1/38
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Canter et al. (2004) organised offenders
data from 100 US murders committed by different serial killers were examined using smallest space analysis
Analysis revealed there is a set of behaviours that co-occur in serial killings, which matched the typology for organised offenders
Meketa (2017) typology application to burglary
Typology profiling to burglaries led to an 85% rise in solved cases in 3 US states
Canter & Heritage (1990) characteristic patterns
data from 66 sexual assault cases was examined using smallest space analysis
Several behaviours were identified as common, such as impersonal language, lack of reaction to victim
Each individual displayed a characteristic pattern of behaviours which could be used to link cases
Evidence supports principles of investigative psychology, that people are consistent in their behaviour
Lundrigan & Canter (2001) centre of gravity
Data from 120 murder cases involving US serial killers was examined by smallest space analysis
Found spatial consistency in killers behaviour, locations of body disposal created a ‘centre of gravity’
Effect was more noticeable for marauders than commuters
Amnesty International UK (2025) institutional racism
report by Amnesty International UK found that data-driven profiling disproportionately targets black and ethnic minority groups leading to racial bias
The algorithms rely on historical data that reflects the structural and institutional racism and discrimination in policing over the years e.g. stop-and-search arrests
Copson (1995) accuracy?
surveyed 48 police departments and found advice from a profiler was judges as useful in 83% of cases
But only in 3% of cases did it lead to accurate identification of the offender
Case of Rachel Nickell’s murder (1992) misleading
in 1992, Rachel Nickell (21) was sexually assaulted and murdered, with her son (2) as the only witness
With the help of an offender profiler the police targeted a local man who often walked his dog where Rachel was attacked
The police launched a long and expensive operation to try catch him
In 2008 with new forensic evidence another man was convicted of Rachel’s murder and was ruled out of the earlier investigation because he was a few inches taller than the profile
Kocsis et al. (2002) chemistry students
Found that chemistry students produced more accurate offending profiles on a solved murder case than experienced senior detectives
Christiansen (1977) Danish twin study
studied 3500 twin pairs in Denmark
Concordance rates for offending behaviour was 35% for MZ twins (male) and 13% for DZ twins (male)
Women had slightly lower rates
Crowe (1972) adoption study
adopted children with biological mothers with a criminal record had a 50% risk of having a criminal record by 18
adopted children with biological mothers without a criminal record had a 5% risk of having a criminal record by 18
Tiihonen et al. (2015) candidate genes
conducted a genetic analysis of around 800 Finnish offenders
Suggests MAOA and CDH13 may be associated with violent crime
5-10% of all severe violent crimes in Finland are attributed to the MAOA and CDH13 genotypes
Raine et al. (2000) grey matter
Found an 11% reduction in the volume of grey matter in the prefrontal cortex of people with APD compared to controls
Keysers et al. (2011) mirror neurons
found only when offenders were asked to empathise with a person depicted on film experiencing pain did their empathy reaction controlled by mirror neurons in the brain activate
Mednick et al. (1984) Danish adoptees
studied over 14,000 Danish adoptees With at least 1 court conviction
13.5% of adoptees with neither biological nor adoptive parents with convictions, had convictions
20% of adoptees with biological patents with convictions had convictions
24.5% of adoptees with both biological and adoptive parents with convictions had convictions
Kandel & Freed (1989) frontal lobe damage
reviewed evidence of frontal lobe damage (including the prefrontal cortex) and antisocial behaviour, the frontal lobe is associated with planning behaviour
People with such damage tended to show impulsive behaviour, emotional instability, and an inability to learn from their mistakes
Farrington et al. (2006) childhood trauma
studied a group of men with high APD scores
Found they’d experienced various risk factors during childhood like:
Raised by a convicted parents
Physically neglected
Possibly these early childhood experiences cause APD or other neural differences
So the relationship between neural differences, APD and offending behaviour is complex
Eysenck & Eysenck (1977) EPQ scores
compared 2070 prisoners’ EPQ scores with 2422 controls (all men)
For all age groups prisoners recorded higher in extraversion, neuroticism, and psychoticism
Farrington et al. (1982) only psychoticism
meta-analysis
Found offenders only tended to score high in psychoticism
Küssner (2017) cortical arousal
couldn’t find differences in EEG (to measure cortical arousal) between introverts and extraverts
Kohlberg et al. (1975) Just community
set up a residential community for women with custodial sentences
They lived in a small cottage where staff and residents would make rules, decision, and settle conflicts democratically
After 2 years only 16% had returned to prison (typical reoffending rate 40%)
