Slides - The commodification of wo/men in the English marriage market

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/24

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

25 Terms

1
New cards

Main argument

Over the Georgian era (1714-1837), marriage shifted from an ideology of arranged marriage to an ideology of companionate marriage. Even so, marriage kept features of a business transaction, and women were still treated as objects and commodities in the marriage market. Austen (1775-1817), a product of the Georgian era, wrote several novels in the Regency (1811-1820), and they reflect this.

2
New cards

What drove the change from arranged to companionate

Enlightenment ideas about freedom, equality and individual rights made marriage a matter of individual choice, not parental mandate.


3
New cards

The core question behind the shift from arranged to companionate

To whom did the right to exchange the female body belong?

4
New cards

The new problem companionate marriage created

Choosing your own spouse let marriages cross class, status and economic lines, which advanced social mobility and threatened the social interests that arranged marriage protected.

5
New cards

Ideology of arranged marriage

marriage as a business transaction arranged by parents and guardians. Sons and daughters were treated as assets or pawns in efforts to gain or maintain wealth, connections and power.

6
New cards

Ideology of companionate marriage

young people chose their spouses by the end of the Georgian era. It was never free of business features, because both sides still brought property, dowries, fortunes, trades, skills, social connections and the ability to provide heirs.

7
New cards

Conduct manuals

the equivalent of today’s self-help books, and they originated in medieval literature. They advised how to find the right mate by those criteria, and their function was conservative.

8
New cards

Patriarchal exchange

the system in which women are objects traded between men through marriage. Women can also embody patriarchy, such as Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine de Bourgh in P&P, who arrange the exchange of their daughters with men they choose.

9
New cards

Entailment

if a family had no son, the property was inherited by the closest male relative rather than going to the daughters and their husbands. Titles and land passed to the eldest direct male heir. The gentry invented it to prevent the erosion of its class by aspiring bourgeois professionals who wanted status by marrying into it.

10
New cards

Accomplished woman (Regency):

a woman with the skills that made her a social asset to her husband. Core skills were education and enough mathematics to run a household, sewing (with decorative needlework a bonus), gardening, food preservation, and knowing servants’ work and household remedies. Truly accomplished women could also sing, dance, play an instrument, draw and paint, and speak French or Italian to entertain his guests.

11
New cards

Patriarchy in Pride and Prejudice (Regency, 1813)

  • Women under patriarchy are objects and commodities in a system of exchange (marriage).

  • Women can also embody patriarchy: Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine de Bourgh arrange the “exchange” of their daughters.

  • Opening line, ch. 1: “a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife.” He is “considered the rightful property of some one or other of their daughters.” So the marriage market treats men and women as property.


12
New cards

Accomplished women in P&P (Regency, 1813)

  • Ch. 8: Bingley and Darcy discuss what makes a woman accomplished.

  • Bingley’s traditional view: music, painting, singing, drawing, dancing, modern languages.

  • Darcy’s counter-traditional view: “improvement of her mind by extensive reading”, which makes him a spokesman for Austen.

  • The Bennet girls had little formal education. Jane and Elizabeth have excellent manners but not the typical accomplishments that draw excellent suitors. Elizabeth’s wit was considered a disadvantage.


13
New cards

Entailment in P&P (Regency, 1813)

  • Mr Bennet has no son, so the estate is entailed to his closest male relative, Mr Collins, who will inherit when Mr Bennet dies.

  • That is why Collins proposes expecting acceptance. Elizabeth’s dowry is small, so her bargaining position is low.


14
New cards

1. What is the difference between the ideologies of arranged and companionate marriage?

Arranged marriage treated marriage as a business transaction run by parents and guardians. Children were assets or pawns in the effort to gain or maintain wealth, connections and power. Companionate marriage, which took hold by the end of the Georgian era (1714-1837), let young people choose their spouses. Even then, marriage kept business features, because both sides brought property, dowries, fortunes and connections.

15
New cards


2. Why did arranged marriage decline?

Enlightenment ideas about freedom, equality and individual rights shifted attitudes. Marriage became an individual choice, not a parental mandate. The key question was who had the right to exchange the female body.

16
New cards

3. What problems did companionate marriage create?

It could cross class, status and economic lines, and so advanced social mobility. That jeopardized the social interests that arranged marriage had served by negotiating class, status and money.

17
New cards

4. What was the conservative function of conduct literature?

Conduct manuals (the self-help books of their day, originating in medieval literature) advised people on finding the right mate by societal criteria. Their purpose was conservative, because they taught people to meet the system’s expectations, not to change it.

18
New cards

5. Explain entailment and why it existed.

If a family had only daughters, the property passed to the closest male relative, not to the daughters and their husbands. The gentry invented it to stop aspiring bourgeois professionals from rising by marrying into it. In P&P, Mr Bennet’s estate is entailed to Mr Collins.

19
New cards


6. What did “accomplished” mean in the Regency, and how does P&P challenge it?

It meant useful and ornamental skills: household management and mathematics, needlework, gardening, and for the truly accomplished woman, music, dancing, drawing and languages to entertain her husband’s guests. In ch. 8, Bingley holds the traditional view, and Darcy adds “improvement of her mind by extensive reading.” The Bennet girls lack typical accomplishments, and Elizabeth’s wit counted against her.

20
New cards

7. How are women both objects and agents of patriarchy in P&P?

Women are commodities in a system of patriarchal exchange. But Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine also embody patriarchy, arranging their daughters’ exchange with the men they choose. So patriarchy is not only men acting on women.

21
New cards


8. What does P&P’s opening line show?

It shows the marriage market’s view of men and women as property. A single man with a fortune “is considered the rightful property of some one or other of their daughters.” The line is ironic about how families treat suitors as goods to be claimed.

22
New cards

B. How does Pride and Prejudice show the commodification of women in the marriage market?

  1. Opening line (ch. 1): a single man in possession of a good fortune is “the rightful property” of a family’s daughter.

  2. Patriarchal exchange: Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine arrange their daughters’ exchange.

  3. Entailment: the estate goes to Collins, which leaves the daughters dependent on good marriages.

  4. Accomplishments (ch. 8): Bingley’s list of skills treats a woman as a social asset, and Darcy’s “extensive reading” pushes back.

  5. Bargaining position: Collins proposes expecting acceptance because Elizabeth’s dowry is small.

  6. Conclusion: the novel shows commodification and critiques it, especially through Elizabeth.


23
New cards

Blazon

it alludes both to a system of patriarchal exchange and to the bourgeois marketplace, with exchange at equal value by aligning male and female blazons. On the surface it essentializes the heroine’s role, so within the commodity market the blazon is the heroine’s truth. But it “stands under erasure” by the rest of the text, which shows it as a partial truth needing revision.

24
New cards

Courtship novel (1740-1820)

it was new because women were not autonomous, free individuals. Daughters were under their father’s authority, which included an arranged settlement negotiated on class and money. It is progressive and feminist, the opposite of the Act’s conservative ideology.

25
New cards

A Serious Proposal (1750)

the pamphlet stresses the advantages of choice for middle-class men and women, a prerogative that patriarchal exchange denied to women of the nobility and gentry.