Ch. 20 - Misue of Legal Procedure

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/245

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

246 Terms

1
New cards
  1. The tort that addresses wrongful criminal charges is ________________________. [p. 1265]


  1. The tort that addresses wrongful criminal charges is malicious prosecution. (p. 1265)


2
New cards
  1. The legal process challenged in this unit is a ________________________. [p. 1266]


  1. The legal process challenged in this unit is a criminal prosecution. (p. 1266)


3
New cards
  1. A proceeding can be wrongful when improperly instituted or improperly ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. A proceeding can be wrongful when improperly instituted or improperly continued. (p. 1266)
4
New cards
  1. The core favorable-ending concept is ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. The core favorable-ending concept is favorable termination. (p. 1266)
5
New cards
  1. The belief requirement governing initiation is ________________________. [p. 1267]
  1. The belief requirement governing initiation is probable cause. (p. 1267)
6
New cards
  1. Under the Arkansas formulation in Texas Skaggs, the first requirement is a prosecution ________________________ against the plaintiff. [p. 1266]
  1. Under the Arkansas formulation in Texas Skaggs, the first requirement is a prosecution instituted or continued by the defendant against the plaintiff. (p. 1266)
7
New cards
  1. The criminal proceeding must terminate in favor of the ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. The criminal proceeding must terminate in favor of the accused. (p. 1266)
8
New cards
  1. A third required showing is absence of ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. A third required showing is absence of probable cause. (p. 1266)
9
New cards
  1. The motive element of the cause of action is ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. The motive element of the cause of action is malice. (p. 1266)
10
New cards
  1. The final enumerated requirement is ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. The final enumerated requirement is damages. (p. 1266)
11
New cards
  1. A defendant who knowingly insists that prosecution proceed after exculpatory information arrives may have ________________________ the prosecution. [p. 1268]
  1. A defendant who knowingly insists that prosecution proceed after exculpatory information arrives may have continued the prosecution. (p. 1268)
12
New cards
  1. Probable cause asks whether the accuser honestly and reasonably believed the accusation was ________________________. [p. 1267]
  1. Probable cause asks whether the accuser honestly and reasonably believed the accusation was true. (p. 1267)
13
New cards
  1. A merely reasonable but false factual belief can sometimes establish ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. A merely reasonable but false factual belief can sometimes establish probable cause. (p. 1271)
14
New cards
  1. The accuser’s subjective belief is a question of ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. The accuser’s subjective belief is a question of fact. (p. 1271)
15
New cards
  1. On established facts, whether probable cause exists is generally a question for the ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. On established facts, whether probable cause exists is generally a question for the court. (p. 1271)
16
New cards
  1. When reasonable caution would demand investigation, failure to inquire may undermine ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. When reasonable caution would demand investigation, failure to inquire may undermine probable cause. (p. 1271)
17
New cards
  1. An innocent person may still face a prosecution begun with ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. An innocent person may still face a prosecution begun with probable cause. (p. 1271)
18
New cards
  1. An acquittal does not automatically prove absence of ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. An acquittal does not automatically prove absence of probable cause. (p. 1272)
19
New cards
  1. Advice of counsel protects an accuser only after a full and ________________________ of known facts. [p. 1272]
  1. Advice of counsel protects an accuser only after a full and fair disclosure of known facts. (p. 1272)
20
New cards
  1. For punitive damages, some jurisdictions demand an independently established heightened form of ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. For punitive damages, some jurisdictions demand an independently established heightened form of malice. (p. 1273)
21
New cards
  1. A termination resulting from voluntary compromise initiated by the accused generally is not a ________________________ under the approach discussed in Skaggs. [p. 1266]
  1. A termination resulting from voluntary compromise initiated by the accused generally is not a favorable termination under the approach discussed in Skaggs. (p. 1266)
22
New cards
  1. An accuser’s proof that the plaintiff was actually guilty may constitute a ________________________ in the historical approach used by Skaggs. [p. 1267]
  1. An accuser’s proof that the plaintiff was actually guilty may constitute a defense in the historical approach used by Skaggs. (p. 1267)
23
New cards
