1/8
Looks like no tags are added yet.
1. Introduction: The EU as a legal order
1.1 What is the EU legal order?
The EU is described as a new and distinct legal order, separate from traditional international law and national law.
This was established in:
Case 26/62 Van Gend en Loos [1963]
The Court of Justice stated that:
The Community constitutes a new legal order of international law.
This was significant because the Court was saying that EU law was not simply an ordinary international treaty between Member States.
Instead, EU law creates rights and obligations for:
Member States.
Individuals.
Businesses.
Individuals can enforce certain EU rights directly before their national courts.
Why is this important?
Normally, international treaties primarily regulate relationships between states. However, EU law goes further by allowing individuals to rely on certain EU legal provisions in national courts.
For example, an individual or business may rely on an EU right when bringing a claim against another party or a Member State, provided the relevant conditions are satisfied.
The lecturer also highlighted that the UK's Trade and Cooperation Agreement with the EU expressly excludes direct effect. This illustrates that not every agreement with the EU creates enforceable individual rights.
1.2 Four characteristics of the EU legal order
Characteristic | Meaning |
Direct effect | Certain EU law provisions create rights for individuals which can be enforced before national courts. |
Supremacy (primacy) | EU law takes precedence over conflicting national law. |
Autonomy | EU law operates as an independent legal order, distinct from national and traditional international law. |
Dual model of enforcement | EU law can be enforced both by individuals through national courts and by the Commission through proceedings against Member States. |
The principle of autonomy
EU law is autonomous because it has its own legal system and its own methods of interpretation.
It is not simply controlled by traditional international law or the domestic legal systems of Member States.
The lecturer explained that the CJEU has developed its own interpretation of EU law, even where international law addresses similar issues.
The dual model of enforcement
EU law can be enforced in two ways:
Enforcement from below: Individuals bring legal proceedings before national courts to protect their EU law rights.
Enforcement from above: The European Commission brings proceedings against Member States that fail to comply with EU law.
The Commission is known as the guardian of the Treaties.
Relevant provisions: Articles 258–260 TFEU.
1.3 The Court's interpretative approach: Teleological interpretation
The CJEU frequently uses a teleological (purposive) approach when interpreting EU law.
This means that the Court considers:
The purpose of the Treaty.
The aims of EU integration.
What the Member States were trying to achieve.
The wider objectives behind the legislation.
Rather than looking only at the literal wording, the Court considers the spirit and purpose of EU law.
Example: In Van Gend en Loos, the Court interpreted the Treaty in a way that recognised individuals as holders of enforceable EU rights.
This approach is important throughout the development of EU law, including the creation of supremacy.
2. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)
2.1 Structure of the CJEU
Article 19 TEU establishes the Court of Justice of the European Union.
The CJEU consists of:
The Court of Justice: The higher court, which deals with preliminary rulings and appeals from the General Court, among other matters.
The General Court: Deals with certain direct actions and other matters within its jurisdiction.
Specialised courts: Courts that may be established to deal with particular categories of cases.
Important historical terminology
Former name | Current name |
European Court of Justice (ECJ) | Court of Justice |
Court of First Instance (CFI) | General Court |
The lecturer explained that the General Court was established in 1989 because the Court of Justice was becoming overwhelmed with cases as EU membership and the EU's powers expanded.
The Lisbon Treaty renamed the Court of First Instance as the General Court.
Important: The CJEU refers to the EU judicial institution as a whole, whereas the Court of Justice is one of its constituent courts.
2.2 The role of the CJEU and national courts
Article 19(1) TEU
The CJEU:
Shall ensure that in the interpretation and application of the Treaties the law is observed.
In simple terms, the Court ensures that EU law is interpreted and applied correctly.
However, the CJEU does not work alone. National courts also play an important role in enforcing EU law within Member States.
Article 4(3) TEU – Duty of sincere cooperation
Member States must cooperate with the EU and take appropriate measures to fulfil their obligations under EU law.
This means Member States must:
Comply with EU law.
Take appropriate steps to enforce EU obligations.
Avoid actions that undermine EU objectives.
The lecturer explained that the CJEU has relied on this principle to develop the responsibilities of national courts when applying EU law.
