Three Kinds of Error: Factual, Logical, and Conceptual

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/12

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Vocabulary flashcards detailing factual, logical, and conceptual errors (category mistakes), including examples such as Gilbert Ryle's mind-brain distinction and orbital vs. positional reasoning in planetary astronomy.

13 Terms

1
New cards

Factual Error

A mistaken claim about facts in the world, which are typically thought to be justified through experience (e.g., claiming that Plato lived in London instead of Athens).

2
New cards

Logical Error

A mistaken claim about which propositions follow from (or are implied by) other propositions, which are typically thought to be justified through reason (e.g., claiming that Plato did not have a sibling even though he had a brother).

3
New cards

Conceptual Error

A mistaken claim about concepts (e.g., claiming that all medical doctors are pediatricians rather than recognizing that a pediatrician is a kind of medical doctor).

4
New cards

Category Mistake

An error that occurs when properties or concepts applying to things in one logical category are incorrectly applied to things in a different logical category (e.g., claiming happiness has a colour or thinking justice has a mass).

5
New cards

Institutional Category Mistake

Confusing individual units of physical infrastructure (e.g., libraries and laboratories) with the institutions that encompass those units (e.g., universities).

6
New cards

Gilbert Ryle's Example of a Category Mistake

Thinking that the mind is an object, rather than a collection of capacities and dispositions of a brain.

7
New cards

Justification of Conceptual Claims

The basis on which concepts are validated: some (such as scientific concepts) are typically justified through experience, while others (such as mathematical concepts) are typically justified through reason.

8
New cards

Average Planetary Distances to the Sun

The average orbital distances of planets from the Sun: approx. 58 million km58\text{ million km} for Mercury, approx. 150 million km150\text{ million km} for Earth, and approx. 228 million km228\text{ million km} for Mars.

9
New cards

Earth-Mars Distance Range

A distance that measures approx. 78 million km78\text{ million km} at their closest, but reaches approx. 378 million km378\text{ million km} at their farthest.

10
New cards

Earth-Mercury Distance Range

A distance that measures approx. 92 million km92\text{ million km} at their closest, but reaches approx. 208 million km208\text{ million km} at their farthest.

11
New cards

Planetary Example: Factual Error

Thinking that all the planets are in synchronous, heliocentric orbits and remain stationary with respect to each other while orbiting on the same side of the Sun.

12
New cards

Planetary Example: Logical Error

Thinking that because we know something about the orbits of the planets, it follows that we can infer something about the actual positions of the planets.

13
New cards

Planetary Example: Conceptual Error

Making a category mistake by treating the orbit of a planet and the position of a planet as the same thing, falsely assuming "orbit" and "position" are synonyms.