arar received a settlement of $10.5 million and an apology from the Canadian government.
racial profiling as systemic illiberalism
Racial profiling violates the liberal tenet of equality. When the state targets individuals based on race or religion rather than behavior, it undermines the rule of law.
This practice erodes public trust and disproportionately affects marginalized communities in both domestic policing and border security.
secularism laws: bill 21
Bans teachers, police officers, judges, and many other professionals from wearing items like hijabs, turbans, kippahs, and crucifixes in the course of their duties.
Currently being expanded to include banning prayer rooms at universities and schools and banning public prayer.
*Pre-emptive use of the notwithstanding clause to shield the laws from legal, constitutional, challenges
freedom of religion: Opponents claim it is an illiberal imposition that forces individuals to choose between their faith and their career, violating the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
state neutrality: Quebec's Bill 21 prohibits public servants (teachers and police) from wearing religious symbols. Supporters argue it protects the secular nature of the state.
hate crimes
Is it right to punish someone for the intent of their crime? If someone vandalizes a building, should there be a more serious punishment because it was a mosque or synagogue? Does that mean we are punishing people for their thoughts?