1/28
Looks like no tags are added yet.
vicarious liability
an employer may be vicariously liable for torts of an employee committed within the scope of of employment
Ordinarily an employer is not liable for intentional torts committed by an employee because those torts are typically outside the scope of employment
But an employer may be vicariously liable for an employees intentional tort if that intentional tort arose out of the nature of the employees work
Employer Liability - Direct Negligence
In some cases an employer may be liable (directly themselves) for reasons such as
1. Negligent hiring, Training , And/or supervision of employees; or
2. Unreasonable management choices in operations
Intent for intentional torts
person acts with intent to produce consequences if:
person has purpose of producing that consequence ; or
person knows with a substantial certainty, consequences will ensue from persons conduct
Battery (Dual Intent)
intend
contact with another; and
intend that contact to be harmful or offensive; and
contact results in harmful or offensive touching
Battery (Single Intent)
intend
contact with another ; and
contact results in harmful or offensive touching
Assault
an overt act which is intended to and does, in fact, put another in reasonable apprehension of imminent harmful or offensive contact
Intentional Infliction of Emotional DIstress
Intentional or reckless; extreme and outrageous conduct; which is intended to and, in fact causes; severe emotional distress
False Imprisonment
willful detention preformed without consent and without authority of law
Trespass to Chattels
intentional
use or intermeddling with temporary dispossession of chattel of another
such that defendant is liable damage or harm to chattel
Conversion
intentional
exercise or dominion or control over a chattel
which so seriously interferes with chattel owners right
that defendant is liable for full value of chattel
Trespass to land
intent to enter; and
tangible intrusion on the property in posession of another
Affirmative defense - Consent
express; or implied (apparent) words and/or conduct by plaintiff reasonably understood by another to be intended as consent (or emergency)
Consent is ineffective if
consenting person lacks capacity
- capacity is substantial impaired by abnormality (infancy) ; and
-defendant knows; or has reason to know of impairment of consenting person
consent is given under duress
-constraints which clearly and immediately overpower are sufficient
consent is based on fraud or mistake
consent exceeds the scope of consent
Self Defense
where a person reasonably believes themseleves to be
threatened with immediate bodily harm
that person may use whatever force appears reasonably necessary to protect v. threatened injury
factors in assessing self defense
relative size, age, and strength of parties
parties reputations for violence
who was the initial aggressor
degree o harm reasonably feared (deadly force or extreme bodily harm)
presence or absence of weapons
Self defense retreat rules for non deadly force
a person who has established grounds for self defense in tort law has no duty to retreat before using NON DEADLY force
Regardless of whwther that person is inside or outside the home
Self Defense- Deadly force
use of deadly force outside ones home in self defense in accordance with tort law is subject to the following rules
- common law/ traditional rule
- duty to retreat if can do so safley before using deadly force
-Stand your ground laws
- no duty to retreat even if can do so safely
Defense of others 1st approach
person may use reasonable force; if
actually necessary
to defend another person facing immediate harm
defense of others 2nd approach
person may use reasonable force if
it appeared necessary to reasonable person (even if mistaken)
to defend another of immediate harm
Defense of Property
may use reasonable force to prevent tort against property
--may not use deadly force to prevent tort against property
Castle Doctorine
May not be invoked on the defense of property
- it may only be invoked to justify force used to defend people in a home.
If people are at home à castle doctrine applies deadly force to defend yourself or other people in the home without retreat is permitted
2. If you and/or others are threatened with deadly force
a. If no one is home à deadly force v. intruders is not permitted
Defense of Private Necessity
a person is privileged to enter land in possession of another (or to use property belonging to another) • if it is, or reasonably appears to be • necessary to prevent serious harm to the actor or their property • but defendant must pay compensatory damages for any harm to property caused by the trespass
Private Necessity details
defense of private necessity eliminates potential liability for punitive damages or nominal damages
-- but no compensatory damages
defense of private necessity destroys a landowners immunity from potential liability for harm that landowner cause by resisting anothers trespass to land
Doctrine of Transferred Intent
the doctrine of Transferred Intent takes an actor's intent from planned conduct/ goal and allows it to be used for liability for tge tort the actor in fact committed
same tort v. different person
different v. same person
different v. different
Additional Details for False Imprisonment
detention restraint or confinement in a limited area
-- no reasonable means of escape
-=-- force not required words alone may be sufficient to detain
- only a breif time required
- traditional rule requires knowledge of detention by plaintiff or more than nominal harm to plaintiff (if unaware of dention)
Factors in distinguishing trespass to chattels v. conversion
- extent and duration of interference actors exercised of dominion or control
- actors good faith
-actors intent to assert a right inconsistent with others rights of control
- extent and duration of resulting interference with others rights of control
harm done to chattel
inconvience an expense to chattel owner
- actors intent to assert a right incosistent with others rights of control
Dobbs factors to aid in determing extreme and outrageous conduct
-abuse of a position of power
ex. teacher student ; boss employee
-targeting plaintiffs vulnerbailties
- race, sexual orientation, general, mental health condtion etc.
- special concern for captive audience
ex. comments from another in the work place
reptition
violence or threats of violence
Additional Details for battery
- actor need not have intended precise harm or offensive
- offensive- to a reasonable person ( reasonable sense of personal dignity)
- voluntary action by defendant causing contact required
- indirect contact sufficient
Shop Keepers Privilege - defense to false imprisonment
• when person reasonably believes another has stolen or is attempting to steal property
• person has legal justification to detain other
• in reasonable manner and
• for reasonable time to investigate ownership of property