PBL 6: Charismatic and Narcissistic Leadership

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/79

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

80 Terms

1
New cards

Personality Traits of Effective Leaders

High energy levels and stress tolerance, self-confidence, internal locus of control, emotional stability and maturity, power motivation, personal integrity, narcissism, achievement motivation, need of affiliation and big 5 traits

2
New cards

High Energy Levels and Stress Tolerance

Managerial jobs often have a high level of stress due to the pressure to make important decisions without adequate information

  • these help managers cope with hectic pace and great demand of managerial roles

  • they help managers make decisions and give direction to subordinates


3
New cards

Self-Confidence

Includes concepts like self-esteen and self-efficacy, it allows them to attempt difficult tasks and to set challenging objectives and have successful influence attempts

4
New cards

Internal Locus of Control

believe that events in their lives are determined by their own actions than chance

  • they take more initiative in problem solving and are more likely to proactively plan how to accomplish goals


5
New cards

Emotional Stability and Maturity

have more self-awareness of their strengths and weaknesses and are therefore more oriented to self-improvement, are less self-centered and have more stable emotions

6
New cards

Power Motivation:

People with high needs for power enjoy influencing people and events and are likely to seek positions of authority

  • However a socialised power orientations is more likely to lead to effective leadership rather than personalised power orientations


7
New cards

Socialised vs Personalised Power Orientations

Personalised: use power to satisfy their need for esteem, dominate subordinates to keep them weak, have authority to make important decisions, use rewards and punishments to maniptulate

Socialised: more emotionally mature, use power to benefit others, use participative coaching style, use influence to build up organisation

8
New cards

Personal Integrity and how its measured:

meaning: persons behaviours align with their beliefs and values and the person is honest, trustworthy and ethical

  • measured by how they keep promises, takes responsibility, behaviour is consistent, leader fulfils the responsibility of service


9
New cards

Personal integrity is a primary determinant of

  • Interpersonal Trust: leaders must be seen as trustworthy to gain or keep loyalty of followers

  • Expert and refrent power


10
New cards

Narcissism

A personality disorder that includes several traits for effective leadership like

  • strong need for esteem and power, low integrity and emotional maturity


11
New cards

Origin of Narcissists:

People who’s parents may have been emotionally unresponsive and rejecting may come to believe that they cannot depend on anyones love or loyalty (and therefore beome innerly lonely)

12
New cards

Characteristics of Narcissists due to Internal Loneliness

lack of empathy, exaggerated sense of self importance, manipulate, defensive (see cristisism as sign of rejecting), oversimplify relationships into good and bad

  • become preoccupied for control and power, fantasies over success and power


13
New cards

What do Narcissists do in Leader Positions:

surround themselves with loyal followers, make decisions without advice of others and gathering adequate information, ignore or reject negative information, refuse to dmit responsibility when failure

14
New cards

Advantages of Narcissism in Leaders:

  • they have strong self-confidence and optimism which influences other to make bold and innovative objectives

  • successful in leading organisations through times of threats or unusual oppurtunities


15
New cards

Achievement Orientation:

an individual's drive to meet or exceed a standard of excellence, accomplish goals, and continuously improve

16
New cards

Characteristics of Managers with `strong Achievement Orientation:

strong concern for task objectives, take initiative in finding problems and solving them, like solutions that have moderate level of risk rather than very risky or conservative, set challenging but realistic goals

17
New cards

Downsides of Achievement Orientation:

  • likely managers efforts will be directed to their own achievement and advancement rather than towards the team (personalised orientation power)

  • fails to develop strong sense of responsibility because they try to achieve everything alone


18
New cards

Type A Personality:

Have a strong achievement orientation but also a strong need for control over other events

  • they have high expectations for themselves, set high performance objectives, prefer to maintain control over all aspects of their work, express hostility


19
New cards

Need for Affiliation:

People with a strong need of affiliation receive great satisfaction from being liked and accepted by others and enjoy working with people who are friendly/cooperative

  • Negatively correlated with management effectiveness


20
New cards

Managers with a High Need of Affiliation:

  • more focused on interpersonal relationships than task, avoid conflicts, dispense rewards to be approved rather than effective performance, show favouritism


21
New cards

Managers with a Low Need of Affiliation

tend to be a ‘loner’ who doesn’t socialise with others, lack motivation to engage in any social activities, fail to develop interpersonal skills and lack confidence in influencing others

22
New cards

Big-Five Personality Traits:

Extroversion, Conscientiousness (dependability), Neuroticism (self-esteem), Intellectance (Open Minded), Agreeableness (Need for Affiliation)

  • High extroversion, conscientiousness and intellectance

  • Low Agreeableness and Neuroticism


23
New cards

Charismatic Leadership:

Leaders inspire followers through their personal charm, confidence, compelling vision, and strong communication skills, creating emotional attachment and commitment.