  1. A conviction usually gives powerful support for the existence of ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. A conviction usually gives powerful support for the existence of probable cause. (p. 1272)
24
New cards
  1. The effect of a preliminary magistrate determination depends on whether it was contaminated by ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. The effect of a preliminary magistrate determination depends on whether it was contaminated by deception. (p. 1272)
25
New cards
  1. The relevant reasonable-belief standard combines objective prudence with the defendant’s ________________________. [p. 1267]
  1. The relevant reasonable-belief standard combines objective prudence with the defendant’s honest belief. (p. 1267)
26
New cards
  1. When no honest belief exists despite circumstances that might persuade others, probable cause can still be ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. When no honest belief exists despite circumstances that might persuade others, probable cause can still be absent. (p. 1271)
27
New cards
  1. A modern favorable-termination formulation asks whether disposition is not inconsistent with ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. A modern favorable-termination formulation asks whether disposition is not inconsistent with innocence. (p. 1272)
28
New cards
  1. Malice may be inferred from want of probable cause, but malice does not itself prove absence of ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. Malice may be inferred from want of probable cause, but malice does not itself prove absence of probable cause. (p. 1273)
29
New cards
  1. Filing a report that simply supplies truthful facts and leaves the decision to authorities may not amount to ________________________. [p. 1270]
  1. Filing a report that simply supplies truthful facts and leaves the decision to authorities may not amount to instituting criminal proceedings. (p. 1270)
30
New cards
  1. The probable-cause inquiry distinguishes a mistake of fact from a mistake of ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. The probable-cause inquiry distinguishes a mistake of fact from a mistake of law. (p. 1271)
31
New cards
  1. In some jurisdictions, a reasonable mistake of law may still fail to establish ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. In some jurisdictions, a reasonable mistake of law may still fail to establish probable cause. (p. 1272)
32
New cards
  1. The preliminary-hearing outcome may create a presumption of probable cause subject to proof of ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. The preliminary-hearing outcome may create a presumption of probable cause subject to proof of deception. (p. 1272)
33
New cards
  1. The merchant in the principal criminal case was ________________________. [p. 1265]
  1. The merchant in the principal criminal case was Texas Skaggs, Inc.. (p. 1265)
34
New cards
  1. The plaintiff arrested over checks that had already been paid was ________________________. [p. 1265]
  1. The plaintiff arrested over checks that had already been paid was Sharon Graves. (p. 1265)
35
New cards
  1. The criminal charges in Skaggs were dismissed because the prosecution could not produce the ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. The criminal charges in Skaggs were dismissed because the prosecution could not produce the checks. (p. 1266)
36
New cards
  1. The court affirmed the jury’s finding of ________________________ in actual damages to Graves. [p. 1270]
  1. The court affirmed the jury’s finding of $20,000 in actual damages to Graves. (p. 1270)
37
New cards
  1. The Alabama case cited for lack of honest belief despite objective circumstances is ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. The Alabama case cited for lack of honest belief despite objective circumstances is Hanson v. Couch. (p. 1271)
38
New cards
  1. The Alabama case calling malicious prosecution disfavored by law is ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. The Alabama case calling malicious prosecution disfavored by law is Moon v. Pillion. (p. 1273)
39
New cards
  1. Skaggs illustrates that continued prosecution after proof of repayment can demonstrate a lack of ________________________. [p. 1268]
  1. Skaggs illustrates that continued prosecution after proof of repayment can demonstrate a lack of probable cause. (p. 1268)
40
New cards
  1. In Skaggs, using criminal prosecution as debt collection supported an inference of ________________________. [p. 1269]
  1. In Skaggs, using criminal prosecution as debt collection supported an inference of malice. (p. 1269)
41
New cards
  1. Under the chapter’s case notes, an acquittal is not affirmative proof that the accuser lacked ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. Under the chapter’s case notes, an acquittal is not affirmative proof that the accuser lacked probable cause. (p. 1272)
42
New cards
  1. The subjective factual question of honest belief should not be confused with the court’s ultimate ________________________ about probable cause. [p. 1271]
  1. The subjective factual question of honest belief should not be confused with the court’s ultimate legal determination about probable cause. (p. 1271)
43
New cards

H1.01. A merchant reports a customer for theft but never discloses video proving the customer paid. The merchant urges continued prosecution. Charges are later dismissed for insufficient evidence. Prompt: Identify the strongest tort and the probable-cause issue.

