Crime - Lecture 6

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/83

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Neuropsychological and structural neuroimaging

84 Terms

1
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - core problem and primary objective

to address inconsistent grey matter volume (GMV) findings caused by heterogeneous conduct problem samples and small sample sizes by conducting the first quantitative, image-based whole-brain VBm meta-analysis comparing youths with CP to typically developing controls

2
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - inclusion criteria, exclusion criteria, and final sample

included whole-brain VBM studies (2007-2015) comparing CP and TD youths (excluding ROI-only, DTI, surface-based morphometry, and duplicate datasets), yielding 13 studies with 394 CP youths (83% male) and 350 TP youths (77.7% male)

3
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - meta-analytic technique and secondary analyses used

used anisotropic effect-size signed differential mapping with raw statistical parametric maps for 11 of 13 studies, alongside jackknife sensitivity analysis, a childhood-onset subgroup meta-analysis, and a meta-regressions

4
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - main contrast GMV findings in youths with CP vs TD controls

bilateral GMV reductions (with no increases) in:

  • left amygdala (extending to anterior insula)

  • right insula (extending to vlPFC/OFC and STG)

  • left medial superior frontal gyrus (extending to right ACC)

  • left fusiform gyrus


5
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - jackknife sensitivity analysis findings

the left amygdala GMV reduction was the most robust finding, remaining significant across all 13 leave-one-out iterations, while insular and frontal GMV reductions remained stable across 11 to 12 iterations

6
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - subgroup and meta-regression effects of childhood-onset CP and CU traits

  • childhood-onset CP showed a left-lateralised GMV reduction in the left anterior insula and left amygdala

  • whereas, higher CU traits were associated with a smaller GMV reduction in the left putamen, bringing volume closer to TD controls


7
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - effects of sex, age range, CD severity, ADHD, and IQ

  • higher male proportion and wider age ranges predicted greater left amygdala GMV reductions

  • higher female proportion linked to increased right inferior temporal gyrus GMV (driven by one female-only study)

  • higher CD severity linked to right STG reductions

  • ADHD comorbidity and ID had no moderating effect


8
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - functional roles and clinical manifestations of amygdala and anterior insula reductions in CP/CD

  • amygdala (threat processing, aversive conditioning, face emotion recognition, emotion empathy) reductions align with blunted distress recognition and poor moral socialisation

  • anterior insula (interoception, empathic pain, risk adjustment) reductions explain impaired empathy and risk-insensitive decision-making


9
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - functional roles and clinical manifestations of vlPFC/OFC, medial SFG/rostral ACC, and putamen alterations in CP/CD

  • vlPFC/OFC (emotion regulation, inhibition, reversal learning) deficits promote reactive aggression and impulsivity

  • medial SFG/rostral ACC (social cognition, Theory of Mind, affective empathy) deficits drive peer disregard

  • putamen (reward/reinforcement learning) differences relfect distinct reward-driven pathways in psychopathy


10
New cards

rogers et al. (2016) - methodological strengths and limitations

  • strengths:

    • used raw statistical maps for 85% of studies (avoiding peak-coordinate bias)

    • showed no publication bias

    • ruled out ADHD confounds

  • limitations

    • VBM cannot separate thickness, surface area, or gyrification

    • could not isolate adolescent-onset CP

    • obly 5 studies reported CU traits

    • cross-sectional design precludes causality


11
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - core problem & primary objective

  • core problem

    • males exhibit cross-culturally higher rates of crime, violence, and APD) than females, which traditional socio-cultural models fail to robustly explain

  • primary objective

    • test whether structural grey matter reductions in PFC sub-regions (specifically orbitofrontal and middle frontal grey) characterise APD, predict antisocially across sexes, and explain the gender gap in APD


12
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - rutter, caspi & moffitt’s (2003) three evidential criteria for causation

  1. males and females must differ on the supposed risk factor

  2. the risk factor must predict psychopathology within each sex

  3. controlling for the risk factor must reduce or eliminate the observed sex difference in psychopathology


13
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - ppt sample design

  • recruited from LA temporary employment agencies (community sample with high antisocial base rates)

    • males: 18 DSM-IV APD, 30 healthy controls, 24 substance-dependent controls

    • psychiatric control subsample: matched to APD group on comorbidites (schizophrenia-spectrum, affective, anxiety, other personality disorders)

    • females: independent sample from the same agencies to test sex differences and cross-sex generalisability


14
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - diagnostic, offending, and cognitive/psychosocial measures

  • diagnostics: SCID-I and SCID-II

  • offending: self-report crime checklist (44 lifespan offences)

  • cognitive & psychosocial: WAIS-R (IQ), SES, and 10 demographic/family trauma variables


15
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - structural MRI analysis & parcellation

  • scanner: 1.5T scanner

  • parcellation: manual delineation of 5 bilateral sub-regions

    • superior frontal, middle frontal, inferior frontal, orbitofrontal, and rectus gyri

  • scaling & reliability: volumes corrected for whole-brain volume

    • high inter-rater reliability


16
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - prefrontal specificity & hemisphere laterality in APD males

  • grey matter reductions vs healthy controls: orbitofrontal, middle frontal, and right rectus gyrus

  • specificity: restricted to grey matter (no differences in prefrontal white matter or total brain volume)

    • superior and inferior gyro were spared

  • laterality: bilateral in orbitofrontal cortex, but significantly stronger in the right hemisphere for middle frontal and rectus gyri


17
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - cross-sex relationships supporting criterion 2

  • inverse correlations between frontal grey matter and antisociality generalised across both sexes

  • females: orbitofrontal volume correlated with crime and APD symptoms

    • middle frontal volume correlated with crime

  • males: orbitofrontal volume correlated with crime and APD

    • middle frontal volume correlated with crime and APD


18
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - explaining the gender gap via criterion 1 & 3

  • criterion 1 (sex dimorphism)

    • unselected males showed significantly lower relative orbitofrontal and middle frontal grey volumes than females

  • criterion 3 (statistical mediation)

