1/243
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What did the Wall mean? (economic stabilisation)
- no longer had to deal with dwindling labour supply
- secure work force
- enabled better government planning
- living standards improved
What became issues after the Wall?
- housing becomes the issue as does employment → overqualified workers doing low level jobs
- can’t blame emigration
When was Ulbricht’s New Economic System (NES) and the Economic System of Socialism (ESS)?
- NES = 1963-68
- ESS = 1968-71
What did NES and ESS do?
attempted to make the economy more efficient → reduced central control, allowed some measures of profit to drive industry forward
What were the successes and failures of the NES and ESS?
✅ some success in generating growth
❌ both lacked Soviet support
❌ both restricted by political manoeuvring
When was Ulbricht removed from power and replaced by Honecker and what did he do?
1971 = immediately reversed the policies and reintroduced central planning
What did Honecker’s Unity of Social and Economic Policy (USEP) do?
tried to unite spheres of welfare and the economy
What were the successes and failures of USEP?
✅ some early success in creation of consumer socialism
❌ favoured social side = underinvestment in industry
Why was there an international economic crisis in the 1970s and who did the GDR rely on too much?
OPEC oil price rises = GDR ill prepared
- too reliant on the dominant economy of the USSR = when they interfered with prices and traded for own benefit GDR paid increasing costs
What is consumer socialism?
the idea of rewarding workers: if they work for the state, the state would provide them with consumer goods - Honecker’s
Why was the GDR suffering from a faltering economy in the 1980s?
frequently turned away from COMECON nations and towards the FRG for assistance (Ostpolitik) = germinated economic problems which proved fatal in the late 1980s
Why was there such little resistance to the Berlin Wall going up?
- sudden physical division = shock and disbelief
- memories of 1953 uprising - didn't want widespread repression
- rearmament of GDR and FRG since 1950s = fear of conflict/ nuclear war
- some supported it for GDR's survival
- resentment at 'border-crossers'
- no encouragement from West
- division was fixed = had to accept it (led to niche society)
- psychological impact = conform, co-operate and collaborate
When was the New Economic System (NES)?
1963-68
Why was the NES implemented?
Berlin Wall allowed them to adopt and experiment with new policies
coincided with USSR and Eastern Bloc governments e.g in Hungary and Czechoslovakia - need for economic reforms
What were advantages of the NES?
decision-making allowed at lower levels
quality goods and funds for re-investment
incentives for workers e.g bonuses and higher wages
scientific and technological developments esp. in chemical, optic and electronic industries → rewarded experts
encouraged universities and industry to develop links to improve production
deviating from central planning
What were disadvantages of the NES?
government retained control over economic planning
managers lacked appropriate financial skills = difficulty obtaining necessary resources
overqualified workers = dissatisfaction and high labour turnover
no political concessions
opposition deliberately sabotaged e.g extended sick leave
fear of creating very wealthy class (financial incentives)
argued wage differentials were unnecessary → very little to buy anyways
led to Apel shooting himself
Why was there a change in attitude towards the NES by the USSR?
Brezhnev taking over in 1964 - beliefs more orthodox and unease that economic deviation could create a class of ultra-rich elite
What made Brezhnev's feelings towards the NES quite clear?
his visit to the GDR in December 1965
Who was Erich Apel?
- former rocket scientist for Nazi regime and Soviets
- Ulbricht's key NES supporter - appointed him Chairman of the State Planning Commission
What damaged Apel's political standing?
failure to meet targets, accusations of relying on West Germany, as well as personal attacks on his character
When did Apel shoot himself?
December 1966 (signalled end to NES)
When was the Economic System of Socialism announced?
April 1967
What were the key features of the ESS?
- included agriculture and trade as well as industry
- restored some price subsidies by the state
- more emphasis on developing computer technology, chemical and plastic industries with higher production quotas
What led Brezhnev to impose centralisation of the economy throughout the Eastern Bloc and hard-line policies?
The Warsaw Pact's invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968 to repress a popular revolt
What happened in September in 1970?
- Ulbricht on holiday
- Honecker introduced a Politburo resolution, reversing the narrow emphasis in the economy and dramatically increased central planning
What did the GDR achieve in 1970?
- replaced Poland as USSR's main trading partner
- claimed to be in top 10 industrial nations in the world (was 10th) → proudly noted that this was without relying on Marshall Aid
What were the advantages of the ESS?
- attempts to make the planned economy function more efficiently
- average income for white collar workers rose
- success with growth in production
What were the disadvantages of the ESS?
💔 production failed to meet Ulbricht's prime aim of overtaking the FRG
🏭 GDR lacked facilities, experts and financial investment for progression in research and development
🤲 economic authority in hands of the Party = weakened ability of reforms to promote initiative and efficiency at local level
🛍 too much emphasis on a few industries = shortages of consumer goods
What has there been historical debate over the NES/ESS?
views over the extent to which Ulbricht wished to stray, or even leave, the Marxist economic model
What does it seem the enlightened view of Ulbricht is?
maybe an exaggeration - the policies were more attempts to slow the descent into economic decline rather than a serious plan to solve the underlying economic problems
What percentage of the GDR owned a car in 1960 and by 1970?
