1/23
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Good __, could you please introduce yourself to the court?
Hello, my name is Sage Everly
What do you do for a living, Mr. Everly?
I used to work in the utility industry, but now I’m a consultant, which means I help other companies make sure their overall policies are up to code
How did you get into that area of work?
Well I studied mechanical engineering in uni, and after graduation, I went abroad working for a utility company to help developing countries with their infrastructure. After a few years, I got a job at the Midland’s Department of Transportation looking at power transmission designs. I worked there for 7 years, and then I decided it was time to build something of my own, so I opened my Power Consulting Company.
How did you get involved in today’s case?
I was contacted by MG&E following the incident to look at their procedures prior to the fire, and the actions they took on the night of the fire, and specifically whether they were in line with industry standards.
What materials did you review in doing this analysis?
I reviewed MG&E’s rules, internal reports, and sensor data, a number of photos from the site of the crash, the police reports, and Dr. Prescott’s report into the cause of the fire. And naturally, I visited the scene in person.
Did you use a method in your review?
Yes, I did. My method is pretty simple - it’s called comparative analysis. I look at the company’s procedures and actions and compare them to standard industry practice. This is a gold standard practice in my field that’s been extensively peer reviewed.
Did you reliably apply the method to the facts and data in today’s case?
Yes.
Was your review sufficient to come to a conclusion?
Yes. I concluded that MG&E’s actions aligned with industry standards based on the information they had when they made three key decisions that night.
Well, Mr. Everly. I want to take those decisions one at a time. What was the first decision MG&E made on the night of the fire?
The first decision they made was to delay the dispatch of a maintenance technician by a few hours following the reported car crash with their utility pole on Dip road.
Based on the records you reviewed, what information did MG&E have when they made that decision?
Well, MG&E was informed there was a crash to their pole, and the pole was leaning. But the key piece of information they had was their SCADA readings, which showed electricity flowing normally at the time.
Hold on a minute, Mr. Everly. I’m not too familiar with electrical infrastructure. What do you mean by a SCADA reading?
I apologize, I’m so used to spending all day around other grid-heads that I forget that normal people don’t know these things. SCADA stands for Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition - it’s the master system which shows the company what’s going on with the grid at any given moment. I like to think of it as a car’s dashboard - a dashboard could flash up a check engine or low tire pressure light, and the monitoring system does the same thing for the grid.
Does MG&E have policies related to its monitoring systems in a situation like this?
Yes, their policies are all laid out in their manual
Would you recognize MG&E’s manual if I showed it to you today in court?
Yes, I reviewed it for my report
YH, approaching w Exhibit 4, which has been entered into evidence. What did I just hand you Mr. Everly?
This is MG&E’s Operations Manual.
What does MG&E’s manual say about a situation with a leaning pole like this one?
Well that policy is outlined in section 4.2 - it’s just here on page 6. Essentially, it says that when there is no fault with its monitoring systems, it’s up to the company to exercise discretion.
So, was MG&E’s first decision not to dispatch in line with industry standards?
Yes, absolutely. The discretion MG&E exercised that night was in line with industry standards. Going back to that car metaphor -let’s say you’re driving down a highway in the middle of the night and hit a pothole. But the car is handling ok, and the dashboard hasn’t flashed up a flat tire or check engine light. It would be reasonable to keep driving and not immediately pull over where you are, especially if you decide to take it into the shop the next morning.
Okay, now I want to move on to the next decision MG&E made that night. What was the second decision they made?
The second decision was based on a notification from their Environmental Monitoring System. That’s basically a system of sensors that measure temperature and dust levels at various locations across the entire grid. The sensor near the pole on Dip Road flashed up a warning that the temperature and dust levels were both elevated.
How did MG&E choose to respond when the environmental sensor went off?
They made the decision to not dispatch. It’s important to note here, however, that the same sensor had flashed false positive warnings a number of times in the past, meaning that it was reasonable to disregard it.
Why was it reasonable for MG&E to disregard the environmental sensor warning?
Well at the time, the grid monitoring system still showed no issues. It’s just like an oil pressure warning light on your dashboard - if it’s gone off a few times, but you know you’ve just changed the oil, it would be pretty reasonable to assume that it’s faulty and that there is no issue.
Then I want to talk about the last decision MG&E made that night. Could you tell us what that third decision was?
The final decision was to delay deenergizing the grid. Deenergizing is essentially shutting down the power for the entire grid and it impacts a lot of people.
Mr. Everly, what impacts can de-energization have?
Well think about it this way - how many things do you rely on in your daily life that need electricity to work? Deenergization means that none of those things work. Stoplights, the heat, even medical support systems - all gone in an instant. These are the factors that utilities must weigh when making the decision to deenergize.
Considering the impacts of de-energization, was MG&E’s delay that night in line with industry standards?
Yes - absolutely. Deenergization is considered an absolute last-resort measure in the industry, and MG&E’s decision to not deploy it immediately was in line with industry standards.
If MG&E had chosen to de-energize earlier, can you say with any certainty whether that would have prevented the fire’s spread?
No - certainly not. There is no guarantee that deenergization would have changed the events which took place that night. De-energization may not have been necessary before the fire began.
Mr. Everly, in your professional opinion, were MG&E’s actions on the night of the fire ever out of line with the industry standard practice?
No, I did not find any evidence to suggest that the steps MG&E took that night ever fell out of line with industry standards. The decisions they made were reasonable based on the information available to them.