    • controlling for orbitofrontal grey alone reduced the sex difference in ASB by 65.9%

    • controlling for all 3 regions reduced it by 77.3%, rendering the gender gap non-significant


19
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - robustness against confounds

  • substance & psychiatric comorbidity

    • APD males still showed significant orbitofrontal, middle frontal, and right rectal deficits compared to substance-dependent and matched psychiatric controls

  • head injury & trauma

    • deficits persisted after covarying for head injury and trauma response

  • psychological risk factors

    • the 3 frontal grey matrics predicted APD over and above 10 psychosocial risk factors (e.g. poverty, abuse, institutional rearing, parental criminality), raising classification accuracy from 73.9% to 100%


20
New cards

raine et al. (2011) - neurofunctional mechanisms & critical evaluation

  • mechanisms

    • orbitofrontal/ventral PFC (reward encoding, passive avoidance, reversal learning, empathy)

    • middle frontal gyrus (contingency awareness, moral decision-making, delay of gratification)

    • right rectal/ventromedial hyrus (inhibiting responses to unexpected stimuli, self-reflection)

  • strengths

    • strict control groups

    • manual ROI tracing

    • satisfying all 3 causal criteria

  • limitations

    • small female sample

    • cross-sectional design (cannot establish temporal causality)

    • multi-etiological complexity (social, genetic, neurochemical, and amygdala factors interact)


21
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - core thesis

  • typically developing individuals refrain from corrupt and immoral acts by unconsciously binding social values with the anticipatory emotional risk of punishment

  • immoral, corrupt, and psychopathic behaviours stem from a failure of the somatic marker circuitry

    • primarily the vmPFC and amygdala

    • resulting in a dissociation between declarative moral knowledge and actual behaviour


22
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - mechanism of somatic marker hypothesis framework

  • when pondering decisions under uncertainty, covert or overt emotional signals (‘somatic markers’) are triggered to bias choices toward advantageous outcomes and away from punitive ones

  • deprived from these markers, individuals rely solely on immediate rewards


23
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - primary vs secondary inducers in somatic state activation

  • primary inducers are immediate, direct emotional stimuli in the environment (e.g. an immediate threat or reward) processed by the amygdala

  • secondary inducers are complex memories, imagined future scenarios, cognition, and moral deliberation (e.g. anticipating future societal punishment) processed by the vmPFC


24
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - signalling routes & neurotransmitter modulation in the SMH

  • the body loop activates visceral/autonomic changes via the hypothalamus, brainstem, and vagus nerve, relayed back to the somatosensory cortex and insula

  • the ‘as-if-body’ loop is an internal shortcut simulating bodily states (via the insula and posterior cingulate) without peripheral effectors

  • both modulate dopamine and serotonin nuclei in the brainstem to drive reward prediction errors and behavioural adjustment


25
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - iowa gambling task & autonomic signalling findings

  • healthy controls generate anticipatory skin conductance responses (SCRs) before picking risky cards (decks A & B), guiding them to safe decks (C & D) during the unconscious ‘pre-hunch’ phase

  • vmPFC lesion patients lack anticipatory SCRs (despite normal reactive SCRs after outcomes) and persistently choose badly

  • 50% reach the ‘conceptual period’ and explicitly know which decks are bad yet still select them


26
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - double dissociation between working memory and decision-making

dlPFC damage impairs working memory while leaving IGT decision-making relatively intact, whereas vmPFC damage impairs real-life and IGT decision-making even in patients who possess superior IQ and intact working memory

27
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - moral judgment impairments in vmPFC damage (young et al., 2010)

vmPFC patients exhibit abnormally utilitarian moral judgments (e.g. willingness to push someone off a bridge to save five others) and judge attempted harms (e.g. attempted murder) as morally permissible if no actual physical harm occurred, because harmful intent fails to trigger an aversive somatic marker

28
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - myopic loss aversion & ‘advantageous’ lack of emotion (shiv et al., 2005)

  • in a financial investment task, healthy controls become overly conservative after losses due to negative emotional biasing

  • whereas patients with focal lesions in emotion circuitry (vmPFC, amygdala, insula) lack loss-aversion signals, take optimal statistical risks, and earn significantly more money

    • explaining how ‘functional psychopaths’ prosper in finance, boardrooms, or politics


29
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - primary psychopathy vs secondary/functional psychopathy & corruption

  • primary psychopathy involves innate neurodevelopmental amygdala dysfunction (extending to posterior vmPFC/septal areas), low trait anxiety, and overt violent/callous crime

  • secondary/functional psychopathy & corruption stem from environmental/reactive factors or vmPFC dysfunction, manifesting as covert manipulation, fraud, bribery, and white-collar sociopathy

  • in ultimatum/dictator games, primary psychopathic prisoners mirror vmPFC patients by rejecting unfair offers and making lower offers


30
New cards

sobhani & bechara (2011) - critical synthesis: acquired vs developmental sociopathy & diagnostic dissociation

  • adult-onset vmPFC lesions (‘acquired sociopathy’) rarely cause severe predatory violence because early social rules were internalised, whereas childhood-onset vmPFC lesions prevent moral socialisation and produce persistent adult antisociality

  • furthermore, organic somatic defects cause punishment insensitivity, whereas environmentally conditioned corruption (with intact circuitry) responds to enforced punishment contingences

    • explaining ‘absence of a lesion of the intellect’ alongside severe antisocial exploitation


31
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - core problem & diagnostic dilemma

  • persistent violent offenders are clinically heterogeneous:

    • most show reactive aggression and emotional lability, while a minority exhibit CU traits, psychopathy, and instrumental violence

  • diagnostic systems like the DSM treat ASPD as a single unitary category, and past imaging studies conflated psychopathic and nom-psychopathic offenders, lowered diagnostic cutoffs, used non-blind manual tracing, or failed to control for substance use disorders (SUDs) and comorbities


32
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - primary objective

to use automayed, whole-brain voxel-based morphometry to test whether structural grey matter (GM) volume differences categorically distinguish violent offenders with ASPD and pyschopathy (ASPD+P) from violent offenders with ASPD without psychopathy (ASPD-P) and healthy offenders

