1/72
Looks like no tags are added yet.
define subject matter jurisdiction
before a court can hear a case, it must have the legal authority over the topic of the dispute
state courts are courts of __ jurisdiction
general
what does it mean to say that state courts are courts of general jurisdiction
they can hear just about any case as a matter of subject matter jurisdiction, except the limited cases explicitly given to federal courts by statute
federal courts are courts of ___ jurisdiction
limited
where does federal subject matter jurisdiction power come from
Article III Section 2
define diversity jurisdiction
cases between citizens of different states and the amount in controversy exceeding 75k
where does the diversity jurisdiction rule come from (code)
28 USC 1332(a)
what does 28 USC § 1332(a) say
the district courts shall have original jurisdiction of all civil actions where the matter in controversy exceeds the sum of 75k and is between the four options
§ 1332(a) 1-4 options of situations where you can invoke diversity jurisdiction
(1) citizens of different States;
(2) citizens of a State and citizens or subjects of a foreign state, (except if the foreign citizen is a permanent resident and is domiciled in the same state)
(3) citizens of different States and citizens of a foreign state are additional parties; and
(4) a foreign state, defined in section 1603(a) of this title, as plaintiff and citizens of a State or of different States
when must the parties be diverse
at the date of filing the lawsuit
state citizenship of individuals general rule
a us citizen is a citizen of the us state where they are domiciles
define a person’s domicile
the place of their true, fixed, and permanent home and principal establishment, and to which they have the intention of returning whenever absent from
the domicile test: factors to affirmatively change your domicile to a new domicile
must be physically present at the location
must intend to make that place their permanent home for the time at least
you retain your domicile until what happens
you have affirmatively change it
if there is a definite end date to the residence, making it temporary, how does that affect the establishment of domicile
the new domicile has not been established
gordon v. steele holding
A college student is domiciled in the state of their school if they intended to stay there at any point after moving
what rules did gordon v. steele implement
the intent to remain indefinitely standard generally rules
explain the strawbridge v. curtiss complete diversity rule
no plaintiff can be a citizen of the same state as any defendant
how do you practically implement the complete diversity rule
imagine that each plaintiff had sued each defendant in a seperate action; if they had, would all the cases be proper diversity cases?
mas v. perry holding
Diversity jurisdiction authorizes cases between a citizen and a citizen of another country even if the foreign citizen is domiciled in the US
white v. tenant holding
If the individual has the intent to move and completes the move, they have acquired a new domicile at the point of
estate of jones holding + facts
Native of Wales lived in Iowa 30 years; Sold property, booked passage on Lusitania; Died at sea before arrival; Holding: Domicile in Iowa remained because he did not complete his move
perfecting diversity jurisdiction general rule
diversity can be perfected by dropping a party, even well into the case
what rule allows perfecting diversity and what is the rule
Rule 21 allows dismissal of a “jurisdictional spoiler” before final judgment
what is the test for corporate citizenship
the nerve center test
explain the nerve center test
for diversity purposes, a corporation is deemed to be a citizen of every state/foreign country in which is it incorporated and the one state/foreign country in which it has its principal place of business
where does the corporate citizenship of a citizen of every state/foreign country in which is it incorporated rule come from
1332(c)(1)
what are the limits of the nerve center test
changing headquarters: court must choose based on actual facts as of the day of filing
small, dispersed offices: looks to the place of “actual direction, control, and coordination”
hertz corp v. friend principal place of business definition
the place where the corporation’s high-level officers direct, control, and coordinate the corporation’s activities
the principal place of business is typically where
the headquarters
citizenship for unincorporated associations general rule
measured by the collective state citizenship of all individual members or partners
holding in carden v. arkoma associates
citizenship of all limited partners must be considered because the entity was not a corporation
amount in controversy general rule
plaintiff’s claim amount will be accepted if it appears to be made in good faith
when is the amount in controversy determined
at the time the complaint is filed, not how much is ultimately recovered
what exception to the general amount in controversy rule does diefenthal v. cab establish
allegations of damages are accepted unless it is clear to a legal certainty that the plaintiff cannot recover more than the required amount in controversy
general rule for aggregating claims to meet the amount in controversy requirements
a single plaintiff may aggregate any separate claims they have against a single defendant to meet the amount in controversy requirement even if the claims are unrelated
