1/108
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Bill of Rights Speech Clause
The First Amendment text barring Congress from abridging freedom of speech, applied to states through the 14th Amendment Due Process Clause.
Democratic Self-Governance rationale
Holds that government control of narratives and suppression of dissent is prevented by free speech protection.
Marketplace of Ideas
Holds that competing thoughts battle until truth or the best ideas emerge.
Individual Autonomy and Self-Expression
Protects personal identity and freedom through self-expression.
Tolerance and Safety Valve rationale
Fosters societal tolerance and prevents violence that results from suppressing unpopular views.
Content-Based Restriction
Speech restrictions that target speech because of its topic or idea/message; presumptively invalid and trigger strict scrutiny.
Content-Neutral Restriction
Regulations that apply broadly regardless of message or topic and trigger intermediate scrutiny.
Viewpoint Discrimination
Government discrimination against speech based on the specific idea or perspective expressed; the most egregious form of content discrimination and virtually per se unconstitutional.
Subject-Matter Discrimination
Regulations that restrict the subject matter of speech, such as limiting discussion of a particular topic.
Time, Place, and Manner (TPM) Regulation
Restrictions on the time, place, or manner of speech that are content-neutral and reviewed under intermediate scrutiny.
Secondary Effects Doctrine
Zoning rules targeting negative secondary effects of speech businesses (such as crime near adult theaters) rather than the speech itself; treated as content-neutral.
Strict Scrutiny
The test requiring a compelling government interest, necessity, and narrow tailoring using the least restrictive means.
Intermediate Scrutiny
The test requiring an important or substantial government interest and a substantial relation to that interest, leaving ample alternative channels in open forums.
Ample Alternative Channels
The requirement that TPM rules in open forums leave open ample alternative channels of communication.
Expressive Conduct Threshold Test
Conduct qualifies as protected speech when the speaker intended to convey a particularized message and others would likely understand it.
O'Brien Test
The test under which non-speech conduct may be regulated if the regulation is within government power, furthers an important interest unrelated to suppressing expression, and restricts speech no more than essential.
Freedom of Association
The right to gather in groups to advance shared political, economic, religious, or cultural beliefs, protected as a core First Amendment activity.
Expressive Association Standard
Government interference with expressive association triggers strict scrutiny.
Compelled Speech
Government coercion forcing a person or entity to affirm or convey a particular message; treated with strict scrutiny.
Abridgment
Any government action imposing a significant burden or disincentive on speech that triggers First Amendment scrutiny.
Differential Taxation of the Press
Targeted special taxes on the press are presumptively unconstitutional and trigger strict scrutiny; raising general revenue is not a compelling interest.
Minneapolis Star and Tribune
Minneapolis Star and Tribune case about singling out the press for special taxes.
Limiting Financial Rewards for Speech
Statutes stripping income from speech content, such as Son of Sam laws, which are content-based financial burdens under strict scrutiny.
Simon and Schuster v. Crime Victims Board
Simon and Schuster case striking down laws that escrow criminal profits from works describing crimes as overinclusive.
Unconstitutional Conditions Doctrine
Government cannot condition public benefits, subsidies, or tax exemptions on giving up free speech rights.
Speiser v. Randall
Speiser v. Randall, which struck down a loyalty oath required for a veteran tax exemption.
Program-Scope Distinction
Government may limit funded programs and bar use of program funds for disfavored speech, provided recipients can speak using separate, non-funded resources.
Rust v. Sullivan
Rust v. Sullivan, which permitted barring Title X funds from being used for abortion counseling.
No Reporter's Testimonial Privilege
The First Amendment does not exempt journalists from answering neutral grand jury subpoenas or revealing confidential sources.
Branzburg v. Hayes
Branzburg v. Hayes, holding reporters have no special privilege against grand jury subpoenas.
Right of Access to Criminal Trials
The public and press have a presumptive right to attend criminal trials; closure requires an overriding interest and no less restrictive alternatives.
Richmond Newspapers v. Virginia
Richmond Newspapers v. Virginia, establishing the presumptive right of public access to criminal trials.