33
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - participant sample & grouping

  • 66 men aged 20-50 recruited from National Probation Services and community sites in London

  • ASPD+P: DSM-IV ASPD with PCL-R score >/= 25

  • ASPD-P: persistently violent offenders with DSM-IV ASPD and PCL-R score < 25

  • healthy non offenders: control men with no criminal convictions, ASPD, or psychopathy


34
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - matching, exclusions & objective testing

  • exclusions: lifetime major psychotic and mood disorders (schizophrenia spectrum, bipolar, MDD), neurological illness, and head injury with loss of consciousness >/= 1 hour

  • matching: offender groups were matched on age, full-scale IQ, educational attainment, and lifetime SUD rates (alcohol, cannabis, cocaine)

  • objective testing: daily urine and saliva toxicological screening on testing days


35
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - imaging & statistical analysis

  • high-resolution spoiled gradient-echo structural images were acquired on a 1.5T scanner

  • fully automated, modulated whole-brain VBM

  • small volume corrections were applied to a priori ROIs with age and IQ as nuisance covariates


36
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - key findings: ASPD+P vs healthy nonoffenders

  • violent offenders with psychopathy (ASPD+P) showed marked bilateral grey matter volume reductions in discrete social brain regions

  • anterior rostral medial PFC extending into superior frontal gyrus

  • temporal poles, extending into inferior and middle temporal gyri

  • anterior insula, extending into primary and premotor cortices


37
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - key findings: ASPD+P vs ASPD-P & ASPD-P vs nonoffenders

  • ASPD+P vs ASPD-P:

    • ASPD+P showed significantly reduced GM volume in bilateral arMPFC and bilateral temporal poles

    • temporal pole differences survived corrected thresholds after controlling for scanning-day positive drug screens and co-occuring personality disoders

  • ASPD-P vs nonoffenders:

    • no significant GM volume differences in whole-brain or ROI analyses


38
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - amygdala & vmPFC null findings

  • no volumetric differences were found in the amygdala or vmPFC across ASPD+P, ASPD-P, and controls

  • the authors argued prior reports of atrophy were likely driven by manual tracking biases, lower PCL-R thresholds, or unexcluded comorbidities, noting that functional or microstructural connectivity deficits can still exist without macrostructural volume loss


39
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - functional neuroanatomy & clinical implications of affected regions in ASPD+P

  • arMPFC:

    • self-relfection, cognitive branching, and understanding others’ intentions

    • disruption impairs guilt, remorse, and moral appraisal

  • temporal poles

    • social conceptual knowledge and socio-emotional framing

    • disruption parallels kluver-bucy syndrome and frontotemporal dementia (emotional blunting, empathy loss)

  • anterior insula

    • interoception, distress processing, and averive conditioning

    • disruption drives punishment insensitivity and lack of empathic resonance


40
New cards

gregory et al. (2012) - critical evaluation: clinical relevance, strengths & limitations

  • clinical relevance

    • psychopathy (ASPD+P) is a distinct neurodevelopmental phenotype

    • while ASPD-P responds to standard CBT, ASPD+P shows minimal response and requires tailored interventions

  • strengths

    • standardised european PCL-R cutoff, tight matching on age/IQ/lifetime SUDs, and automated bias-free VBM

  • limitations

    • male-only cohort, small cell size, and VBM’s inability to separate cortical thickness, surface area, or white matter microstructure


41
New cards

phineas gage - the accident

  • 25 year old phineas gage was wokring with a blasting crew when he was in an accident that drove a tamping iron through his head

  • the rod entered through the left cheekbone, past his eye, and out the top of his head

  • he survived the trauma, but exhibited significant personality & behavioural changes

    • erratic, impulsive, aggressive, lacking guilt

  • the lesion was mostly indicating the vmPFC

  • theory of the somatic marker hypothesis


<ul><li><p>25 year old phineas gage was wokring with a blasting crew when he was in an accident that drove a tamping iron through his head</p></li><li><p>the rod entered through the left cheekbone, past his eye, and out the top of his head</p></li><li><p>he survived the trauma, but exhibited significant personality &amp; behavioural changes </p><ul><li><p>erratic, impulsive, aggressive, lacking guilt </p></li></ul></li><li><p>the lesion was mostly indicating the vmPFC</p></li><li><p>theory of the somatic marker hypothesis </p></li></ul><p></p>
42
New cards

more recent evidence - vmPFC damage

tumour growing in the brain that is compressing the vmPFC

<p>tumour growing in the brain that is compressing the vmPFC</p>
43
New cards

glenn & raine (2014) - more recent evidence of vmPFC damage

  • single case example

  • the lesion is show to link to behaviour

    • when it is there, so is the behaviour and vice versa

  • can now do pharmacological intervention to show this

    • but this was a ‘natural’ example

  • lesion in the area is associated with the onset of abnormal and antisocial behaviour


<ul><li><p>single case example</p></li><li><p>the lesion is show to link to behaviour </p><ul><li><p>when it is there, so is the behaviour and vice versa</p></li></ul></li><li><p>can now do pharmacological intervention to show this </p><ul><li><p>but this was a ‘natural’ example</p></li></ul></li><li><p>lesion in the area is associated with the onset of abnormal and antisocial behaviour </p></li></ul><p></p>
44
New cards

de brito & hodgins (2009) - antisocial personality disorder

  • indexes a lifelong pattern of ASB

    • conduct disorder and ASPD

  • the symptoms of ASPD include impulsivity, consistent irresponsibility, repeated criminal acts, repeated fights or assaults, recklessness, deceitfulness, and a lack of remorse

  • poor decision-making

    • excessive risk-taking

    • impulsivity

  • symptoms you often see in patients who have sustained lesions in the vmPFC


45
New cards

anderson et al. - acquired antisocial personality disorder/psychopathy

  • lesions to vmPFC lead to changes:

