Research Ethics: Naturalism and Rationalism

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/41

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Done by Gemini

42 Terms

1
New cards

What is Morality?

Traditions or beliefs about right and wrong conduct; a social and cultural institution with learnable rules.

2
New cards

What is Ethics?

The study of social morality and philosophical discussion of society's norms and practices; the practical application of moral philosophy.

3
New cards

What is the basis of Naturalism?

Action arising from or based on natural instincts and desires alone.

4
New cards

In Naturalism, what is the main motivating factor in moral decision-making?

Sympathy (feelings of pleasure/warmth towards others and hostility towards those who inflict pain).

5
New cards

What is Rationalism?

The principle of accepting reason as the supreme authority in matters of opinion, belief, or conduct, rather than intuition.

6
New cards

Does Rationalism believe in relative or absolute truths?

Absolute truths that are not dependent on human nature or circumstances.

7
New cards

What is Utilitarianism?

A system of ethics where the rightness or wrongness of an action is judged by its consequences, aiming for the greatest happiness for the greatest number.

8
New cards

In Utilitarianism, are a person's motives considered important?

No, only the consequence, outcome, or end result of the action matters.

9
New cards

Who is considered the father of modern utilitarianism?

Jeremy Bentham.

10
New cards

Which utilitarian philosopher subscribed to the golden rule ("Do unto others as you would have them do unto you")?

John Stuart Mill.

11
New cards

What is a major critique of Utilitarianism?

It provides insufficient respect and autonomy of persons, and might sacrifice the minority for the good of the majority.

12
New cards

What is another name for Rationalism as formulated by Immanuel Kant?

Kantianism or Deontology.

13
New cards

What does the Greek word "Deon" mean in Deontology?

Duty.

14
New cards

According to Kantianism, for what sake must one always act?

For the sake of duty or obligation.

15
New cards

What is Kant's Categorical Imperative?

The rule that there are no exceptions; one's actions must reasonably be able to become a universal law for all people under similar circumstances.

16
New cards

What is Kant's Practical Imperative?

Act as if you treat people as an end rather than as a means to an end.

17
New cards

What are the negative critiques of Deontology?

It is exceptionless and rigid, does not help in choosing among conflicting alternatives, and disregards negative consequences that can lead to disastrous results.

18
New cards

What are the positive critiques of Deontology?

It provides a foundation for contemporary beliefs, offers clear guidelines, and recognizes the dignity, autonomy, and equality of individuals.

19
New cards



20
New cards

What principle did Moses Maimonides instruct his colleagues to follow?

To treat patients as an end in themselves, not merely as a means for learning new truth.

21
New cards

Who made the first significant impact in medical practice regarding immunization using cowpox?

Edward Jenner.

22
New cards

On whom did Edward Jenner test his early smallpox/cowpox vaccines?

His 1-year-old son (swinepox) and an 8-year-old boy (cowpox).

23
New cards

Who swallowed varying doses of 17 different drugs to analyze their effects in the 19th century?

Johann Jorg.

24
New cards

Who inhaled chloroform and awoke on the floor while searching for a better anesthetic gas?

Sir James Young Simpson.

25
New cards

Who conducted long-term gastric studies on a man with an open stomach wound by providing him payment, board, and lodging?

William Beaumont.

26
New cards

What was "Unit 731"?

A unit of the Japanese Army that conducted extremely cruel and inhumane biological warfare research on Chinese prisoners.

27
New cards

Who headed Unit 731?

General Shiro Ishii.

28
New cards

What happened to General Shiro Ishii after WWII?

He was never found guilty of war crimes, reportedly handed research to the USA in exchange for immunity, and received retirement pay.

29
New cards

Name some of the atrocities committed by Nazi doctors during WWII.

Freezing experiments, twin experiments, malaria experiments, mustard gas experiments, and sterilization experiments on Jews, Gypsies, Poles, and Russians.

30
New cards

What was one justification Nazi doctors used for their experiments?

That they were merely carrying out orders, the subjects were condemned to die anyway, or that the subjects were considered "subhuman species".

31
New cards

What was the Tuskegee Syphilis Study?

A study funded by the US Public Health Service (started in 1932) on the natural progression of untreated syphilis in 400 black men.

32
New cards

What major ethical violation occurred in the Tuskegee Syphilis Study?

Subjects were misinformed, treatment (penicillin) was deliberately withheld, and they were told painful lumbar punctures were a "treatment".

33
New cards

What unethical research did the US Army conduct during and after WWII?

Involuntarily enrolling over 60,000 servicemen in studies involving exposure to chemical warfare agents like mustard gas and lewisite.

34
New cards

What unethical research occurred at the Oregon State Prison?

Prisoners had their testicles exposed to X-rays to study sperm production without being informed that the radiation could cause cancer.

35
New cards

What unethical research occurred at the Willowbrook institution in New York?

Mentally retarded residents were deliberately fed live hepatitis virus to study the disease and create a vaccine.

36
New cards

What unethical research occurred at the Brooklyn Jewish Chronic Disease Hospital?

21 elderly and senile patients were deliberately injected with cancer cells without being told the cells were cancerous.

37
New cards

What famous code of conduct for human research was drafted as a result of the post-WWII War Crime trials?

The Nuremberg Code.

38
New cards

Besides the Nuremberg Code, name two other major standards/declarations guiding human experimentation today.

The Declaration of Helsinki and the ICH / WHO Good Clinical Practice standards.

39
New cards

Tutorial Q: Based on Utilitarianism, is it ethical to drive through a red light at a deserted junction in an emergency?

It may be unethical because the action risks an unexpected accident that could endanger more lives, whereas the emergency itself might not risk anyone's life.

40
New cards

Tutorial Q: Based on Rationalism (Deontology), is it ethical to drive through a red light at a deserted junction in an emergency?

It is morally right based on duty and obligation; it is logical to rush through to fulfill an obligation when there is no immediate danger.

41
New cards

Tutorial Q: Based on Utilitarianism, is conceiving a baby to find a bone marrow match for an elder child ethical?

It can be seen as morally right because there is a greater benefit (saving the elder child and gaining another child), but it is also morally wrong if it treats the new baby as an object, sacrificing the minority for the majority.

42
New cards

Tutorial Q: Based on Rationalism, is conceiving a baby to find a bone marrow match for an elder child ethical?

It is not morally right if it disregards the autonomy and equality of the unborn child by using them as a means to an end, despite the parents' duty to save their elder child.