1/23
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What’s the difference between a void contract and a voidable contract
void is no contract at all, voidable is valid but challengeable
When is a contract void
when there is no genuine consent at all, so no rights or obligations
When is a contract voidable
where the parties have consented to the contract, but the consent is vitiated in some relevant way
What are the consequences of a voidable contract
if successfully reduced, restutio in integrum, parties restored to original positions
In what circumstances may a court refuse the reduction of a voidable contract
unnecessary delay, personal bar
What two cases are used to distinguish void and voidable contracts
Morrison v Robertson 1908, void.
MacLeod v Kerr 1965, voidable
What is the subject of error concerned with
whether the parties truly and voluntarily consented to the agreement
What is an error in the consensus
when the parties have not reached a consensus in idem
What case is used for error in the consensus
Mathieson Gee (Ayrshire) Ltd v Quigley 1952
What are essential errors
error that is fundamental to the entire agreement
What are Bell’s 5 heads of essential error (Principles, s11)
subject matter
identity
price
quality
nature of the contract
What case is used for essential error
Stewart v Kennedy (1890)
What is uninduced error
an error that has not been brought about by the other party
What case is used for uninduced error
Raffles v Wichelhaus (1864)
What is a unilateral uninduced error
Where one of the parties is under a misapprehension
What case is used for unilateral uninduced errors
Steel v Bradley Homes (Scotland) Ltd 1972
What is misrepresentation
A misleading error being brought about by a party
What must be shown to establish misrepresentation
1. A statement or item of conduct made by defender (or their agent) to the pursuer
2. The statement is inaccurate
3. It induced the pursuer to enter into the contract
4. It is material
What case is used for an inaccurate representation (under misrepresentation)
Royal Bank of Scotland Plc v O’Donnell 2015
What cases are used in establishing that a misleading representation has been made
Patterson v Landsberg (1905)
Lyon & Turnbull v Sabine [2012]
What case is used to show inducement
Cramsao LLP v Earl of Seafield [2014]
What case is used to show inducement
Menzies v Menzies (1893)
What are the remedies for a misrepresentation that was either fraudulent or negligent
the contract is voidable and can be reduced
the pursuer can claim restitution and damages
What are the remedies for a misrepresentation that was innocent
the contract is voidable and can be reduced
the pursuer can claim restitution but not damages