    • behaviour

    • affect

    • personality

  • lesions in childhood and adulthood

  • resemble the clinical presentation of ASPD/psychopathy

  • hypothesis: individuals with ASPD/psychopathy may have abnormalities within the PFC (vmPFC/OFC)


<ul><li><p>lesions to vmPFC lead to changes: </p><ul><li><p>behaviour </p></li><li><p>affect </p></li><li><p>personality</p></li></ul></li><li><p>lesions in childhood and adulthood </p></li><li><p>resemble the clinical presentation of ASPD/psychopathy </p></li><li><p><em>hypothesis</em>: individuals with ASPD/psychopathy may have abnormalities within the PFC (vmPFC/OFC) </p></li></ul><p></p>
46
New cards

raine et al. - reduced prefrontal grey matter volume and reduced autonomic activity in ASPD - methods

  • clinical control group: individuals who had substance dependence

    • high comorbidity between ASPD and substance dependence

  • looked at grey and white matter

  • also interested in linking this to the ANS (skin conductance & HR)

  • PFC is also implicated in generating the somatic marker


<ul><li><p>clinical control group: individuals who had substance dependence </p><ul><li><p>high comorbidity between ASPD and substance dependence </p></li></ul></li><li><p>looked at grey and white matter </p></li><li><p>also interested in linking this to the ANS (skin conductance &amp; HR)</p></li><li><p>PFC is also implicated in generating the somatic marker </p></li></ul><p></p>
47
New cards

raine et al. - reduced prefrontal grey matter volume and reduced autonomic activity in ASPD - results

  • in terms of grey matter:

    • individuals with ASPD had decreased volume of PFC compared to both other groups

  • no differences in white matter between the three groups

  • those with ASPD showed reduced HR and skin conductance compared to the other groups

  • ASPD group were impaired compared to the other groups

  • conducted all analyses controlling for other confounding variables

    • e.g. SES, parental divorce, abuse, family size, foster care


<ul><li><p>in terms of grey matter:</p><ul><li><p>individuals with ASPD had decreased volume of PFC compared to both other groups </p></li></ul></li><li><p>no differences in white matter between the three groups </p></li><li><p>those with ASPD showed reduced HR and skin conductance compared to the other groups </p></li><li><p>ASPD group were impaired compared to the other groups </p></li><li><p>conducted all analyses controlling for other confounding variables </p><ul><li><p>e.g. SES, parental divorce, abuse, family size, foster care </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
48
New cards

yang & raine (2009) - prefrontal structural and functional brain imaging findings in antisocial, violent, and psychotic individuals: meta-analysis - methods

  • 43 studies across structural and functional

  • test the hypothesis of can we see abnormalities within the PFC when we compare the literature


<ul><li><p>43 studies across structural and functional </p></li><li><p>test the hypothesis of can we see abnormalities within the PFC when we compare the literature </p></li></ul><p></p>
49
New cards

yang & raine (2009) - prefrontal structural and functional brain imaging findings in antisocial, violent, and psychotic individuals: meta-analysis - results

  • subdivided the PFC into subregions

  • could show across those three studies that individuals with antisocial, violent behaviour, or psychopathy within the orbitofrontal cortex, specifically within the right

    • also in the left dlPFC (associated with executive functions, such as working memory)

    • also in the anterior cingulate cortex (mostly right)

  • show reliable abnormalities in several subregions of the PFC

  • limited by methods available at the time

    • not just PFC


<ul><li><p>subdivided the PFC into subregions </p></li><li><p>could show across those three studies that individuals with antisocial, violent behaviour, or psychopathy within the orbitofrontal cortex, specifically within the right </p><ul><li><p>also in the left dlPFC (associated with executive functions, such as working memory)</p></li><li><p>also in the anterior cingulate cortex (mostly right)</p></li></ul></li><li><p>show reliable abnormalities in several subregions of the PFC </p></li><li><p>limited by methods available at the time </p><ul><li><p>not just PFC </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
50
New cards

aoki et al. (2013) - neural bases of ASB: a voxel-based meta-analysis - methods

  • voxel-based morphometry

    • require an image of the brain

    • can use software to automatically segment the brain into three tissue types (grey, white and CSF)

    • gives you a proxy for the measure of the size of the ventricles (filled with spinal fluid)

    • do not have to limit yourself to subregions of the brain

  • included adults as well as children

    • young people with CD

    • adults with ASPD or psychopathy


<ul><li><p>voxel-based morphometry</p><ul><li><p>require an image of the brain</p></li><li><p>can use software to automatically segment the brain into three tissue types (grey, white and CSF)</p></li><li><p>gives you a proxy for the measure of the size of the ventricles (filled with spinal fluid)</p></li><li><p>do not have to limit yourself to subregions of the brain </p></li></ul></li><li><p>included adults as well as children </p><ul><li><p>young people with CD</p></li><li><p>adults with ASPD or psychopathy </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
51
New cards

aoki et al. (2013) - neural bases of ASB: a voxel-based meta-analysis - results

  • among AS individuals, there was a reduction in grey matter in three regions

    • lentiform nucleus → part of the basal ganglia, includes subnuclei

    • also in left insular & left superior frontal gyrus

  • the AS group showed increased grey matter in several different regions

    • fusiform gyrus (face region)

    • inferior & superior parietal lobule

    • cingular gyrus

    • right postcentral gyrus

  • a combination of decreased and increased grey matter in AS individuals

  • big limitation of meta-analyses

    • did not look at subgroups (e.g. children, CU traits)


<ul><li><p>among AS individuals, there was a reduction in grey matter in three regions </p><ul><li><p>lentiform nucleus → part of the basal ganglia, includes subnuclei </p></li><li><p>also in left insular &amp; left superior frontal gyrus </p></li></ul></li><li><p>the AS group showed increased grey matter in several different regions </p><ul><li><p>fusiform gyrus (face region)</p></li><li><p>inferior &amp; superior parietal lobule </p></li><li><p>cingular gyrus </p></li><li><p>right postcentral gyrus </p></li></ul></li><li><p>a combination of decreased and increased grey matter in AS individuals </p></li><li><p>big limitation of meta-analyses</p><ul><li><p>did not look at subgroups (e.g. children, CU traits)</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
52
New cards

clark et al. (2004) - vmPFC and affective decision-making

  • vmPFC is essential for adequate affective decision-making

  • affective decision-making involves the evaluation of multiple responses associated with differing probabilities of reward and punishment, followed by the selection of the optimal response

