1/46
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Construction Administration
Landscape architect’s responsibilities
• Ensure the project is built as documented.
• DOCUMENT
• Health, safety, and welfare of the public.
• Client gets what client is owed.
• CRITICAL that the LA and owner DO
NOT dictate “means and methods” to contractor.
• “As documented, on budget, on time.
Pick any Two
Good, fast, cheap
Major Considerations
1. Quality of Documentation
2. Quality of Bid
3. Quality of Contractor
4. Experience Level of Client
5. Rapport and Trust in the Process
6. Schedule
Common Challenges
Clients/contractor have expectations for real time responses.
• Contract Document Errors/Omissions will have consequences.
• Any issues (“I don’t know, we will figure that out later....”) that have been avoided will now be addressed.
• Allocation of fee may be low / difficult to project in advance.
• LA cannot be on site at all times
Common Stressors
• Low Construction Budget
• Low Designer Fees
• Contract schedules and payment deadlines
• Client
• Site Discoveries
• Greater Aversion to Risk
• Process of Tradespeople / Available Specializations
• Project Fatigue
Site Preparation
Protection of vegetation
Topsoil removal
erosion and sediment control
clearing and demolition
placement of grade stakes
bulk excavation
back filling and fine grading
finish surfacing
LA responsibilities
• May act as owner’s representative to review and accept completed work
• Review for conformance with contract documents – DO NOT
COMMENT ON MEANS AND METHODS.
• Field visits to observe and document progress
• Field reports should be completed and submitted to owner in a timeline manner
• Contractor’s work is accepted to rejected based on conformance to the contract documents.
Factors Influencing Construction Schedule
Contract Clauses
• Incentive Clause – predetermined award per unit of time paid to a
contractor as an incentive to early completion
• Liquidated Damages – predetermined sum (fixed sum per day)
amount of damages to be paid to owner if contractor fails to
complete work within certain time frame
• “NOT A PENALTY” – sums relative to the cost to owner to keep
project under construction
• Long Lead Times
• Sensitive Items (Planting before Freeze)
• Submittals (Need Design Team Review)
RFI
Correspondence between contractor and design team
• Contractor submits RFI to design team
• Design team issues RFI Response, which may be written text and/or drawing revisions “L-SK”
• L-SKs should be numbered and date with related RFI information noted
RFI may address issues such as:
• Clarification to contract documents
• Direction on how to proceed if unforeseen site conditions come up
• Direction on how to proceed if there are procurement or construction obstacles
L-SK or SK-L (Sketches)
Issued by design team to provide further clarification or to make adjustments in response to newly discovered site conditions
• Abbreviations sometimes vary between firms
• “Landscape Sketch”
• A-SK/SK-A: “Architecture
Sketch”
• C-SK/SK-C: “Civil Sketch”
Submittals – Shop Drawings
Drawings by fabricator – how will the shop build the proposed design elements
• Reviewed by LA / other consultants for conformance with contract documents
(drawings and specifications)
• LA submits comments if needed, shop then needs to revise drawings and resubmit
Submittals- Mock ups
Physical “test” study by fabricator before building all units.
• Mock ups may be required per specifications as part of the construction contract documents.
• Reviewed by LA / consultants / client.
• Important to discuss early with contractor and set up schedule and lead times to use mock ups effectively.
3 Types of Changes
Change order
• Amendment to contract signed by owner and contractor
• Reflects a change in contractor’s scope of work
• Can result from missing information, unknown/unforeseeable site conditions, changes after bids are accepted, errors/omissions
• May change contract documents, usually increase contract price and/or adjusts amount of time it will take to complete work
Construction Change Directive
• Process typically outlined in original construction contract
• May allow for contractor to perform work while negotiating the value of the change order so work can proceed
Minor Change Directive
• No change in contract sum or time frame
• ASI (Architects Supplemental Instruction) may be released as clarification
• Field Change – typically issued by client, LA, or construction manager based on field conditions
Request for Payment
• General Contractor will submit request for payment to owner at intervals throughout the project – money used for suppliers and subcontractors
• LA reviews payment request to confirm that the work that contractor requests to be paid for was completed completely and in conformance with contract documents
Liens
A lien is a legal claim on property that lets someone keep rights to it until a debt is paid. It stays with the property even if it’s sold.
A mechanic’s lien lets workers or suppliers claim the property if they aren’t paid.
A tax lien lets the government claim property for unpaid taxes.
A lien waiver/release shows how much of the debt has been paid.
On public projects, mechanic’s liens are often not allowed—so a stop work notice may be used instead.
In that case, the owner can withhold payment from the general contractor until the issue is resolved.
