1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
How does Aristotle define what it is to be morally responsible?
Virtue is concerned with emotions and actions and is only voluntary feelings and actions for which praise and blame are given. To be morally responsible people must act through their own free will. Their actions need to be the rest of their free choices. Therefore if you are forced or ignorant about the significance of what you are doing then you should not be held morally responsible. You also need to be conscience and capable of making the decision
What do libertarians believe?
That humans are free moral agents who have free will. There are some limitations like physical, psychological and social. Free will is a contingent truth as we have a sense of freedom. Many are mind body dualists like Descartes. We may be influenced but they arent determinant as we have a choice
Name a famous libertarian and his view?
Sartre claimes a psychological argument and claimed that there is no objective purpose and nothing else determines our actions because ‘existence precedes essence’ meaning humans exist before they have a defined purpose and so have to subjectively define their purpose for themselves. He thought people feared not having a purpose and this radical freedom led to feelings of abandonment and so its easier to think we have no free will.
A weakness of Sartres argument?
As its a psychological argument he does not provide metaphysical grounds for rejecting determinism and so is arguably committing the genetic fallacy which is assuming the way in which someone comes up with a theory is relevant to whether it is true or false. Just because people have a psychological need to believe in objective purpose that doesnt mean it doesnt exist.
What is sartres counter response?
Sartre could say this is a misunderstanding of his argument and that his starting premise is that there is nothing in our experience which suggests we have a telos or are determined. All we experience is radical freedom not God
What does Humes compatibilism say?
A view that human freedom is compatible with determinism. Redefines the term freedom based on external or internal causes. Sometimes known as soft determinism. Hume says we have a liberty of spontaneity- the ability to do what you desire determined by your personality. We are determined by our personality. Freedom means acting upon these without external restrictions. He says that this gives us the conception of moral responsibility we want.
What is the issues with compatibilism?
People dont like that definition of free will as they want to be the uncaused cause of their actions and have the ability to have done otherwise. Compatibilists argue free will does not exist but they claim to have found a definition of free will that allows for ethics. The distinction between internal and external causes is incoherent as surely internal causes if traced back to before we were born lead to external causes
What is hard determinism?
There is no free will. All events are the necessary consequences of a previous event all the way back to the big bang and because we arent responsible for the big bang we are not responsible for our actions. Spinoza says Free will is an illusion and we cannot claim moral responsibility for our actions because we have not freely chosen them
What is John Lockes argument against the idea that the feeling of free will means it exists
He says its an illusion. Locke says imagine a man who woke up in a room and is unaware that its locked, he chooses to stay in the room. He feels like he made the choice but in reality he didnt have a choice. Locke argues this could be the reality for human action. We are unable to directly perceive all the causes and effects that determined our actions which leaves us with the illusion that we are not determined when we are
How does Quantum mechanics go against determinism and its critique and Honderich s response?
It says that some things happen without a cause therefore determinism is false.
However if our actions happen because of random quantum mechanics that hardly seems better for free will than determinism.
Honderich argues that the structures of the brain might be large enough that the laws of quantum mechanics (which only apply to the small atomic level) might not actually apply to them nor their function. If this is right determinism may not apply at quantum level but may still at macro level.
What is existentialism?
It emphasises the existence of the individual person as a free and responsible agent determining their own development through acts of will. Existentialists believe that existence precedes essence our lives have no inherent purpose. Instead we must discover one for ourselves and this reflects our individuality and freedom.
As an existentialist what does Jean-Paul Sartre say about free will and moral responsibility?
‘ man is condemned to be free because once thrown into the world he is responsible for everything he does’
He says it is up to everyone to create their own existence for which they are then responsible. They cannot not be free there is a form of necessity for freedom
When we become aware of this freedom as an inescapbale given of the human condition it fills us with fear
There is no moral absolute, divine will or natural law that can give us guidance or justify our actions
‘There are no excuses behind us nor justifications before us’
What do religious libertarians say?
That God has given man a gift of freedom but at the same time that Gods foreknowledge knows everything that man will do. He exists in a simultaneous present where he sees all of time all at once
What does kant say about free will and moral responsibility
One of his three postulates is free will. In order for us to have autonomy as moral decision makers we have to assume we possess free will. If we are not free we cannot be held morally responsible for our moral actions
What is moral responsibility?
The idea that a person is responsible for their actions in a moral way such that they deserve praise or blame for them
What are the main main types of theory about why punishment is justified?
Retributive- reward or punishment is justified because someone deserves it. This requires people to be responsible for their actions
Protection from society- reward or punishment is justified because it protects people and society from harmful actions. This doesn require them to he morally responsible. And there are three main ways in which punishment can enable protection of society
What are the three main ways society can be protected through punishment?
Rehabilitation: justified because it helps to improve a persons character to a point where it becomes safe enough for them to be released in society again
Deterrence: justified because motivates people to avoid harmful criminal behaviour
Incapacitation: punishment like prison is justified because it can completely prevent a person harming society