1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why is menopause an evolutionary puzzle?
Classic life-history theory says animals should reproduce until they die and that Menopause shouldn't exist because there's no direct fitness benefit yet it does in humans killer whales and pilot whales
What is the main hypothesis of the study?
Post Reproductive females act as "repositories of ecological knowledge." They help their kin survive by leading them to food during hard times (Inclusive Fitness).
Where was the study conducted and who were the subjects?
Coastal waters of British Columbia and Washington (Southern resident killer whales). They analyzed 102 individuals (58 females, 44 males) over 9 summers (2001–2009).
How did they collect data and define "leadership"?
They analyzed 751 hours of video footage. They defined the "leader" as the individual at the very front of a traveling group, and the rest as "followers."
What statistical test did they use?
Permutation-based binomial regression models. (This is used because it accounts for repeated measures on the same individuals over multiple years)
What did Figure 1 (the "leader score" graphs) show?
Adult females lead significantly more than males (p<0.0001p<0.0001). Among females, postreproductive females (35+ years) lead more than reproductive females (12-34 years) (p<0.001p<0.001).
What did Figure 2 show about salmon abundance?
When salmon abundance is LOW, postreproductive females step up and lead the group the most. When salmon is high, they don't lead as much. (p=0.048p=0.048).
Who follows the old females the most?
Sons follow their mothers significantly more than daughters do. (p<0.001p<0.001). Both sexes prefer following postreproductive leaders, but males more
Why did the authors mention African elephants?
As supporting evidence of the "wisdom of elders." Older elephant matriarchs have better knowledge of predators and social threats. Their presence boosts the reproductive success of the herd (Inclusive Fitness).
If old elephants are so smart and helpful, why don't they have menopause like orcas?
Menopause only evolves if inclusive fitness benefits outweigh the costs because in orcas neither sex leaves the group so old female relatedness in group increases with age but in elephants males disperse so the genetic math differs
What are the limitations or confounding variables of this study?
Observational, couldn’t track what the females were doing to lead, environmental factors impacting salmon confounding leaderhsip data
Repositories of ecological knowledge
Older individuals who store decades of information about where and when to find resources.
Inclusive Fitness
Passing on your genes directly (your own babies) AND indirectly (helping your relatives survive).
Postreproductive
The stage of life after an animal has stopped having babies.