1/19
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are psychodynamic explanations?
focus on the influence of early childhood experiences and how they impact later development. It predominantly focuses on the role of the superego
What is the role of the superego in a non-offender and how is it different from that of an offender?
it punishes the ego with guilt for wrongdoing and rewards it with pride for goof behaviour. In offenders, because the superego is faulty and the id is given ‘free rein’
What are the 3 types of superegos that explain offending?
weak, deviant and over-harsh
When does a weak superego develop?
when the same-sex parent is absent during the phallic stage (3-5 years)
Why does absence of the same-sex parent cause a weak superego?
the child cannot properly internalise moral values from same-sex parent
How does a weak superego lead to offending?
the individual has little control over antisocial behaviour
What is a deviant superego?
when a child internalises immoral or criminal values from same-sex parent as they also have deviant values (e.g a boy raised by a criminal father)
What is an over-harsh superego?
an excessively strict one that cripples the individuals with guilt and anxiety. This unconsciously drives them to crime to satisfy their need for punishment
What happens if the superego is inadequate?
primitive, emotional demands (Id) guide moral behaviour
How does the psychodynamic approach differ from other explanations?
it focuses on emotional life and unconscious processes e.g the role of anxiety and guilt
Explain Bowlby’s maternal deprivation theory
need a warm, continuous relationship with mother figure - failing to form a bond has irreversible consequences
leads to affectionless psychopathy - lack of guilt, empathy and feeling for others
What di Bowlby find from his 44 thieves study?
14 of the thieves could be considered to be an affectionless psychopath and 12 of the 14 had experienced early separation. Concluded that there were links between maternal deprivation and delinquent behaviour
How is the fact that the psychodynamic explanation of criminality is unfalsifiable a weakness?
because concepts that cannot be observed like this approach lack the methodological rigour of cognitive or biological approaches. This reduces their scientific credibility within modern psychology and limits their usefulness in forensic settings
Give an example of this weakness
for instance, core concepts proposed by Freud such as the id, ego, superego, unconscious guilt and repressed trauma cannot be directly observed or measured. Much of the supporting evidence comes from case studies, which are subjective and vulnerable to researcher bias
How is the fact that the psychodynamic explanation has a highly deterministic view of criminality a limitation?
because it oversimplifies the complex pathways that lead to crime. Many individuals with difficult childhoods grow up to be law-abiding adults, while many offenders report stable upbringings. By placing weight on early experiences, the theory neglects later influences such as peer groups, socioeconomic pressures and personal choice. This reduces explanatory depth and usefulness for intervention, as it implies criminality is fixed in early life
Give an example of this limitation
for instance, Freud argued that early childhood experiences, particularly issues such as over-harsh superego formed in the first few years of life, rigidly shape behaviour into adulthood. This suggests individuals who experience trauma, inconsistent parenting or early separation are destined to become offenders
How is the fact that the methodology of the research evidence used to support the psychodynamic explanation a significant limitation?
as such a small sample size is not representative of the target population and so the results can’t be generalised meaning the research lacks population validity. The interviewing of the families also brings about the issue of social desirability. This is therefore a weakness of the psychodynamic explanation as it reduces its validity
Give an example of this limitation
for example, a key issue with Bowlby’s research is that his sample size consisted of only 44 thieves. Additionally, Bowlby interviewed the families of the participants to see if they have been maternally deprived
How is the fact that the psychodynamic explanation may be gender biased a key disadvantage of it?
because it implies that females develop a weaker superego, yet statistically males commit more crimes which contradicts the theory making it unreliable
Give an example of this disadvantage
for instance, Freud suggested that the superego develops during the resolution of the Oedipus complex, which focuses on primary male development