1/53
Looks like no tags are added yet.
tort
a civil wrong other than a breach of contract that causes another person injury or harm, resulting in legal liability
tort law
intended to compensate those who suffer a loss (damages), injury (death), due to another’s wrongful (possibly criminal) act
some torts provide a basis for:
criminal prosecution and a civil lawsuit based on tort, brought by the private victim (plaintiff) against wrongdoer (defendant), goal is to compensate injured party for their losses through monetary damages rather than to punish offender
purpose of tort law
provide remedies for protected interests, including freedom from personal injury or interference with physical security and freedom of movement, wrongs and compensation
tort law provides legal remedies for:
personal injury/wrongful death
property damage
harm to reputation
invasion of privacy
false imprisonment
compensatory damages
designed to reimburse injured party for actual losses and make them “whole” again, put them back into position they would have been in had tort never occurred; special and general
compensatory damages - special
compensate plaintiff fro quantifiable monetary losses such as:
medical expenses
lost wages and benefits (present and future)
extra costs
loss of irreplaceable items
cost of repairing or replacing damaged property
compensatory damages - general
compensate individuals for individuals (not businesses) for non monetary harm, such as:
pain and suffering
loss of consortium
punitive damages
when defendant’s intentional conduct was particularly egregious or reprehensible, purpose is to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar conduct in the future
punitive damages may be available in two situations:
intentional torts
gross negligence
rarely awarded in ordinary negligence, typically reserved for situations where conduct was intentional, malicious, outrageous
eighth amendment
excessive fines and punishments, “excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted” generally applies to criminal law and protects individuals from government punishments and excessive fines paid to the state, generally does not apply to private torts because money goes to private plaintiff rather than government
due process, fourteenth amendment
requires that no person or corporation be deprived of life, liberty, or property without fair procedures and non arbitrary laws, directly limits tort awards and strikes down on “grossly excessive” punitive damages as an unconstitutional taking of property
legislative caps on damages
target general damages mainly and statutory limits on punitive damages to prevent massive punishment wards
limit amount of both punitive and general damages
capping attorneys contingency fees
requiring losing party to pay both plaintiff and defendant’s expenses
intentional torts
requires that defendant committed an act with intent to consequences of that act or knew with substantial certainty that specific consequences would result, not necessarily about intending to cause harm but rather intending to do the act that brings about the result; intending to punch someone, even if you didn’t mean to break their nose
unintentional torts
carelessness or failure to act as a “reasonable” person, occurs when someone suffers injury because the defendant failed to exercise a sufficient standard of care, but without any intent to cause harm
defense for intentional torts
consent, self defense, necessity
defense for negligent torts
comparative negligence, assumption of risk, superseding clause, statue of limitations
intentional torts against persons
intentional tort requires the intent to commit an act, an evil or harmful motive is not required
assault
any intentional act that creates a reasonable apprehension or fear of immediate harmful or offensive physical contact, focused on the anticipation and threat of harm, rather than the physical contact itself
an intentional
unexcused threat
immediate harmful
offensive contact
apprehension not the same as fear
someone can commit assault without ever touching the victim, raising a fist and treating to punch someone within arm’s reach creates an immediate apprehension of battery, qualifying as a civil assault
battery
unexcused and harmful or offensive intentional physical contact, any unpermitted, offensive contact, whether harmful or not, is battery; plaintiff must show they did not grant permission for this act; contact must result in actual physical harm or be offensive to personal dignity, spitting on someone, unwanted groping, aggressively snatching an item out of someone’s hands
eggshell/thin skull rule
if a defendant commits a tort, they are held fully liable for all the resulting damages and injuries
defenses to assault and battery
self defense, defense of others, defense of property; threat must be happening right now or immediately ahead, force used in response must be proportional to the threat, cannot use deadly force to find off a minor push or verbal threat
false imprisonment
intentional confinement or restraint without justification, interference with freedom to move without restriction:
physical barriers
physical restraint
threats of physical force
consent is a defense
shopkeepers privilege
allows a merchant to detain a suspected shoplifter under specific conditions, as long as it is reasonable in time and manner
intentional infliction of emotional distress
extreme and outrageous conduct exceeding society’s bounds of decency, resulting in sever emotional distress to another; must act with deliberate intent or with reckless disregard
i.k. v banana republic
johnny chan previously employed at kaiser and discovered secretly recording other employees using restroom and fired as result
later hired by banana republic, did the same
affected employees sued banana republic for negligent hiring
banana republic ultimately lost, right to privacy a legally protected interest especially in a place like restrooms
defenses to iied
consent, context matters; behavior not considered atrocious, did not act with deliberate purpose of causing emotional distress, or with reckless disregard, can dispute the security of emotional trauma, demonstrate plaintiff’s emotional distress caused by other unrelated events