H1.01. Criminal malicious prosecution is the strongest theory; deliberate nondisclosure and insistence on continuation undermine honest and reasonable probable cause. Analyze favorable termination, malice, and damages.

44
New cards

H1.02. A homeowner honestly and reasonably believes a burglar broke in. A prosecutor independently reviews a truthful report and charges an innocent neighbor; the neighbor is acquitted. Prompt: Is acquittal by itself enough to establish malicious prosecution against the homeowner?

H1.02. No. Acquittal does not establish lack of probable cause; truthful reporting with an independent prosecutorial decision may also fail the initiation element.

45
New cards

H1.03. A shop manager files criminal charges solely to force repayment of a civil debt, despite knowing that no crime occurred. Prompt: What is the malice analysis?

H1.03. Using criminal charges to collect a debt is an improper purpose; this supports malice, together with lack of probable cause, but the other elements still require proof.

46
New cards

H1.04. A prosecution terminates because the accused agrees to a voluntary compromise that leaves guilt unresolved. Prompt: What is the vulnerable element?

H1.04. Favorable termination is vulnerable under the approach described in Skaggs; modern jurisdictional standards must be identified.

47
New cards

H1.05. An employee is charged after a supervisor makes a reasonable factual mistake despite a fair investigation. A jury later acquits the employee. Prompt: Which element is most difficult to establish?

H1.05. Absence of probable cause is difficult where the supervisor honestly and reasonably believed the facts; a later acquittal is not conclusive.

48
New cards

H1.06. The accuser gives counsel a selective account omitting facts demonstrating innocence. Counsel recommends prosecution. Prompt: Does the advice-of-counsel rule conclusively establish probable cause?

H1.06. No. The protective advice-of-counsel rule requires good faith and full, fair disclosure; selective omission defeats that prerequisite.

49
New cards

H1.07. A plaintiff proves malicious criminal prosecution and seeks lost work, humiliation, criminal-defense costs, and punitive damages. Prompt: Separate potentially compensatory and punitive categories.

H1.07. Lost work, humiliation, and defense expenses may support compensatory recovery, subject to proof and jurisdiction; punitive damages require separate jurisdiction-specific grounds.

