causation

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/8

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

9 Terms

1
New cards

factual causation

  • ‘but for’ test

  • “but for the D conduct, would the result have occurred when it did? if the answer is no, factual causation is established

  • case: R v White White poisoned his mother's drink intending to kill her.

  • Before she drank enough poison to die, she died of a heart attack.

Test:

But for White's poisoning, would she have died?

Yes, because she died from a heart attack anyway.

✅ No factual causation.

✅ Therefore no murder.


Ali stabs Ben.

Ben dies from the stab wound.

Question: But for Ali stabbing Ben, would Ben have died?

Answer: No.

✅ Factual causation established.


2
New cards

legal causation

  • Even if factual causation exists, the prosecution must prove legal causation

  • the defendants conduct must be substantial and operating cause of the result. it does not have to be the only cause

  • case: R v Smith:

  • solider stabbed another soldier, V received poor medical treatment, victim died, court held:

  • OG wound was still a substantial and operating cause of death

  • defendant liable

  • The defendant's conduct need not be the sole cause, but it must be more than minimal and remain an operating cause of the consequence.


3
New cards

chain of causation

Once causation is established, the prosecution must show the chain was not broken.

A novus actus interveniens (new intervening act) may break the chain.

4
New cards

3 ways the chain may be broken

5
New cards
  1. victims own act


the victim does something after the defendants conduct. if the V reaction was reasonably foreseeable the chain remains intact but it i was not foreseeable it may be broken.

case: R v Roberts = a girl jumped from a moving car to escape unwanted advances, she was injured, her reaction was foreseeable so the chain was not broken

6
New cards
  1. medical treatment


medical negligence rarely breaks the chain.

  • case: R v Cheshire = V shot, poor hospital treatment, V died from complications

  • court: original shooting remained a significant cause= defendant liable

  • test: medical treatment breaks the chain only when it becomes so potent in causing death that the defendant's contribution becomes insignificant.

  • case: R v Jordan= V recovering, doctors gave treatment known to be inappropriate, V died. = medical treatment broke the chain, defendant not liable for death


7
New cards
  1. acts of third parties


  • a third party intervenes

  • if the third party’s act makes the defendants contribution insignificant then the chain is broken if not the chain continues

  • R v Pagett: used his preggo gf as a human shield during a shootout, police shot and killed her.

  • court: police response was foreseeable, chain not broken, Pagett caused death


8
New cards

thin skull rule

  • sometimes victims have unusual vulnerabilities

  • the defendant must take the victim as they find them

  • case: R v Blaue = V stabbed, needed blood transfusion, was a Jehovah witness so refused blood, she died.

  • defendant refused that they were the cause of death

  • court: no, thin skull rule applies, defendant is liable


9
New cards