1/245
Looks like no tags are added yet.
The tort that addresses wrongful criminal charges is ________________________. [p. 1265]
The tort that addresses wrongful criminal charges is malicious prosecution. (p. 1265)
The legal process challenged in this unit is a ________________________. [p. 1266]
The legal process challenged in this unit is a criminal prosecution. (p. 1266)
H1.01. A merchant reports a customer for theft but never discloses video proving the customer paid. The merchant urges continued prosecution. Charges are later dismissed for insufficient evidence. Prompt: Identify the strongest tort and the probable-cause issue.
H1.01. Criminal malicious prosecution is the strongest theory; deliberate nondisclosure and insistence on continuation undermine honest and reasonable probable cause. Analyze favorable termination, malice, and damages.
H1.02. A homeowner honestly and reasonably believes a burglar broke in. A prosecutor independently reviews a truthful report and charges an innocent neighbor; the neighbor is acquitted. Prompt: Is acquittal by itself enough to establish malicious prosecution against the homeowner?
H1.02. No. Acquittal does not establish lack of probable cause; truthful reporting with an independent prosecutorial decision may also fail the initiation element.
H1.03. A shop manager files criminal charges solely to force repayment of a civil debt, despite knowing that no crime occurred. Prompt: What is the malice analysis?
H1.03. Using criminal charges to collect a debt is an improper purpose; this supports malice, together with lack of probable cause, but the other elements still require proof.
H1.04. A prosecution terminates because the accused agrees to a voluntary compromise that leaves guilt unresolved. Prompt: What is the vulnerable element?
H1.04. Favorable termination is vulnerable under the approach described in Skaggs; modern jurisdictional standards must be identified.
H1.05. An employee is charged after a supervisor makes a reasonable factual mistake despite a fair investigation. A jury later acquits the employee. Prompt: Which element is most difficult to establish?
H1.05. Absence of probable cause is difficult where the supervisor honestly and reasonably believed the facts; a later acquittal is not conclusive.
H1.06. The accuser gives counsel a selective account omitting facts demonstrating innocence. Counsel recommends prosecution. Prompt: Does the advice-of-counsel rule conclusively establish probable cause?
H1.06. No. The protective advice-of-counsel rule requires good faith and full, fair disclosure; selective omission defeats that prerequisite.
H1.07. A plaintiff proves malicious criminal prosecution and seeks lost work, humiliation, criminal-defense costs, and punitive damages. Prompt: Separate potentially compensatory and punitive categories.
H1.07. Lost work, humiliation, and defense expenses may support compensatory recovery, subject to proof and jurisdiction; punitive damages require separate jurisdiction-specific grounds.