1/39
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is an fMRI scan?
An fMRI scan measures the changes in blood flow that occur as a result of neural activity in specific parts of the brain after participants are given a cognitive task to perform
How does an fMRI work?
participants are given a cognitive task
when an area of the brain is active, it consumes more oxygen
the brain responds to this by increasing blood flow to the active area - delivers oxygen via haemoglobin in red blood cells (haemodynamic activity) - and this indicates on the fMRI that there is neural activity
Strengths of fMRI scans x4
Non-invasive - Unlike many other scanning techniques, it is non-invasive and does not use potentially harmful radiation so is virtually risk-free for the patient
Very high spatial resolution - It shows detail by the millimetre and so is capable of producing a very clear image of how brain activity is localised
More objective - it offers a more objective and reliable measure of psychological processes than what is possible with verbal reports. It is useful as a way of investigating psychological phenomena that people would not be capable of providing in verbal reports
Measures deep subcortical regions - measures deep subcortical regions of the brain, such as the hippocampus and amygdala
Limitations of fMRI scans x2
poor temporal resolution - they have poor temporal resolution as there is about a 1 second time lag between the firing of a neuron and the image on the screen. Also, for a clear picture to be produced, the patient must keep perfectly still
Expensive - they are expensive compared to other neuroimaging techniques as fMRI machines are very costly to buy and maintain, and require specially trained operators
What is an EEG?
an EEG measures electrical activity in the brain to identify abnormalities in brain waves, which would indicate a mental disorder
How do EEGs work?
electrodes are placed on the scalp using skull caps
These detect and record electrical changes in the brain resulting from activity in the brain cells
These signals are graphed over a period of time - the 4 basic patterns are alpha waves, beta waves, delta waves and theta waves
They are often used to detect various types of brain disorders such as Alzheimer’s and epilepsy (patients with epilepsy show spikes of electrical activity)
Strengths of EEG scans x2
high temporal resolution - unlike fMRIs, they have extremely high temporal validity as today’s technology can detect brain activity at a resolution of a single millisecond, meaning it can record brain activity in real time rather than a still image of a passive brain. This means the researcher can accurately measure a particular task with the brain activity associated with it
Uses in clinical diagnosis - EEGs have been incredibly useful for clinical diagnosis e.g. for epilepsy. Epileptic seizures are caused by abnormal firing of neurons in the brain and this can be easily detected by the EEG
Limitations of EEGs x2
Can’t measure deep subcortical regions - It records the activity of the entire surface of the brain. This makes it very difficult to pinpoint the exact source of neural activity. EEGs can also only detect activity in the superficial areas of the brain, therefore it cannot reveal what is going on in deeper regions of the brain e.g. the hypothalamus
Skullcaps are uncomfortable - it can be argued that the skullcaps are uncomfortable for participants as the electrodes are attached to the head. This could lead to unrepresentative readings as the discomfort could be affecting cognitive responses to situations
What is an ERP?
An ERP uses the same equipment as an EEG but measures very small voltage changes in the brain that are triggered by specific stimuli or events
How does an ERP work?
ERPs work by the participant being presented with a cognitive task/stimulus many times
the numerous responses are averaged together
an neural activity that is not related to the stimuli will not occur consistently, whereas activity linked to the stimuli will and so the extraneous brain activity from the readings can be filtered out, leaving only the ones that relate to the task
sensory ERPs occur within the first 100 milliseconds after the presentation of the stimulus and show an initial response to its physical characteristics
Cognitive ERPs are generated after the first 100 milliseconds and reflect the subject’s evaluation of the stimulus - show information processing
Strengths of ERPs x2
Provide a specific measurement - Bring a much more specific measurement than could ever be achieved using raw EEG data. This is because they provide a continuous measurement of processing in response to a particular stimulus, meaning researchers can determine how processing is affected by a specific experimental manipulation e.g. during the presentation of different visual stimuli
Excellent temporal resolution - as they are derived from EEGs, they have excellent temporal resolution, especially when compared to neuroimaging techniques such as fMRIs, which has led to their widespread use
Limitations of ERPs x3
Hard to establish cause and effect - critics have pointed out a lack of standardisation in methodology in different ERP studies, which makes it difficult to establish a cause and effect relationship
Extraneous variables - in order to establish pure data in ERP studies, background noise and extraneous material must be completely eliminated, which is not always easy to do
Only strong voltage changes are recordable - only sufficiently strong voltage changes across the scalp are recorded. Important electrical activity occurring deep in the brain are not recorded, meaning that the generation of ERPs tend to be restricted to the neocortex.
