1/75
Looks like no tags are added yet.
manslaughter
unlawful killing of another where one had no intent to do another harm
(absent malice aforethought)
2 kinds:
1. voluntary: suddenly and intentionally killing another person in the heat of anger following adequate provocation
OR
honestly had to believe they were killing in self defense
ex : drag racing
2. involuntary: unintentionally killing by a voluntary act or omission
ex: drunk driving, cruise ship
drug dealer and its bad batch but didn't know and person dies
murder
intentionally planned, deliberate killing with malice aforethoughts
actus reus: the killing (guilty act)
mens rea: the intent (guilty mind)
aggravated circumstances: concurrence, produces death -> circumstance increasing the seriousness of crime (not just assault but used a dangerous weapon to leave severe bodily injury)
2 kinds:
1. first degree: premeditated, deliberate or intent to kill
example:
felony murders: a murder that occurs during the commission of another felony
ex:
2. second degree: intentional murders that weren't premeditated or deliberate
example:
depraved heart murder or reckless murder: unintentional but VERY reckless
ex: drug dealer knew batch was bad but still sold it and people saw it
murder and manslaughter facts
very rare
murder=egregious act (outstandingly bad)
historically if you kill someone=death penalty-> forfeiting your life if you take another
murder=violation (desecration) of natural orders of things
what was murder in the common law
killing a person with malice aforethought
felony
more definitive definitions of law 4 murder:
1. sound memory/discretion
2. unlawfully (without justification/excuse)
3. Killeth (murder actus reus) (causing death by poisoning, striking, drowning)
4. reasonable creature in being (somebody born alive and breathing at time of killing)
5. under the king's peace: killing anybody other than an alien enemy during time of war
6. with malice aforethought expressed or implied (acts planned in advance of killing with specific intent- spite, hate, bad will)
what was manslaughter in the common law
killing a person without malice aforethought
what are the three types of homicides
1. justifiable
2. excusable
3. criminal
what is justifiable homicides
can be:
1. self defense
2. capital punishment-> if appropriate/sanctioned then it is justifiable if the law for the crime states it
killing someone-> Death penalty
3. law enforcement using RIGHTFUL deadly force
Imminent threat of death to officer or public-> then officer can use force to protect themselves and others (tenn v. Garner)
Deadly force to stop a fleeing felon with a violent nature
if offender isn't immediately apprehended and impose a fear of death or injury
what is Graham v. Connor
reasonable policeman standards
what is excusable homicides
homicide done by someone not of sound memory or discretion
examples:
insanity
immaturity/infancy: they cannot form the intent to commit a crime-> don't have the mental capacity
what is criminal homicides
all homicides that aren't justifiable or excusable with a reasonable person (mens rea and actus reus)
felony of violent nature (fleeing)
what is considered a reasonable creature in being
we are al this by definition (humans), in homicide, happens in the killing of a fetus, it is not a murder if the fetus is not viable and couldn't survive outside of the womb, original common law said breath is important in viewing it as murder
what is the born alive rule
has to be born alive, capable of breathing on its own and a heartbeat to be considered homicide victim
the rule that to be a person, and therefore a homicide victim, a baby had to be "born alive" and capable of breathing and maintaining a heartbeat on its own
facts of 1st degree murder
premeditated, deliberate, intent to kill
acting willfully, deliberately premeditatedly, acting with purpose and knowledge
more heinous crime - use of death penalty
?SOME states drop felony murder with 1st degree
felony murder: when committing a felony- someone dies as a result
facts of 2nd degree murder
no death penalty
-primary goal in making 2nd degree murder a thing was to LIMIT the use of death penalty for it
anything that isn't 1st degree is 2nd degree
-depraved heart murders:
unintentionally but extremely reckless murders
consciously creating a substantial risk of criminal harm
example of being v reckless: throwing a hammer off the side of a building without looking and killing someone
what is the deadly weapon doctrine
-falls under premediation
-"one who intentionally uses a deadly weapon on another human being and thereby kills him or her, presumably intends to kill the person"
->not a mandatory presumption, but permissible for a judge or jury to infer (permissible inference)
-individuals are presumed to intend the natural and probable consequences of their acts (death)
what is manslaughter
principle difference between murder and manslaughter:
-manslaughter arises from sudden heat of passion, murder from the wickedness of the heart
2 types: voluntary and involuntary
what is voluntary manslaughter
INTENTIONAL ACT BUT DOESNT HAVE MALICE
letting anger get the best of you in the worst way: Understands that human frailty exists, doesn't diminish acts but added provocation exists so its not treated as harshly as murder
Adequate provocation - people can be provoked--> REDUCING MURDER TO MANSLAUGHTER
•Is not available to everyone who flies of the handle, only applies when there is adequate provocation
•4 elements to adequate provocation
what qualifications or restrictions to what is considered adequate provocation for voluntary manslaughter are there...
