Chapter 14 - scientific argument

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/41

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

42 Terms

1
New cards

What is the difference between a hypothesis and a theory?

A hypothesis is a specific explanation or claim about a phenomenon. A theory is a set of claims or explanations about interrelated phenomena. A hypothesis focuses on a particular explanation, while a theory connects multiple explanations into a broader account.

2
New cards

What is a phenomenon in scientific reasoning?

A phenomenon is the thing, event, or experience that scientists want to explain or understand better. It is the focus of scientific investigation and determines what question the researcher is trying to answer.

3
New cards

What is a prediction in scientific reasoning?

A prediction is a consequence or future event that should occur if a hypothesis is true. It is an implication of the hypothesis. Scientists use predictions to determine what evidence or observations they should expect to find.

4
New cards

What is evidence in scientific reasoning?

Evidence consists of facts that seem to imply that a hypothesis is true. Scientific evidence is provisional and probabilistic rather than an absolute deductive proof. It can make a hypothesis more or less strongly supported.

5
New cards

Why is scientific evidence described as provisional and probabilistic?

Scientific evidence does not provide the same certainty as a deductive proof. It supports conclusions through inductive reasoning, meaning the conclusion is more or less likely to be true based on the available evidence. New evidence may strengthen or weaken the conclusion.

6
New cards

What is the difference between a precipitating cause and a remote cause?

A precipitating cause is the most direct or immediate cause of an event. Remote causes are more indirect causes or variables that contribute to the event. A complete explanation may need to consider both the immediate cause and the wider set of contributing factors.

7
New cards

What is a causal network?

A causal network is the collection of most or all of the causes involved in producing an event, including how those causes combine and interact. It helps explain why an event happened instead of assuming that only one factor caused it.

8
New cards

Why is the simplistic view of causality misleading?

The simplistic view assumes that every effect or event has only one cause. This is often misleading because events usually result from multiple variables and contributing factors that work together. A more sophisticated explanation considers precipitating causes, remote causes, and the causal network.

9
New cards

What are the seven steps of the scientific method presented in the PowerPoint?

  1. Focus: determine the question or phenomenon to explain. 2. Hypothesize: formulate a hypothesis. 3. Predict: derive implications that should occur if the hypothesis is true. 4. Experiment: gather new observations or conduct tests. 5. Confirm: if predictions are true, provisionally accept the hypothesis. 6. Falsify: if predictions are false, reject the hypothesis. 7. Hypothesize again: propose a new hypothesis and repeat the process as needed.
10
New cards

What happens during Step 1, Focus, of the scientific method?

Scientists determine the question they want to answer or the phenomenon they want to explain. This establishes what the investigation is about before a hypothesis is developed.

11
New cards

What happens during Step 2, Hypothesize, of the scientific method?

Scientists formulate a hypothesis in light of what they have already observed. The hypothesis is a proposed explanation that can be examined through predictions and testing.

12
New cards

What happens during Step 3, Predict, of the scientific method?

Scientists derive predictions from the hypothesis. These are implications or expected events that should occur if the hypothesis is true. The predictions provide something specific to investigate.

13
New cards

What happens during Step 4, Experiment, of the scientific method?

Scientists make new observations, collect sense-data, conduct tests, or perform experiments. They gather evidence to determine whether the predictions actually turn out to be true.

14
New cards

What happens during Step 5, Confirm, of the scientific method?

If the predictions turn out to be true, the hypothesis is accepted and confirmed as provisionally true. This means the evidence supports it for now, not that it has been proven with absolute certainty.

15
New cards

What happens during Step 6, Falsify, of the scientific method?

If the predictions turn out to be false, the hypothesis is rejected as false or considered refuted and falsified. The failure of a prediction gives scientists a reason to reconsider the proposed explanation.

16
New cards

What happens after a hypothesis is falsified?

Scientists propose a new hypothesis, called h2 in the PowerPoint, and repeat the process of deriving predictions, testing them, and evaluating the results. The process can continue until a hypothesis passes its tests.

17
New cards

What is a controlled experiment?

A controlled experiment is an experiment in which multiple experimental setups differ by only one variable. Keeping the other conditions the same helps scientists determine whether the variable being tested is responsible for a difference in results.

18
New cards

What is an experimental group?

The experimental group is the group that receives or gets the variable being tested. Scientists examine this group to observe the effects of the variable.

19
New cards

What is a control group?

The control group is the group in which the variable being tested is withheld. It provides a comparison for the experimental group so researchers can better evaluate the effect of the variable.

20
New cards

What are the five criteria for determining causality in Baronett's textbook?

  1. There should be a correlation between the cause and effect. 2. The cause should precede the effect. 3. The cause should be in proximity to the effect. 4. A set of sufficient and necessary conditions should exist. 5. Alternative explanations should be ruled out. No single criterion is enough by itself; the combined weight of all five supports a causal conclusion.
21
New cards

Why is correlation alone insufficient to establish causation?

Correlation means that a cause and effect are associated, but an association by itself does not establish that one caused the other. Other criteria must also be considered, including timing, proximity, sufficient and necessary conditions, and alternative explanations.

22
New cards

Why must a cause precede its effect when determining causality?