Article 19(1), second paragraph, TEU – Effective legal protection
Member States must provide sufficient remedies to ensure effective legal protection in areas covered by EU law.
This provision was introduced by the Lisbon Treaty.
Its original purpose was to improve individuals' access to justice, particularly in judicial review proceedings.
However, the CJEU has also used it to protect the independence of national courts.
For example, concerns about judicial independence in countries such as Poland and Portugal have made this provision particularly important.
Key point: Article 19 TEU is important not only because it establishes the role of the CJEU but also because it supports effective judicial protection and the rule of law within Member States.
2.3 Jurisdiction of the CJEU
Article 19(3) TEU
The Court of Justice has jurisdiction to:
Rule on actions brought by Member States, EU institutions and individuals or legal persons, where the Treaties provide.
Give preliminary rulings.
Rule in other cases provided for by the Treaties.
There are two main categories of proceedings:
Direct actions.
Indirect actions.
2.4 Direct actions
Direct actions involve proceedings brought directly before the EU courts.
They include:
Action | Treaty provision | Purpose |
Infringement proceedings | Articles 258–260 TFEU | Enforce EU obligations against Member States. |
Action for annulment | Article 263 TFEU | Challenge the legality of EU institutional acts. |
Action for failure to act | Article 265 TFEU | Challenge an EU institution's failure to act when legally required. |
Non-contractual liability | Article 340 TFEU | Claim damages for unlawful conduct by EU institutions. |
A. Infringement proceedings – Articles 258–260 TFEU
These proceedings are used when a Member State fails to fulfil its obligations under EU law.
They can be brought by:
The European Commission.
Another Member State.
The Commission is the most common applicant.
How does it work?
A Member State allegedly breaches EU law.
The Commission investigates and normally attempts to resolve the issue.
If the problem is not resolved, the Commission can bring proceedings before the CJEU.
The Court determines whether the Member State has breached EU law.
Financial sanctions may be imposed in the circumstances provided for by the Treaties.
Remember: The Commission acts as the guardian of the Treaties.
B. Action for annulment – Article 263 TFEU
This is a form of judicial review.
It allows certain applicants to challenge the legality of acts adopted by EU institutions.
For example, an EU institution may adopt a measure that:
Breaches the Treaties.
Exceeds its legal powers.
Violates procedural requirements.
Misuses its powers.
Important case:
Case 294/83 Parti Ecologiste Les Verts v Parliament [1986]
The Court established that the EU is a Community based on the rule of law.
This means that neither Member States nor EU institutions can avoid judicial review of whether their actions comply with the Treaties.
Problem: Individuals face a very strict test when attempting to challenge EU acts directly under Article 263.
The Lisbon Treaty introduced limited reforms to improve access to justice, but the requirements remain restrictive.
C. Action for failure to act – Article 265 TFEU
This allows certain applicants to challenge an EU institution where it has unlawfully failed to act when it was legally required to do so.
D. Non-contractual liability – Article 340 TFEU
This allows claims for damages against EU institutions for harm caused by their unlawful conduct.
For example, a business might seek compensation where unlawful conduct by an EU institution has caused it financial loss.
2.5 Indirect actions: Preliminary ruling procedure
Particularly important
Article 267 TFEU
The preliminary ruling procedure allows national courts to refer questions to the CJEU about:
The interpretation of EU law.
The validity of EU legal acts.
Its main purpose is to ensure that EU law is interpreted and applied consistently across all Member States.
How does the procedure work?
1. National court
A dispute involving EU law arises. The national judge identifies a question about the interpretation or validity of EU law.
Question referred under Article 267 TFEU
2. CJEU
The CJEU considers the question and delivers its interpretation of EU law or ruling on validity.
Judgment returned to the national court
3. National court
The national court applies the CJEU's ruling to the original dispute and delivers its decision.
Important things to understand
The CJEU does not act as an appeal court for the national dispute.
Individuals cannot simply appeal their cases directly to the CJEU.
It is the national judge who decides whether to make a reference, subject to the Treaty obligations on courts of last instance.
The CJEU answers the EU law question.
The national court applies that answer to the facts of the case.
Binding effect: The ruling binds the referring national court. It also provides an authoritative interpretation that other national courts must follow when applying the same EU law.
When must a national court refer a question?
Article 267 distinguishes between different national courts.