50
New cards
  1. Both malicious prosecution and abuse of process regulate misuse of the ________________________. [p. 1283]
  1. Both malicious prosecution and abuse of process regulate misuse of the legal system. (p. 1283)
51
New cards
  1. Unlike abuse of process, criminal malicious prosecution requires a favorable ________________________. [p. 1282]
  1. Unlike abuse of process, criminal malicious prosecution requires a favorable termination. (p. 1282)
52
New cards
  1. Unlike abuse of process, malicious prosecution ordinarily requires lack of ________________________. [p. 1282]
  1. Unlike abuse of process, malicious prosecution ordinarily requires lack of probable cause. (p. 1282)
53
New cards
  1. One may pursue an improper objective without the special act of process misuse required by ________________________. [p. 1275]
  1. One may pursue an improper objective without the special act of process misuse required by abuse of process. (p. 1275)
54
New cards
  1. The plaintiff bears the burden to show the absence of ________________________. [p. 1267]
  1. The plaintiff bears the burden to show the absence of probable cause. (p. 1267)
55
New cards
  1. The plaintiff also must prove the defendant’s ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. The plaintiff also must prove the defendant’s malice. (p. 1266)
56
New cards
  1. The accusing party relying on advice of counsel must establish full and fair ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. The accusing party relying on advice of counsel must establish full and fair disclosure. (p. 1272)
57
New cards
  1. Compensatory recovery may include injury to ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. Compensatory recovery may include injury to reputation. (p. 1273)
58
New cards
  1. Humiliation and mental distress are examples of ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. Humiliation and mental distress are examples of noneconomic injury. (p. 1273)
59
New cards
  1. Reasonable fees spent defending the criminal proceeding can constitute ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. Reasonable fees spent defending the criminal proceeding can constitute special damages. (p. 1273)
60
New cards
  1. Punitive damages may be available, but their heightened requirements may vary by ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. Punitive damages may be available, but their heightened requirements may vary by jurisdiction. (p. 1273)
61
New cards
  1. The Second Restatement sections cited for termination are §§ ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. The Second Restatement sections cited for termination are §§ 658 and 659. (p. 1266)
62
New cards
  1. The Second Restatement section cited for malice is § ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. The Second Restatement section cited for malice is § 668. (p. 1273)
63
New cards
  1. The Third Restatement of Liability for Economic Harm provision addressing favorable criminal termination is § ________________________. [p. 1272]
  1. The Third Restatement of Liability for Economic Harm provision addressing favorable criminal termination is § 23. (p. 1272)
64
New cards
  1. Texas Skaggs applied an Arkansas formulation of ________________________. [p. 1266]
  1. Texas Skaggs applied an Arkansas formulation of criminal malicious prosecution. (p. 1266)
65
New cards
  1. Hanson v. Couch is discussed as an ________________________ decision. [p. 1271]
  1. Hanson v. Couch is discussed as an Alabama decision. (p. 1271)
66
New cards
  1. The precise effect of dismissal on favorable termination can vary across ________________________. [p. 1271]
  1. The precise effect of dismissal on favorable termination can vary across jurisdictions. (p. 1271)
67
New cards
  1. The chapter identifies Alabama as among jurisdictions cautious about expanding ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. The chapter identifies Alabama as among jurisdictions cautious about expanding malicious prosecution. (p. 1273)
68
New cards
  1. The Restatement (Third) calls malicious civil prosecution ________________________. [p. 1280]
  1. The Restatement (Third) calls malicious civil prosecution wrongful use of civil proceedings. (p. 1280)
69
New cards
  1. Civil proceedings concern the assertion of a legal ________________________ rather than a criminal charge. [p. 1280]
  1. Civil proceedings concern the assertion of a legal claim rather than a criminal charge. (p. 1280)
70
New cards
  1. The disfavored recovery rule requiring unusual harm is the ________________________. [p. 1276]
  1. The disfavored recovery rule requiring unusual harm is the English rule. (p. 1276)
71
New cards
  1. The more permissive approach is commonly called the ________________________. [p. 1276]
  1. The more permissive approach is commonly called the American rule. (p. 1276)
72
New cards
  1. The original civil proceeding generally must terminate in the present plaintiff’s ________________________. [p. 1277]
  1. The original civil proceeding generally must terminate in the present plaintiff’s favor. (p. 1277)
73
New cards
  1. Civil malicious prosecution also requires absence of ________________________. [p. 1277]
  1. Civil malicious prosecution also requires absence of probable cause. (p. 1277)
74
New cards
  1. An additional mental element is an improper purpose, also called ________________________. [p. 1277]
  1. An additional mental element is an improper purpose, also called malice. (p. 1277)
75
New cards
  1. Under Michigan’s approach in Friedman, a civil malicious prosecution plaintiff must plead ________________________. [p. 1276]
  1. Under Michigan’s approach in Friedman, a civil malicious prosecution plaintiff must plead special injury. (p. 1276)
76
New cards
