1/28
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Travel of ideas
-An idea may originate in one organization, profession, country, or historical period and then appear somewhere else
-Each time it enters a new context, people translate it into terms that make sense locally
-Idea --> object or model --> local translation --> organized action --> institution --> new ideas and models
2 traditional dominant explanations of organizational change
-Change as planned innovation
-Change as environmental adaptation
Change as planned innovation
-Leaders identify a problem, choose a solution, design a plan, and implement it
-Change is presented as intentional, controlled, and rational
-Problem --> decision --> implementation --> desired outcome
-The problem is that actual change rarely follows the original plan --> reforms generate unexpected consequences, resistance, reinterpretations, and new problems
Change as environmental adaptation
-Organizations change because markets, technologies, regulations, professions, or social expectations have changed
-It can make organizations appear passive, as if outside conditions automatically cause internal change
-It struggles to explain why organizations facing similar pressures respond differently or why they sometimes adopt fashionable reforms even when there is no clear practical need
Real organizational change
-Contain both intention and accident
-Imitation and invention
-Control and contingency
-Local interpretation and external influence
-Planned action and unintended consequences
Garbage-can model
-Organizations do not always solve problems through orderly rational analysis, problems, solutions, participants circulate separately and are connected somewhat unpredictably
-The authors alter this in 2 ways: They take actors' interpretations seriously and they reject the assumption that researchers necessarily possess a superior explanation
-Practictioners must simplify reality enough to act and researchers can pause, compare cases, and reflect on complexity
What is an idea
-Ideas can be communicated, represented, remembered, modified, and attached to material objects
-An idea might appear as a phrase, an image, a managemnet concept, a diagram, a policy document, or prototype
-Ideas become influential partly because they can be expressed in simple, transferable forms --> this allows it to travel to other locations but this simplification also removes context
Ideas become objects
-An idea may first become an object, such as a report, proposal, model, representation, machine, new building, formal decision, or a set of performance indicators
-These objects make the idea durable
Objects travel
-Documents, technologies, models, and stories can be moved from one organization to another
-Consultants, professional associations, government agencies, universities, conferences, and the media frequently act as carriers
Objects are translated locally
-A model cannot simply be inserted into a new organization
-Local actors must decide what the model means, which problem it is supposed to solve, which parts should be retained, who should be responsible, and how it fits existing practices
Translation produces action
-Once the idea has been adapted, it can become meetings, budgets, appointments, construction projects, procedures, or technologies
-Action produces additional interpretations: people look at what happened and tell stories about whether the reform succeeded, failed, or was misunderstood
Diffusion
-Suggests that an idea spreads while remaining essentially the same
-It imagines a relatively stable object moving from a source to multiple recipients
-The recipient is largely passive: it accepts, rejects, or slowly adopts the innovation
Translation
-Assumes that an idea changes as it moves --> every recipient is also an interpreter and co-creator
-People may rename the idea, connect it to different problems, remove controversial elements, add locally attractive elements, combine it with existing practice, or even present it as something new
Diffusion perspective
-Ideas spread
-The idea remains stable
-Recipients adopt or reject
-Variation is imperfect adoption
-Focus on speed and extent
Translation perspective
-Ideas are edited and reconstructed
-The idea changes during travel
-Recipients actively interpret
-Variation is a normal result
-Focus on meaning and transformation
Local and global are interconnected
-What appears to be a global idea is usually reproduced through many local actions, but at the same time apparent local decisions are influenced by international models
-The global exists through connections between localities
-Ideas become mobile when they are disembedded from their original setting: they are turned into generalized models, concepts, or success stories
-They can become re-embedded in another setting, which requires selective forgetting
When does an idea become noticable
-When it connects with a recognized problem
-An existing political agenda
-The interest of powerful actors
-Current professional language
-A crisis or opportunity
-An established organizational identity
-A wider social fashion
The role of fashion
-Organizations frequently adopt similar ideas at approximately the same time, which resembles fashion
-Organizational fashions are not necessarily irrational, they help actors manage uncertainty and adopting a widely accepted model can appear safer
-Fashion can provide legitimacy, recognition, access to funding, professional credibility, protection against criticism, a sense of modernity, and reassurance that others are doing the same
Institution and fashion
-May initially seem opposite: fashion is temporary and changing, whilst institutions are stable and taken for granted
-Fashion helps ideas travel rapidly: if a translated idea becomes repeated, normalized, and embedded in routines, it can become institutionalized
-Once institutionalized, the practice no longer needs to be justified continually, it becomes seen as natural or obvious
-Institutions create the conditions for new fashions
Power and control of attention
-Translation is not politically neutral: not everyone has an equal opportunity to introduce, redefine, or promote ideas
-Power operates through the ability to name problems, place issues on the agenda, produce official documents, organize meetings, allocate money, and define professional standards
-An actor does not need to force everyone to support an idea if competing ideas never receive serious consideration
Decisions
-Formal decisions are often described as moments when an organization selects a course of action
-By the time a decision is officially made, the idea may already by widely accepted, resources committed, opponents marginalized, and organizations may have begun acting
Anchoring ideas
-Broad ideas are often too vague to produce action on their own, they need to be connected to existing concerns
-Ideas can be anchored in familiar organizational problems, established values, influential groups, accepted stories, available technologies, and political priorities
-Ideas that can connect to several interests are especially likely to travel, as their ambiguity becomes an advantage
What can a strong label do
-Attract attention
-Simplify communication
-Mobilize supporters
-Connect a project to wider trends
-Hide internal contradictions
-Make unrelated activities seem coordinated
Important carriers of traveling ideas
-Consultants
-Researchers
-Universities
-Government ministries
-International organizations
-Professional associations
-Conferences
-Books and journals
-Managers moving between organizations
-Technologies and standardized procedures
3 pressures that help explain why organizations often become similar
-Coercive pressures: laws, regulations, funding requirements, or powerful stakeholders
-Mimetic pressures: imitation under uncertainty
-Normative pressures: professional standards and shared education
Material conditions that ideas encounter
-Financial limits
-Physical infrastructure
-Available technologies
-Existing buildings
-Legal structures
-Professional skills
-Geographical conditions
-Political resistance
Institutionalization
-An idea becomes institutionalized when its translated form is repeatedly enacted and eventually treated as normal
-An institution is not simply an idea that everyone believes, it is an idea embedded in actions, objects, rules, and routines
-Institutions are never completely permanent, because they enactment requires interpretation and practices can gradually change
What does institutionalization involve
-Repetition
-Stabilization
-Standardization
-Formal rules
-Pressional training
-Material investment
-Shared expectations
-Forgetting that alternatives were once possible
Control and contingency
-Managers, politicians, consultants, and employees attempt to shape change, their intentions matter because they influence which ideas are promoted
-No actor fully controls how others interpret the idea, which alliances form around it, which objects are created, how material conditions interfere, and what unintended consequences emerge