Courts whose decisions can be appealed: They generally have discretion to refer a question where necessary.
Courts of last instance: They must generally refer questions of EU law interpretation where a ruling is necessary to give judgment, subject to recognised exceptions.
For questions concerning validity, national courts cannot themselves declare an EU act invalid. If they consider that an EU act may be invalid, they must refer the question to the CJEU.
Case: Case 314/85 Foto-Frost [1987]
Principle: National courts cannot declare EU acts invalid.
If a national court considers an EU measure invalid, it must refer the question to the CJEU.
Why?
To maintain uniformity across the EU. Otherwise, one national court could declare an EU measure invalid while another national court considers it valid.
Changes from October 2024
The General Court gained jurisdiction to give preliminary rulings in six specific areas.
One example is EU air passenger rights.
However, the Court of Justice retains an important supervisory role in maintaining consistency in EU law.
2.6 Why is the preliminary ruling procedure important?
The lecturer emphasised that this procedure has played a central role in developing the EU legal order.
There are five main functions.
Function | Explanation |
1. Uniformity | Ensures EU law is interpreted consistently across Member States. |
2. Constitutional development | Allows the CJEU to develop important principles such as direct effect, supremacy and fundamental rights protection. |
3. Protection of individuals | Allows national courts to protect individuals' EU rights through direct effect, indirect effect and State liability. |
4. Indirect judicial review | Allows individuals to challenge the validity of EU measures through proceedings before national courts. |
5. Judicial dialogue | Creates communication between national courts and the CJEU about the interpretation of EU law. |
Case: Case 166/73 Rheinmühlen [1974]
Relevant to the importance of the preliminary ruling procedure and the relationship between national courts and the CJEU.
Case: Case 314/85 Foto-Frost [1987]
Demonstrates how the procedure allows the CJEU to maintain uniformity by retaining the power to declare EU acts invalid.
Judicial dialogue
The relationship between national courts and the CJEU is not simply one-way.
National courts:
Ask questions about EU law.
Explain the legal problems they face.
Sometimes suggest possible interpretations.
The CJEU can accept, reject or develop the interpretation suggested by the national court.
This creates a form of judicial dialogue that contributes to the development of the EU legal order.
2.7 Accountability: The EU as a rule-of-law system
Article 2 TEU
The EU is founded on values including:
Human dignity.
Freedom.
Democracy.
Equality.
The rule of law.
Human rights.
These values establish the foundation of the EU legal system.
Case 294/83 Parti Ecologiste Les Verts [1986]
The Court described the EU as a Community based on the rule of law.
What does this mean?
EU institutions cannot exercise unlimited power. Their actions must comply with the Treaties and can be challenged through judicial review.
The action for annulment under Article 263 TFEU is one of the main ways of ensuring this accountability.
2.8 Enforcement of EU law
There are two main ways of enforcing EU law.
Enforcement from above | Enforcement from below |
The European Commission brings proceedings against Member States. | Individuals bring legal proceedings before national courts. |
Articles 258–260 TFEU. | National litigation relying on EU rights. |
Focuses on Member States complying with their obligations. | Focuses on protecting individual rights under EU law. |
Article 4(3) TEU – Sincere cooperation
Member States must take appropriate measures to fulfil their EU obligations and must not undermine EU objectives.
This supports the enforcement of EU law.
3. The principle of supremacy (primacy) of EU law
3.1 What is supremacy?
The principle of supremacy, also known as primacy, means that where EU law conflicts with national law, EU law takes precedence.
The lecturer explained that:
English-language legal literature commonly uses the word supremacy.
The CJEU and continental European legal literature generally use primacy.
Both terms refer to the same principle.
Important: Supremacy does not mean EU law overrides every national law automatically. It becomes relevant when there is a conflict between applicable EU law and national law.
3.2 Example: Conflict between EU law and national law
Imagine a Member State introduces a new law stating:
Companies can only register on its national companies register if the majority of their directors and shareholders are nationals of that Member State.
Company F is registered in that country, but most of its directors are nationals of another Member State.
The problem:
National law restricts company registration based on nationality.
EU law provides for freedom of establishment and non-discrimination based on nationality.
Question: Which law should apply?
