1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
moral problems
a situation in which all of the possible actions you can do and all of the choices you make lead to morally problematic consequences or involve morally problematic actions
business involves questions about…
humans
the environment
consumption decisions
human rights
fair labor
ethics
looks at moral dilemmas from an objective point of view and tries to create principals, ideas, and theories that we can really analyze the situations with
ex. “according to this theory, this is what we should do”
utilitarianism theory
looks at calculations
in business we calculate everything so the question becomes why can’t we calculate what the right decision is?
philosopher believed that the only thing that humans care about is pleasure over pain. We want pleasure as much as possible. His idea was that we should look at what action would bring about the most pleasures compared to pain. Important that this is not just about yourself, but rather about the whole community
key aspect is this theory looks at the consequences of an act. what brings about the most happiness and quality?
criticism of utilitarian theory
John Stewart Mill liked this theory but was critical because he argued it was not just about pleasures in a quantitative sense, we have the look at the sense of pleasures from a sense of quality. We can also look at measures of happiness (think of the netflix show vs reading a book example)
people’s criticism:
we can’t calculate happiness because we don’t know what is actually going on. Maybe if we save those 20 children one of them could go on to cure cancer and cause more happiness. We just do not know
it is not okay to trade a human life for some other kind of happiness. If human life is so sacred, nothing else should be more important
two things to know before calculating the right choice from a utilitarian perspective
you must know two things before calculating:
this theory is an agent neutral one: this means your own happiness is not more important than the happiness of other people. You must consider the happiness of all
diminishing marginal utility of money: this means that money means something different to each person. For example, $5 to a billionaire does not mean a lot but to a person on the street it could make their day - they can find food, maybe a place to stay, etc. Money has less utility the more you already have
how to calculate the right decision from a utilitarian perspective
Think of the moral dilemma scenario where we are choosing which charity to donate to: the drugs for children (we have the possibility to save 20 children with this drug) and the hospital for blind people.
Drugs for children - utility goes up. 20 x 100 utility units (child) +
20 × 100 utility units (parents) = 4000 utility units
healing people from blindness - compared to saving a life, it is 1 utility unity so 10,000 × 1 utility unit (blind person) + 10,000 × 1 utility unit (family) = 20,000 utility units
according to utilitarianism, we should go with the hospital that heals the blind
deontology theory
deon = obligation/duty
we should never treat human beings as a means to an end. Essentially, we should always treat humans with respect and dignity. We should never violate the rights of the humans. We should also always help people and defend them for their rights
This philosopher believes that some actions are morally wrong in themselves. For example, violating a person’s rights is morally wrong
deontology principal
if we are choosing a certain law, idea, or act we want to do, ask ourselves if this law can be applied to everyone (universal) or if in doing so it would be mad. If so, you should not do that act yourself
application of deontology to our moral dilemma
both charities are morally good, but we only have money for one. We then must think back to how this philosopher believes in the importance of dignity and autonomy.
If people die, they have no chance anymore to live a life
If we don’t heal the blind - it does not take away their autonomy or the life they have
in this case, according to this theory, we should save the kids
ethics and morality
all human beings have a certain degree of morality
the morality of people is observable, ethics is the academic study of morality
philosophers ask what should be there, what would be the ideal state of the world and what hinders us from getting there
contract theory
john rawls perspective - looked at institutions and asked how they should be designed so that everybody could have a good life. So essentially, how we should design our world so that everybody could lead a good life?
we have a social contract between us - what are the rules we can all agree on to make this world a better place to live
the vale of ignorance
a thought experiment
we should imagine our institutions, governments, also companies, the whole world behind a vale of ignorance. This means that we do not know who we are going to be in the real world (poor or rich, poc or not, male or female). He asks us to imagine this world and to get rid of our biases and think of the fairest way
his idea here is that if we don’t know who we are then we are the fairest
two principals from the vale of ignorance
equal basic liberties - same for everybody, we will all agree
social and economic inequalities are only justified if:
there is fair equal opportunity for all
they benefit the least advantage
communitarianism theory
believes that individualism endangers the communities we live in. As individuals in those communities, we really need to think about how we can contribute to them. So the question is, we kind of values do we share? Aristotle said to be a good member of the community, we need to strive for excellence
shareholder theory
the idea that the owner of a company is the central focal point and that all actions that happen in the company need to serve one goal and that is maximize profit
there are long term share holders and quick as well
both are interested in raising the value of the company o
stakeholder theory
we cannot create value without good relations with customers, employees, financial backers, etc.
instrumental stakeholder
a sort of ranking of which stakeholders matter more (the ones that matter are instrumental in creating more value)
normative stakeholder
relies on utilitarian and deontology theory. If we rank the importance of stakeholders we are treating humans as a means to an end
Here, we consider all stakeholders and their rightful claims to the company
ex. workers have a right to safe working conditions
the happiness of the owner is not more important than the stakeholders
shareholder theory is not enough on its own - we need to rely on the stakeholder theory