  • ‘divinely inspired gifts’ and that they have exceptional qualities

  • charisma occurs during social crisis in which charismatic leaders come up with radical change in vision that offers a solution and attracts followers


24
New cards

Neo-Charismatic Theories:

describe the motives and behaviours of charismatic leaders and the psychological processes that explain how these leaders influence followers

25
New cards

Attribution Theory of Charismatic Leadership:

posits that charisma is not an inherent trait a leader possesses, but rather an attribution made by followers based on the leader's behavior, expertise, and situational context

26
New cards

Leader Behaviours that make Followers Attribute Charisma to Them

Novel and Appealing Vision, Emotional Appeals to Values, Unconventional Behaviour, Self-Sacrifice, Confidence/Optimism

27
New cards

Novel and Appealing Vision:

`Followers are more likely to attribute charisma to leaders who advocate a vision that is highly different from status quo, so they see opportunities in which others fail to recognise and achieve objectives that initially seemed impossible

28
New cards

Emotional Appeals to values:

Followers are more likely to attribute charism to leaders who inspire them with emotional appeal to their values and ideals

29
New cards

Unconventional Behaviour

Followers are more likely to attribute charisma to leaders who act in unconventional ways through the use of innovative strategies that appear affective (expertise)

  • timing is critical: one strategy may work at one time and not the next


30
New cards

Self-Sacrificies:

Followers are more likely to attribute charisma to followers who make self sacrifices to benefit followers and take personal risks that incur high costs to achieve their vision

  • more motivated by concern for followers rather than self-interest


31
New cards

Confidence and Optimism

Followers attribute charisma to leaders who are confident about their visions rather than doubtful (optimism is contagious and self-confidence must be communicated otherwise it will be attributed to luck)

32
New cards

Personal Identification of Charismatic Leadership (Influence Process)

followers idolise and want to be like the leaders, so they try to please and imitate them

  • leader approval becomes the measure of their self-worth and motivation stem from fear of disappointing the leader and being rejected

  • Leader does this by communicating an appealing vision and self-sacrifices


33
New cards

Internalisation of Charismatic Leadership: (Influence Process)

a charismatic leader who can share a vision can influence followers internal attitudes and beliefs that will serve as a source of intrinsic motivation to carry out organisation mission

  • done by emphasising the symbolic and ideological aspects of the work


34
New cards

How do Charismatic Leaders Come About?

  • During crisis people are worried about economic loss, physical danger and threats to core values

  • Not during a crisis, these individual can create a sense of dissatisfaction with current conditions and provide a vision of a more promising future


35
New cards

Self-Concept Theory of Charismatic Leaders

the collection of beliefs individuals hold about themselves lead them to willingly obey leadrs, feel affection toward leader, have high performance goals and believe that they contribute to success of organisation

36
New cards

Social Identification (Influence Process)

people take pride in being part of the group and regard membership as one of their most important social identities

  • this results in strengthening of shared values, beliefs and behaviour norms among members of the group

Done through articulating a vision that relates to followers self-concept


37
New cards

Self and Collective Efficacy: (Influence Process)

Individual: a belief that one is competent and capable of attaining a difficult task objectives

Collective: belief that group members can accomplish exceptional feats when working together

  • Leader can enhance this by articulating an inspiring vision and emotional contagion


38
New cards

What is Emotional Contagion:

When leaders act enthusiastic and confident, it increases followers enthusiasm for work and creates the perception they can accomplish difficult things

39
New cards

Other Conceptions of Charisma:

Include Psychodynamic Processes, Close vs Distant charismatics and differentiation of charismatics

40
New cards

Psychodynamic Processes:

the intensity of personal identification of followers is explained by psychodynamic processes such as regression, transference and projection

