1/22
Looks like no tags are added yet.
why is everyone trying to fix this?
$5.7 trillion - US health spending last year. More than other countries and sill rising
We aren’t healthier for it
Worse in infant mortality and life expectancy than peer countries
Every dollar is someone’s income
so cost control gets force pushback: people want the newest drug choice, and many profit from the status quo
Coverage is a patchwork
Employer, self-purchase, Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP, VA, IHS. Each has gaps, so millions fall through
Healthcare is a Right
Markets don’t work in health care, government is the answer
What Universal Systems have in common
Insurers are NOT-for-profit
Insurers take everyone. No picking healthy people
Every provider get paid the same rate
Everyone has to be covered. No opting out
Let the market Work
Government is the problem
Consumers should control the money and the choice
Consumer-Directed Health Care (CDHC)
Give people the money
Vouchers instead of entitlements. Higher wages instead of employer-paid plans
Give people more information
prices, quality report cards, provider comparisons, Electronic Health Records
Let providers compete
remove subsidies and regulations that block selling
Hope: Cost falls
patients shop for value, so providers cut prices to win them
Same as retirement: pensions (define benefit) became 401Ks (defined contribution). Instas of a plan with a set of benefits, you get a set amount of money and decide how to spend it.
Health Saving Acounts (HSAs)
High-Deductibke Health Plan
covers the big, catastrophic cost
2026 minimum deductible: $1,700 single / 3,400 family
HSA (a saving account, not a plan)
pre-tax money goes in, grows tax free
tax free when spent on approved medical care
Debit card, rolls over every year, your after 65
FOR : CDHC: the case for and against
Lower cost if people make cost-conscious decisions
Cut unnecessary and high-cost care
Providers lower prices to attract consumers
Cheap options that could cover more uninsured people
Entrepreneurs fill gaps with new ideas
Against : CDHC: the case for and against
Healthy people join HSAs , sick people stay in regular plans (adverse selection)
High out-of-pocket cost
Tax breaks helps high earners most
Doesn’t touch the suckers 5% who drive most spending; just shifts the burden
You can’t really shop for care, especially in an emergency
Does “Skin in the Game” work
Rand Health Insurance Experiment:
~7,000 people randomly assigned to plans with 0% to 95% coinsurance, or an HMO
Results:
Yes, people used less care
free care led to more visits; cot-sharing cut use
But it cut needed care too
people skipped appropriate care as much as unnecessary care
It hurst the poor and the sick most
High cost-sharing worsened outcomes for low-income, sicker people
Newer studies agree: COPD patients in high-deductible plans skip care and end up in the ER more
The Middle Ground
Keep what works, fix what does not
Three places to Intervene
Employer-based
make employers cover workers
employer mandate, pay or play
Individual market
make insurances buyable for everyone
Insurances rules, mandates, subsidies, pools
Government programs
cover more people publicly
Expand Medicaid, medicare, CHIP
Hybrid Model: combine all three
Employer Mandate
Straight Mandate:
employers must provide coverage
Pay or play:
Play: cover your workers
Pay: pay into a public fund that covers them
Why this is hard
Businesses fight it in court and in the legislature
leaves the unemployed uninsured
May push wages down
keeps health insurance to your job
big new cost for employers who don’t offer coverage now
Federal Law (ERISA) blocks states from doing it
The fix: The Three Legged Stool
No underwriting
insures cover everyone, regardless of health
Mandate
get healthy and young people into the risk pool
Help buying a plan
subsidies and clear information
Take away any leg and the stool falls over
Kick out a leg: What happens?
Leg 2 removed:
2017 tax law cut individual mandate penalty to $0 starting 2019
Predict: What happened to the risk pool and premiums
Leg 3 weakened:
extra ACA subsidies expired Dec 31, 2025. Marketplace premiums jumped and enrollment felly by millions
predict: who drops coverage first, the healthy or the sick
Massachusetts 2006: the hybrid
Employer:
pay or play:
10+ EMPLOYEES: offer coverage (at minimum a pre-tax plan) or pay a fee
Individual:
No underwriting. Tax penalty up to $912 for going uninsured
Help
subsidies + connector
subsidies for low-income people. A state-run marketplace to shop for plans
Government
Medicaid expansion
Medicaid for everyone under ~135% of poverty
Clinton’s health Security Act: what it proposed
employer mandate, with care delivery through HMOs
Regional health alliances to buy coverage
a standard benefit package
A National Health Board
Government budgets and spending caps
Discussion worksheets
Provide 2 examples of countries using market forces their government system
Britain requires hospital to compete on items other than cost: quality, time to appointment, nicer rooms
Germany requires some copayments
Which country’s health care system is most like that of the US? Why?
Switzerland — had private insurance companies, businesses, gov’t and individual all have a role, the country was divided on whether health care us a right
What are the main lessons learned from the film, according to TR Reid?
Insurance companies
Not-for-profit
Take ALL people (no selection)
Pay same to ALL providers
Everyone must have coverage
ether on own, via company or via government
Can’t opt out
Describe how each of the systems listed above is reflected in the US delivery system
National Insurance —Medicare
Beveridge — The VA
Bismark — our entire system, except the government doens’t coverall all who need it