1960 = 3.2%
by 1970 = 15.6%
How many people were killed at other border crossings outside Berlin 1961-89?
500
During the 1960s what was there a significant increase in?
availability of household items such as televisions, refrigerators and washing machines at a much higher rate than that of other states within the Eastern Bloc - often with shortages
What meant that individuals were often dissatisfied with consumer goods?
the inferior quality, compared with the FRG, of more basic consumer goods
Who were blamed for the lack of consumer goods?
- SED
- USSR for scale of reparations
- result of Germany's division
How many Intershops were there?
400
What did Intershops do?
- sold Western goods at lower prices than West Berlin/FRG →main aim was to bring Western currency into the GDR
- set up from 1962
Describe Intershops?
- located in GDR along motorways, border crossings, airports and major railway stations
- no window displays, illegal to take photos, frequently staffed by Stasi informers
- GDR citizens not allowed to use them, illegal for East Germans to possess western currency
Who were the Intershops opened to in 1974?
East Germans who had access to Western currency through personal contacts with Westerners, such as friends and family
What did the existence of Intershops highlight?
- difference in the quality of FRG and GDR goods
- division between those who did and didn't have Western currency
What was animosity by East Germans extended to?
towards the chains of Delikat and Exquisit shops
Explain the Delikat and Exquisit shops?
- high-quality, luxurious goods (some imported from West)
- designed for elite Party members and accepted East German currency
- unaffordable for majority of GDR citizens
Explain the compound of Wandlitz?
- where senior members of SED lived
- included extensive nuclear bunker (500 people)
- privileged sites
What was Vilm?
an island in the Baltic Sea - used as a holiday resort for senior Party members
Describe the isolated lifestyle of senior Party members which angered many East Germans?
- able to access much higher quality goods e.g Volvo cars
- superior health and sports facilities (not available to general population)
After 1971, what did the SED focus on?
trying to raise standards of living through 'consumer socialism' (meant accept state control and state will reward you) and better welfare
When was the Unity of Social and Economic Policy (USEP) implemented and by who?
after 1971, under Honecker
Who did the USEP take full agreement of?
Brezhnev
What were the key features of the USEP?
- 'social contract'/'consumer socialism'
- economic centralisation (political reasons?)
→ meant all private and semi-private businesses were nationalised
What percentage of GDR production did private and semi-private business contribute and how many people did it employ?
over 11%
500,000 people
→ loss restricted impact of Honecker's vision
What were the positives of USEP?
- focused on social aspects = greatly improved GDR welfare and housing standards throughout the 1970s
- stabilised economy = allowed state to maintain control
What were the negatives of USEP?
- consistent under-investment in industry = serious decline of 1980s
- unambitious policy did not build an economy able to cope with the succession of problems that arose from mid-1970s onwards
- undermined ability to produce consumer goods
When was the OPEC crisis and what happened?
- 1973 = suddenly raised the worldwide oil prices
- hurt GDR as had few natural resources - reduced GDR's purchasing power for exports
By 1982, what was the GDR finding it increasingly difficult to do?
secure credit and slow-down in retail trade caused a shortage in consumer goods
What was the liquidity crisis?
rising production costs, increasing state expenditure, mounting interest rates on debts and failing trade = dried up GDR's ability to borrow money
What was the solution to the liquidity crisis?
- frantic and secret negotiations between the elite leadership of the SED and FRG
- secured nearly 2 billion DM loans in 1983 and 1984 → cash placed in banks - make illusion of credible investment
- reduced domestic consumption of Soviet oil (led to energy cuts which restricted industrial production) - more oil sold to West along with consumer goods
What did East Germans note vanished from stores?
the 'thousand little things'
In 1982 how much did imports fall and exports rise?
imports fell by 30 percent
exports rose by 9.1 percent
What did the desperate variety of measures do? (1970s)
enough to allow the GDR to function but only allowed breathing space, not recovery before the next economic crisis
When were the absurdities of the bureaucratic obsession with planning seen?
- order went out that all factories should use a certain quota of robots
- order was fulfilled by reclassifying all lifts and vacuum cleaners as robots
What was the inferior quality of consumer goods highlighted by?
- the Trabant or 'Trabi' = expensive cars that were deliberately under-produced as state felt private ownership of automobiles was ideologically wrong (as well as encouraging unsupervised travel)
What was a popular joke at the time about the Trabant?
"What's the best feature of a Trabant? There's a heater at the back to keep your hands warm when you're pushing it."
When did the GDR become a member of COMECON?
1950
How much of the GDR's trade was with the USSR and the Eastern Bloc?
76%
What happened for the next two decades after the GDR joined COMECON?
- GDR's economic planning became intrinsically linked with COMECON → establishment and focus on 5-Year Plans
- GDR focused production for demands of USSR and Eastern European allies
- most sophisticated industrial economy and highest living standards in Eastern Bloc
- supplied USSR and other COMECON members with vital technology in areas such as chemicals, microelectronics and electric engineering below market price
In the 1970s, what did a labour shortage mean?