Under the principle of supremacy, the conflicting national provision must give way to applicable EU law, provided the relevant EU provision can be relied upon in the dispute.
This illustrates why supremacy is important for maintaining the EU internal market.
3.3 Relationship between international law and national law
Before understanding supremacy, it is important to understand two approaches to the relationship between international law and domestic law.
A. Monism
Monism views international law and national law as part of one legal system.
International law becomes part of the domestic legal order once the relevant treaty is signed, according to the lecture's simplified explanation.
International law can take precedence over conflicting domestic law.
Examples from the lecture: France and the Netherlands.
B. Dualism
Dualism views international law and national law as two separate legal systems.
Signing an international treaty does not automatically make it part of domestic law.
The treaty must be incorporated into national law through legislation.
Under the doctrine of lex posterior, a later conflicting statute may take precedence over an earlier statute.
Examples from the lecture: Germany, Italy, Republic of Ireland and the UK.
Comparison
Monism | Dualism |
One legal system. | Two separate legal systems. |
International law becomes part of domestic law without separate incorporation. | International law requires incorporation into domestic law. |
International law can prevail over conflicting domestic law. | A later domestic statute may prevail under the traditional approach. |
The problem with EU law
The EU Treaties are silent on which law should prevail when EU law conflicts with national law.
This created a problem.
If each Member State applied its own constitutional rules, the outcome could differ between countries.
For example:
A monist state might give priority to international obligations.
A dualist state might apply a later national statute.
This would undermine the uniform application of EU law.
The CJEU therefore developed the principle of supremacy through its case law.
4. The origin of supremacy: Costa v ENEL
Case 6/64 Costa v ENEL [1964]
Facts
Mr Costa was an Italian citizen who challenged the nationalisation of Italy's electricity industry.
The Italian government had passed legislation nationalising electricity companies and creating ENEL, the national electricity company.
Costa argued that the national legislation conflicted with provisions of the EEC Treaty.
The issue was whether national legislation could override conflicting EU law.
Legal issue
Could a Member State override EU law by introducing its own national legislation?
Judgment
The CJEU held that the EEC Treaty had created its own legal system.
The Court stated that EU law:
Became an integral part of the legal systems of Member States.
Was binding on national courts.
Could not be overridden by domestic legal provisions.
The Court reasoned that allowing national law to override EU law would undermine the nature and effectiveness of the EU legal order.
Key quotation
The law stemming from the Treaty, an independent source of law, could not because of its special and original nature, be overridden by domestic legal provisions.
Principle established
EU law takes precedence over conflicting national law.
Why was the decision important?
The Treaties did not expressly establish supremacy.
The CJEU developed the principle through judicial interpretation.
It ensured that Member States could not undermine EU obligations by introducing conflicting national legislation.
It protected the uniform application and effectiveness of EU law.
Teleological interpretation in Costa
The Court used a purposive approach.
It considered the objectives of European integration and concluded that EU law could not function effectively if Member States could override it whenever they wished.
Remember: Costa v ENEL established the origin of the principle of supremacy.
5. Expansion of the principle of supremacy
After Costa v ENEL, further cases clarified how far supremacy extends and what national courts must do when a conflict arises.
There are three particularly important developments.
5.1 Supremacy applies even against national constitutions
Case 11/70 Internationale Handelsgesellschaft [1970]
Facts
A German national court questioned the validity of an EU regulation because it appeared to conflict with fundamental rights protected by the German Constitution.
The question was whether EU law could be challenged or overridden because it conflicted with a national constitution.
Judgment
The CJEU confirmed that EU law takes precedence over all national law, including national constitutional provisions.
The validity or effect of EU law cannot be affected simply because it allegedly conflicts with:
Fundamental rights protected by a national constitution.
Principles forming part of a national constitutional structure.
Principle established:
EU law takes precedence over all national law, however it is framed, including national constitutions.
Why is this important?
It extended the principle established in Costa v ENEL.
The Court was asserting the autonomy and authority of the EU legal order.
Important qualification: National constitutional courts
The lecturer explained that national constitutional courts have not universally accepted the CJEU's unconditional understanding of supremacy.
For example, the German Federal Constitutional Court has historically accepted supremacy subject to certain constitutional conditions, particularly concerning fundamental rights protection.
