1/10
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Gender affects the structure of language:
Male as the norm: language which implies that females are a subsection of the male group and therefore less important- Dale Spender 1980.
Prejoration over time: words get more negatively associated over time- like bachelor vs spinster.
Marked/unmarked terms: adding on extra detail to a word- this implies what is or isn’t included in the original word. e.g ‘family man’, ‘male nurse’, ‘women’s football’.
Collocations: couple of words that are often heard together in a way that sounds natural e.g ‘fast food’.
Deficit - Lakoff 1975
Lakoff is a feminist who suggested that women have been dominated in society because their language is less powerful than mens.
Such as women speak less, apologise more, avoid taboo language and hedge more.
However, this is based on her personal observations rather than a scientific study.
Dominance- Zimmerman and West 1975
Based on conversations recorded at Uni of California.
All subjects were white, middle class and under 35.
They reported that in 11 conversations between men and women, men used 46 interruptions while women only used 2.
They concluded that men interrupt more so dominate in society.
However, not representative, small sample size, interruptions don’t have to mean dominance, personality of subjects.
Dominance - Beattie 1982
Could have one very voluble man in study and also interruptions don’t have to reflect dominance. (response to Zimmerman’s study)
He recorded 557 interruptions in study (compared to Z+W’s 55) and Beattie found no difference in interruptions between men and women.
Dominance- Fishman 1983
Women are 4 times more likely to use tag questions than men.
Tag questions used to start and keep conversations going -the ‘conversational shitwork’.
Men are reluctant to do the ‘conversation shitwork’ because of what they perceive to be their dominant role.
Difference- Tannen 1990
Men and women speak differently and there are 6 contrasts to show this.
status vs support, independence vs intimacy, advice vs understanding, information vs feelings, orders vs proposals, conflict vs compromise.
Difference- Coates
Girls and boys belong to same sex friend groups when they grow up usually.
So subsequently develop different styles of speaking.
Female language is cooperative in single sex conversations through tag questions and modality- more supportive
Difference- Holmes
Bases research off Brown and Levison’s positive and negative face.
Women are more likely to use positively orientated politeness, while men use more negatively orientated politeness.
Due to: men use language as a tool to give and obtain information (referential function of language).
Women use language to keep in touch (social function), including politeness.
So, women are more polite than men.
Constructionist- Cameron 2009
‘The idea that men and women use language in very different ways and for very different reasons is one of the great myths of our time’.
Most of the claims about men and women using language differently are not supported by evidence.
Language use is determined by context: role, relationship, status, situation, ect. rather than gender.
‘Gender is a performative social construct’.
Both men and women adopt ‘male or female gender scripts’ -depends on context and what role they are performing.
Constructionist- Hyde 2005
There is more variation within each gender than there is between them.
Those differences that we can see between genders are due to other variables like age, class, ethnicity, education, occupation, power.
Called: ‘gender similarities hypothesis’
Judith Butler- performance 1990
‘We act and walk and speak and talk in ways that consolidate an impression of being a man or being a women’