The proposed cause must happen before the effect it is supposed to produce. An event that happens after an effect cannot ordinarily explain that earlier effect as its cause.

23
New cards

Why must alternative explanations be ruled out when determining causality?

Other possible explanations may account for the same observed effect. If researchers do not consider and rule out reasonable alternatives, they may incorrectly attribute the effect to the proposed cause.

24
New cards

Why can controlled experiments have limitations when explaining real-world causality?

Controlled experiments are artificial by definition, so their results may not always match what happens in real life. For example, results from testing a drug on animals may not apply to humans because their physiology differs. Researchers must be careful when applying laboratory findings to the outside world.

25
New cards

What is a fair test of a hypothesis?

A fair test requires predictions that can be objectively checked and that are nontrivial in light of background knowledge. A prediction must provide meaningful evidence for the hypothesis, rather than simply being something that is easy or almost certain to happen.

26
New cards

What is a verifiable prediction?

A verifiable prediction is one whose truth or falsity can be objectively checked through an acceptable method. If there is no acceptable way to determine whether the prediction is true, it cannot satisfy the verifiability requirement for a fair test.

27
New cards

What is a nontrivial prediction?

A nontrivial prediction is one that requires reference to background knowledge and is not already highly likely to happen. It must provide meaningful evidence for the hypothesis instead of predicting something that would probably happen regardless of whether the hypothesis is true.

28
New cards

Why is predicting that the sun will rise tomorrow a trivial prediction when testing a claim of seeing the future?

The sun rising tomorrow is already highly likely according to background knowledge. Even if the prediction comes true, it provides almost no meaningful support for the claim that someone can see the future. A prediction must be more specific and informative to count as nontrivial.

29
New cards

What is the difference between a verifiable prediction and a nontrivial prediction?

A verifiable prediction can be objectively checked to determine whether it is true or false. A nontrivial prediction is meaningful in light of background knowledge and is not something highly likely to happen anyway. A fair test requires both qualities.

30
New cards

Why is a prediction being verifiable not enough by itself to make a fair test?

A prediction can be verifiable but still be trivial. For example, predicting that the sun will rise tomorrow can be checked, but it is already extremely likely to happen. The prediction therefore provides almost no meaningful evidence for a hypothesis.

31
New cards

What does it mean to connect a hypothesis and a prediction?

The prediction must follow from the hypothesis: if the hypothesis is true, the predicted result should be expected. A prediction that has no meaningful connection to the hypothesis cannot properly test or support it.

32
New cards

What is empirical adequacy as a virtue of a strong scientific theory?

Empirical adequacy means that a theory seems consistent with known facts. A strong theory should fit the observations and evidence that scientists already have.

33
New cards

What is theoretical coherence as a virtue of a strong scientific theory?

Theoretical coherence means that a theory seems consistent with other established theories. For example, a theory should fit with well-supported explanations in related scientific fields rather than conflict with them without good reason.

34
New cards

What is explanatory depth as a virtue of a strong scientific theory?

Explanatory depth means that a theory helps us understand the main phenomenon in fine detail. It explains how or why something happens rather than merely describing that it happens.

35
New cards

What is explanatory breadth as a virtue of a strong scientific theory?

Explanatory breadth means that a theory successfully explains a broad range of phenomena. A theory with broad explanatory power can account for multiple related events or observations rather than only one narrow example.

36
New cards

What is parsimony, also called economy, as a virtue of a strong scientific theory?

Parsimony means that a theory explains a broad range of phenomena using concise terms or principles. A strong theory can explain many things without requiring an unnecessarily complicated explanation.

37
New cards

What is predictive power as a virtue of a strong scientific theory?

Predictive power means that a theory successfully produces many predictions about facts or events that should result if the theory is true. Repeatedly successful predictions strengthen the theory.

38
New cards

What is testability or predictability as a virtue of a strong scientific theory?

Testability means that a theory produces nontrivial predictions that can be tested through experiments and potentially confirmed or disconfirmed. A theory must allow meaningful testing rather than making claims that cannot be checked.

39
New cards

What is the difference between predictive power and testability?

Predictive power concerns how successfully a theory produces predictions that turn out to be correct. Testability concerns whether the theory produces nontrivial predictions that can actually be examined through experiments. Both involve predictions, but one emphasizes successful results and the other emphasizes the ability to test them.

40
New cards

What are the seven virtues of strong scientific theories?

  1. Empirical adequacy: consistency with known facts. 2. Theoretical coherence: consistency with established theories. 3. Explanatory depth: explaining a phenomenon in fine detail. 4. Explanatory breadth: explaining a broad range of phenomena. 5. Parsimony or economy: explaining broadly using concise principles. 6. Predictive power: successfully producing many predictions. 7. Testability or predictability: producing nontrivial predictions that can be tested.
41
New cards

How does scientific reasoning resemble legal reasoning?

Both begin by identifying a question that needs to be answered. They then gather relevant evidence to help reach a conclusion. Legal reasoning uses evidence to reach a decision about a case, while scientific reasoning uses evidence to understand a phenomenon or causal process.

42
New cards

What does it mean for a hypothesis to be provisionally confirmed?

It means that the predictions derived from the hypothesis have turned out as expected, so the hypothesis is supported and accepted for now. It remains open to further testing and possible revision if new evidence challenges it.