1/12
Looks like no tags are added yet.
explain why Utilitarianisms believe in the principle of utility
Utilitarians argue that happiness is the underlying goal and preferred state for all human beings. Everything we do is geared towards bringing greater happiness into our lives, and/or minimising pain. For example, any choice we make – whether that be what we want to eat, do or who we want to become – is ultimately tied to the future consequences of happiness/suffering.
Secondly, as reasoning beings, we know that others can and will feel pain and pleasure. If we were to seek happiness and pain avoidance only for our benefit, that it would be egotistic and not a moral action. Rather, to be moral, we must seek to maximise happiness for all of society – not just for ourselves. From a Utilitarian view, everyone is of equal value, meaning that the morality of an action must depend on its effect on all stakeholders. In Quinn’s case, Utilitarians demand that he seek to maximise the net happiness of society, while minimising the suffering caused (the practicalities of this claim with be examined in SF1, P2).
what is Kant’s counterargument about utilitarianism on human rights?
Kant’s counterarguments have two components. Firstly, the principle of utility can justify morally questionable actions, such as sacrificing an individual’s rights or wellbeing, provided that doing so produces the greatest overall happiness. For example, actions such as ‘organ harvesting’ (taking vital organs from unconsenting healthy people) to restore health to many more people technically produces greater happiness than suffering, so would this be considered morally right? This, evidently, contradicts with Kant’s ‘Humanity Formulation’, which states that to be moral, we must “act in such a way that we treat humanity…always as an end and never as a mere means.” By failing to respect and acknowledge one’s humanity, autonomy, values and interests in these circumstances, one would be acting immorally while still following the principle of utility.
How do utilitarians respond to Kant’s first counterargument?
Utilitarianisms respond to this by using an act’s long-term consequences. For example, if it was seen that the law does not protect people from organ harvesting, then society would feel unsafe, social order would deteriorate and ‘the greatest good for the greatest number’ would not be achieved. A society that breaches human rights would not be one with high utility.
what is Kant’s counterargument about utilitarianism on basing morality on happiness?
Kant also argues that for actions to be moral, they must follow commands from the categorical imperative (This will be explained in P1, SF2). A system of morals based off the inclination to produce happiness is grounded in a hypothetical imperative, where commands are followed to achieve a certain outcome. If Quinn were to act with the intent of creating more happiness, Kant argues that his actions possess no genuine moral worth, as he is not acting from duty, but rather in pursuit of a desired consequence (“in accord with duty”). This distinction is important because, unlike universal moral obligations, happiness is subjective and varies according to individual desires.
How do utilitarians respond to Kant’s second counterargument?
However, Utilitarians respond by arguing that the consequences of an action are more important than the motives of the agent that executed it. Kant is a motivist – meaning that he believes an action’s morality depends on its initial intent. Utilitarians are consequentialist and thus argue that acting ‘from duty’ doesn’t guarantee a morally desirable outcome. Kant prioritises individual motivation (which is arguably more subjective) over the wellbeing of society. For example, Quinn could act according to the categorical imperative and still produce greater overall suffering. In comparison, Utilitarianism objectively measures the amount of happiness/pain produced by an act, thus having more practical and moral value.
In the application part of evaluating utilitarianism, what is an issue to point out?
While these outcomes are likely, they cannot be guaranteed. It is impossible to capture the scope of the impact or know it with certainty. This is a key weakness in Utilitarian theory and hence weakens its practical applicability. However, Utilitarians address this using rule utilitarianism – determining an act’s probable moral rightness beforehand. They argue that an act is right if it conforms to a set of general rules, that when universally followed, typically create the greatest good.
If we were to argue that one’s suffering should weigh more, what is a way that Utilitarians respond?
However, this goes against utilitarianism’s main beliefs – that the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few. To use hedonic calculus (the method in which Utilitarians calculate the pain or pleasure of an act), we must apply it objectively. If we prioritise the individual’s wellbeing and circumstances, then we are ignoring the greater suffering likely caused to society as a whole (which has the potential to scale high in…)
Explain the catergorical imperative (in evaluation form)
It is derived from Kant’s catergorical imperative (CI), which states that our moral duties are determined by objective, rationally necessary and unconditional commands. According to the Universal Law of Nature Formation (the first formation of the CI), we must “act only in accordance with that maxim (law/principle” and “will that it should become a universal law without contradiction”. In summary, universalisation means that we should judge our own actions in the light of how the world would be if everyone, everywhere and at every time acted accordingly. If it would be acceptable, then the act is moral and we have a duty to do it. If it were not to be acceptable, then the act is immoral and we have a duty not to do it. For example, “you should not steal” can be universalised, as it allows everyone to possess their own personal property. If this were to not be followed, then it would produce a contradiction: as everyone would be stealing from each other, nobody would truly possess anything
Explain the merits of Universalisation.
Prima facie, this seems true because we should realistically hold ourselves to the same account as others. We ought to believe that one would act in a way consistent with that in which society functions. These rules are either explicit (i.e. legislation) or implicit (unspoken), yet they can be universalised and are there to ensure the wellbeing of society. By consistently universalising actions, Kantianism ensures that an individual cannot ignore a duty while simultaneously expecting everyone else to perform it. For example, Kantians argue that if Quinn were to expect someone in his situation to report the crime, then it would be contradictory to not execute that action himself (the practicalities of this stance will be discussed in SF2, P2). Under their absolutist view, these unconditional, subconscious rules dictate what is morally ‘right’ and ‘wrong’.
what is the ‘relativist’ counterargument to Kantianism? (using reporting a crime)
However, a relevant counterargument is that morality may be circumstantial, and such, some acts that can be universalised may not be our duty in certain instances. For the example of reporting a crime, the majority of us has witnessed a jaywalker in our lifetime. However, it would be a waste of time to report every jaywalker and would distract the police force from more important matters. Additionally, Kant doesn’t consider the issue of a universal law conflicting with a mandated or legal obligation. This comes from a relativist view, which takes the position that no single, objective morality exists. What makes ‘crime reporting’ wrong in some situations and right in others depends on circumstances, culture and context.
What is Kantian’s response to the ‘relativist’ argument? (using crime reporting)
However, Kant is a moral absolutist, meaning that he believes if something, such as shoplifting, is wrong, then it is always wrong and individual circumstances (such as having a starving family) don’t change that. Absolutists argue that some things are ‘widely understood as morally wrong’ for good reasons and that there’s always alternatives to wrongdoing. For example, the shoplifter that Quinn observed could instead seek help from a friend or one of the many charities, government agencies and community groups that exist to assist people in financial hardship.
during weighing, what should you say to justify why Kantian’s theory is still plausible (despite the counterargument?)
If moral obligations depended on personal preferences or circumstances, there could be various cases where individuals create exceptions for themselves, despite not having reasonable justification. Thus, universalisation (even if harsh) ensures individuals are held to the same moral obligations.
during the application of Kantian theory, what should you talk about?
upholds underlying principles, achieved with no inherent logical contradiction - doesn’t prevent others from doing the same and doesn’t destroy any necessary human practices.