What is a Post-Mortem exam?
when a persons body, including the brain, is examined after they have died and are used to establish the underlying neurobiology of a particular behaviour
Who are usually subject to Post Mortem exams?
likely to be those who have experienced unusual behaviours or a rare disorder during their lifetime
it is used to find any areas of damage as a way of establishing a likely cause
Strengths of Post Mortem exams x2
allow for examination of deep subcortical regions as it is invasive - they allow for more detailed examination of an atomically and neurochemical aspects of the brain than would be possible with the sole use of non-invasive scanning techniques e.g. fMRI and EEG. They allow researchers to examine deeper regions of the brain such as the hypothalamus
Understanding Schizophrenia - they have played a central role in our understanding of schizophrenia. For example, as a result of PME, researchers have found evidence of structural abnormalities of the brain associated with this disorder
Limitations of Post Mortem exams x3
A problem is that the post-mortem brain may have been affected or changed by the reason for death e.g. illness
ethical issues - it raises the ethical issue of consent from the patient before death. Patients may not be able to provide informed consent e.g. in the case of HM who was unable to consent but still had post-mortem research conducted on his brain
Retrospective - they are retrospective as the person is already dead. As a result, the researcher is unable to follow up on anything that arises from the exam concerning a possible relationship between brain abnormalities and cognitive functioning
What is localisation of function in the brain?
The theory that different parts of the brain are responsible for different behaviours, processes or activities
What does contralateral wiring mean?
The left hemisphere controls the right side of the brain, and vice versa
this is because the optic nerve crosses over near the optic chiasm
What is the motor cortex, where is it found and what is a way to remember it?
responsible for creating voluntary movements
located in frontal lobe of both hemispheres - left hemispherical motor cortex controls right side of body and vice versa
Motor function is highly localised as different parts of the motor cortex control different parts of the body
Way to remember - Mo Farah = Motor cortex, Frontal lobe
What is the somatosensory cortex, where is it found and what is a way of remembering it?
relates to sensations of the body - uses sensory info from the skin to produce sensations of touch, pressure, pain and temperature
located in the parietal lobe of both hemispheres, next to the motor cortex
the amount of somatosensory cortex devoted to each body part is determined by how touch sensitive the area is e.g. receptors on our face and hands make up over half of the somatosensory cortex - is shown via the Homunculus diagram
Way to remember - Sean Paul = somatosensory cortex, Parietal lobe
What are the visual centres of the brain, where are they found and what is a way of remembering them?
main visual centre is located in the occipital lobe
contains several different areas with each processing different types of visual information e.g. colour, shape, movement
each eye sends visual information via the optic nerve to the opposite hemisphere e.g. left visual cortex = right hemisphere. This means that damage to the left hemisphere can cause blindness in part of the right visual field of both eyes
way of remembering - Vera Ora = Visual centres, Occipital lobe
What are the auditory centres, where are they found and what is a way of remembering them?
concerned with hearing and auditory information
mostly in the temporal lobe where the auditory cortex is located
the auditory pathway begins in the cochlea in the inner ear where sound waves are converted to nerve impulses. These travel via the auditory nerve to the auditory cortex in the temporal lobe where it is recognised and may result in an appropriate response
way of remembering - Andrea Turner = Auditory centre, temporal lobe
What are the 2 language centres called and where are they localised/lateralised?
Broca’s area and Wernicke’s area
localised and lateralised to the left hemisphere
What is Broca’s area, where is it found, what is the result of damage to it and what is a way of remembering it?
Named after Paul Broca in the 1880s
responsible for language production
found in the LEFT frontal lobe
Damage can cause Broca’s aphasia - speech that is slow, laborious (requires effort) and lacking in fluency
way of remembering - Big Foot = Broca’s area, Frontal lobe
What case study provided evidence for the Broca’s area?
Case study of ‘Tan’ by Broca
named ‘Tan’ as it was the only word he could say
could fully understand language but not produce it
Broca conducted a post-mortem exam on Tan’s brain and discovered a lesion in Tan’s left frontal lobe
He later discovered similar lesions in several other patients with similar speech problems
What is Wernicke’s area, where is it found, what is the result of damage to it and what is a way of remembering it?