Project Closeout
• Project Closeout is initiated by contractor issuing written request for owner and owners’
representatives to inspect completed work.
• Contractor’s final payment is linked to final completion/final acceptance by owner.
• Contractor must demonstrate that completed project meets the terms of the agreement
between owner and contractor.
Substantial Completion
Owner may occupy site (Certificate of occupancy issued by the appropriate regulating agency)
• All parties agree to a list of walk that remains
• Certificate of Substantial Completion issued by LA after inspection
• Final periodic payment is made, only retainage remains
• All liens, bonds, operations and maintenance manuals, and warranties are provided to owner as required by contract
As built Drawings
Drawings after construction which
identify changes made to contract
documents during construction
• Survey of completed work –
commonly required for utilities,
detention/retention stormwater
systems
Punch list and final inspection
The punch list is the list of outstanding
items that need to be addressed after
substantial completion – note all
discrepancies, repair needs, cleaning,
deficiencies, etc.
• Final inspection is the final review of
construction to determine if punch list
items have all been addressed and work
is complete.
• After final inspection, certificate for
payment is issued.
• Owner issues final acceptance and final
payment to contractor is made
Warranty
A warranty is a promise that work or materials meet what was agreed in a contract.
Owners may require a maintenance bond (often 1 year, included in performance bonds) to ensure the work holds up.
Guarantee/Warranty: A legally enforceable promise that work or products will perform as expected.
Express warranty: A clearly stated promise (e.g., contractor guarantees materials and workmanship).
Implied warranty: A promise automatically required by law, even if not written in the contract.
Warranty and maintenance
Maintenance requirements are defined in the technical specifications of the contract.
A 1-year maintenance bond is usually included in construction contracts.
Manufacturers often provide warranties for specific systems/equipment.
The contract may add warranties for items not covered (e.g., 1-year plant warranty).
During the warranty period, maintenance may be done by the contractor or a subcontractor.
Design and Documentation Synergies
Design and documentation are practices that depend on one another for quality results.
Poor Design + Poor Documentation = Poorly Executed Work
Good Design + Poor Documentation = Poorly Executed Work
Poor Design + Good Documentation = Poorly Executed Work
Good Design + Good Documentation = Well-Executed Work
Construction Documents
Construction Documents
• The drawings are graphic representations of project as the project is intended to be built.
• Avoid redundancy, conflicts, vagueness, and ambiguous information.
• Project manual is the written, technical representation of project.
• May include general conditions of the roles of parties in a construction agreement and procedures to follow
• Written requirements for specifications - site preparation, materials, equipment, etc.
• Must be technically accurate and adequate, fair and unambiguous requirements, and legally enforceable.
Specifications
Construction Specification Institute (CSI) provides standard format.
• “Drawings show size, form, quantity, relationship, generic type, and graphic representation of
construction materials. The specifications define the qualitative requirements for products, materials and workmanship upon which the construction contract is
based. The specifications also describe administrative procedures regarding both drawings and
specifications.” (CSI)
• “Say it once, in the right location.”
Methods of Specification
Descriptive / Prescriptive
• Describes desired physical properties, appearance, function, and methods of installation
Reference Standard
• Standards set by Industry Consensus
• Product or Material Standard ASTM, ANSI, ACI, AWWA, ASME
• Standards are established and updated by trade associations, professional societies, or
government
• Often incorporated into code requirements
Proprietary
• Proprietary entity is specified – product and materials are described by manufacturer name,
brand/product name, model numbers, etc
“Or equal”
• May be used to permit products which are “equal” to a certain proprietary entity referenced in
the specification
Bidding and negotiation
Landscape architect’s involvement varies
• Develop bidding criteria
• Prepare/issue addenda
• Facilitate meetings
• Evaluate bids and make recommendations
• Evaluate contractor qualifications
• Review/make recommendations with construction contract
Opportunity to set the stag
Types of Bids
Public
• Process is predetermined, strict outline of requirements set by governing agency, with intent of maintaining fairness, transparency, and efficiency
• Prequalifications may be necessary
• Notice must be given to all who are interested and qualified
Private
• Selection process determined by owner
• No defined process
• Negotiations with contractor are possible
• Bid by Invitation is possible – only have to notify select group
• May advertise to encourage competition
Public Bidding Procedures
Open Bidding
• Most common
• RFP is issued to interested vendors who must submit proposals by specified date and time
• Proposals are opened publicly
• Lowest responsive and responsible bidder is typically awarded the contract
Closed Bidding
• More selective than open bidding
• Used with project/contracts of high value
• Government identifies list of pre-qualified bidders who are invited to submit
• Proposals are evaluated on technical factors, and lowest bidder meeting specifications is
typically awarded the contract
Limited Bidding
• Typically used for emergency situations – not common for design/infrastructure work
Two-Stage Bidding
• Prequalification stage establishes “shortlist” of bidders
• Shortlist of bidders submit a final bid
• Method often used for large and complex projects that require innovation solutions
Issues in Pubic bidding
• 1890 Sherman Act – Prohibits agreements among competitors to fix
prices, rig bids, or engage in other anticompetitive activity.