Occurs among individuals who have low self-esteem and weak social identity

41
New cards

What is Regression, Transference and Projection

Regression: feelings and behaviours present from when you were a child come back

Transference: feelings towards an important figure from the past are transferred onto someone else from the present

Projection: attributing negative emotions and feelings for one person on someone else

42
New cards

Close and Distant Charisma

attributions made by people who have close contact with leaders differ from people who don’t

  • Distant: affected more by performance cues and shared stereotypes

  • Close: leader behaviour and interpersonal skills


43
New cards

Charismatic vs Ideological and Pragmatic Leaders:

three different types of leaders emerge in situations involving crises, turbulence and uncertainty (ideological, charismatic and pragmatic)

44
New cards

Ideological Leaders:

more likely to emerge when there is a strong culture of shared values and they can articulate a vision that embodies these values (more effective in political and ideological conflict)

45
New cards

Charismatic Leaders:

Appeal to emotions and articulate a vision that builds confidence that the leader can show followers how to resolve a crisis (more effective in political and ideological conflict)

46
New cards

Pragmatic Leadership:

Likely to emerge when they are perceived by followers to have the expertise and commitment to guide the process of strategy formation and crisis management (more effective in little political conflict and more emphasis in constructive problem solving)

47
New cards

Negative Charismatics (Consequence)

Charismatic Leaders that are focused on personalised-oriented power, emphasise personal identification rather than internalisation, seek to dominate followers, authority for making important decisions is centralised in the leader, use rewards and punishment to manipulate and control followers


48
New cards

Positive Charismatics (Consequence)

Charismatic Leaders that are focused on societal-oriented power, emphasise internalisation rather than personal identification, participation for making important decisions is encouraged, use rewards and punishment to reinforce good behaviour


49
New cards

What Follower Characteristics explain the type of charismatic relationship

Low Self-Efficacy: Negative

Clear self-concept and high self-esteem: Positive

50
New cards

Effects of Positive Charismatics

Creates an achievement oriented culture, high performing system and hands on-value driven environment

51
New cards

Effects of Negative Charisma:

excessive confidence blinds leaders to danger, denial of problems reduces organisational learning, taking credit for other followers work alienates key followers, impulsive non-traditional behaviour creates enemies

52
New cards

What Occurs when a Charismatic leader Dies?

a succession crisis is likely, and many organizations founded by a charismatic leader fail to survive this crisis

Routinisation of Charisma: the process of trying to perpetuate a charismatic leaders influence on the organisation

  • The leader’s authority can be transferred to a designated successor, but it is seldom possible to find a successor who will appear as extraordinary as the initial charismatic leader


53
New cards

Practical Implications of Charismatic Leadership in Organisations

its risky, implies radical change in strategy and culture of organisation, its a rare and transitionary phenomenon (The beneficial accomplishments of a charismatic leader may not persist after the leader departs/dies)

54
New cards

Differences between Transformational and Charasmatic Leadership:

how often each type of leadership occurs and the facilitating conditions for it

  • T: found at any level in organisation and universally relevant for all types of situations

  • C: rare and dependant on unusual conditions

The way people react to leaders

  • T: seen as competent and proffesional

  • C: more extreme and diverse reactions that split into camps of followers and opposers

The emphasis on attributed charisma and personal identification


55
New cards

Narcissistic Leadership

Occurs when leaders actions are motivated by their own egomaniacal needs and beliefs, superseding the needs and interests of the subordinates and organisations they leafer

56
New cards

Narcissism:

a personality trait encompassing grandiosity, arrogance, self-absorption, entitlement, fragile self esteem and hostility

57
New cards

Key Motivator for Narcissists to Seek Leadership Postions

they desire to garner power so the ‘external world’ has to support their grandiose needs and visions

58
New cards

Kernberg described narcissists with what characteristics?

unusual degree of self-refrence, shallow emotional lives, envy, exploitativeness, lack of empathy

59
New cards

Two Types of Narcissism:

Mature, Healthy: a balanced, realistic self-regard that builds genuine self-esteem, autonomy, and emotional resilience without exploiting or devaluing others

Pathological: when one is unable to integrate the idealised belief one has about oneself with the realities of ones inadequacies

60
New cards

Narcissitic Personality Disorder Traits

Lack of empathy, envy, grandiose sense of self-importance, arrogant behaviours, belief in special status