discovered by Carl Wernicke
responsible for language comprehension
located in the LEFT temporal lobe
he reported patients had no problem producing language but severe difficulty understanding it, so the speech they produced was meaningless
damage would cause Wernicke’s aphasia - producing nonsense as part of their speech
way of remembering - Winnie The (pooh) = Wernicke’s area, Temporal lobe
Strength of research into localisation of function - Brain scan evidence
There is a huge amount of evidence from brain scans that support the idea that many brain functions are localised, particularly in relation to language and memory
For example, Peterson et al (1988) used fMRI scans to demonstrate how Wernicke’s area was activated during a listening task and Broca’s area was active during a speaking task
Also, a review of long term memory by Buckner and Peterson (1996) found that evidence regarding the localisation of semantic and episodic memories and concluded that the left pre-frontal cortex was involved in semantic memories, whereas episodic memories are found on the right pre-frontal cortex
Procedural memory, on the other hand, is associated with the cerebellum
These sophisticated and objective methods for measuring activity in the brain provide scientific evidence of localisation of function
Limitation of research into localisation of function - language production may not be confined to Broca’s area
one problem is that lesions often affect several brain areas
For example, Dronkers et al (2007) examined the preserved brains of 2 of Broca’s patients using MRIs, and found other areas were damaged too
In fact, lesions that only affect Broca’s area generally only result in temporary speech disruptions
This suggests that language involves networks of brain regions, not just a few specific areas
Strength of research into localisation of function - neurosurgical evidence
Early attempts at lobotomies were brutal and imprecise. However, controversially they are still used rarely in extreme cases of OCD and depression, and they provide evidence for localisation
For example, Dougherty (2002) reported on 44 OCD patients who had a procedure to create lesions on the cingulotomy gyrus in their brain
At post-surgical follow ups after 32 weeks, 1/3 had mental
criteria for successful response to the surgery, and 14% with partial response
This suggests strong evidence that symptoms associated with mental disorders are localised to different parts of the brain
Strength of research into localisation of function - Phineas Gage
in 1848, Phineas Gage was working on the development of a new railway line and was preparing to use a tampering iron to blast a rock
Gage dropped the iron onto a rock, creating a spark that ignited the explosives
The rod was propelled through his left cheek bone and entered his skull, exiting through the frontal lobe
Despite his injury, Gage made a good recovery, but his injury had a permanent impact on his mental condition - he was reported to have turned from a calm and reserved man into being quick tempered, rude and ‘no longer Gage’
Gage’s injuries provide some of the first evidence that personality and behaviour are localised to the frontal cortex
Limitation of research into localisation of function - Not all research agrees that all functions are localised
Karl Lashley argues that whilst basic motor and sensory functions are indeed localised, higher mental functions were not
Lashley removed areas of the cortex (10-50%) in rats that were learning a maze
He found that no area of the brain was more important that another in the rats’ ability to learn the maze
This suggests that learning is too complex to be localised and requires the involvement of the whole brain, and that higher cognitive processes are distributed in a more holistic way in the brain. This is known as the equipotentiality theory
What does lateralisation mean?
the fact that the 2 halves of the brain are not exactly alike and that certain mental processes and behaviours are controlled by one hemisphere rather than the other
Example of hemispheric lateralisation - language centres
Wernicke’s area seems to be responsible for the interpretation of speech - damage leads to Wernicke’s aphasia
Broca’s area was thought to be responsible for production of speech and damage leads to Broca’s aphasia
This suggests that mostly language is subject to hemisphere lateralisation
What is the corpus callosum?
a bundle of fibres that connects the two halves of the brain, which communicates info between the 2 hemispheres
What are split brain studies?
studying individuals who have their corpus callosum severed
they usually have their corpus callosum severed because they wanted to reduce the epileptic ‘brain storms’ which create seizures in epileptic patients
Split Brain research by Sperry (1968) - procedure
11 patients (epileptic patients with their corpus callosum severed to stop seizures) focus on a dot in the middle of the screen whilst an image or word is projected to either a patient’s right VF and the same or different image is projected to the left VF for 1/10th of a second
They were then asked to either “say what you see”, “draw what they see” or “select the correct object” - the results are then recorded
In the neurotypical brain, the corpus callosum ‘shares’ info begtween both hemispheres. In a split brain, the info cannot be conveyed from the chosen hemisphere to the other
What was found in Sperry’s split brain study?
Describing task:
info presented to RVF (left hemisphere) - the patient could describe verbally what they saw, demonstrating the superiority of the left hemisphere when it comes to verbal tasks and language production
info presented to LVF (right hemisphere) - the patient could not describe what was shown and often reported that there was nothing present
Drawing task:
info presented to RVF (left hemisphere) - while the right hand would attempt to draw a picture, the picture was never as clear as the left hand, demonstrating the superiority of the right hemisphere for visual motor task
info presented to LVF (right hemisphere) - the left hand would consistently draw clearer and better pictures than the right hand (even though all ppts were right handed)
What are the conclusions of Sperry’s study?
language is lateralised/controlled by the left hemisphere
drawing/motor skills are controlled by the right hemisphere
the connectivity between different regions is as important as the operation of different parts
Strength of split brain research - methodological strengths
split brain experiments use highly specialised and standardised procedures e.g. Sperry ensured that the image was presented to only one visual field for 1/10th of a second, making it impossible for the patient to move both eyes across the image
This is a good thing because it allowed him to ensure that only one hemisphere was receiving information at a time meaning that it is a well controlled and standardised method
allows the researcher can establish a cause and effect relationship and conclude that language is lateralised to the left hemisphere of the brain
Limitations of split brain research - methodological problems
there were a number of problems with the way in which split brain patients were studied which affected the validity of the research e.g. the disconnection between the hemispheres was greater in some patients than others
In addition to this, the control groups were not considered to be valid as they were often people with no history of epileptic seizures so argued to be not comparable
any differences between the groups may be due to epilepsy and not split brain so it can be classed as a confounding variable
This means that some of the unique features of the split brain ppts cognitive ability might be due to their epilepsy