This creates tension between the CJEU's understanding of EU primacy and the constitutional identity or fundamental rights concerns of Member States.
The lecturer mentioned that Estonia is particularly accepting of the CJEU's position, whereas other national constitutional courts have asserted their own conditions.
For this topic, remember that the CJEU's position and the position of national constitutional courts are not always identical.
5.2 Supremacy applies to earlier and later national legislation
Case 106/77 Simmenthal (No 2) [1978]
Legal issue
What happens when national legislation conflicts with EU law?
Does it matter whether the national law was passed before or after the relevant EU law?
Judgment
The CJEU held that national courts must give full effect to EU law.
Where necessary, they must refuse to apply conflicting national legislation, even where that legislation was adopted subsequently.
Principle established:
EU law takes precedence over conflicting national law regardless of whether the national legislation:
Was introduced before EU law.
Was introduced after EU law.
This means a Member State cannot avoid its EU obligations simply by passing a new national law.
5.3 National courts must immediately disapply conflicting national law
Simmenthal also established an important practical requirement.
National courts must immediately give effect to applicable EU law.
They do not need to wait for:
Parliament to repeal the conflicting legislation.
A national constitutional court to declare the legislation unconstitutional.
Another national authority to formally remove the legislation.
What does disapply mean?
Disapplication means that the national court refuses to apply the conflicting national provision in the particular case.
It does not mean that the national legislation is automatically repealed or removed from the statute book.
Case 106/77 Simmenthal (No 2) [1978]
The Court stated that:
Every national court must, in a case within its jurisdiction, apply Community law in its entirety.
The national court must set aside conflicting national provisions to protect the rights EU law confers on individuals.
Key principle: All national courts have a responsibility to give effect to applicable EU law.
Case C-213/89 Factortame [1990]
Facts
The UK introduced the Merchant Shipping Act 1988, which imposed nationality and residence requirements on fishing vessels wishing to register as British fishing vessels.
Spanish fishing companies argued that these requirements conflicted with EU law.
The House of Lords referred questions to the CJEU.
Legal issue
Could a UK court grant interim relief where national law prevented it from doing so, despite the possibility that the national legislation conflicted with EU law?
Judgment
The CJEU held that national courts must set aside national rules that prevent them from granting interim relief where necessary to protect EU law rights.
Principle established:
National courts must be able to provide effective protection of EU law rights, even where national legislation would otherwise prevent them from doing so.
Why is this important?
Factortame demonstrates the practical consequences of supremacy.
It shows that national courts must not only recognise EU law but also ensure that individuals can obtain effective remedies to protect their EU rights.
6. Supremacy and direct effect: Popławski II
Case C-573/17 Popławski II
This case clarified an important limitation on the application of supremacy.
After Simmenthal, an important question remained:
Does every EU law provision automatically require national courts to disapply conflicting national law?
The CJEU clarified that the answer is no.
Judgment
The obligation to disapply conflicting national legislation depends on whether the relevant EU law provision has direct effect.
In other words:
If the EU law provision has direct effect, the national court must disapply conflicting national law.
If the EU law provision does not have direct effect, the national court is not required to disapply national law solely on the basis of EU law supremacy.
What happens if EU law does not have direct effect?
The national court must attempt to interpret national law consistently with EU law, as far as possible.
This is known as indirect effect (consistent interpretation).
Understanding the relationship
There is a conflict between national law and EU law.
Does the relevant EU law provision have direct effect?
YES
Direct effect exists.
The national court must disapply the conflicting national provision.
NO
No direct effect.
The national court must attempt to interpret national law consistently with EU law, as far as possible.
Key distinction
Direct effect | Indirect effect |
Individuals can rely directly on qualifying EU provisions before national courts. | National law is interpreted consistently with EU law as far as possible. |
Can require conflicting national law to be disapplied. | Does not automatically require national law to be disapplied. |
Important in Popławski II. | Alternative where direct effect is unavailable. |
The key takeaway from Popławski II:
Supremacy does not automatically mean that every EU law provision can be used to disapply national legislation. Direct effect is a precondition for that particular obligation.
This is particularly important because Topic 5 examines direct effect in more detail.
7. Should supremacy be codified?
7.1 What does codification mean?
Codification means formally writing a legal principle into legislation or a Treaty rather than leaving it primarily to judicial decisions.