Must:
•has to be one that is already recognized in the law
•defendant himself has to be provoked (no transferred provocation)
• provocation is one that would provoke a reasonable person under the same circumstances (one that would provoke a person to act of passion and not reason) •cause a reasonable person to overcome a restraint normally expected of them
CANT BE WORDS TO REDUCE MURDER TO MANSLAUGHTER
4 elements of adequate provocation for the murder to be considered voluntary manslaughter
1. mutual combat
2. assault and battery
3. trespass
4. adultery
what is considered mutual combat for adequate provocation in voluntary manslaughter (4 elements)
mutual combat can be...
1. pistol whipping
2. staggering body blows
3. a real fight
what is considered assault and batter for adequate provocation in voluntary manslaughter (4 elements)
assault and battery can be...
1. unwanted physical touching of another human (battery)
2. placed you in reasonable fear of impending battery (assault)
what is considered trespassing for adequate provocation in voluntary manslaughter (4 elements)
trespassing is...
only when a home or business is being invaded and one is being threatened
what is considered adultery for adequate provocation in voluntary manslaughter (4 elements)
adultery is...
when a spouse catches their spouse in the act of adultery is considered to have reason to be provoked
some states recognize this even when spouse doesn't witness the cheating
Paramour Rule: A husband who caught his wife in the act of adultery had adequate provocation to kill and could reduce criminal homicide to voluntary manslaughter. (used to be only available to husbands)
what is involuntary manslaughter
•Unintentional killing by a voluntary act or omission
•also called criminal negligence manslaughter or misdemeanor manslaughter
•defendants acts create a high risk (substantial and unjustifiable) of death or serious injury-> defendants know risk but still do it
•this type usually has to do with vehicles and firearms
-> both are dangerous within themselves so caution is needed, therefore if you takes one's like when caution isn't used it is involuntary manslaughter (not intentional but RECKLESS)
example: drunk driving, speeding excessively
•Omission: when one has a special duty to someone else and screw up and ignore it (NEGLECT) that ends up being reckless
examples: doctor to patient, parents to child
cruise ship that captain was showing up and crashing ship which lead to many dying
what is rape in the common law
•Most serious form of sexual assault and second to murder of egregiousness acts
•traditionally is the cardinal knowledge of a woman by a man not your wife with force and over the women's upmost resistance of the woman
historically: only women can be raped, penal and vaginal penetration, men cannot rape their wives (women property), element of force→ actual force and a resistance by the woman
oProsecutors have to push all these things to get a conviction → used to be better to get a conviction if woman killed
•focuses on events surrounding rape
•prompt reporting rule: must immediately report rape-> but this isn't behavior for victims
corroboration rule: victims has to have a corroborating witness
common law for sodomy
originally: ANY oral or anal sex
but common law: then made it anal sex or intercourse among gay couples illegal
what happened in the 70's and 80's in regard to sexual offenses
(REFORMS)
it included a wide range of nonconsensual penetrations and contacts
which
expanded definitions of sex crimes and changes how cases could be presented in course
reforms included:
1. Marital rape exception excluded: husband can be prosecuted
2. corroboration and prompt reporting rule stopped
THIS NOW INCLUDED ALL SEXUAL PENETRATIONS AND SEXUAL CONTACTS NONCONSENSUAL
aggravated or stranger rape
rape by a stranger often with weapons who physically injure their victims
acquaintance rape *unarmed*
nonconsensual sex with someone the victim knows
('date rape,' co-workers, friends, classmates)
what are some issues with investigating acquaintance rape
•victims reluctant to report because of...
