1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
1Issue:
The issue is whether Dublin Beverages is liable to Mary in the tort of negligence. Negligence happens when a person does not take reasonable care and this causes harm to another person.
2Issue:
To succeed, Mary must prove a duty of care, a breach of that duty, causation and damage.
1Law:
A duty of care is a legal duty to take reasonable care so that you do not harm other people. The leading case is Donoghue v Stevenson, where the court created the "neighbour principle":
2Law:
you must take reasonable care not to harm people who are closely and directly affected by what you do. The court also said that a manufacturer owes a duty of care to the final consumer, even if there is no contract between them.
3Law:
In Ireland, the courts ask if the harm was foreseeable, if there was a close relationship between the parties, and if it is fair to impose a duty (Glencar).
4Law :
The standard of care is the level of care that a reasonable person would take in the same situation. To decide if there was a breach, the courts look at how likely the harm was (Bolton v Stone), how serious the harm could be (Paris v Stepney), how useful the activity is, and how easy it is to prevent the harm.
5Law:
Causation means that the breach must cause the harm. The courts use the "but for" test: but for the defendant's breach, would the harm have happened? (Barnett v Chelsea Hospital).The type of harm must also be foreseeable (The Wagon Mound).
6Law
Damages are money that the court gives the plaintiff to compensate her for her loss. General damages are for pain and suffering, and special damages are for exact money losses, such as medical bills and lost income.
7Law
Mental harm is only compensated if it is a recognised psychiatric illness; normal worry or upset is not enough (Kelly v Hennessy).
Application A
The facts are very similar to Donoghue v Stevenson. It was foreseeable that a contaminated drink could make a consumer sick. Mary is the final consumer, so she is closely and directly affected by the drink. The bottle was dark, so nobody could check the drink before she drank it. It does not matter that Alice bought the drink, because a duty of care does not need a contract. Therefore, Dublin Beverages owed Mary a duty of care.
Application B
A reasonable drinks manufacturer would clean and check its bottles so that nothing gets inside. If a drink is contaminated, the harm can be serious, because people get sick. It is easy and cheap to check the bottles compared to this risk. A dead snail inside a sealed bottle shows that Dublin Beverages did not take reasonable care. Therefore, it did not meet the standard of care and breached its duty.
Application C
Mary became sick the same evening, after drinking from the bottle. But for the snail in the drink, she would not have had stomach pain and vomiting. Getting sick is a foreseeable result of drinking a contaminated drink. Therefore, Mary can prove causation for her physical illness. Her nervousness about bottled drinks is more difficult, and she can only connect it to the snail if a doctor confirms a real mental illness.
Application D
Mary can claim general damages for her stomach pain, vomiting and suffering. She can claim special damages for her medical costs and for any costs from missing her college exams, such as repeat fees. For her nervousness, she can only claim if a doctor confirms a recognised psychiatric illness (Kelly v Hennessy).
Conclusion
In conclusion, Dublin Beverages owed Mary a duty of care, breached it, and caused her illness. Mary is likely to succeed in negligence and recover general and special damages.