The question is whether the principle of supremacy should be expressly included in the EU Treaties.
7.2 Article I-6 Constitutional Treaty
The proposed Constitutional Treaty contained an express supremacy provision.
It stated:
The Constitution and law adopted by the institutions of the Union in exercising competences conferred on it shall have primacy over the law of the Member States.
However, the Constitutional Treaty was never ratified.
Therefore, the proposed provision never entered into force.
7.3 Declaration 17 to the Lisbon Treaty
The Lisbon Treaty did not retain the express supremacy clause.
Instead, it included Declaration 17, which recalls that, according to the established case law of the CJEU, EU Treaties and EU law adopted under them have primacy over national law under the conditions established by that case law.
Important points:
Declaration 17 is not legally binding in the same way as a Treaty article.
It acknowledges the established case law of the CJEU.
Supremacy remains a principle developed through judicial decisions.
The lecturer also highlighted:
Case C-357/19 Euro Box Promotion
The CJEU relied on Declaration 17 as an additional argument supporting the principle of supremacy.
Why was supremacy not expressly codified?
The lecturer explained that retaining an express supremacy clause was considered too reminiscent of creating a European constitution.
There was also continuing tension between the CJEU's position and the constitutional concerns of Member States.
Overall: Supremacy remains a judge-made constitutional principle which continues to develop through CJEU case law.
8. Summary: The development of supremacy through case law
This is one of the most important things to memorise from the lecture.
Case | Year | Principle established |
Van Gend en Loos | 1963 | EU constitutes a new legal order; introduced the principle of direct effect. |
Costa v ENEL | 1964 | Established the principle of supremacy of EU law over conflicting national law. |
Internationale Handelsgesellschaft | 1970 | Supremacy extends to national constitutional provisions. |
Rheinmühlen | 1974 | Important for the role of preliminary rulings and the relationship between national courts and the CJEU. |
Simmenthal (No 2) | 1978 | EU law takes precedence over earlier and later national legislation; national courts must immediately disapply conflicting national provisions. |
Foto-Frost | 1987 | National courts cannot declare EU acts invalid; they must refer validity questions to the CJEU. |
Factortame | 1990 | National courts must set aside national rules preventing effective interim relief to protect EU law rights. |
Popławski II | 2019 | Disapplication of conflicting national law depends on the direct effect of the relevant EU provision. |
Euro Box Promotion | 2021 | Declaration 17 supports the established principle of supremacy. |
The development in simple terms
Van Gend en Loos (1963) : EU law is a new legal order which can create enforceable rights for individuals.
Costa v ENEL (1964): EU law takes precedence over conflicting national law.
Internationale Handelsgesellschaft (1970): Supremacy extends even to national constitutions.
Simmenthal (1978): National courts must immediately disapply conflicting national legislation, whether earlier or later.
Factortame (1990): National courts must protect EU law rights effectively, including through interim relief.
Popławski II (2019): Disapplication depends on the relevant EU provision having direct effect.
11. Important distinctions to avoid confusing in the exam
Do not confuse | Correct distinction |
CJEU and Court of Justice | CJEU is the wider judicial institution; Court of Justice is one of its courts. |
Direct and indirect actions | Direct actions are brought before EU courts; preliminary rulings involve national courts referring questions to the CJEU. |
Supremacy and direct effect | Supremacy concerns priority between conflicting laws; direct effect concerns whether individuals can rely on EU provisions in court. |
Repeal and disapplication | Disapplication means not applying a national provision in the particular case; it does not repeal the legislation. |
Interpretation and validity | Interpretation concerns what EU law means; validity concerns whether an EU measure is legally valid. |
Costa and Simmenthal | Costa established supremacy; Simmenthal clarified the duty of national courts to disapply conflicting national law immediately. |
Simmenthal and Popławski II | Simmenthal established the duty to disapply; Popławski clarified that this duty depends on direct effect. |
My main advice: Do not learn supremacy as just a definition. Learn its development through the cases. In a problem question, you need to identify the conflict, establish which EU provision applies, consider direct effect, and explain what the national court must do.
These notes cover the material in both the lecture recording and PowerPoint. The next topic, Topic 5, on direct effect, will build directly on Van Gend en Loos and Popławski II.