defamation
wrongfully hurting another’s good reputation
false statement of fact
statement was understood to be about the plaintiff and harmed the plaintiff’s reputation
statement was published
if plaintiff was public figure, must have been made with actual malice
statement of fact requirement
must assert or imply a provably false statement of fact rather than a protected expression of opinion, hyperbole, satires, general insults generally protected
damages for libel
generally viewed as more damaging because they leave a permanent record and can be widely circulated, can recover general damages without needing to prove specific economic losses
damages for slander
requires special damages unlike libel, spoken words traditionally viewed as more temporary and limited
defenses to defamation
truth, plaintiff cannot win lawsuit regardless of speaker’s malicious intent if defamatory statement is substantially true
actual malice
knowledge of falsity and reckless disregard of the truth
invasion of privacy
individuals have a right to solitude and freedom from prying eyes
intrusion
intentional physical or electronic intrusion into a person’s private affairs or spaces in a way that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person, focuses on how the information was gathered
publication of information that places a person in a false light
publicly placing someone in a false light that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person, may also be defamation, acted in reckless disregard regarding falsity
public disclosure of private facts
highly intimate, private details that are not of public concern
(mis)appropriation of identity
use of a person’s name, picture, likeness or other identifiable characteristic for commercial purposes without permission
fraudulent misrepresentation
occurs when a party unknowingly or recklessly makes a false statement of material fact to induce another person to act or enter into a transaction, resulting in actual loss and intentional deception
misrepresentation or failure to disclose a material fact with knowledge it is false or reckless disregard for the truth
intent to induce reliance on the misrepresentation
justifiable reliance
damages
causation
false statement must be made with specific intent that plaintiff would rely on it and take a specific course of action, must actually rely on misrepresentation
statement of fact vs opinion
requires more than sellers talk, requires statement of fact such as new thing installed, buyer cannot sue if seller says it is greatest car on earth
negligent misrepresentation
occurs when a party makes a false statement of material fact in a professional capacity without exercising reasonable care or competence, misrepresentation not intentional but without a reasonable basis for believing its truthfulness; usually requires duty of care to supply correct information
malicious prosecution
lawsuits that lack any reasonable basis in law or fact, initiated primarily to harass, delay, or extract improper concessions from opponent; plaintiff must prove that defendant actively initiated judicial proceeding against plaintiff with lack of probable cause
abuse of process
perversion or misuse of a specific legal procedure such as subpoenas, attachments, garnishments, or discovery requests after a lawsuit has already been lawfully or unlawfully initiated, in order to achieve ulterior advantage; must be an improper act using the process itself
wrongful interference with a contractual relationship
when an outsider improperly meddles in an existing, valid contract between two other parties, causing one of them to breach it and inflicting economic harm on the other
a valid enforceable contract
knowledge of contract
intentionally inducing a breach
wrongful interference with a business relationship
unfair trade practice, difference between competitive practices and predatory behavior; plaintiff must prove that defendant’s interference involved independently wrongful or unlawful means such as fraud, violence, defamation, threats, or antitrust violations rather than normal aggressive competition
established business relationship
predatory methods to intentionally cause relationship to end
damages
defenses to wrongful interference
competitor’s privilege, able to aggressively solicit customers, offer lower prices, or market superior products, even if it causes a rival to lose business or fail to secure a contract, only fails when they use illegal and improper means
intentional torts against property
protects an individual’s legal rights, possessory interests, and ownership in both real property and personal property, focus entirely on unauthorized interference with material assets and economic security
trespass to land
anyone who without permission enter on to, above, or below land owned by another, causes anything to enter, remains on the land, permits anything to remain; actual harm or damage not required; if defendant honestly believes they have permission but are mistaken, intent still satisfied as long as they intended the physical movement
attractive nuisance doctrine
if landowner maintains a dangerous condition on their property that is likely to lure children onto the land, landowner can be held liable for physical injuries suffered by child
defenses against trespass to land
warranted, public necessity and protecting community as a whole, private necessity and protecting themselves but may still have to pay for actual harm, consent or having a license and can be explicitly stated but usually limited
trespass to personal property
taking, harm or interference with owner’s possession and enjoyment without consent; damage or destruction or anything else that diminishes value, condition, or quality; good faith mistake not defense and intent still satisfied even if you mistakenly believe you have permission
conversion
occurs when defendant exercises such an intentional level of control over another person’s personal property that it completely deprives owner of use; defendant takes, alters, destroys personal property