1/12
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Objectivity v Subjectivity
Usually objective, but subjective can be used if the offeree is aware of the mistake, or if the mistake of the offeror induced the offeree to agree to the contract.
“Backwards reasoning” v “forward reasoning”
Backwards refers to the most common way to decide cases and means finding the outcome and fitting it back into theory and case law. Forwards reasoning means using the tests and case law to find the outcome.
The offer
Must be unequivocal, with the intention of an agreement being formed is accepted.
Invitation to treat
A willingness to enter into negotiations, such as the display of goods for sale.
Hartog v Colin and Shields
Hartog v Colin and Shields concerned the sale of hare skins sold per pound - rather than per piece, as had been discussed. As the pre-sale discussions had been done according to per piece measurements, the court found the contract void.
Scriven Bros v Hindley [1913] 3 KB 564
Bros bought tow and hemp lots at auction, but the second turned out to contain only tow, as opposed to a mix, which was valued much lower. The negligence of the auctioneers caused a nondisclosure of price inflation.
Gibson v Manchester City Council
A leaflet said they “may be prepared” to sell council houses to inhabitants. Mr Gibson accepted the offer, but it was taken back after new Government banned the sale of council houses. The House of Lords determined it an ITT due to the wording.
Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256
Advertised a ‘smoke ball’ which prevented influenza if used properly, and they offered £100 for anyone who used it as directed and got ill. Mrs Carlill contracted influenza after depositing some money, but they refused to pay, saying it was a sales gimmick. The court ruled for Mrs Carlill. The newspaper ad was a valid offer, and the acceptance was her performance.
Reasons for termination of an offer:
Acceptance, rejection, counter-offer, revocation (withdrawal of offer), lapse of time, or death.
Terms of acceptance
The offeror must know you have accepted the offer, and silence does not suffice, although action does.
The postal Rule
Acceptance of an offer is valid at the moment of postage, even if the offeror never receives it. It must be properly stamped, addressed, and a reasonable method of communication - it should not cause inconvenience. This does NOT include emails.
Counter offer v request for information
A counter offer is when the offeree tries to establish new terms in the contract, extinguishing the original offer. It is a termination of the OG offer, which cannot be returned to.
Request for information does not bring an offer to an end, but it is also not acceptance. The offer remains open.
Hyde v Wrench (1840) 3 BEAV 334
Land was offered to be sold for £1,000, and a counter offer of £950 was rejected by the seller. The buyer attempted to buy the land for the original £1,000 offer. The seller withdrew from sale as the counter offer extinguished the original contract.