1. self blame
2. handling it a different way
•when they are reported the cases are...
1. not handled well
2. prosecutors dont charge or approve warrant
3. juries dont convict often
•if the victim didn't follow 'the rules of middle class morality' jury not likely to convict
most likely defense attorney will blamed victim for...: drinking, working late hours, hitchhiking, things found to cause rape...
•80% of unreported rapes are acquaintance
•75% new assailant
•so hard to prosecute because comes down to consent of both parties
^rape shield status (developed because of this)- defendants are limited in cross examination to bring up victims past sexual behaviors and stops publication of identity of rape victims
Modern rape Laws
The crime of forcing another person to submit to sex acts.
offender must have:
1. actus reus: sexual penetration by force or threat of force
2. mens rea: intentional sexual penetration
3. special circumstancesL non consent by the victim??
what are the force and resistance standards for rape
common law or historically:
•victim had to est they forcibly resisted rape
•utmost resistance standard:
->to show there wasn't consent a woman had to have basically or actually fought to the death to show she used all her physical force to spot the rape (easier to prosecute if she died)
•reasonable resistance rule:
->resistance within an amount of force to show there wasn't consent, looking at the totality of circumstances
•intrinsic and extrinsic test
•statutory rape: sexual intercourse of minor
what is the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic test
•intrinsic: is like just the force needed for penetration
•Extrinsic: is like a force more than just the actual penetration
what is statutory rape
•is the sexual intercourse of a minor
•age restriction is needed because we must protect minors because they don't have the maturity to give consent for such an act-> older people can manipulate minors
•age in MD of consent: 16 ->so no reasonable mistake for age in MD
•parentice: since teacher has guardian role, consent for student/teacher relations is 18 years old
what are the 4 mental states of crime
1. purposely
2. knowingly
3. recklessly
4. negligently
mental state of crime: purposely
•its the CONSCIOUS thought of the offender to commit the offense
->this is the most blameworthy mental state = MENS REA
mental state of crime: knowingly
•aware that it is PRACTICALLY certain their conduct will result in criminal act
mental state of crime: recklessly
•CONSCIOUSLY DISREGARD of a substantial and unjustifiable risk resulting in criminal harm
-> grossly violating a standard of conduct
mental state of crime: negligently
•one SHOULD be aware of a substantial unjustifiable risk their conduct cases, but they aren
what is strict liability
strict liability crime= crime requiring NO mens rea, regardless you are blameworthy
EXAMPLES of this:
•statutory rape, speeding, selling alcohol to minors
•definition:
->In criminal law its the liability for which mens rea doesn't have to be proven in relation to one or more elements comprising the actus reus although intention, recklessness or knowledge may be required in relation to other elements of the offense.
therefore->
•it is the liability without thought of guilty mind and act
•prosector just proves it happened-> without/without intent
•any violation of law is considered criminal within MR. & MRS. LAMB
common law felonies
M- murder->intent of malice to kill
R-rape-> nonconsensual forced penetration of a woman against will
&
M- manslaughter-> killing without malice or intent
R- robbery -> person to person taking someones property with force or threat (gun)
S-sodomy -> consensual or nonconsensual anal sex of gay ppl
L- Larceny->taking away someone's property with intent to deprive them, without force
A- Arson-> intention; burning
M- Mayhem-> malicious injuring someone (incapacitated)
B-burgarly-> breaking/entering into another structure and stealing
what did Pennsylvania v. Mimms est
not as inclined to use death penalty for 2nd degree murder
what was established in the late 1700's in regard to murder ??
