1/81
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Transactional vs. collaborative vs. strategic relationships
Transactional (vendor): little or no integration, arm's length. Collaborative (partner): more integration, shared info and planning. Strategic (alliance): most strategic and highly relational.
Core competency assessment factors (decision to collaborate)
Expertise, strategic fit, ability to invest
Vertical collaboration
Collaboration up and down one supply chain (supplier, manufacturer, distributor, retailer)
Horizontal collaboration
Companies at the same level, even competitors, working together (Ocean Spray and Tropicana backhauls, Dal-Tile and Whirlpool co-loading, Hershey and Ferrero shared warehouses)
Full collaboration
Both vertical and horizontal collaboration at the same time
7 elements of successful collaboration
1) Well understood goals and objectives 2) Trust and commitment 3) Organizational compatibility and communication 4) Equitable sharing of gains and losses 5) Benefits greater than going it alone 6) Dedication to continuous improvement 7) Strategic plan to give direction
Barriers to collaboration
Resistance to change, conflicting objectives, inconsistent goals and KPIs, lack of trust, unwillingness to share info, lack of management support, turf protection
1PL
Shippers or receivers of product moved through the supply chain
2PL
Asset based providers that physically move product (carriers of various modes)
3PL
Firms that manage and/or provide logistics services for clients; mostly non asset based
4PL
Broader, more strategic scope; manages multiple 3PLs (lead logistics provider), takes more risk, advanced IT, consulting, control tower services
5PL
Aggregates 3PL demand into bulk volumes to negotiate better rates
Roots / types of 3PL providers
Transportation based, Contract logistics based (warehousing), Freight forwarding based, Financial based, Information based, Corporate subsidiary based
Transportation based 3PL examples
FedEx Supply Chain, UPS Supply Chain Solutions, Ryder, Schneider, Penske
Contract logistics based 3PL examples
CEVA, DSC, DHL Supply Chain, Geodis, Saddle Creek
Freight forwarding based 3PL examples
C.H. Robinson, Expeditors, Hub Group
Financial based 3PL examples
Cass Information Systems, CTSI, Tranzact (freight payment and auditing)
Information based 3PL example
Transplace
Corporate subsidiary based 3PL example
Neovia (formerly Caterpillar Logistics), IBM Global Business Services
Region with largest 3PL volume and CAGR
Asia Pacific ($269.6B in 2014, 10.2% CAGR)
U.S. 3PL spending in 2018
$195.8 billion (projected $246B in 2025)
Top 5 outsourced logistics services in order
1) Domestic transportation 80% 2) Warehousing 66% 3) International transportation 60% 4) Freight forwarding 48% 5) Customs brokerage 45%
Measure
Broadly stated, general, simple, no calculation (ex: "a measure of SC efficiency")
Metric
Specifically defined, calculated, often a ratio (ex: inventory turns = COGS / avg inventory)
Index
Combines two or more metrics into a single number to track overall performance (textbook)
Characteristics of a good metric
Quantitative, defined and easy to understand, multi dimensional, economical to create, system supported, facilitates trust, encourages collaboration
Other metric considerations
Look at the range and worst results, not just averages; adapt metrics as business changes; raise the bar over time; customer point of view matters most
Top 5 distribution center metrics (textbook)
On time shipments, order picking accuracy, average warehouse capacity used, dock to stock cycle time, internal order cycle time
Process measures: TIME
Order cycle time, on time delivery, dock to stock time
Process measures: QUALITY
Perfect order, picking accuracy, damage free, fill rate
Process measures: COST
Cost per order, transportation cost per shipment, inventory carrying cost, total landed cost
5 SCOR metric categories (textbook)
Reliability, Responsiveness, Agility, Cost, Asset management efficiency
Efficiency
Cost oriented: how well resources are used; required service at lowest cost (inventory turns, cost per order, cash to cash cycle)
Effectiveness
Service oriented: gap between customer expectations and perceived service (perfect order, on shelf in stock %)
Efficiency vs. effectiveness trade off
As cost cutting increases, service may suffer; as service increases, cost performance may suffer
Perfect order
Order received, picked, packed, shipped, documented, and delivered on time without damage. 7 steps at 95% each = only 69%
Balanced scorecard SC components
Customer benefits, SCM goals, SCM improvement, financial benefits
Cash to cash cycle time
Time to convert a dollar spent on raw materials into a dollar collected; inventory days + receivable days minus payable days
How SC decisions affect ROA