  • affective decision-making under ambiguity

    • outcome probabilties are unknown (being punished or rewarded)

    • i.e. Iowa Gambling Task

  • affective decision-making under risk

    • outcome probabilities are known

    • i.e. Cambridge Gambling Task


53
New cards

bechara et al. (1994) - affective decision-making in ASPD - Iowa Gambling Task

  • uses four decks of cards

  • the individual is instructed to draw one card at a time from any of the decks

  • have to earn as many points as they can in the time

  • bad decks - if you draw a card from them, they will either lead to a gain or a high level of punishment (loss)

    • if you only draw from these decks, in the long run you lose $250

  • good decks - less of a reward, but the punishment is also much less

    • if you only draw from these decks, in the long run you gain $250

  • in healthy individuals

    • will start with decks A and B (bad)

    • quickly will realise it is beneficial to draw from decks C and D (good)


<ul><li><p>uses four decks of cards</p></li><li><p>the individual is instructed to draw one card at a time from any of the decks </p></li><li><p>have to earn as many points as they can in the time </p></li><li><p>bad decks - if you draw a card from them, they will either lead to a gain or a high level of punishment (loss)</p><ul><li><p>if you only draw from these decks, in the long run you lose $250</p></li></ul></li><li><p>good decks - less of a reward, but the punishment is also much less</p><ul><li><p>if you only draw from these decks, in the long run you gain $250 </p></li></ul></li><li><p>in healthy individuals</p><ul><li><p>will start with decks A and B (bad)</p></li><li><p>quickly will realise it is beneficial to draw from decks C and D (good) </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
54
New cards

bechara et al. (1994) - affective decision-making in ASPD - Iowa Gambling Task - men with ASPD

  • patients with vmPFC lesions

  • are impaired at the task

  • tend to persist at drawing cards from decks A and B

  • can consciously state they knew it is not a good decision, but keep making it

  • also down in young people with CD


<ul><li><p>patients with vmPFC lesions </p></li><li><p>are impaired at the task</p></li><li><p>tend to persist at drawing cards from decks A and B</p></li><li><p>can consciously state they knew it is not a good decision, but keep making it </p></li><li><p>also down in young people with CD </p></li></ul><p></p>
55
New cards

bechara et al. - different contributions of the human amygdala and ventromedial PFC to decision-making

  • regions implicated in the Iowa Gambling task

  • three groups: controls, amygdala lesions, vmPFC lesions

  • controls

    • initially, start drawing from decks A and B

    • quickly begin to draw more cards from decks C and D

    • somatic marker and skin conductance shown

  • amygdala and vmPFC lesions

    • persist in drawing from the bad decks of cards

    • both regions of the brain are important for appropriate affective decision-making in ambiguity

    • when the outcomes are unknown, and need to be worked out


<ul><li><p>regions implicated in the Iowa Gambling task</p></li><li><p>three groups: controls, amygdala lesions, vmPFC lesions </p></li><li><p>controls </p><ul><li><p>initially, start drawing from decks A and B</p></li><li><p>quickly begin to draw more cards from decks C and D</p></li><li><p>somatic marker and skin conductance shown </p></li></ul></li><li><p>amygdala and vmPFC lesions </p><ul><li><p>persist in drawing from the bad decks of cards </p></li><li><p>both regions of the brain are important for appropriate affective decision-making in ambiguity </p></li><li><p>when the outcomes are unknown, and need to be worked out </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
56
New cards

mitchell et al. (2002) - risky decisions and response reversal: is there evidence of orbitofrontal cortex dysfunction in psychopathic individuals? - results


  • control group

    • learnt as the task progresses

    • sample less from the high-risk decks

  • psychopathy

    • improvement is not there

    • improve and then reach a plateau

    • still sample of the high risk

  • vassileva et al.

    • included a group with substance use disorder

    • associated with poor decision making and dysfunction in oribtofrontal cortex


<p></p><ul><li><p>control group</p><ul><li><p>learnt as the task progresses</p></li><li><p>sample less from the high-risk decks </p></li></ul></li><li><p>psychopathy</p><ul><li><p>improvement is not there </p></li><li><p>improve and then reach a plateau </p></li><li><p>still sample of the high risk </p></li></ul></li><li><p>vassileva et al.</p><ul><li><p>included a group with substance use disorder </p></li><li><p>associated with poor decision making and dysfunction in oribtofrontal cortex </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
57
New cards

mitchell et al. (2002) - risky decisions and response reversal: is there evidence of orbitofrontal cortex dysfunction in psychopathic individuals? - methods

  • administering several tasks, including the Iowa Gambling

  • psychopathic inmates, and control inmates

  • no differences in age or IQ


58
New cards

anderson et al. - impairment of social and moral behaviour related to early damage in the human PFC - methods

  • tested whether lesions sustained early in development are also associated with the clinical presentation

  • normal control group (no lesion), 2 subjects (male and female; sustained lesions in vmPFC before age 16 months)

  • both subjects made a full recovery, but had an increase in ASB ad aggression

    • lack of guilt/remorse

  • compared subjects to those who developed lesions in adulthood

  • iowa gambling task


59
New cards

anderson et al. - impairment of social and moral behaviour related to early damage in the human PFC - results

  • both subjects sample more from the ‘bad’ decks of cards

  • anticipatory SCRs

    • subjects have reduced SCRs compared to controls for both decks, but especially the bad decks

  • subjects (early onset) were more impaired than those who developed lesions in adulthood


<ul><li><p>both subjects sample more from the ‘bad’ decks of cards </p></li><li><p>anticipatory SCRs</p><ul><li><p>subjects have reduced SCRs compared to controls for both decks, but especially the bad decks </p></li></ul></li><li><p>subjects (early onset) were more impaired than those who developed lesions in adulthood </p></li></ul><p></p>
60
New cards

mataro et al. (2001) - does PFC damage necessarily lead tp antisocial and aggressive behaviour?

