1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What situation does Singer start from? What is his overall claim?
What is Assumption 1?
State Singer's principle. What does "comparable moral importance" mean?
What is the drowning child case, and how does it support the principle?
Why does Singer think the principle would fundamentally change our lives and
society?
Be able to state each objection and Singer's reply:
i. Proximity and distance.
ii. Others could help too. What is the difference between a situation where
everyone gives $5 and our actual situation?
iii. The over-giving challenge.
iv. The conclusion is too drastic a revision of our moral scheme.
v. Isn't this an empirical question about what most effectively secures good
outcomes? (Sidgwick–Urmson)
vi. We would have to be working full time.
vii. Isn't it the government's job?
What happens to the traditional distinction between duty and charity?
What does Singer say about longer-term solutions?