1/10
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Schenck v US
Charles Schenck and Elizabeth Baer are part of the socialist party in Philadelphia during WW1. Print and mail 15,000 anti draft flyers. Federal gov accuses them of violating the espionage act of 1917, they argue the first amendment.
1st amendment
Gov argues Espionage act of 1917
Flyers argue that the draft violated the 13th amendment ban on involuntary servitude
In a 9-0 decision, upholds convictions and espionage act. Bans free speech if it creates clear and present danger, and bans inciteful speech
Brown v Board of Education
Black students were denied use of certain schools due to race, 5 seperate lawsuits that begin in Topeka Kansas
14th amendments equal protection clause
Segregation in public schools is inherently unequal, overturned seperate but equal from Plessy v Ferguson.
Mapp v Ohio
Searched a woman’s house without a warrant, looking for a suspect related to another person living in the house. Found illegal materials in her room and arrested her as the owner of the house
4th amendment- exclusionary rule
14th amendment- due process clause
Illegally obtained evidence is not admissible in court.
Engel v Vitale
New York schools start each day with a prayer, parents complain.
1st amendment- establishment clause
14th amendment
For parents, against the school. School sponsored religion is not allowed.
Gideon v Wainwright
Gideon is larceny from a pool hall, 2 men say they saw him. It’s not a capital case so Florida didn’t give him an attorney. He appealed to the SC from jail.
6th amendment
14th amendment
Established public defender system, held in favor of Clarence Gideon.
Griswold v Connecticut
Old Connecticut law banned birth control. Griswold opened a planned parenthood there and was arrested.
Right to privacy implied by the 1, 4, 5, 9th amendments
14th amendment
Privacy is implied, protects right to contraception, right to intimate personal matters.
Tinker v Des Moines
Students wore black arm bands to protest Vietnam war, school banned them.
1st amendment- right to symbolic speech
Symbolic speech is protected under the 1st amendment, 7-2 in favor of the students since it was peaceful, students don’t lose rights in school.
NY times v US
During Vietnam war, Daniel Ellsberg steals the Pentagon papers, sends to NY times to publish, Gov says no. Also sent to Washington Times, Gov allows them to publish it. NY times says it’s unfair.
1st amendments- prior restraint is not applicable in this case, it doesn’t endanger public safety
Gov does not have evidence that the papers are dangerous, 6-3 in favor of NY times.
Wisconsin v Yoder
Parents are Amish, withdraw kids from school after 8th grade. Wisconsin has a law to go till 16 years old, parents say secular public HS threatens their faith.
1st amendment- free exercise clause
Found in favor of Amish, public school contrasted their religious beliefs.
McDonald v Chicago
City had handgun restrictions, people in Chicago want them for self defense
2nd amendment
14th amendment
Selective incorporation for all states of 2nd amendment
5-4 vote in favor of McDonald
Obergefell v Hodges
Married husbands, Ohio wouldn’t recognize their marriage.
14th amendments- equal protection clause
Overturned Defense of Marriage Act
In favor of obergefell