nuances of the general rule for aggregating claims
if there are multiple parties, each party must meet the amount in controversy separately
a counterclaim cannot be aggregated with the plaintiff’s claim to meet amount requirement
what code grants federal question jurisdiction
28 USC 1331
define federal question jurisdiction
jurisdiction to the federal district court over all cases “arising under the Constitution, law or treaties of the United States
what is federal question jurisdiction based on
the well-pleaded complaint rather than the counterclaim
explain the well-pleaded complaint/mottley rule
federal jurisdiction exists only when a federal issue is presented on the face of the plaintiff’s properly pleaded complaint
what nuances to the well-pleaded complaint rule does louisville & nashville road co v. mottley
jurisdiction cannot be based on anticipated defenses or counterclaims
if the plaintiff is not enforcing a federal rule properly, there is no federal question jurisdiction
what exception to the general well-pleaded complaint rule does grable & sons v. darue engineering establish
Federal question jurisdiction (under § 1331) can exist over a state-law claim even if there is no federal cause of action, provided the federal issue is substantial and disputed
what is the four part test that gunn v. minton gives for the grable exception:
does the state law claim necessarily raise a stated federal issue
does the state law claim actually dispute a federal issue
was the federal rule substantial to the outcome
can a federal forum entertain it without disturbing any congressionally approved balance of federal and state jurisdiction responsibilities
explain the holmes creation test
"a suit arises under the law that creates the cause of action”
holmes creation test: if a state law creates the right to sue, how does that affect federal question jurisdiction
there is generally no federal jurisdiction
holmes creation test: if a federal law creates the right to sue or the remedy, how does that affect federal question jurisdiction
the case arises under federal law
where does the legislative power for removal jurisdiction come from
1441(a)
what is the 1441(a) removal jurisdiction rule say
Any civil action brought in a state court of which the district courts of the US have original jurisdiction may be removed by the defendant to the district court of the US
how does the court apply removal jurisdiction
can only remove to federal court from state court, cannot remove from federal court to state court
the plaintiff cannot remove it
what is the general rule of removal jurisdiction
the defendants should only be entitled to remove a case if the case, as pleaded by the plaintiff, could have been filed in federal court by the plaintiff
exception to the general removal jurisdiction rule
the in state defendant rule
where does the in-state defendant rule come from
1442(b)(2)
explain the in-state defendant rule
if any defendant is a citizen of the forum state, removal is barred if the only way to get to federal court is diversity jurisdiction
where do the removal procedure requirements come from
1446
what are the 1446 removal procedural requirements
must file a signed notice in the federal court
notice must be filed within 30 days after the defendant receives the initial pleadings or summons
the rule of unanimity
what must the signed notice of removal contain
a short and plain statement of the grounds for which removal
all process pleadings, and order from the state court
what nuance exists to the requirement that notice be filed within 30 days after the defendant receives the initial pleadings or summons
the 30 day removal starts afresh for each newly served defendant
explain the rule of unanimity
all defendants that have been properly joined and served must join in or consent to the removal, ensuring unanimity among the defense
if the plaintiff thinks that the removal was improper, what can they do
they can move to remand under 1447
when must a motion to remand be filled
within 30 days after the filing of the notice of removal
where does the post removal procedure come from
1447
if at any time before final judgment it appears that the federal court lacks subject matter jurisdiction, what do they do
remand to the state court
explain remand finality
an order remanding a case to state court is generally not reviewable on appeal
explain the interlocutory appeal of removal
If the federal district court judge concludes that it has jurisdiction over a removed case, the plaintiff may not appeal immediately
where does the interlocutory appeal of removal rule come from
1291
where does the rule for later removal come from
1446(b)
what is the rule for later removal under 1446(b)
provides the option to remove when a case “becomes removeable”
what is the application of the rule for later removal under 1446(b)
if the original case was removable and the defendant did not remove, 1446(b) will not give a second chance at it
what rule provides for the waiver of objections
1447(c)
explain the rule for the waiver of objections under 1447(c)
failure to raise a motion to remand within 30 days of filing the notice of removal results in the waiver of the procedural objection
what rule come from avitts v. amoco production co
the plaintiff is the master of the complaint
what exception to the interlocutory appeal rule does avitts v. amoco establish
Because the court entered interim orders, the defendant was able to appeal under § 1291(a)(1)