61
New cards

The Downside of Narcissistic Leaders:

take credit for success, blame others for failure, abusive

  • because of their drive and grandiosity narcissists make poor decisions with greater confidence and thus greater influence


62
New cards

Psychological Underpinnings of Narcissistic Leaders:

Arrogance, Inferiority, Need for Recognition and Superiority, Hypersensitivity and Anger, Lack of Empathy, Amorality, Irrationality and Inflexibility and Paranoia

63
New cards

The Upside of Narcissistic Leaders (The selection of Narcissists)

When ‘mirror hungry’ narcissistic leaders find a group of ‘ideal hungry’ followers, in a particular historic context, it can be successful

  • todays hectic world needs leaders who are grand visionaries and don’t try to understand the future, but only shape it


64
New cards

Two strengths particular to productive narcissists that make them ideal for out times:

  • They are visionaries

    • See the great picture and leave analysing up to others (when they don’t like rules they ignore or change them)

  • They inspire grand numbers of followers

    • charmers who can convert the masses with their rhetoric

    • Through grand visions and great charisma they gain followers and they fulfill narcissists need for admiration, boosting their confidence


65
New cards

Five Weaknesses of Productive Narcissists;

  • Hypersensitive to criticism

  • Poor Listener

  • Lacking in Empathy

  • Unwilling or unable to mentor or be mentored

  • Competitive


66
New cards

Attaining Leadership vs Performing Leadership

Narcissists are good at attaining leadership but not performing well in that position

  • narcissisms fuels poor decision making, and the power they attain through leadership fuels their narcissism, spurring into a spiral of poor leadership


67
New cards

When are Narcissists Expected to Succeeed:

  • in positions where extroversion and charisma is important

  • Self-absorption and gradiosity are important

  • Personal goals converge with those of followers

  • Times that call for a new order to be established


68
New cards

Implicit Leadership Theory:

we choose as our leaders those people who seem to be the most ‘leaderlike’

  • and they frequently mistake the behavioral traits of narcissists for those true leadership qualities


69
New cards

Temporal Trajectory:

while narcissistic follower will experience pleasure from seeing how leader work up the ranks, they would feel the same pleasure from seeing them brought down a notch

70
New cards

Two Types of Charismatic Leadership with Narcissism

  1. Socialised Charismatic Relationship: followers identift with the collective relationships with the group and it’s broad set of values

  2. Personalised Charismatic Relationship: followers identify directly with the leader based on the leaders personal attributed rather than the values and ideas they present (more likely in narcissitic leaders)


71
New cards
72
New cards

How can Narcissism be Measured:

individuals can be assigned scores amongst four dimensions of the Narcissism Personality Inventory:

  • Exploitativeness/Entitlement: I insist upon getting the respect that is entitled to me

  • Leadership/authority: I like to be the center of attention

  • Superiority/Arrogance: I am better than other

  • Self-Absorption/Self-Admiration: I am preoccupied with how special I am


73
New cards

Contingent Self-Esteem

Narcissists are highly sensitive to interpersonal feedback and require continuous reinforcement of their inflated selves

74
New cards

Narcissism can be expected to lead strategic actions through 2 dimensions:

The CEOs assignment of probabilities to outcomes

  • their elevated self-image will lead to relative optimism and confidence about positive outcomes shifting estimates of payoffs in an upward direction

The CEOs preference ordering among alternatives

  • favour alternatives that would suit their personal preferences


75
New cards

Hubris Hypothesis:

the CEOs mistaken belief that they can run the company better than the incumbent management

76
New cards

Supported Hypothesis

  • The greater the narcissistic tendencies of a CEO, the greater the dyanmism of the companies strategy (strategic dynamism)

  • The greater the narcissistic tendencies of a CEO, the greater number and size acquisitions made by the company


77
New cards

Considerable Support Hypothesis

  • The greater the narcissistic tendencies of a CEO, the more extreme the companies performance

    • Narcissism is positively related to ROA extremeness

      Positive but no significant effect on TSR extremeness


78
New cards

Partial Support Hypothesis:

  • The greater the narcissistic tendencies of a CEO, the greater the fluctuation in the companies performance

    • Narcissism is positively related to ROA fluctuation

    • Positive but no significant effect on TSR fluctuation


79
New cards
80
New cards