1/31
Looks like no tags are added yet.
STOCKTON’S EIGHT THEMES OF ANTI-ARAB STEREOTYPES
Sexual depravity, Creature analogies, Physiological and psychological traits, Savage leaders, War of darkness against light, Deceit, Secret Power, Hatred of Israel and antisemitism
Mcallister Four Major US Interests in the Mid East
Military (imperialism - empire, cold war), Religious (Christianity), Israel (Zionism, geopolitical, cultural), Economic (oil).
Alsultany’s seven strategies of simplified complex representation
Inserting Patriotic Arabs or Muslim Americans, Sympathizing with the plight of Arab or Muslim Americans post 9/11, Challenging the Arab/Muslim conflation with representations of diverse Muslim identities, Flipping the enemy, Humanizing the terrorist, Projecting a multicultural society, Fictionalizing a Middle Eastern or Muslim country
Steryotypes explanation
Media stereotypes are systematic representations, repeated in a variety of forms from jokes and cartoons to news broadcasts, feature films, and television series. A descriptive or designative (based on physical appearance) aspect combines with an evaluative aspect in which people are judged from a particular perspective or point of view.
Steryotype Definition
Systematic representations, repeated in a variety of forms
How are stereotypes connected to hegemony
Powerful groups to characterize subordinate groups...[through] the systematic suggestion that all people of a group are this way, and this way by nature (Seiter) Steryotypes are a reflection of hegemony as they tell us what is hegemonic
Descriptive aspect of stereotypes
The observable physical traits assigned to a group / what a group is depicted as looking like
Evaluative Aspect
Passes moral, social, or psychological judgment on the descriptive physical features features from a dominant perspective in order to justify social hierarchies and the status quo
Inserting Patriotic Arabs or Muslim Americans
Adding loyal arab or muslim characters who serve in US law enforcement, the military or government agencies. This constructs the “Good” Muslim trop and shows audiences that “acceptable” muslims actively assist the US national security state in fighting terrorism
Sympathizing with the Plight of Arab and Muslim Americans
Framing episodes or storylines around Arab and Muslim Americans who experience post-9/11 hate crimes, discrimination, or false accusations. This elicits viewer empathy and projects an image of a compassionate, fair-minded society, which helps obscure ongoing state-sanctioned profiling and surveillance
How Quantico connects to the 7 strategies
Inserting Patriotic Arabs or Muslim Americans
Sympathizing with the Plight of Arab and Muslim Americans
Challenging the Arab/Muslim Conflation through diverse characters
Including non-Arab Muslim characters to teach audiences that “arab” and Muslim are not the same thing but it still keeps Muslim identities tethered to narratives of terrorism, surveillance, and national security
Flipping the Enemy
A narrative plot twist where the ultimate villian or terrorist is actually a white American and not the Arab/Muslim character that they have been building up as the terrorist. This deflects accusations that the TV show is anti-arab or anti-muslim by demonstrating that white americans can also be portrayed as terrorists
Humanizing the Terrorist
Giving terrorist characters complex backstories, family ties, or lines of dialogue articulating explicit political critiques of US foreign policy and empire. Gives the appearance of intellectual nuance and psychological depth, making the narrative feel balanced rather than one-dimensional
Projecting a Multicultural US society
Having a racially diverse cast in the institutions in the show/movie (police precincts, FBI academies, etc). This reinforces colorblind and post-race ideologies by portraying US state institutions as harmonious, equal-opportunity spaces that are inherently non-racist
Colorblind Idealogy
An ideology which perpetuates racial discrimination while absolving people of accountability
Post-Race Idealogy
The cultural belief or illusion that American society has completely transcended racism and achieved full racial equality while masking ongoing systemic discrimination and makes state-sanctioned profiling and violence look justified
Fictionalizing a middle eastern or muslim country
Inventing fictional nations (such as agrabah) as the backdrop for geopolitical conflict or terrorism. This allows media producers to maintain terrorism0centered plots without insulting real-world US diplomatic partners or complicating foreign relations
Sexual Depravity