Cost cuts raise Net Income (Income Statement). Inventory cuts lower assets (Balance Sheet) AND lower carrying cost (Income Statement)
Income Statement vs Balance Sheet rule
Small Income Statement changes cause large ROA changes; larger Balance Sheet changes cause smaller ROA changes
Effect of higher on time delivery
More sales and fewer expediting/penalty costs, so net profit rises, raising ROA and ROE
Effect of inventory reduction on financials
Lower carrying cost (higher NI), lower current assets, long run lower fixed assets; higher ROA, asset turnover, inventory turns
SC decisions affecting ROA
Income Statement: increase revenue, reduce operating costs. Balance Sheet: reduce asset expenditure
Income Statement order (Appendix 13A)
Sales minus COGS = Gross Margin minus Operating Expenses = EBIT minus Interest minus Taxes = Net Income
Balance Sheet (Appendix 13A)
Assets (current: cash, A/R, inventory; fixed: property and equipment) = Liabilities (A/P, short term loans, long term debt) + Stockholders' Equity
3 principal information requirements
Meet quality standards, support multidirectional flows, provide decision support
Information quality standards (slide lists 7)
Accuracy, Accessibility, Relevancy, Timeliness, Transferability, Usability, Reliability
7 supply chain process enablers
Cross chain visibility, Agility, Velocity, Synchronization, Adaptability, Segmentation, Optimization
3 network elements to link
Process, People, Technology (integrated technologies, skilled people, robust processes)
3 systems capabilities
Enable process excellence, link network elements, mitigate technology risks
4 categories of SCM software
Supply chain planning, supply chain execution, event management, business intelligence
Demand planning and strategic network design belong to
Supply chain PLANNING
Warehouse Management Systems and Transportation Management Systems belong to
Supply chain EXECUTION
Facilitating tools around SCM software
ERP, SRM (supplier relationship mgmt), CRM (customer relationship mgmt), auto ID / data capture
5G wireless is what type of innovation
Mobile connectivity (other innovations: Internet of Things, functional automation)
Data
Unorganized facts that need processing (ex: inventory levels at end of financial periods)
Information
Data gathered, processed, organized in a context (ex: average inventory, inventory by SKU)
Understanding
Information examined in a specific business situation (ex: inventory levels relative to economic conditions)
4 levels of SC analytics maturity
Descriptive, Predictive, Prescriptive, Cognitive (operational to strategic)
Descriptive analytics resources
Standard and ad hoc reporting, partner data, alerts and notifications, query/drill down
Predictive analytics resources
Forecasting, heuristic analysis, simulation, statistical analysis, predictive modeling
Prescriptive analytics resources
Stochastic optimization, scenario planning
Cognitive analytics resource
IBM Watson Analytics
First holiday season of online gift buying (textbook)
1999
Omni-channel concept
"Anytime, anywhere, anyhow, and any device"; one seamless experience across stores, web, and mobile
6 strategies for omni-channel retailers
One view of customer, short term forecasts, seamless order entry and management, one view of inventory, flexible fulfillment network, store operations
How omni-channel affects store operations
Stores replicate many fulfillment center operations (picking, packing, ship from store, in store pickup, returns) while staying focused on being a retail store
4 R's of sustainability
Reuse, Remanufacturing, Reconditioning, Recycling
Reuse
Disassemble a product and reuse parts or components after cleaning and repair
Remanufacturing
Product returned to market "as good as new" (auto parts, tires, electronics)
Reconditioning
Returned to working order but NOT as good as new
Recycling
Secondary use of materials; last resort and lowest value salvaged
Business case for sustainability
Regulation, Risk, Reputation, Profit
Reverse flows vs forward flows
Reverse flow is growing (easy returns, recycling, obsolescence), seen as a necessary evil / cost center, value from returns under emphasized, less predictable in volume, timing, and condition
Products made with 3D printing (textbook)
Prototypes, dental implants, hearing aids, prosthetics, aircraft and auto parts, spare parts, shoes, toys
3D printing also called
Additive manufacturing
3D printing effect on inventory
Inventory goes DOWN: print on demand near the customer, so less finished goods and spare parts stock
3D printing outlook
Near term: prototypes, low demand parts with long lead times, inventory mgmt. Longer term: "open source collaboration"
Supply chain talent outlook
Demand for SC talent exceeds supply. Steps: acquire new staff, develop talent, foster advancement of top talent
Mode #1 in value, tons, and ton-miles
Trucking
Lowest cost transportation mode
Pipeline
Highest accessibility mode
Trucking