1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Compliance
Compliance:
Compliance refers to the result of direct pressure to respond to a request
Unlike obedience, compliance is not the result of a command by someone with more authority
Unlike conformity, compliance is a response to an explicit request, whereas conformity results from a group norm that is "unspoken" (real or imagined pressure)
Robert Cialdini
Robert Cialdini has outlined the compliance techniques, or ways in which individuals are influenced to comply with the demands of others
Utilised often in advertising and marketing, where sales tactics are always carefully examined based on what would most likely persuade consumers to buy specific products
Dialdini outlines six factors that influence the likelihood that people will comply with a request:
Authority: people comply more often with those in positions of authority. Advertisers use famous people to brand their products so that people associate the brand with the famous person
Commitment: once people have agreed to something, either by their behaviour or by a statement of belief, they are likely to comply with similar requests
Liking: people comply with requests from people they like
Reciprocity: people often feel they need to "return a favour"
Scarcity: opportunities seem more valuable to people when they are less readily available. This is why there are so many "last chance" and "limited time only" sales
Social proof: people view a behaviour as correct if they see others performing it
Foot-in-the-door technique
Foot-in-the-door technique:
A compliance tactic in which a small initial request is made, followed by a larger, related request. Agreeing to the smaller request makes the target more likely to agree to the larger request
Principle of consistency
This works because people strive for internal consistency
Self-perception theory - people infer their attitudes by observing their own behaviour
View themselves as helpful or cooperative - continue behaving consistently --> hence more likely to agree to large request
If the initial request is too demanding, the effect is less likely to work - request has to be small and acceptable
If the gap is too long to make the larger request, the initial compliance may lose influence
Relies on self-consistency
Self-perception Theory
Self-perception Theory:
When people agree to a small request, they start to see themselves as helpful or supportive of that cause. So when a larger request follows, they want to stay consistent with that self-image
Gradual Escalation
Gradual Escalation:
Starting small lowers resistance. Once someone says yes, they're psychologically "on board," making it harder to say no later without feeling uncomfortable
Factors affecting FITD - Size of the request
Factors affecting FITD - Size of the request:
Size of the request: it must be small enough that most people are willing to agree, but still meaningful
If it's too trivial, it won't trigger self-perception
If it's too large, people may reject it outright, running the effect
Factors affecting FITD - Timing
Factors affecting FITD - Timing:
Timing: the delay between the first and second request cannot be too long
A public commitment (e.g. wearing a sticker or signing something) can amplify the pressure to stay consistent with that behaviour
The small request must be seen as freely chosen. If people feel pressured or manipulated, they won't internalise the behaviour as part of their self-concept, reducing effectiveness
Cultural Differences FITD
Cultural Differences FITD:
Individualistic cultures:
Self-perception and persona consistency are highly valued
People are more likely to agree to the second request to maintain a consistent self-image
Collectivist cultures:
Social harmony and relational obligations take priority over individual consistency
FITD is often less effective, unless the second request also aligns with group goals or social expectations
Application of FITD
Application of FITD:
A salesman offers you a free sample of their product. When you accept, you may unconsciously view yourself as open, helpful, or interested, which makes you more likely to say yes when they later ask you to purchase the full product
Causality
Causality:
True experiment - controlled variables - improves internal validity
Four random groups - improves internal validity
Conducted in participants' homes - improves ecological validity
Extraneous variables - could not control distractions, the participant's mood, or who answered the phone
Statistical significance - big gap between 52.8% and 22.2%
Motivation - unsure if compliance was the sole reason; motivation to fulfil self-perception theory
Agency - illusion of free will
Mundane realism - large requests are somewhat unrealistic?
Reductionism - simplifies social dynamics, ignores factors such as social politeness, inability to say "no" to authority, or the need for social approval
Naturalistic environmental - high ecological validity - increases external validity
Standardised procedure - IV causes DV - increases internal validity
Temporal validity - 1960's - changes in sociocultural factors
Bias
Bias:
Participant variables/individual differences --> internal validity
Cultural bias - individualist/collectivist
Gender bias --> sample were all women
1966 --> representative generalisability
Quantitative data
Minimal researcher bias
Standardised procedure
Attention bias
Measurement
Measurement:
Use of control group - smaller - skewed data
True experiment --> quantitative data - scientific
More objective
Other factors that account for compliance