  • does damage to PFC (ventromedial) lead to antisocial/aggressive behaviour

  • none of the symptoms include antisocial and aggressive behaviour

  • wife provided a good network of social support following the injury


<ul><li><p>does damage to PFC (ventromedial) lead to antisocial/aggressive behaviour </p></li><li><p>none of the symptoms include antisocial and aggressive behaviour </p></li><li><p>wife provided a good network of social support following the injury </p></li></ul><p></p>
61
New cards

bigler et al. (2001) - gunshot wound to mPFC

  • adolescent woth a long-standing and well-documented history of CD, also comorbid for ADHD

  • during the course of playing russian roulette sustained a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the mPFC

  • no personality and behavioural changes following injury

  • still exhibited symptoms of CD and ASB

  • no changes in clinical presentation


<ul><li><p>adolescent woth a long-standing and well-documented history of CD, also comorbid for ADHD</p></li><li><p>during the course of playing russian roulette sustained a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the mPFC </p></li><li><p>no personality and behavioural changes following injury </p></li><li><p>still exhibited symptoms of CD and ASB</p></li><li><p>no changes in clinical presentation </p></li></ul><p></p>
62
New cards

ellenbogen et al. - ventromedial frontal lobe trauma

  • 33-year-old man attempted suicide with a crossbow

  • prior history of violent behaviour

  • afterwards was docile and inappropriately cheerful

  • ‘cured’ him of his ASB

  • ventromedial frontal lobe trauma


<ul><li><p>33-year-old man attempted suicide with a crossbow </p></li><li><p>prior history of violent behaviour </p></li><li><p>afterwards was docile and inappropriately cheerful </p></li><li><p>‘cured’ him of his ASB</p></li><li><p>ventromedial frontal lobe trauma </p></li></ul><p></p>
63
New cards

raine et al. (2009) - sex differences in orbitofrontal grey as a partial explanation for sex differences in antisocial personality - methods

  • used structural MRI to understand if there is a neural basis in the sex differences of ASPD

  • three groups: ASPD, substance misuse, healthy control

  • what is the relationship between structural brain correlates (specifically PFC subdivisions)

  • correlations between brain matter in regions and the measure of ASB for the group (self-report and diagnostic)


<ul><li><p>used structural MRI to understand if there is a neural basis in the sex differences of ASPD</p></li><li><p>three groups: ASPD, substance misuse, healthy control </p></li><li><p>what is the relationship between structural brain correlates (specifically PFC subdivisions)</p></li><li><p>correlations between brain matter in regions and the measure of ASB for the group (self-report and diagnostic) </p></li></ul><p></p>
64
New cards

raine et al. (2009) - sex differences in orbitofrontal grey as a partial explanation for sex differences in antisocial personality - results

  • across males and females, the lower the volume of PFC subdivisions, the greater the score on ASB

  • males score higher than females on ASB

  • males have lower volumes than females

  • does brain matter volume explain the sex differences in ASB; needed to show:

    • males and females differ on risk factors (brain volume) - is the case

    • the risk factor is associated with an increase in ASB in both sexes - is the case

    • control statistically for the sex differences, then the differences in ASB between the sexes should be diminished - is the case


<ul><li><p>across males and females, the lower the volume of PFC subdivisions, the greater the score on ASB</p></li><li><p>males score higher than females on ASB</p></li><li><p>males have lower volumes than females </p></li><li><p>does brain matter volume explain the sex differences in ASB; needed to show:</p><ul><li><p>males and females differ on risk factors (brain volume) - is the case</p></li><li><p>the risk factor is associated with an increase in ASB in both sexes - is the case </p></li><li><p>control statistically for the sex differences, then the differences in ASB between the sexes should be diminished - is the case</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
65
New cards

blair et al. (2006); raine et al. (2010) - psychopathy: a neurodevelopmental disorder?

  • it has been suggested that psychopathy might be a neurodevelopmental disorder

  • need to study children to explore this hypothesis

    • results are unlikely to be confounded by prolonged substance abuse, which is an important confound in the adult studies


66
New cards

raine et al. (2010) - neurodevelopmental marker for limbic maldevelopment in ASPD and psychopathy - methods

  • control and ASPD

  • demographics, trauma, antisocial

  • cavum septum pellicudum

    • cave between the two ventricles in the brain

    • as we develop, the ‘cave’ is fully apparent

    • around 20 weeks of gestation, it will close

    • by 3-6 months postnatal, it will have fully closed

  • two ventricles with a thin sheet in the middle

  • are individuals with ASPD more likely to be characterised by neutral markers such as this


<ul><li><p>control and ASPD</p></li><li><p>demographics, trauma, antisocial </p></li><li><p>cavum septum pellicudum</p><ul><li><p>cave between the two ventricles in the brain </p></li><li><p>as we develop, the ‘cave’ is fully apparent </p></li><li><p>around 20 weeks of gestation, it will close </p></li><li><p>by 3-6 months postnatal, it will have fully closed </p></li></ul></li><li><p>two ventricles with a thin sheet in the middle </p></li><li><p>are individuals with ASPD more likely to be characterised by neutral markers such as this </p></li></ul><p></p>
67
New cards

raine et al. (2010) - neurodevelopmental marker for limbic maldevelopment in ASPD and psychopathy - results

  • those with cavum septum pellicudum are more likely to be charged for a criminal offence

  • those with score higher in:

