1/23
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Defense of Others: Rule (Common Law)
[Specific to defense of others]
Given the circumstances, D must subjectively and reasonably believe the third party could lawfully act in self defense
D’s intervention is necessary to protect that person.
[Classic self-defense component]
a) the third party is not the aggressor;
b) force is necessary
c) the force is proportional
Defense of Others: Mistaken Belief Rule (Common Law)
Mistaken belief
a. Majority: a reasonable but mistaken belief still counts.
b. Minority (borrow from alter-ego/other-self): Ignores mistake. if the third party couldn’t claim self-defense, D can’t either.
Defense of Others: RULE (MPC)
If D himself faced the same threat, would D be justified in using this force? Would D be justified in using the force under the classic self defense analysis? (put D in the victim’s shoes).
Is the force justified for the person who’s actually being protected? Under the circumstances as D believes them, would the person protected be justified in using the force under the classic self defense elements? (e.g., the movie rehearsal hypo).
D believes intervention is necessary
(no objective test)
Defense of Others: Mistaken Belief Rule (MPC)
Still justified if mistake was honest.
How is the Objective prong of D’s reasonable belief tested for Defense of Others? (Preamble, Common Law)
What would a person of ordinary intelligence and prudence have believed in the defendant’s position?
State v. Giminski
On July 30, 1999, U.S. Secret Service agents came to John Giminski’s home to seize two vehicles under a search warrant.
His daughter Elva tried to drive away in one. An agent pursued and collided with her car, and Giminski’s other daughter screamed that an agent had a gun to Elva’s head.
Giminski got a handgun, pointed it at Agent Hirt, and demanded he get away from her. In a struggle the gun fired several times, wounding both.
Did Giminski commit homicide or defense of others?
Homicide.
Even assuming he honestly believed Elva was in danger (subjective element met), his belief was objectively unreasonable: he knew the agents were lawfully executing a warrant, that Elva was interfering, and that Hirt could lawfully stop her (it was broad daylight in a residential neighborhood).
Defense of Personal Property: Rule
Deadly force to protect mere personal property (a car, computer, or expensive thermos) is per se unreasonable and disproportionate, whatever its monetary or sentimental value.
Exceptions:
1) items tied to human life (e.g., an oxygen tank in use or epipen); 2) high-level military or nuclear assets.
A mugger grabs a mother’s purse holding her severely allergic daughter’s EpiPen, and she stabs him, admitting she feared only losing the purse.
Defense of others or valid defense of property?
Deadly force is not justified to protect property alone.
Defense of others. Turns on whether losing the EpiPen created an imminent lethal threat to the daughter (time of day, location, how fast a replacement could be had, history of going out without it).
Defense of Habitation, an Alternative to the Castle Doctrine: Rule
The home is a place where a person may 1) stand his ground, 2) repel intruders, and 3) deny entry.
The homeowner may use lethal force when he reasonably believes:
a VIOLENT felony in the home against the occupants is immediately at hand (e.g. kidnaping, assault) (some jurisdictions don’t require “violent”)
lethal force is necessary to prevent it, using means no greater than a normally prudent person would find necessary (applies whether the intruder dies or survives; e.g., shooting someone is lethal force even if he lives).
Does Defense of Habitation apply if the homeowner and suspect are not in the home?
No. If both the owner and the threat are outside, the rule does not apply
(though counsel may argue an owner on the porch or threshold is within the curtilage).
Is trespass a felony under the Defense of Habitation rule?
No
The home intruder is retreating (back turned, heading for the exit). The homeowner uses force against the home intruder.
Did the homeowner act reasonably?
No, the homeowner did not act reasonably as the intruder was retreating and posed no immediate threat.
The rivalry: Boyett and Rhodes had a long-running feud because both were romantically interested in the same woman, Renate Wilder.
The engagement: after a long courtship, Boyett and Wilder planned to marry on February 6, 2004.
The breakup: a few days before the wedding, Wilder left Boyett and went to stay with Rhodes, his rival.
The visit: on February 5, the day before the planned wedding, Rhodes came to Boyett’s home.
The banging: Boyett said he heard loud banging at the front door. He grabbed his gun before answering.
The door opens: he opened the door and found a furious Rhodes outside.