Hidden Viewpoint Discrimination Rule
Even within unprotected categories, government cannot engage in viewpoint or content discrimination.
Incitement of Lawless Action
Abstract advocacy of force or lawlessness is protected; speech loses protection only if it is intended, imminent, and likely to produce lawless action.
Brandenburg v. Ohio
Brandenburg v. Ohio, establishing the three-prong test for incitement.
Fighting Words
Words that by their very utterance inflict injury or incite an immediate breach of the peace; unprotected when specific direct personal insults face-to-face provoke immediate violence.
Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire
Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire, establishing the fighting words doctrine.
True Threats
Statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of intent to commit unlawful violence against a particular individual or group; unprotected.
Virginia v. Black
Virginia v. Black, holding that intentional intimidation is sufficient and the speaker need not intend to carry out the violence.
Miller Test for Obscenity
Material is unprotected obscenity only if it appeals to prurient interest under local standards, is patently offensive under state law, and lacks serious value under a national reasonable person standard.
Miller v. California
Miller v. California, establishing the three-prong obscenity test.
Stanley v. Georgia Private Possession Rule
Government may not criminalize mere private possession of obscene material inside one's home.
Child Pornography
Child pornography is completely unprotected and does not need to meet the Miller test; it must depict actual minors.
New York v. Ferber
New York v. Ferber, establishing that child pornography is unprotected and virtual or adult-actor images fall outside it.
Osborne v. Ohio Possession Rule
Government may criminalize private home possession of child pornography to dry up the market.
U.S. v. Stevens Rule
Violence and vulgarity are protected; courts will not create new unprotected categories through simple balancing tests.
Broadcast Indecency
Over-the-air radio and TV may be regulated for indecent language when children are likely in the audience; does not extend to the Internet or print.
FCC v. Pacifica
FCC v. Pacifica, upholding regulation of indecent broadcast speech.
Commercial Speech Definition
Speech that proposes a commercial transaction or references a specific product with economic motivation.
Unprotected Commercial Speech
Commercial speech promoting illegal activity, being false or misleading, or involving pressured in-person solicitation may be banned without scrutiny.
Central Hudson Test
Intermediate scrutiny for truthful, lawful commercial speech requiring a substantial interest, direct advancement, and no more extensive restriction than necessary.
Direct Advancement Fit Requirement
Central Hudson requirement that the regulation directly advances the goal with evidence rather than speculation.
Not More Extensive Than Necessary
Requires government to consider non-speech alternatives such as taxes or minimum prices rather than advertising bans.
44 Liquormart
44 Liquormart, which rejected liquor advertising bans in favor of non-speech alternatives.
Lorillard Tobacco Case
Lorillard, which struck down near-total tobacco advertising bans and addressed the 5-foot rule.
As-Applied Challenge
A challenge arguing a law is unconstitutional only as applied to the specific litigant's conduct.
Facial Challenge
A challenge invalidating a law in all applications; permitted in First Amendment cases for prior restraints, licensing, vagueness, and overbreadth.
Prior Restraint
Preventing speech before it occurs through injunctions, censorship, or permits; carries a heavy presumption against constitutionality.
Pentagon Papers Rule
Judicial injunctions against publication, almost never upheld; mere conjecture of harm is insufficient.
NYT v. U.S.
New York Times v. United States, the Pentagon Papers case on prior restraints.
Collateral Bar Rule
A speaker must obey a court injunction until overturned on appeal; violating it forfeits the right to challenge its constitutionality later.
Walker v. City of Birmingham
Walker v. City of Birmingham, establishing the collateral bar rule.
Licensing and Permitting Safeguards
Licensing schemes are constitutional only with clear, narrow, objective criteria, promptness, and prompt judicial review.
City of Lakewood
City of Lakewood, establishing procedural safeguards for licensing schemes.
Vagueness Doctrine
A law is unconstitutionally vague if people of common intelligence must guess at its meaning and differ as to its application.
Coates v. City of Cincinnati
Coates v. City of Cincinnati, a case applying the vagueness doctrine.