1st degree murder was divided in late 1700s, 2nd, premeditated, deliberate, attempt to kill murders, willful (intent to kill), minimal amount of status require a prolonged thought process for premeditated
failure to render medical care
moral v. legal duties
legal duty vs. moral duty
humanity and moral duty would demand you to jump in, BUT no legal duty to do something, vehicle cases are DUIs (deaths 5300)
what is the rape reporting process
1. need to alert for violent crimes
2. might have to shoot him
3. need to get description from victim
4. protect crime scene and victim
5. need to establish perimeter to catch offender, most likely not at scene
1st cop, sergeant, detectives, doctors, states attorneys, family, victims chastity put on trial- does she have sex a lot?
what is malice aforethoughts
it is originally the mental state of intentional killing, with an amount of...
spite, hate, bad will, premeditated
what is implied malice aforethought
intentional killings WITHOUT premeditation or reasonable provocation,
it is the unintentional killings during the commission of felonies
-> depraved heart killings, and intent to inflict grievous bodily harm killings
2nd degree murder
murder actus reus
murder actus reus the act of killing by poisoning, striking, starving, drowning, and a thousand other forms by which human nature can be overcome
murder mens rea
include purposefully, knowingly, or recklessly killing
what are considered capital cases or punishment
in state with death penalty (only for felony murders in the 1st degree)
states with dp: "mandatory life without parole"
what is the bifurcation
the requirement that the death penalty decision be made in two phases
1. a trial to determine guilt
2. second separate proceeding, after a finding of guilt to consider the aggravating factors for, and mitigating factors against, capital punishment
objective test of cooling off time
this is for voluntary manslaughter cases it has to find out if a reasonable person would 'cool off' under the same circumstances rather than turn to killing (injunction w/ adequate provocation)
WORDS CAN NOT BE CONSIDERED ADEQUATE PROVOCATION
WHAT IS THE LAST straw or long smoldering or slow burn rule for adequate provocation
adequate provocation defined as a smoldering resentment or pent up rage resulting from earlier insults or humiliating events culminating in a triggering event that by itself might be insufficient to provoke the deadly act
what is extreme mental or emotional disturbance manslaughter
a homicide committed under the influence of extreme mental or emotional disturbance for which there is reasonable explanation or excuse.
the reasonable of such explanation or excuse shall be determined from the viewpoint of the person in the actor's situation under the circumstances as he believes them to be
what is an emotional act distinction
distinction separating the emotions that led to the killing from the question if it was reasonable
what is the act reasonableness
finding that a reasonable person in defendant's shoes would have responded violently also
what is emotional reasonableness
finding that the defendant's emotional outrage or passion was reasonable
what is criminal negligence manslaughter
death caused by a person who is aware that her acts create a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death or serious bodily injury but acts anyway
omission can be under this
unlawful act manslaughter or misdemeanor manslaughter
unintended deaths occurring during commission of non-homicide offenses
-misdemeanor crime??
what is a malum prohibitum crime
death MUST be foreseeable consequence of the unlawful act committed->
act unlawful ONLY because t is prohibited by a specific statue or ordinance
malum in se
act wrong because it is evil in itself
presumption of bodily integrity
state can't exercise power over individuals except when to prevent harm to the greater society
what is subjective fear for a victim
honest fear of imminent and serious bodily harm
fraud in the fact (in rape)
this is rape-rapist fraudulently convinces victims the act consented to was something other than sexual intercourse
fraud in the inducement (in rape)
act of intercourse cannot be considered rape -> fraud in the befits promise not in the act
what is a honest and reasonable mistake rule
a negligence mental element in rape cases in which the defendant argues that he honestly, mistakenly, believed the victim consented to sex
simple rape
2nd degree rape
rape committed without aggravated circumstances
intrinsic
what is stalking
intentionally scaring another person by following, tormenting, or harassing them
attempted battery assault
consists of having the specific intent to commit battery and taking substantial steps toward carrying it out without actually completing the attempt
what is intentional scaring
threatened battery assault sometimes called intentional scaring requires only that actors intend to frighten their victims thus expanding assault beyond attempted battery
wha are conditional threats
threats based upon the existence of certain conditions that don't presently exist aren't enough to satisfy the mens rea of assault because they're not immediate
what is cyberstalking
use of the internet email or other electronic communication devices to stalk another person through threatening behavior
right of locomotion ????
right to come and go without restraints (car)
kidnapping
taking/carrying away of another person with intent to deprive the person of personal liberty
false imprisonment
depriving others their personal liberty without asportation requirement
express malice aforethought
intentional WITH malice and premeditated
1st degree murder