- GDR brought in workers from other socialist countries like Vietnam, Mozambique, Angola and Cuba
- students studied at East German universities, often graduating in science and technology → many from European sphere suffered social inequalities and hostility in the 1980s
Who was the GDR's largest trading partner and what shows this?
- the USSR
- accounted for 45% of GDR exports of plant and machinery
Why was GDR's trading with the USSR not very profitable?
products sent to the USSR were never bought at a real price and the USSR paid with natural resources so when USSR changed
What % of GDR's iron-ore, oil and wood did the USSR supply?
90%
What % of GDR's rolled and sheet metal did the USSR supply?
80%
Why did links to COMECON prove only some value during the OPEC crisis'?
- during OPEC Crisis 1973 GDR was partly sheltered from the steepest oil prices by using Soviet supplies
- by 1980, after a second OPEC price rise, the Soviets began to reduce its oil supplies, despite personal letter from Honecker to Brezhnev to plead → GDR began to run up its National debt with the USSR
What did COMECON membership do little to protect the GDR from?
the financial woes of the late 1970s and 1980s
By the 1980s what was more important in terms of trade; agricultural production and availability of loans?
GDR's growing trade with FRG rather than COMECON members
What is the word for distinct identity?
Abgrenzung
What were the views of Ulbricht and Honecker on a distinct identity?
- Ulbricht advocated there was a single German state
- 1971 Honecker understood entrenched position of Germany
- wanted to promote and preserve socialism in East
- attempts to create separate identity and give the population something to be proud of
Explain the creation of the distinct identity?
- new measures taken to stress difference between FRG and DDR
- demarcation to give confidence to DDR
- claimed crimes of Nazis not DDR responsibility
- exports no longer 'Made in Germany' but 'Made in DDR/GDR'
- two methods: mass media and sport
What was the main newspaper in the GDR?
SED's Neues Deutschland
How was Honecker involved with newspapers?
had daily meetings with editor of ND to approve front page
How was newspaper publishing under control?
- only one single news agency
- funded from government money → no competition for income
- others published by National Bloc and regional newspapers but all newspapers given instructions on what to write
- strict controls on printing machines and photocopiers
When was it illegal to display or read Western newspapers and what was it like after Wall construction?
before 1961, after Wall many Western visitors had newspapers taken
What were the only Western newspapers allowed?
those of the Western communist parties
What underlying messages did all newspapers have?
SED leaders adulated, widespread social problems in FRG and anniversaries promoted
What percentage of all publications in the GDR were directly controlled by the Party and what were most of the rest?
70%
- most of the rest were papers and magazines produced by mass organisations e.g. Free German Youth
Which newspapers were the only ones not controlled?
Church organisations - expected to write solely on religious matters and be strictly non-controversial
When was radio widespread since and by when were there several radio stations?
widespread since 1920s, by 1970s several radio stations
When was Radio DDR1 and DDR2 established?
Radio DDR1 = August 1963
Radio DDR2 = 1968
Which radio station catered for the capital?
Berliner Rundfunk
What radio station was added in 1964 and what did it broadcast?
youth music station DT64 - broadcasted mix of music and spoken work, sports reporting was popular
How many licensed radios were there by 1985?
6.6 million, 39.9 for every 100
Where were Western ratio stations broadcast and what were they often more popular than?
across most of GDR → often more popular than GDR output → demand for Western music high amongst young
What did the government attempt to do with radios that was outlawed by international agreement and what did it risk?
jam foreign signals, risked the West jamming East German radio stations in retaliation
When were TVs widely available and why was this a particular concern?
by the 1970s, most houses in the GDR could pick up Western station broadcast from West Berlin
What was TV controlled by and how many stations did it have by 1969?
Fernsehen der DDR (DDR-FS) → 2 stations
What else began in 1969? (TVs)
colour programming
What was care taken to ensure? (television)
news programmes were not broadcast at the same time as those on FRG stations, popular entertainment was scheduled against West German news broadcasts
What was the output of the GDR TV stations like?
heavily political and often not very subtle
Explain Karl Eduard Von Schnitzler?
- regime's leading propagandist
- weekly programme Der Schwarce Kanal (The Black Channel) bombarded viewer with uncompromisingly hostile views of the West
- FRG referred to as 'Land of Wolves' and Kondrad Adenauer as 'Hitler's Heir'
- many claimed to not watch but most did, aghast
- one of most despised men in GDR
When was Schnitzler dismissed as political director of GDR TV and how did he reappear?
1958, always resurfaced in another role as a television discussion host (Honecker recognised more subtle approach was likely to be more effective)
What was the television output that came out of the GDR?
turgid propaganda - but just since East Germans were very sceptical, did not mean they believed in news transmitted by West German channels
What children's programme was adored by generations of East Germans and was a cultural icon of the GDR?
The Sand Man