Scönenberg & Juyste (2014) facial expressions
presented 55 violent offenders and a control group with emotionally ambiguous facial expressions
Offender group was significantly more likely to perceive the images as angry / hostile
Dodge & Frame (1982) ‘aggressive’ children
showed ‘aggressive’ and ‘non-aggressive’ children a video clip of an ambiguous provocation
The ‘aggressive’ children interpreted the situation as more hostile
Barbaree (1991) rapists
among 26 incarcerated rapists:
54% denied committing an offence
40% minimised the harm they’d caused the victim
Palmer & Hollin (1998) dilemmas
compared moral reasoning in 332 non-offenders with 126 convicted offenders using the sociomoral reflection measure short form (SRM-SF), containing moral dilemmas
Offender group showed less mature moral reasoning than the non-offender group
Chen & Howitt (2007) different crimes
examined male offenders from youth correctional institutions in Taiwan and controls (non-offender high schoolers)
Kohlberg model was good at distinguishing offenders from non-offenders
Model was less effective for differentiating among offender types e.g. drugs, violence
Harkins et al. (2010) reoffending
Suggests that reduced incidence of denial and minimalisation in therapy is highly associated with a reduced risk of reoffending
Howitt & Sheldon (2007) sex offenders
examined questionnaire responses from sexual offenders
Non-contact sexual offenders used more cognitive distortions than contact sez offenders
Individuals with an offending history were more likely to use distortions as a justification
Farrington et al (2006) London boys
longitudinal survey of offending and antisocial behaviour in 411 boys, monitored from 8-50
Boys were from deprived inner-city areas in London
41% were convicted of at least 1 offence between 10-50
Average conviction career was from 19-28 with 5 convictions
Biggest childhood risk factors were: family criminality, low school attainment, daring, poverty, poor parenting
7% were chronic offenders (accounted for half of recorded offences)
Shirley (2019) college programmes
offenders who took part in a college education programme were 43% less likely to reoffend following release
Prisons who offered these programmes report fewer violent incidents
Ministry of Justice (2025) suicide rates
in England and Wales in 1 year 96 offenders committed suicide in prison custody
Most at risk were young single men in their first 24 hours of confinement
That rate is 10x more of the general population
Prison Reform Trust (2014) psychosis
25% of women and 15% of men reported symptoms of psychosis
HOWEVER, the figures don’t include the number of inmates who were already experiencing psychotics symptoms before incarceration
Ministry of Justice (2016) cost of recidivism
reports suggest the economic and social costs of reoffending on 2017 be adult ex-prisoners in England and Wales was around £16.7 billion
Factors that cause this price are repeated imprisonment, court proceedings etc
Hobbs & Holt (1976) token economy
introduced a token economy programme to young offenders
Observed a significant increase in positive behaviour compared to control group
Field et al. (2004) individualised programmes
found token economies used with young people with behavioural problems were generally effective
Found better results if people who didn’t respond to the programme initially were put into a special programme where rewards are more immediate and frequent
Bassett & Blanchard (1977) inconsistency
found any benefits from a token economy were lost if staff applied techniques inconsistently
Inconsistency was mainly due to high staff turnover and lack of appropriate staff training
Elbers et al. (2022) ethical?
conducted a systematic review of 21 studies on behaviour modification in prisons
Found using family contact as a reward had an overall positive effect on incarcerated individuals achieving target behaviours
Some suggest that family contact is a right not a privilege to be earned or taken away, especially when family contact plays a role in reducing recidivism and maintains mental health
Meena (2024) valid indicator?
conducted an extensive review of studies investigating the effectiveness of anger management
Saw most studies used reoffending rates as a measure of efficacy
Which may not be a valid indicator of reduced anger because anger isn’t the sole motivation why offenders re-offend
Inmates may reoffend outside the time frame of studies or not get caught
Keen et al. (2000) CALM
studied the progress of young offenders during an anger management course (CALM)
Faced initial problems with offenders not taking the course seriously
Final outcomes were generally positive and offenders reported increased awareness of their anger management difficulties and an increased capacity to exercise self-control
Henwood et al. (2015) anger management effectiveness
conducted a meta-analysis to find the effectiveness of anger management at reducing recidivism among adult male offenders
Compared adult male offenders who completed the course with those who dropped out
Effect size of treatment completion on general recidivism was 0.58, indicating a 42% risk reduction compared to attrition group
Effect size of treatment completion on violent recidivism was 0.44, indicating a 56% risk reduction compared to attrition group