Portrays arab men as driven by unchecked, anamalistic lust toward western women, viewing women strictly as objects of pleasure or chattel. For women it creates a binary where arab women are deicted either as oppressed, faceless “bundles in black” or as exotic, sexually promiscuous belly dancers and manipulators
Deceit
this theme frames arabs as inherently dishonest, double-talking and untrustworthy. It depicts them as wrapping themselves in a false mantle of peace while secretly working toward war and destruction
Secret Power
depicts rich “oil sheikhs” as sinister financial manipulators. They are shown using secret wealth, bags of cash, and bribes to control world politics and buy up Western assets behind the scenes
Creature Analogies
Draws on ape caricatures and vermin imagery (rats, snakes, insects). Comparing arabs or Palestinians to animals or pests serves dehumanizing function, lowering the moral threshold for Western audience to accept state violence and military force against them
Savage Leaders (and Mobs)
Depicts political leaders as bloodthirsty, irrational dictators and local populations as mindless, chanting mobs incapable of democratic self-governance
War of Darkness Against Light
Frames violence or political conflicts involving Arabs not as historical struggles over land, rights, or foreign intervention, but as an irrational, metaphysical crusade to destroy Western civilization. It presents Arab actors as “children of darkness” who enjoy destruction for its own sake
Psychological and Physiological Traits
A double overlap combining anti-black caricatures (heavy brown stooped posture, dark skin) with anti-semetic caricatures (hooked nose, shifty eyes, scruffy beard, weak chin). They’re seen as naturally aggressive, hateful, and deceitful toward everyone else. Instead of seeing conflict as a result of eat political or historical events, the stereotype claims Arabs are simply born hating society. Reduces a whole populations complexity into fixed boxes of negative traits and assumes that every member of the Arab community thinks the same way. That arabs thinking is so abnormal that “normal humans” can’t reason with them.
Irrational Hatred of Israel
Reduces Palestinian genocide into innate fanatical and ancient religious hatred of jews and Israel. It removes US and Israeli state policies from critique by framing the conflict purely driven by Arab hatred
Military Interest
U.S. military interest in the SWANA region stems from wanting to expand US global power after World War 2 to contain Soviet influence during the Cold War and rebuilding American military confidence after losing the Vietnam War. US policymakers framed this not as a territorial conquest but as a benevolent American partnership which allowed them to claim that they were intervening out of goodwill to help decolonize nations and modernizing while masking its underlying imperial dominance.
Economic Interest (Oil, Gas, and corporate neoliberalism)
The US wanted to secure reliable, low-cost access to Middle Eastern oil and gas to power Western economies and corporate trade under the narrative of a “benevolent American partnership.” The economic interest directly drove major military actions such as the Gulf and Iraq War
Religious Interest
Interest driven by cultural and spiritual claims to the Middle East as the “Holly Land” by evangelical Christian Zionism and biblical prophecy. Evangelical Christians believed that gathering Jewish people in Palestine was a divine requirement to trigger the second coming of christ and the rapture
Support for Israel
US gave a lot of money and weapons to Israel to have a partner in the SWANA region and protect American power to stop arab nations from staying independent of US influence and block the Soviet Union from taking over the region. In the media this alliance helped overcome the “Vietnam Syndrome” (domestic embarrassment of losing the Vietnam War) by identifying rith Israeli military toughness
Projecting a Multicultural US society connection to Support for Israel
Strong support for the sate of Israel served, in part, to project a liberal multicultural image abroad while distracting from the US governments own history of antisemitic immigration restrictions of jewish immigration
Quantico and Stocktons 8 themes
Deceit and Secret power: The main terrorist plot relies on “secret power” as a hidden operative working inside the FBI who has high level security access
Irrational Hatred of Israel: Through the tension between Nimah and Simon, the narrative plays on audience expectations of anti-semetic tension between arab and jewish characters
Physiological and Psychological traits: Nimah experienced racial profiling and harassment in a gas station bathroom simply based on her appearance
Sexual Depravity: When Alex and Ryan hook up the story frames her not only as lustful and morally messy but that she has a