1/63
Looks like no tags are added yet.
List the four criteria for statehood established by the 1933 Montevideo Convention.
The criteria are (a) permanent population, (b) defined territory, (c) government, and (d) capacity to enter into international relations.
Define the 'doctrine of state continuity' regarding failed states.
It is the presumption that a state continues to exist internationally even if its government temporarily loses effective control.
In international law, what is the minimum population or land area required for an entity to be recognized as a state?
There is no minimum size or population required under international law.
According to the Vienna Convention on Succession of States in Respect of Treaties (1978), how is 'succession of states' defined?
The replacement of one state by another in the responsibility for the international relations of territory.
What is the primary conceptual distinction between a 'predecessor state' and a 'successor state'?
The predecessor state is the one replaced, while the successor state is the one that replaces it in territorial responsibility.
Define 'Decolonization' in the context of state succession types.
A situation where a colony or dependency achieves independence while the colonizing state continues to exist.
How does 'Dissolution' differ from 'Secession' in state succession?
In dissolution the predecessor state ceases to exist, whereas in secession the predecessor state continues to exist after losing territory.
What is 'Unification' in state succession?
The process where two or more states merge to form a single successor state.
The transfer of part of a state's territory to another state by treaty is known as _____.
Cession
Which state was recognized as the 'continuator' of the USSR following its 1991 dissolution?
The Russian Federation (Russia).
State the 'Clean Slate Rule' (tabula rasa) regarding newly independent states and treaties.
A newly independent state is generally not bound by the treaty obligations of the predecessor state.
Under VCSST Article 11, which specific category of treaties is exempted from the clean slate rule?
Boundary treaties and boundary regimes.
Explain the principle of 'uti possidetis juris' established in the 1986 Frontier Dispute case.
The principle that administrative boundaries from the colonial period become international boundaries upon independence.
What are 'localized obligations' under VCSST Article 12?
Treaty obligations relating to specific geographical features like waterways or passage rights that pass to the successor state.
What is the 'Continuity Rule' regarding state succession resulting from unification or dissolution?
The principle that treaty obligations generally pass to the successor state for the applicable territory.
How are 'political treaties' (like military alliances) typically treated during state succession?
They are generally not binding on successor states.
What is the general practice of human rights treaty bodies regarding states formed from dissolution?
They typically treat successor states as parties to human rights treaties that were already applicable to the territory.
Why was the 1947 partition of British India relevant to Nepal's treaty relations?
Nepal's treaties with British India were succeeded to by India as the primary successor/continuator state.
Define 'State Property' according to the 1983 Vienna Convention (VCSPD).
Property, rights, and interests owned by the predecessor state at the date of succession according to its internal law.
What happens to 'immovable state property' situated in a territory during succession?
It automatically passes from the predecessor state to the successor state.
Describe the 'Zero Option' agreement used during the USSR dissolution.
Russia assumed all USSR external debts in exchange for receiving all USSR external assets.
Which rule governs the succession of 'state archives' that relate to the territory of a successor state?
They should pass to the successor state because archives should accompany the territory they document.
Under VCSPD Article 38, what is the default rule for debts of a predecessor state in the case of newly independent states?
No state debt passes to the newly independent state unless it specifically agrees to assume it.
State the three criteria for a debt to be considered an 'Odious Debt'.
It must be (1) incurred without consent, (2) used for purposes contrary to the population's interest, and (3) the creditor was aware of these facts.
Is the 'Odious Debt' doctrine considered established customary international law?
No, it remains controversial and has never been formally applied by international courts.
What is the general rule for a successor state's membership in international organizations (IOs)?
There is no automatic succession; the state must formally apply and be admitted.
What specific UN procedure is required for a new state's admission under Article 4 of the Charter?
A Security Council recommendation followed by a two-thirds vote of the General Assembly.
How did the UN treat the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia's claim to continuity in 1992?
The UN denied continuity, stating the FRY could not automatically continue membership and must apply as a new state.
In the unification of Germany (1990), how was the successor state's legal personality structured?
The GDR acceded to the FRG, meaning the FRG's international legal personality and IO memberships continued.
What risk does state succession pose to the population of the affected territory regarding legal identity?
The risk of statelessness if nationality laws do not automatically extend to the population.
According to the 1999 ILC Draft Articles, who has the right to the nationality of a successor state?
Persons habitually resident in the territory subject to the succession.
Define 'Right of Option' in nationality succession.
The right for affected persons to choose between the nationality of the predecessor state and the successor state.
How was the dissolution of Czechoslovakia (1993) distinct from the dissolutions of the USSR and Yugoslavia?
