1/3
Looks like no tags are added yet.
terrorism case
A terrorist group is holding 2 people hostage. You and your partner are negotiating with them. You have two options – you can either:
Do nothing, in which case the terrorists will kill both hostages. Or
Shoot your partner in the head, in which case the terrorists will be distracted, and the 2 hostages will escape.
theory D (deon) = There’s constraint against killing. So do A, not B
Cant generate a consequentialist version of theory D!
why cant we generate a consequentialist version of theory D
Take the features of an action a Theory D considers to be relevant - Innocent people are not to be killed.
Restate this requirement as the claim that, e.g., the killing of an innocent person is a bad consequence.
Give a lexically prior negative weight to the killing of innocent people (i.e. nothing is worse than killing).
if 2 and 3 are true then you ought to do B, not A because this means fewer killings of innocent people.
agent-neutral vs agent-relative view
agent-neutral = consequentialism
a reason can be given a general form which does not include an essential reference to the person who has it
agent-relative view = deontology
the general form of a reason does include an essential reference to the person who has it
agent centred reasons for action
-
-