• Antitrust violation of the Sherman Act is a felony.
Bid rigging
• Conspiring competitors raise prices by planning who will submit the winning bid
through agreeing who will bid, proposing inflated bids, or withdrawing bid with
intention to become a subcontractor for a higher bidder.
Collusion
• Suppliers or contractors conspire with government officials to secure the contract
Conflict of Interest
• Officials or persons reviewing bids have a personal/financial interest in the
outcome of the bid process.
Bid Protest
• Bidder challenges the outcome, alleging that process was biased.
Bid alternates
Bid alternates are optional parts of a project priced separately to help control costs.
Add alternates: extra items included only if the base bid is affordable.
Deduct alternates: items in the base bid that can be removed if costs are too high (less preferred).
Used to manage budgets, especially in public or grant-funded projects.
Must be clearly defined and stand alone.
Often used for “wish list” upgrades (e.g., better finishes).
Should be used sparingly, since too many can complicate bidding.
Bidding process
Bidding Process
1. Advertisement
2. Instructions to Bidders
3. Bidding Period
4. Pre-Bid Conference
5. Addenda / Pre-Bid RFIs
6. Bid Opening
7. Notice of Award / Notice to Proceed
Bonds
A surety bond is a guarantee that the contractor will fulfill the terms
of the agreement.
• Bid Bond provides assurance that contractor will enter into a binding contract and provide payment and performance bonds if the contract is
rewarded to this contractor.
• Payment Bond protects owner from liens if the prime contractor does not pay subcontractors and/or suppliers.
• Performance Bond assures that financially responsible party will stand behind prime contractor if job is not performed properly, typically up to 100% of contract price.
Mechanics Lien
If a supplier or subcontractor is unpaid, they can file a lien against the property.
Full Price Lien – secures the total amount of work provided by
claimant
Unpaid Balance Lien – secures the amount that property owner has
not already paid to general contractor
Evaluating bids
LA may be part of the process to review bids to
check for mistakes, missing information or requirements, collusion, or outliers
• Public bidding process -> Lowest bid that meets pre-established public bidding process criteria
• Notice of Award/Notice to Proceed sent to selected bidder
Rough order of magnitude
Early cost estimates may be produced in
planning / concept phases to get an understanding of budget
• Rough Order of Magnitude (ROM)
• Initial estimate, with expected accuracy of -25%
to +75% (PMBOK)
• May calculate upper and lower bounds of cost based on industry knowledge
• Actual costs may be 75%-175% of ROM estimate
• Used in earlier project stages, limited accuracy
due to limited availability of knowledge and resources
Cost alternatives
Depending on knowledge of client budget/availability of
funds, LA may develop “cost options” for client review.
• Client may be fundraising, or want to have several options.
• Often developed in schematic design.
• Cost saving strategies may include:
• Considering “add-alternates” that compliment the base design
• Recommendations for alternate materials
• Recommending phased strategies for later additions
• Recommendations for “in house” labor and materials – for instance,
a botanic garden or arboretum that grows and installs its own plant
material
value engineering
f project construction estimates are
too high, the entire project may go
through value engineering
• Scope may be removed, or materials
are drastically simplified
• Not always good to design for lowest
cost upfront – if LA starts low and
other consultants are high, they may
pressure LA to cut more (past the
point of desirability or practicality)
Finanicng options
Financing Options
Equity vs debt. Debt means you won money back under the terms of the agreement, which may include a timeline and fees. Equity means the people giving you the financing have part
Bank Loan: borrowed money repaid with interest
Best for businesses with steady revenue potential
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Angel Investor: Wealthy individual invests in exchange for activity
Best for: Early stage startups needing guidance
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Venture capital: Professional investors funding high growth companies
Best for: Scalable tech or high growth startups
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Crowdfunding: Many small contributions from the public (kickstarter, Indiegogo)
Best for: consumer products with Visual appeal
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Bootstrapping: Self funding, using personal savings or revenue
Best for: low cost or service base businesses
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Small business grants: free funding from government or organizations
Best for: mission driven or innovative businesses
Pros | Cons |
|
|
Phases of firm financing
start up financing
maintenance financing
continuation financing
common debt instruments
lines of credit
commercial loans
leasing
government blacked loan