  1. In wrongful use of civil proceedings, damages generally must be ________________________ rather than assumed. [p. 1280]
  1. In wrongful use of civil proceedings, damages generally must be proved rather than assumed. (p. 1280)
77
New cards
  1. An attorney’s ordinary adversarial obligation is owed primarily to the ________________________. [p. 1275]
  1. An attorney’s ordinary adversarial obligation is owed primarily to the client. (p. 1275)
78
New cards
  1. A civil claim need not have a better-than-even chance of success to have ________________________. [p. 1280]
  1. A civil claim need not have a better-than-even chance of success to have probable cause. (p. 1280)
79
New cards
  1. Losing a lawsuit does not by itself establish absence of ________________________. [p. 1278]
  1. Losing a lawsuit does not by itself establish absence of probable cause. (p. 1278)
80
New cards
  1. Courts weigh access to courts against retaliatory ________________________. [p. 1277]
  1. Courts weigh access to courts against retaliatory litigation. (p. 1277)
81
New cards
  1. An attorney’s good-faith pursuit of a close or novel legal theory is not automatically ________________________. [p. 1279]
  1. An attorney’s good-faith pursuit of a close or novel legal theory is not automatically wrongful. (p. 1279)
82
New cards
  1. The English rule historically identifies injury to fame, liberty, or ________________________. [p. 1276]
  1. The English rule historically identifies injury to fame, liberty, or property. (p. 1276)
83
New cards
  1. A lawyer’s concern about liability to the adversary could create a ________________________. [p. 1275]
  1. A lawyer’s concern about liability to the adversary could create a conflict of interest. (p. 1275)
84
New cards
  1. One rationale for a special-injury requirement is discouraging ________________________ that multiply litigation. [p. 1277]
  1. One rationale for a special-injury requirement is discouraging countersuits that multiply litigation. (p. 1277)
85
New cards
  1. Rule 11 sanctions focus mainly on ________________________ rather than compensation. [p. 1281]
  1. Rule 11 sanctions focus mainly on deterrence rather than compensation. (p. 1281)
86
New cards
  1. The special-injury requirement depends on the jurisdiction’s choice between the English and ________________________ rules. [p. 1276]
  1. The special-injury requirement depends on the jurisdiction’s choice between the English and American rules. (p. 1276)
87
New cards
  1. Rule 11 sanctions do not automatically require the same elements as ________________________. [p. 1282]
  1. Rule 11 sanctions do not automatically require the same elements as malicious prosecution. (p. 1282)
88
New cards
  1. A losing malpractice claim does not by itself furnish a cause of action for attorney ________________________. [p. 1275]
  1. A losing malpractice claim does not by itself furnish a cause of action for attorney negligence to the opposing party. (p. 1275)
89
New cards
  1. The chapter indicates a purely contractual arbitration defeat may be insufficient for a California ________________________ action. [p. 1280]
  1. The chapter indicates a purely contractual arbitration defeat may be insufficient for a California malicious prosecution action. (p. 1280)
90
New cards
  1. Under Friedman, attorney liability for improper purpose needs evidence independent of the proof of no ________________________. [p. 1279]
  1. Under Friedman, attorney liability for improper purpose needs evidence independent of the proof of no probable cause. (p. 1279)
91
New cards
  1. The special-injury approach limits cases to damage beyond the usual expense of ________________________. [p. 1276]
  1. The special-injury approach limits cases to damage beyond the usual expense of defending a lawsuit. (p. 1276)
92
New cards
  1. The no-duty-to-adversary principle rejects ordinary ________________________ liability against opposing counsel. [p. 1275]
  1. The no-duty-to-adversary principle rejects ordinary negligence liability against opposing counsel. (p. 1275)
93
New cards
  1. For federal pleadings, a signed filing must reflect an inquiry ________________________. [p. 1281]
  1. For federal pleadings, a signed filing must reflect an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances. (p. 1281)
94
New cards
  1. A physician’s unsuccessful original case was a medical ________________________ suit. [p. 1274]
  1. A physician’s unsuccessful original case was a medical malpractice suit. (p. 1274)
95
New cards
  1. Attorney conduct must be distinguished from a client’s improper ________________________. [p. 1279]
  1. Attorney conduct must be distinguished from a client’s improper motive. (p. 1279)
96
New cards
  1. A claim for malicious civil proceedings generally cannot ripen until favorable ________________________ of the first proceeding. [p. 1281]
  1. A claim for malicious civil proceedings generally cannot ripen until favorable termination of the first proceeding. (p. 1281)
97
New cards
  1. Federal Rule 11 has a notice and ________________________ withdrawal opportunity for qualifying motion-based sanctions. [p. 1281]
  1. Federal Rule 11 has a notice and 21-day withdrawal opportunity for qualifying motion-based sanctions. (p. 1281)
98
New cards
  1. The principal civil-proceedings case is ________________________. [p. 1273]
  1. The principal civil-proceedings case is Friedman v. Dozorc. (p. 1273)
99
New cards
  1. The claimant in Friedman was the physician Dr. ________________________. [p. 1274]
  1. The claimant in Friedman was the physician Dr. Friedman. (p. 1274)
100
New cards
  1. The Michigan Supreme Court rejected an actionable negligence duty to an ________________________. [p. 1275]
  1. The Michigan Supreme Court rejected an actionable negligence duty to an adverse party. (p. 1275)