The shooting: Boyett said he shouted at her to leave, then saw her reach for a gun she routinely carried. In fear for his life, he shot her in the head from about four feet away.
The key detail: after knocking, Rhodes had stepped back about four feet and was waiting for the door to open. She wasn’t trying to break in or force her way inside.
At trial: Boyett asked for a jury instruction on defense of habitation.
Does the Defense of Habitation rule apply?
No.
The defense can apply to an intruder outside the home who is trying by violence to enter to commit a violent felony against the occupants. But Rhodes wasn’t trying to force entry—she actually stepped back.
What is the Concept behind Necessity?
The state permits a crime because it produces a greater good, saving lives or property (breaking into a home to flee a tornado; setting a firebreak against a forest fire).
Rationale: promoting higher values at the expense of lesser ones.
Necessity: Elements (Nelson)
Standard for all elements: judged by a reasonable person in D’s position (except element 2), on the facts as D reasonably perceived them (reasonable mistakes OK; D’s personal values don’t control). Elements:
SS-ONP
Significant Evil: D acted to prevent a significant evil:
Subjective: D actually believed a significant evil existed; and
Objective: a reasonable person would believe a significant evil existed.
No adequate alternative: a reasonable person would see no adequate legal alternative.
Proportionality: a reasonable person would find the harm caused not disproportionate to the harm avoided (measured by the reasonably foreseeable harm, not what actually happened).
Necessity: Common Law Limits
The evil must come from natural forces (not human threats)
Defendant caused the threat (e.g. he started the forest fire). He is now claiming necessity after breaking into Victim’s home. Is his Necessity defense valid?
Many jurisdictions will deny this defense.
Nelson v. State (Alaska 1979):
Shortly after midnight on May 22, 1976, Dale Nelson’s truck got stuck in a marsh off an Alaska highway. After about an hour of trying, and hours waiting at a fenced Highway Department yard posted “no trespassing,” he and his companions took a dump truck to pull it out; when that got stuck, they took a front-end loader, damaging both. A department employee made a citizen’s arrest.
Is a necessity defense valid?
No. Here’s why:
The “emergency” (fear the truck would tip) was not dire, since it had been stuck for hours and a companion later slept in it
people had stopped and offered help, rides, or to call a tow truck; and
possible roof damage was not greater than the harm of taking restricted heavy equipment, as the statutory penalties showed.
Duress: Concept
An excuse. Defendant met every element of the crime, acted voluntarily, but only because an external force compelled him.
Duress: Elements
Threat: another person threatened (directly, explicitly, or implicitly) to kill or grievously injure D or a third party unless D committed a crime. The crime D is forced to commit can be any crime (e.g., smuggling drugs), except murder in most states.
Belief: D reasonably believed the threat was genuine (not fanciful or a joke) (subjective prong and objective/reasonable person in D’s position prong)
Timing: the threat was present, imminent, and impending at the time of the crime, even if it was made days or months earlier
No escape: there was no reasonable escape except compliance
No fault: she was not at fault in exposing herself to the threat (NOT part of the federal test from Contento)
What does “Present” mean in Duress? (Element 3)
The coercer’s physical proximity
D goes to an illegal drug dealer to buy drugs. The drug dealer says to D, "Become my partner in crime or I will kill you." Because of the threat, D becomes his partner in crime. Can D raise the duress defense?
No, because he exposed himself to the drug dealer
Can Duress be used as a defense to murder? (e.g. D says, “I killed V because Mr. A said “Kill V or I will kill you.”
No, in most jurisdictions, duress cannot be used as a defense to murder. “Sacrificing an innocent person to save oneself or a loved one is not a fair trade.” - Maurer
United States v. Contento-Pachon:
Juan, a Bogotá taxi driver, refused a passenger (“Jorge”) who proposed that he swallow cocaine balloons and carry them to the United States.
Jorge then recited private details about his life and threatened to kill his wife and three-year-old child, and said he would be watched throughout the trip.
Believing the Bogotá police were corrupt and paid off by traffickers, he did not report it. He swallowed 129 balloons and flew to Los Angeles, where customs X-rays found them.
Does Juan have a valid Duress defense?
Yes.
threats from a trafficker who knew his family’s details were immediate, not vague or future, and being watched kept the coercion going.
whether reporting to corrupt police or fleeing Colombia with his family was a reasonable escape was a jury question