    • aggressive/life-course

    • psychopathy

    • ASPD

    • charges and convictions

  • gives us a window into what happened in development to link to ASB

  • do not know why this occurs

    • may be due to alcohol in pregnancy

    • may be due to repeated trauma/brain injury


<ul><li><p>those with cavum septum pellicudum are more likely to be charged for a criminal offence </p></li><li><p>those with score higher in:</p><ul><li><p>aggressive/life-course </p></li><li><p>psychopathy </p></li><li><p>ASPD</p></li><li><p>charges and convictions </p></li></ul></li><li><p>gives us a window into what happened in development to link to ASB</p></li><li><p>do not know why this occurs </p><ul><li><p>may be due to alcohol in pregnancy</p></li><li><p>may be due to repeated trauma/brain injury </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
68
New cards

toivonen et al. (2013) - cavum septum pellicudum and psychopathy

  • did not replicate raine et al. (2010)

  • found the prevalence of CSP to be equal in the two groups


<ul><li><p>did not replicate raine et al. (2010)</p></li><li><p>found the prevalence of CSP to be equal in the two groups </p></li></ul><p></p>
69
New cards

pardini et al. - lower amygdala volume in men is associated with childhood aggression, early psychopathic traits, and future violence - methods

  • sample of boys recruited at age 6-7

  • parents and teachers were given screening questionnaires

  • those scoring in the top 30% on ASB measures were retained for a longitudinal study follow-up

  • another group scoring low on ASB was included as a control

  • assessments were done between aged 10 and 19, then repeated before follow-up at age 26

  • self-report measure of ASB in adolescence, parent and teacher measures in childhood, MRI data at age 26, criminal records

  • classified into three groups

    • control - no evidence of ASB violence

    • transient violence - violence spanning between 1 and 3 years

    • chronic violence - violence repeatedly in assessments spanning 1 to 4 years


<ul><li><p>sample of boys recruited at age 6-7</p></li><li><p>parents and teachers were given screening questionnaires </p></li><li><p>those scoring in the top 30% on ASB measures were retained for a longitudinal study follow-up</p></li><li><p>another group scoring low on ASB was included as a control </p></li><li><p>assessments were done between aged 10 and 19, then repeated before follow-up at age 26 </p></li><li><p>self-report measure of ASB in adolescence, parent and teacher measures in childhood, MRI data at age 26, criminal records </p></li><li><p>classified into three groups </p><ul><li><p>control - no evidence of ASB violence </p></li><li><p>transient violence - violence spanning between 1 and 3 years </p></li><li><p>chronic violence - violence repeatedly in assessments spanning 1 to 4 years </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
70
New cards

pardini et al. - lower amygdala volume in men is associated with childhood aggression, early psychopathic traits, and future violence - results table

  • results of MRI scan at age 26

  • testing the hypothesis of dysfunctional amygdala and psychopathy

  • top table

    • regression analysis looking at ASB measures and amygdala volumes (left & right)

    • aggressive behaviour, impulsive aggression, instrumental aggression are significantly related to the amygdala volume (negative)

    • lower the amygdala volume, the greater the score on these measures

  • bottom table

    • negative relationship of aggressive behaviour and interpersonal callousness with the left amygdala volume

    • proactive aggression, aggressive behaviour, and psychopathic features share a negative relationship with right amygdala volume


<ul><li><p>results of MRI scan at age 26</p></li><li><p>testing the hypothesis of dysfunctional amygdala and psychopathy </p></li><li><p>top table </p><ul><li><p>regression analysis looking at ASB measures and amygdala volumes (left &amp; right) </p></li><li><p>aggressive behaviour, impulsive aggression, instrumental aggression are significantly related to the amygdala volume (negative) </p></li><li><p>lower the amygdala volume, the greater the score on these measures </p></li></ul></li><li><p>bottom table </p><ul><li><p>negative relationship of aggressive behaviour and interpersonal callousness with the left amygdala volume </p></li><li><p>proactive aggression, aggressive behaviour, and psychopathic features share a negative relationship with right amygdala volume</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
71
New cards

pardini et al. - lower amygdala volume in men is associated with childhood aggression, early psychopathic traits, and future violence - results graph

  • whether amygdala volume could predict future measures of violence and psychopathy at age 29

  • after the scan, ppts were classified as those who showed violence and those who did not post-scan

  • those showing violence showed lower amygdala volume bilaterally

  • the lower the volume of the amygdala, the greater the psychopathic features at age 29

  • limitation

    • focused on males


<ul><li><p>whether amygdala volume could predict future measures of violence and psychopathy at age 29 </p></li><li><p>after the scan, ppts were classified as those who showed violence and those who did not post-scan </p></li><li><p>those showing violence showed lower amygdala volume bilaterally </p></li><li><p>the lower the volume of the amygdala, the greater the psychopathic features at age 29 </p></li><li><p>limitation</p><ul><li><p>focused on males </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
72
New cards

dugre & de brito (2024) - unravelling the morphological brain architecture of human aggression: a systematic review of meta-analysis of structural neuroimaging studies

  • found general measures of aggression are associated with reductions in the medial PFC

  • reactive aggression

    • reductions in grey matter volume, bilaterally in the temporal lobes, were associated with aggression

  • proactive aggression

    • increased volume in the caudate was associated with more proactive aggression


<ul><li><p>found general measures of aggression are associated with reductions in the medial PFC </p></li><li><p>reactive aggression </p><ul><li><p>reductions in grey matter volume, bilaterally in the temporal lobes, were associated with aggression </p></li></ul></li><li><p>proactive aggression</p><ul><li><p>increased volume in the caudate was associated with more proactive aggression </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
73
New cards

blair et al. (2006); moffitt et al. (2008) - children with CP+CU traits

  • children with conduct problems and CU traits:

    • early and severe conduct problems

    • lack empathy

    • novelty seeking

  • a possible sub typing index for DSM-V


74
New cards

white et al. (2013) - the relationship between large cavum septum pellucidum and ASB, CU traits and psychopathy in adolescents

  • large CSP was not higher among those with a more severe form of DBD

  • DBD youth with a large CSP did not show increased levels of aggression and PT relative to other DBD youth


<ul><li><p>large CSP was not higher among those with a more severe form of DBD</p></li><li><p>DBD youth with a large CSP did not show increased levels of aggression and PT relative to other DBD youth </p></li></ul><p></p>
75
New cards

blair et al. (2006); Dadds et al. (2006) - neuropsychological profile of CP+CU

  • neuropsychological profile of these children consistent with:

    • amygdala dysfunction

      • failure to recognise fear and sadness in faces

      • failure to learn in passive avoidance paradigms

    • ventromedial/ventrolateral PFC dysfunction

      • extinction paradigms

      • response reversal

      • risky decision-making (iowa gambling task)


76
New cards

evidence for grey matter abnormalities in CD in 2015

  • for reviews see Rogers & De Brito and Baker et al.

