1/8
Looks like no tags are added yet.
factual causation
‘but for’ test
“but for the D conduct, would the result have occurred when it did? if the answer is no, factual causation is established
case: R v White White poisoned his mother's drink intending to kill her.
Before she drank enough poison to die, she died of a heart attack.
Test:
But for White's poisoning, would she have died?
Yes, because she died from a heart attack anyway.
✅ No factual causation.
✅ Therefore no murder.
Ali stabs Ben.
Ben dies from the stab wound.
Question: But for Ali stabbing Ben, would Ben have died?
Answer: No.
✅ Factual causation established.
legal causation
Even if factual causation exists, the prosecution must prove legal causation
the defendants conduct must be substantial and operating cause of the result. it does not have to be the only cause
case: R v Smith:
solider stabbed another soldier, V received poor medical treatment, victim died, court held:
OG wound was still a substantial and operating cause of death
defendant liable
The defendant's conduct need not be the sole cause, but it must be more than minimal and remain an operating cause of the consequence.
chain of causation
Once causation is established, the prosecution must show the chain was not broken.
A novus actus interveniens (new intervening act) may break the chain.
3 ways the chain may be broken
victims own act
the victim does something after the defendants conduct. if the V reaction was reasonably foreseeable the chain remains intact but it i was not foreseeable it may be broken.
case: R v Roberts = a girl jumped from a moving car to escape unwanted advances, she was injured, her reaction was foreseeable so the chain was not broken
medical treatment
medical negligence rarely breaks the chain.
case: R v Cheshire = V shot, poor hospital treatment, V died from complications
court: original shooting remained a significant cause= defendant liable
test: medical treatment breaks the chain only when it becomes so potent in causing death that the defendant's contribution becomes insignificant.
case: R v Jordan= V recovering, doctors gave treatment known to be inappropriate, V died. = medical treatment broke the chain, defendant not liable for death
acts of third parties
a third party intervenes
if the third party’s act makes the defendants contribution insignificant then the chain is broken if not the chain continues
R v Pagett: used his preggo gf as a human shield during a shootout, police shot and killed her.
court: police response was foreseeable, chain not broken, Pagett caused death
thin skull rule
sometimes victims have unusual vulnerabilities
the defendant must take the victim as they find them
case: R v Blaue = V stabbed, needed blood transfusion, was a Jehovah witness so refused blood, she died.
defendant refused that they were the cause of death
court: no, thin skull rule applies, defendant is liable