Overbreadth Doctrine
A law is facially invalid if it sweeps in a substantial amount of protected speech relative to its legitimate sweep.
Board of Airport Commissioners v. Jews for Jesus
Board of Airport Commissioners v. Jews for Jesus, applying the overbreadth doctrine.
Traditional Public Forum
Government property immemorially held in trust for public assembly and debate, such as streets, sidewalks, and parks.
Designated Public Forum
Non-traditional property the government intentionally and generally opens for public expressive activity; treated like a traditional public forum.
Widmar v. Vincent
Widmar v. Vincent, establishing the designated public forum concept.
Limited Public Forum
Property opened only for specific groups or topics; limits must be reasonable and viewpoint-neutral.
Christian Legal Society v. Martinez
Christian Legal Society v. Martinez, addressing limited public forums.
Non-Public Forum
Government property not traditionally or intentionally opened for public speech, such as airports, prisons, and military bases; regulations must be reasonable and viewpoint-neutral.
ISKCON v. Lee
ISKCON v. Lee, applying reasonableness and viewpoint neutrality in non-public forums.
Tinker Standard
Students do not shed rights at the schoolhouse gate; schools may restrict speech only if it causes or is reasonably forecast to cause material and substantial disruption or collides with others' rights.
Tinker v. Des Moines
Tinker v. Des Moines, establishing the material and substantial disruption standard for student speech.
Bethel School District v. Fraser
Schools may prohibit lewd or vulgar speech at school events without showing substantial disruption if the ban is viewpoint-neutral.
Hazelwood Standard
Schools have broad editorial control over school-sponsored curricular activities if reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns.
Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier
Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier, addressing school-sponsored student speech.
Board of Education v. Pico Motive Test
Removing books to impose political or religious orthodoxy is unconstitutional; removing pervasively vulgar or unsuitable books is valid.
Government Speech Doctrine
When the government speaks for itself, the Free Speech Clause does not apply.
Pleasant Grove v. Summum
Pleasant Grove v. Summum, holding monuments in public parks are government speech.
Walker v. Texas Division
Walker v. Texas Division, holding license plates are government speech.
Government Speech Three-Factor Test
Three factors identifying government speech: historical use of the medium, public perception of government identification, and direct government control.
Garcetti Official Duties Rule
Public employee speech made pursuant to official job duties receives no First Amendment protection against employer discipline.
Garcetti v. Ceballos
Garcetti v. Ceballos, holding employees speaking within official duties are not protected as citizens.
Pickering Balancing Test
Private citizen employee speech on a matter of public concern is evaluated by balancing the employee's interest against the employer's interest in efficient public service.
Pickering v. Board of Education
Pickering v. Board of Education, establishing the balancing test for public employee speech.
Provably False Fact Requirement
A plaintiff cannot recover in a speech tort unless the statement asserts a provably false fact, because there is no such thing as a false idea.
Rhetorical Hyperbole
Exaggerated insults or figurative terms that no reasonable reader takes as literal fact are protected and non-actionable.
Letter Carriers v. Austin
Letter Carriers v. Austin, protecting rhetorical hyperbole such as calling a worker a scab and traitor.
Altered Quotations Rule
Deliberate alteration of a quote is falsity only if it materially changes the meaning conveyed.
Masson v. New Yorker
Masson v. New Yorker, addressing altered quotations and material change in meaning.
Actual Malice Standard
Knowledge that a statement was false or reckless disregard of whether it was false; requires subjective awareness of probable falsity.
New York Times Co. v. Sullivan
New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, establishing the actual malice standard.
Public Official Plaintiff
Government officials with substantial responsibility for public affairs must prove actual malice for statements about official conduct or fitness.
All-Purpose Public Figure
Pervasive fame or notoriety in the community and pervasive involvement in societal affairs; must prove actual malice for all claims.
Limited-Purpose Public Figure
A person who voluntarily injects themselves into a specific public controversy; must prove actual malice only for speech germane to that controversy.
Private Figure on Matter of Public Concern
A private person involved in a matter of public interest must show at least negligence, and actual malice is required for presumed or punitive damages.