  • two studies → overall reduction in GMV (6%; 13%)

  • reduction in GMV in several cortical and subcortical brain regions

    • anterior and posterior insula

    • temproal lobes bilaterally

    • right ventromedial PFC incorporating orbitofrontal cortex

    • right dorsolateral PFC

    • anterior cingulate cortex

    • hippocampus

    • amygdala

    • striatal regions


77
New cards

rogers & de brito - cortical and subcortical GMV in youths with CP - meta-analytic evidence

  • 13 VBM studies

  • 394 youths with CP

  • 350 TD youths

  • used 85% of the original data

  • subgroup analysis

  • reliability analysis

  • meta-regression analyses

  • robust evidence for decreased GMV in left amygdala and anterior insula bilaterally

  • reduction in the fusiform gyrus


<ul><li><p>13 VBM studies</p></li><li><p>394 youths with CP</p></li><li><p>350 TD youths </p></li><li><p>used 85% of the original data</p></li><li><p>subgroup analysis </p></li><li><p>reliability analysis </p></li><li><p>meta-regression analyses </p></li><li><p>robust evidence for decreased GMV in left amygdala and anterior insula bilaterally </p></li><li><p>reduction in the fusiform gyrus </p></li></ul><p></p>
78
New cards

hedging et al. (2009) - conduct disorder: sex matters

getting the phenotypes right: an essential ingredient for understanding aetiological mechanims underlying persistent violence and developing effective treatments

<p>getting the phenotypes right: an essential ingredient for understanding aetiological mechanims underlying persistent violence and developing effective treatments </p>
79
New cards

collishaw et al. (2004); afifi et al. (2011); berkout et al. (2011); meier et al. (2011); kerekes et al. (2014) - conduct disorder: sex matters

  • recent evidence suggests that the prevalence of CD in females has increased

  • there are pronounced sex differences in:

    • the development and course of the disorder

    • the aetiology and physiology

    • patterns of comorbidity, particularly for internalising disorders (e.g. PTSD, depression)

  • despite this body of evidence, the majority of neuroimaging studies on CD have focused on male subjects only


80
New cards

fairchild et al. (2013) - brain structure abnormalities in adolescent girls with CD - methods

  • females with CD using MRI

  • healthy controls with CD (aged around 17/18)

  • used VBM

    • entire grey matter across entire cortex


<ul><li><p>females with CD using MRI</p></li><li><p>healthy controls with CD (aged around 17/18)</p></li><li><p>used VBM</p><ul><li><p>entire grey matter across entire cortex </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
81
New cards

fairchild et al. (2013) - brain structure abnormalities in adolescent girls with CD - results

  • amygdala volume

    • main effect of diagnosis

    • both males and females with CD show reduced volume of the right amygdala compared to healthy controls

  • in the anterior insula

    • diagnosis by sex interaction

    • differing patterns between sexes

    • those with CD show increased volume bilaterally

    • opposite for females; those with CD show a reduction in volume


<ul><li><p>amygdala volume </p><ul><li><p>main effect of diagnosis </p></li><li><p>both males and females with CD show reduced volume of the right amygdala compared to healthy controls </p></li></ul></li><li><p>in the anterior insula</p><ul><li><p>diagnosis by sex interaction </p></li><li><p>differing patterns between sexes</p></li><li><p>those with CD show increased volume bilaterally </p></li><li><p>opposite for females; those with CD show a reduction in volume </p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
82
New cards

gao et al. - cortical structure and subcortical volumes in CD: a coordinated analysis of 15 international cohorts from the ENIGMA-antisocial behaviour working group - methods

  • 15 international cohorts (n = 2438)

    • 795 females (32.6%)

    • europe

    • usa

    • china

    • india

  • participants aged 7-21 years


<ul><li><p>15 international cohorts (n = 2438)</p><ul><li><p>795 females (32.6%)</p></li><li><p>europe </p></li><li><p>usa</p></li><li><p>china</p></li><li><p>india </p></li></ul></li><li><p>participants aged 7-21 years </p></li></ul><p></p>
83
New cards

gao et al. - cortical structure and subcortical volumes in CD: a coordinated analysis of 15 international cohorts from the ENIGMA-antisocial behaviour working group - cortical thickness results

  • hardly any differences in cortical thickness

    • increase in the anterior cingulate cortex and decrease in the temporal lobe

    • out of the 34 regions, 26 showed a decrease in surface area in those with CD

    • decreased volume in:

      • hippocampus, amygdala, thalamus, nucleus accumbens


<ul><li><p>hardly any differences in cortical thickness </p><ul><li><p>increase in the anterior cingulate cortex and decrease in the temporal lobe </p></li><li><p>out of the 34 regions, 26 showed a decrease in surface area in those with CD</p></li><li><p>decreased volume in:</p><ul><li><p>hippocampus, amygdala, thalamus, nucleus accumbens </p></li></ul></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
84
New cards

gao et al. - cortical structure and subcortical volumes in CD: a coordinated analysis of 15 international cohorts from the ENIGMA-antisocial behaviour working group - sex differences results

  • no sex differencesin those with CD

  • when they looked at the subgroup, there were not many differences

  • those with high levels of CU traits showed the greatest differences compared to the controls


<ul><li><p>no sex differencesin those with CD</p></li><li><p>when they looked at the subgroup, there were not many differences </p></li><li><p>those with high levels of CU traits showed the greatest differences compared to the controls </p></li></ul><p></p>