1/73
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Partisan media
News outlets that openly report on government and politics from a stated political or ideological point of view, rather than a neutral, “objective” position
Why partisan media
Statehouse bureaus shrink
Partisan outlets fill coverage gaps
Audiences silo into new markets
Self-sorting efffect
Plethora of media options available; audiences select sources that confirm, rather than challenge, their viewpoints
Three core questions of judicial branch
Selection
Power
Structure
Judicial selection
Who picks and removes judges? Legislature? Governor? Voters?
Structure
How many levels of court? Who runs them?
Judicial power
How far may judges go in striking down laws passed by elected officials and voters?
Assissted appointment
Nominating commission screens top justices, governor appoints, then retention votes
System used in 21 states
Judicial elections
13 nonpartisan (including Wisconsin)
8 partisan
Michigan’s hybrid
Direct appointment
5 by the governor w/ confirmation, 2 (SC and Virginia) by the legislature
Judicial terms
6 year common, most states set retirement at 70-75
New York Court of APpeals
One of the longest fixed terms, 14 years
Rhode Island judicial terms
Serve for life
Appellate Layers
42 states have an intermediate appeals court b/w trial courts and the supreme court
Ex. Nevada voters created one in 2014
Maine
No appellate layer
Unified trail court system
Trial courts merged into one level.
Ex. California (2001)
Complex trial court system
States keep many separate trial courts
Ex. New York
Texas & Oklahoma
Both states split civil and criminal appeals b/w two high courts
New York
“Supreme Court” is a trail court, top court is actually Court of Appeals
Delaware
Court of Chancery; hearts major corporate disputes
Miami-Dade County, 1989
First drug court; judge supervises treatment, testing, and progress
FIrst “problem solving court”
Problem-Solving Courts
Courts where a judge supervises cases at all levels beyond sentencing
Laboratory → model began in Miami, exported nationally via federal grants
Modern problem-solving courts
Veterans, mental health, DWI, family treatment
Studies find graduates reoffend less
Electoral pressure
Study found Pennsylvania trial judges found sentences grew longer as elections neared
Elected judges
Tend to be more productive, but also potentially subject to electoral pressure & donor influence
Appointed judges
Tend to write better opinions, repeatedly survive retention votes, but are easily pressured by governors and lawyers
Why judicial elections?
Accountability for judges who shape policy
Appointments shifts power to governors
Contested races gives voters infomration
Why judicial appointments?
Judges should follow the law, and the law only
Commissions can screen for experience
Trust Paradox
As level of government power decreases, Americans tend to trust that government level more
Local → state → federal
Functions of local government
Law enforcement
Roads
Utilities
Parks & Libraries
Schools
Unit overlap
Local governments cannot dictate school districts & vice versa, despite both levels sharing the same residents
Cooperation solves
Georgia
153 counties, 535 municipalities
Reflects Georgia’s colonial distrust of central government → divide power b/w different counties
Hawaii
3 counties, 1 municipality
Reflects Hawaii’s history as a sovereign nation → more used to central government system
Dillon’s Rule
Local government may exercise powers only explicitly granted to them by the state
Ex. Towns and counties in Wisco
Home rule
Local governments may do anything they are not expressly forbidden to by the state
Ex. Villages and cities in Wisco
Preemption
When a state overrides local ordinances
Counties
Derived from English shire law; state’s local branch office for courts, records, and logistical services
Towns
General purpose government, covers unincorporated land outside cities and villages
Villages
Incorporated municipalities, 2,500 residents
Cities
5,000 residents to incorporate a metro are
Organizational trade off
Local control and responsiveness for gov. close to people
Economies of scale and top-down reform with more centralized control
Strong Mayor model
Mayor appoints department heads and can veto city council
Ex. Chicago, NYC
Weak Mayor model
Mayor is largely ceremonial role, council holds most power
Majority of American cities, ex. Dallas, TX
Council-manager model
Council hires a professional city manager to execute policy
Ex. San Antonio, TX
Commission model
Elecrted commissioners each run a city department
Rare today, ex. Portland until 2022
Unique facets of Wisconsin local government
More towns than almost any state
Heavy reliance on property tax
Constitutional home rule for some units only
Wisconsin school districts
440 school districts statewide, 3 to 11 members, 3 year terms
Levies own property tax
Special-purpose district
Exists when one problem does not fit inside existing county or city-lines, mandates a government solely dedicated to rectifying that issue
Ex. Brown County is in a special district for Lambeau’s maintenance
Three sources of local gov revenue
Property tax
Shared revenue
Fees
Municipalities control little of their two largest revenue sources
Property tax
Largest source of revenue for local governments, constrained by state levy limits
State aid
Shared revenue, expenditure restrain and general transportation aid
Fees
Charges for parking, garbage collection, parks, etc.
Fully under control of local govs, but “can only charge so much for parking”
Cooperative agreements
Allows conflict districts to settle disputes w/o litigation
Requires a plan, consistency with all levels of law, and DoA approval
Drivers of investment
Operating cost structure
Labor availability
Labor skill
Location and incentive
4 common cost structures
Energy
Income tax
Property tax
Health Insurance
Energy costs
~9,000 Wisconsin manufacturers use more electricity than all 2.8 million households
Mid-pack for Midwest rates
Taxes cost
7.65% (9th highest)
Tax burden strongest predictor of migration b/w states
Health insurance
Wisco has third highest healthcare cost in America
$27,309
Janesville
Most expensive healthcare market in lower 48; one hospital system w/o competition
Fastest growing labor markets?
Texas, Florida, Carolina
Labor availability
60% of WMC members reported trouble hiring, no replacement-level birthrates since 1974
Labor skill (disad)
Wisconsin talent pool struggling, less workers available
Labor skill (ad)
Strong technical college & apprenticeship systems, tailor programs to local employers
Haribo example
Chose Wisconsin specifically for its skilled workforce
Important location factors
Proximity to target market
Access to water
Nearby infrastructure
Adequate labor pool in commuting distance
Climate
Types of incentives
Cash
Tax credits
Infrastructure
Training grants
Tax incremental financing
Cash incentives
Direct payments or facilities to entice development
Ex. Las Vegas paid Raiders
Tax credits
Most common form of incentives offered, X amount of dollars off per job created
Ex. Austin, TX issued tax credit for Tesla gigaplant
Infrastructure
Public builds roads, sewer, water, or parking
Ex. ~$60M in roads around Miller Park
Training grants
State provide corps with grants to train up local works, overcome skill hurdles
Tax incremental financing (TIF)
Local government dedicates the new property taxes from a development to paying off the infrastructure built for it
Ex. Epic in Verona
CHIPS Act
$52.7B in federal incentives to rebuilding domestic chip manufacturing post-COVID
Mercury Marine (2009)
Planned to move to Oklahoma; state offered $70M low-interest loan → Mercury stayed, moved all manufacturing to Wisco, now a massively successful company
Manufacturing and Agricultural Tax Credit (2011)
Industry-wide income tax credit based on goods produced in Wisconsin
Grew Wisconsin border county manufacturing jobs by 17%, other states lost 4%