It was negotiated consensually through parliamentary vote and neither state claimed to be the continuator.
What was the significance of the 1816 Treaty of Sugauli for Nepal's boundary succession?
It established Nepal's western boundary at the Mahakali River, a boundary that bound India as a successor state.
VCSST Art. 34: If part of a state separates to form a new state, treaties in force for that territory generally _____.
Continue in force for the new state.
Case: Conditions of Admission (ICJ 1948). What was the ruling regarding admission conditions?
The conditions listed in Article 4 of the UN Charter are exhaustive; states cannot add extra political conditions.
Case: Reference re Secession of Quebec. Distinguish between internal and external self-determination.
Internal is participation in government; external is the right to independence (reserved for colonies or those denied internal rights).
Case: Aerial Incident (Israel v. Bulgaria). Why did the ICJ lack jurisdiction?
Bulgaria's 1921 declaration to the PCIJ did not automatically transfer to the ICJ upon its formation.
Case: Lighthouse Arbitration (1956). What principle did it establish for concessions?
Localized obligations (concessions relating to specific property) pass with the territory to the successor state.
Case: Kosovo Advisory Opinion (ICJ 2010). What did the Court decide regarding the declaration of independence?
The declaration itself did not violate general international law, though the court avoided ruling on Kosovo's statehood.
Case: Western Sahara (ICJ 1975). What was the ruling on terra nullius?
The territory was not terra nullius because it was inhabited by peoples with political and social organization.
In state debt succession, what is the 'equitable proportion' rule used for dissolution cases?
Debts are shared based on the property and interests passing to each successor state in connection with that debt.
What is the legal status of the 1983 Vienna Convention on state property and debts (VCSPD)?
It has not yet entered into force due to insufficient ratifications, but is cited as a systematic framework.
How did the 1947 independence of Pakistan affect British India's UN membership?
India was treated as the continuator and kept the seat; Pakistan was treated as a new state and had to apply.
What is the 'Declaratory Theory' of recognition as mentioned in the Badinter Commission context?
The theory that a state exists when it meets factual criteria, regardless of formal recognition by other states.
Identify the primary bilateral framework for Nepal-India relations following the 1947 succession.
The 1950 Treaty of Peace and Friendship.
How does the VCSST treat 'multilateral human rights treaties' regarding newly independent states?
While practice varies, they are generally considered to continue in force for the new state by automatic succession or declaration.
What is the 'Velvet Divorce' a reference to in state succession history?
The peaceful and negotiated dissolution of Czechoslovakia in 1993.
Which agreement resolved the division of Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (SFRY) assets and liabilities in 2001?
The Agreement on Succession Issues.
According to ILC Draft Articles Art. 4, what is the primary duty of states during succession regarding nationality?
To take all necessary measures to prevent statelessness.
Why is 'Russia's continuation of the USSR's UN seat' legally controversial?
Because strictly Russia was one of 15 successors, but political pragmatism allowed it to inherit the permanent SC seat.
VCSST Art. 2: A _____ is a successor state whose territory was a dependent territory for which the predecessor was responsible.
Newly independent state
How does 'cession' affect the state debt of the predecessor state under VCSPD Art. 37?
The debt specifically attributable to the ceded territory passes to the successor state.
In the context of the USSR, what happened to immovable Soviet property located outside the republics' borders (e.g., embassies)?
It was allocated to Russia under the Zero Option agreement.
How did the ICJ's decision in 'Western Sahara' prioritize self-determination over historical title?
It held that historical legal ties do not override the population's right to self-determination in decolonization.
Define 'Internal Self-Determination'.
The right of a people to determine their political status and pursue development through participation in their current state's structures.
What was the result of the 2011 referendum in South Sudan regarding statehood?
98.83% voted for independence, leading to consensual secession and UN admission.
How is the 2015 Constitution of Nepal viewed in terms of state succession?
It is an internal reorganization (constitutional transformation), not a state succession event.
List two examples of micro-states that satisfy the Montevideo criteria despite very small sizes.
Vatican City State and Monaco (or Nauru/Tuvalu).
What is the status of 'Palestine' in the United Nations as of 2012?
Non-member observer state.
Why is the distinction between 'personal' and 'localized' treaties important in succession?
Personal treaties (alliances) usually lapse, while localized treaties (territorial) usually pass to the successor.
Term: Tabula rasa
Definition: Latin for 'clean slate', referring to the rule that new states are not bound by previous treaty obligations.
Under VCSST Article 31, what is the default rule for treaties when states unite?
Treaties in force for any of the merging states continue in force for the successor state.